Palestinian-Canadians feel 'betrayed' by Canada, demand end to violence, starvation in Gaza
Watching the violence in Gaza unfold for the last 22 months has been painful, traumatic, and a "continuous nightmare" for Palestinian-Canadians in Windsor — and according to some advocates, the last several weeks have gotten even worse.
The Gaza death toll has hit 60,000, with reports of widespread starvation, malnutrition and disease after months of an Israeli-imposed blockade and almost two years of Israel's military offensive.
On July 29, the Integrated Food Security Phase Classification (IPC), which monitors hunger around the world, issued a famine alert for the enclave.
Advocates say the Canadian government and international community need to do more to end the violence and the starvation.
"It's like nothing you've ever imagined humanly possible," described Maher El-Masri, a Palestinian-Canadian living in Windsor with family still in his homeland of Gaza.
"To see the sheer level of suffering and trauma, not only in Gaza, but also to us living here," he said. "In my household, we haven't had a normal day. You don't have a normal day."
In the time of genocide, you cannot be political. You have to be principled.
Each day he calls his siblings and cousins to make sure they are alive and to find out where they are located, because they've been displaced many times. He's already experienced direct loss as a result of the conflict: he told CBC that his brother was shot and killed by an Israeli sniper on December 5, 2023. He said his family is exhausted from the prolonged suffering to the point where they are wishing death.
"Food is really dwindling," he described. He's able to send some financial support to his loved ones, but food prices have become "astronomical," he said.
"You can buy a kilogram of bread for close to $50... which is unbelievable. So, they're lucky if they find flour to do bread, pasta, plain pasta, they do it with salt and water, or lentil soup. That's their meal and they eat about pretty much once a day," he said.
'I feel betrayed'
All the while, a report last week suggested that arms still flow from Canada to Israel despite the government being adamant that it has not allowed arms shipments to Israel since January 2024. However, Israeli import data and publicly available shipping records appear to contradict that claim, showing imports of Canadian "bullets" and other military hardware. The data was uncovered by a group of researchers from four NGOs: World Beyond War, the Palestinian Youth Movement, Canadians for Justice and Peace in the Middle East and Independent Jewish Voices.
"To put it mildly, I feel betrayed," El-Masri said. "We're a country that stands for values, stands for principles. We preach freedom and liberty across the world.... And now to see this is happening from a country like Canada, it's a betrayal of everything that we stand for."
It's a sentiment shared with other Palestinian-Canadians in Windsor.
Windsor's Bilal Rafiq, a member of the Palestinian Solidarity Group at the University of Windsor says it's "very difficult" for the community.
"We're watching our people every single day cry out to the world to help us, and the world is... not only turning our backs on the suffering of the Palestinians, we're actually actively aiding and abetting Israel as it commits a genocide against us," he said.
"If Canada actually cared about Palestinian sovereignty and statehood, we would be placing an immediate arms embargo and sanctions on Israel, and working as much as we can to stop this genocide — not being complicit in it."
Rafiq said the arms report should result in a "political crisis" that the government should answer to, saying that the Canadian people should be holding the government accountable to this.
Canada plans to recognize Palestinian state
On July 30 Canada said it planned to recognize a Palestinian state in September, provided the Palestinian Authority commits to certain reforms, including demilitarization. In doing so, Canada joins other Western countries making similar declarations in recent weeks to apply pressure on Israel. Israel has said that a Palestinian statehood would be a "reward" for militant group Hamas, which governs Gaza.
Rafiq said this is a "performative" statehood declaration and does little to end the violence in Gaza.
El-Masri also believes it's "political posturing" to release pressure.
He also stresses that while he would love to see the recognition of a Palestinian state, tying it to conditions like demilitarization is a "recipe for failure."
Advocates with Windsor's Palestinian Canadian Community Association agree.
"We don't want anyone to announce the Palestinian state with any condition. Let the Palestinians themselves to decide. Let them be free. And that's what we're asking all the time. Free Palestine," Maher El-Youssef told CBC.
Fellow advocate Saaed AlFaqeeh explained that the last two years have been exhausting and have taken a toll on the community, watching their people getting "massacred" all while trying to bring awareness and lobby the government for action.
AlFaqeeh said that all the while, the community is facing increased anti-Palestinian racism while still having to go on with their own lives.
"That has been extremely devastating to the community. I mean, we feel let down by our government here in Canada," he said.
A toll on the Palestinian community
El-Masri implores people to tap into their common sense humanity, regardless of their faith or nationality, to intervene and help the Palestinian people. He points out that children and babies are dying of starvation and if action is not taken, the situation will get even worse.
"Send food to people and make sure they're surviving," he implored.
According to the IPC, which describes the situation in Gaza as "the worst-case scenario of famine," more than 20,000 children were admitted for treatment for acute malnutrition between April and mid-July, and hospitals have reported a rapid increase in hunger-related deaths in children under five, with at least 16 deaths since July.
With international criticism growing, Israel announced steps in recent days to slightly ease aid access, but some organizations like the World Food Program said last week, it was not getting the permissions it needed to deliver enough aid.
'End the genocide,' El-Masri implores
Canadian Forces also airdropped humanitarian aid into Gaza for the first time on Monday, even though aid experts have said that airdrops are vastly less effective than truck convoys. Some of the pallets dropped by air earlier this week have fallen into the sea, and at least one has struck and killed Palestinians on the ground.
"In the time of genocide, you cannot be political. You have to be principled," El-Masri said.
Meanwhile, Israeli media is reporting that Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu favours a complete military takeover of Gaza for the first time in two decades, and was to meet senior security officials on Tuesday to finalize a new strategy. This, after mediation between Israel and Hamas collapsed despite intense international pressure for a ceasefire.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Globe and Mail
12 minutes ago
- Globe and Mail
Gaza crisis ‘looks very much' like genocide, senior EU official says
A senior member of the European Union's executive said the displacement and killing in Gaza looked very much like genocide, the first commissioner to level that accusation and publicly break with the body's position on the conflict. 'If it is not genocide, it looks very much like the definition used to express its meaning,' Teresa Ribera – the European Commission's second-highest ranking official – told Politico in an interview published on Thursday. Israel has repeatedly rejected accusations of carrying out genocide in its war in Gaza. Israel's mission to the EU did not immediately respond to a request for comment. What to know as Israel weighs reoccupying the entire Gaza Strip Ribera is the European Commission's Executive Vice President, second only in seniority to President Ursula von der Leyen. The Spanish socialist, whose portfolio includes climate and anti-trust issues, is not responsible for EU foreign policy. 'What we are seeing is a concrete population being targeted, killed and condemned to starve to death,' Ribera told Politico. Her statements went further than the European Commission, which has accused Israel of violating human rights in Gaza, but stopped short of accusing it of genocide. The Commission last week proposed curbing Israeli access to its flagship research funding program after calls from EU countries to increase pressure on Israel to alleviate the humanitarian crisis in the enclave. In that proposal, the Commission said Israel had violated a human rights clause in an agreement that governs its relations with the EU. 'With its intervention in the Gaza Strip and the ensuing humanitarian catastrophe, including thousands of civilian deaths and rapidly rising numbers of spreading extreme malnutrition, specifically of children, Israel is violating human rights and humanitarian law,' it wrote. Israel has fended off accusations of genocide, including a case brought by South Africa at the International Court of Justice in the Hague that Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu condemned as 'outrageous.' The war was triggered when Hamas-led militants attacked Israeli communities and military bases near Gaza on October 7, 2023. About 1,200 people, including more than 700 civilians, were killed, and 251 hostages were taken to Gaza. Israel's military response has devastated the tiny, crowded enclave, killing more than 61,000 people, mostly civilians, according to Palestinian health authorities. Israel has repeatedly said its actions in Gaza are justified as self-defence and accuses Hamas of using civilians as human shields, a charge the militant group denies.
National Post
43 minutes ago
- National Post
Terry Glavin: Synagogue vandalism shows being 'progressive' no shield against antisemitism
Article content Only two weeks ago, Victoria police announced that a 28-year-old man attending one of the anti-Israel rallies at the legislature would be charged with public incitement of hatred, targeting Jews. Khalid El Boyok was arrested June 11. Article content You could say it's somewhat ironic that it was Congregation Emmanu-El's synagogue that was desecrated last weekend. Across town from the legislature, congregants have held their own weekly silent vigils carrying placards bearing the words ' Jews in Mourning for Two Peoples,' expressing dismay at the unprecedented death and destruction in Gaza since Hamas carried out its bloody pogrom in Israel on October 7, 2023. You can be as 'progressive' as you like, and still the antisemites will come after you. Article content Congregation Emmanu-El's vigils are in keeping with the synagogue's long-standing avant-garde traditions. As far back as September, 1895, for lack of a full-time rabbi at the time, the congregation retained a woman, San Francisco Chronicle reporter Rachel 'Ray' Frank, to lecture and officiate for the high Holy Days, decades before women were to be regularly ordained. Article content Article content Last weekend's desecration was just the latest in a series of incidents that have become commonplace in Canada since the Gaza War began nearly two years ago, and while the Netanyahu government's crushing military operations may have deeply divided Israeli society, and Canadian opinion, they have also served as a pretext for the recrudescence of ancient antisemitic hatreds in the guise of 'pro-Palestine' activism. Synagogues have been firebombed and shot at in Vancouver, Montreal and Toronto, and protest groups like Samidoun, which is listed terrorist entity, have been given the run of Canadian cities. Article content 'We have seen a disturbing permissiveness toward these groups in Canada,' said Nico Slobinsky, vice-president of the Centre of Israel and Jewish Affairs. 'Pro-Hamas protesters shut down our streets with chants, threats, and hate, unchecked, unchallenged, and increasingly normalized.' Article content The 150-year-old B'nai Brith organization in Canada says Ottawa has to take some responsibility for this state of affairs. 'You cannot divorce the disgusting antisemitic graffiti found on a synagogue in Victoria, BC, on Shabbat, from the Prime Minister's announcement last week. By declaring its intention to prematurely recognize a Palestinian state, the federal government has further emboldened the vitriolic minority that has been targeting Canada's Jewish community for almost two years. Article content 'This is what happens when our leaders placate those who incite hate and sow division. Synagogues are defiled and Jewish Canadians are threatened.' Article content The most bitter irony in all this is that Congregation Emmanu-El is Canada's oldest synagogue, and from its earliest days Victoria has stood as a beacon of racial and religious toleration. There were perhaps as many Gentiles as Jews among the subscribers to Emmanu-El's construction fundraising drive in the 1860s. Article content Selim Franklin, elected to B.C.'s colonial legislative council in 1859, was the first Jew ever elected to a legislature in Canada. When Lumley Franklin was elected mayor of Victoria in 1865, he became the first Jewish mayor in North America. The year B.C. entered Confederation in 1871, Victoria sent Wharf Street merchant Henry Nathan to Ottawa, Canada's first Jewish Member of Parliament, and an early vice-president of Congregation Emmanu-El was Samuel D. Schultz, the first Jew to be appointed a judge in Canada, in 1914. Article content
National Post
43 minutes ago
- National Post
Michael Higgins: The United Church's abhorrent excuses for October 7
It is loathsome when anyone describes the butchery that happened in Israel on October 7 as an act of 'resistance,' but it is particularly troubling when it comes from people within the United Church of Canada. Article content Such hateful rhetoric can be found in a proposal that will be considered by the church's general council meeting, which starts Thursday. It begins by stating that 'the Gaza genocide is the most recent and most severe expression of the colonialist oppression of the state of Israel upon the Palestinian people.' Article content Article content Article content 'The Palestinians have, from time to time, resisted their oppression by significant use of deadly force,' it continues. 'The largest and most recent expression of this resistance was the October 7th raid into Israeli kibbutzim located along the Gaza border.' Article content Article content How odious to describe the massacre of 1,200 people, including innocent civilians at a music festival, along with mass rape, as an act of resistance. This is the language of terrorists. Article content The proposal goes on to call for a permanent ceasefire, along with other recommendations, but not once does it call for the release of hostages. It is one of seven anti-Israel/pro-Palestinian items on the general council agenda. Other conflicts, such as the one in Sudan, where tens of thousands have died and millions have been displaced, get no mention at all. In an emailed statement to the National Post, Rev. Carmen Lansdowne, the church's moderator and spiritual leader, said proposals to the general council came from various sources and all, or none, could pass. Article content Article content 'The United Church of Canada consistently condemns all acts of violence by all parties in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict,' Lansdowne said. She added that the church had called on the government to secure a ceasefire, ensure the delivery of aid, achieve the release of 'captives, both Israeli and Palestinian,' as well as impose an arms embargo on Israel and end 'Israel's military occupation and annexation of Palestine.' Article content 'There is space, without being antisemitic, for legitimate critique of the current situation in Israel and Palestine that aligns with international law and human rights, and with the legitimate security concerns of the State of Israel,' Lansdowne said. Article content Legitimate critique is one thing, but the proposals are, unfortunately, part of a disturbing pattern from the United Church, which bills itself as the largest Protestant denomination in Canada, ministering to 800,000 people. Article content In a panel discussion in May 2024, Lansdowne echoed a similar point to the 'resistance' proposal when she suggested that Israel had no right to resist the murderous rampages of Hamas. Instead, it had to show restraint.
