
SOPHIE GANNON: Why Harley Reid should not sign a long-term, $20 million deal to stay at West Coast Eagles
I don't think he should do it.
In fact, I think it might be time for him to follow Jason Horne-Francis' lead and, as he so aptly put it to the Port star, 'go back to mummy' by returning to Victoria.
The latest twist in the Reid saga is that his management and the Eagles are considering an 11-year deal — beginning with a two-year contract and the potential to extend for another nine — that would see the 20-year-old star paid $20 million.
And, in what should be music to Eagles fans' ears, Reid and his family have made it clear they do not want the teenager to go to a struggling club in Victoria like St Kilda or Essendon, according to The Agenda Setters' Caroline Wilson.
But while he may not want to move to another sinking ship, how long is he prepared to stay on the one he finds himself at the wheel of already?
As it stands, West Coast are a mess. A historically bad mess.
I don't blame Reid if he's impatient to play in a competitive and relevant football team. After all, he entered the league in a truly unique circumstance.
He was a household name six months before being drafted and the most recognisable person in Perth at the age of 18. He's had to put up with more than anybody else in the league. And for what? Six wins in his first two years.
And with rumours continuing to swirl around Reid going to Hawthorn — a club on the rise that oozes the same brash attitude that is Reid's trademark — they loom as the most obvious destination for a player reportedly keen to join a team that's not mired in a long rebuild.
The Hawks are reportedly willing to offer Reid a contract of eight to ten years at $1.7 to $1.8 million per season, making them his most likely landing point if he leaves Perth.
In February, Reid was pictured sharing a laugh with Hawthorn coach Sam Mitchell at ex-Eagles star, now Hawk, Tom Barrass's wedding, which had tongues wagging that Reid was already being fitted out for his brown and yellow jersey.
So if Reid can get pretty much the same money at Hawthorn for the same period, why would his management put forward the idea of a long-term deal for their star client to stay at a club that has only won one game this season, sits last on the ladder, and doesn't have a quick fix coming?
If history is anything to go by, the Eagles' rebuild is likely to take a decade. If Reid wants to follow Patrick Cripps's example and wait until he's 28 to play his first final, then he should stay an Eagle.
But I just can't see that happening. There are some young superstars who may have the temperament to see out a rebuild this brutal.
It's clear that Reid is not one of them.
He is a fierce competitor. We know this. We've known since the first day he stepped onto an AFL field. He plays right on the edge—and often goes over it.
It's when he plays his best, when the lights are brightest. Problem is, the Eagles aren't going to be playing when the lights are brightest in September for a long time.
Eagles coach Andrew McQualter said after their loss against Richmond that Reid carries their midfield—a clear message to the rest of the team that also puts more pressure on Reid.
Reid, like Horne-Francis, is at his best when he's pushing the boundaries, as their recent fiery battle showed. But Reid's passionate approach on the field is only turning into frustration.
Champion Data recently revealed that Reid was the lowest-rated player in the AFL over the last six weeks prior to Round 19 — not because he is the worst football player, but because of turnovers and 50-metre penalties.
For a player with his talent and ability, this is outrageous. It is clear that the football environment in WA is getting the worst out of Reid, despite a season-best game against the Power this month.
This season he has already racked up 54 free kicks against — the most of any player — and in his 38-game career, he's been fined 13 times.
I know Eagles fans won't like it, but Reid doesn't owe them a career. He came, gave them hope, and provided a spark few of his teammates have been able to make the most of.
The club is not in the state to foster his generational talent. It looks as if it's burning it out.
A long-term deal holding Reid to the club for most of his career is probably not in his best interest, and he may want to be traded a few years into it. So West Coast are probably best to cash in his trade value this off-season.
It just might be the right time for Reid to go home to mummy.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles

Sky News AU
an hour ago
- Sky News AU
Mitchell explains shock Newcombe substitution in Hawks win
Travel and the importance of Hawthorn's upcoming clash with Adelaide was behind coach Sam Mitchell removing star Jai Newcombe from Thursday night's game. Newcombe was forced to pass a fitness test on Wednesday and was substituted out of Hawthorn's 24-point win over Carlton at the MCG. But Mitchell said Newcombe's calf was completely fine and was taken out of the match with one eye on the Crows next week. Hawthorn and Adelaide played a thriller in Launceston earlier this year and only percentage separates them in third and fourth. '(Newcombe) had a bit of a tight calf, we had a five-day break, he did a fitness test before the captain's run yesterday and passed that so he was no worries,' Mitchell said. 'We've got travel, we go over to Adelaide on Friday night next week, it's obviously going to be a massive game for us and them as well. 'That's the game we want our players fresh and ready, and if we've got the chance to take Jai out and get some game time into others, him a freshen up, we thought that was a win. 'He could've kept playing, I actually asked him, got on the phone with him and said, 'How are you feeling mate?' And he goes, 'Yeah that might not be a bad idea'. 'He will certainly play next week, he'll be fine.' The decision to sub Newcombe was softened by the return of Will Day. Day had 15 disposals in limited game time, showing glimpses of the early-season form that catapulted him to Brownlow Medal discussions. 'The first four or five games of the season was when he went out and they tagged him in his first game back so that just shows how Carlton feel about him,' Mitchell said. '70 per cent game time was the marker and I think he finished on 69, we're really pleased we were able to get him through the game. 'He plays the game in a certain way, I think everyone likes the way Will Day plays especially because he's probably not built for playing it like that. 'I think sometimes he's got a loveable demeanour about him, he did a couple of things tonight where you're like, 'Oh yeah, there it is'. 'He will obviously be better for playing the game.' Originally published as Hawthorn star Jai Newcombe was subbed off the MCG out of caution with more big games ahead

News.com.au
3 hours ago
- News.com.au
Hawthorn star Jai Newcombe was subbed off the MCG out of caution with more big games ahead
Travel and the importance of Hawthorn's upcoming clash with Adelaide was behind coach Sam Mitchell removing star Jai Newcombe from Thursday night's game. Newcombe was forced to pass a fitness test on Wednesday and was substituted out of Hawthorn's 25-point win over Carlton at the MCG. But Mitchell said Newcombe's calf was completely fine and was taken out of the match with one eye on the Crows next week. Hawthorn and Adelaide played a thriller in Launceston earlier this year and only percentage separates them in third and fourth. '(Newcombe) had a bit of a tight calf, we had a five-day break, he did a fitness test before the captain's run yesterday and passed that so he was no worries,' Mitchell said. 'We've got travel, we go over to Adelaide on Friday night next week, it's obviously going to be a massive game for us and them as well. 'That's the game we want our players fresh and ready, and if we've got the chance to take Jai out and get some game time into others, him a freshen up, we thought that was a win. 'He could've kept playing, I actually asked him, got on the phone with him and said, 'How are you feeling mate?' And he goes, 'Yeah that might not be a bad idea'. 'He will certainly play next week, he'll be fine.' The decision to sub Newcombe was softened by the return of Will Day. Day had 15 disposals in limited game time, showing glimpses of the early-season form that catapulted him to Brownlow Medal discussions. 'The first four or five games of the season was when he went out and they tagged him in his first game back so that just shows how Carlton feel about him,' Mitchell said. '70 per cent game time was the marker and I think he finished on 69, we're really pleased we were able to get him through the game. 'He plays the game in a certain way, I think everyone likes the way Will Day plays especially because he's probably not built for playing it like that. 'I think sometimes he's got a loveable demeanour about him, he did a couple of things tonight where you're like, 'Oh yeah, there it is'. 'He will obviously be better for playing the game.'


The Advertiser
5 hours ago
- The Advertiser
Blues star Curnow responds to AFL trade rumours
Carlton star Charlie Curnow has declared he isn't going anywhere, emphatically shutting down AFL trade speculation. Curnow has this week been linked to Gold Coast, Sydney and Geelong as the Blues limp towards the end of a horror season. But the 28-year-old on Thursday night denied reports he had sought a move away from Ikon Park. "I obviously want to be here," Curnow told reporters after the Blues' 13.7 (85) to 9.7 (61) defeat to Hawthorn. "I don't really want to make this about me right now, but I'm playing at Carlton next year. There you go. Done." A two-time Coleman Medal winner, Curnow has another four years left to run on his lucrative deal with Carlton. Blues coach Michael Voss said the spearhead's future had not been a talking point internally this week, while Curnow rubbished reports he had told the club he is keen to explore his options. "No, nothing has happened," Curnow said. "I'm just putting all of my time into playing footy at this club for the next year and the future years." Carlton will miss the finals for the first time since 2022, sitting 12th with a 7-12 record. The slide down the ladder has cast doubt over Voss' future as coach, and comes in a year when long-suffering Blues fans had dared to dream of the club ending a 30-year premiership drought. Curnow said he appreciated the frustration Carlton supporters are feeling, but urged them to stay the course. "It's a hard one to cop for them, I know," Curnow said. "Just grow with us, have fun with us. We're trying hard out there. "We do really want to have a crack for them. Just stick with us and something good will happen." Curnow has kicked 32 goals in 18 games this year, failing to reclaim his best form after undergoing knee and ankle surgeries during the pre-season. "That probably lingered around at the start of the season for me," he said. "I tried to find my feet, but I feel like as a team we haven't really found our feet also. That's been obvious." Curnow had a brief moment of enjoyment after the Hawthorn loss, when retiring stalwart Sam Docherty and 200-game defender Jacob Weitering were chaired off the MCG. Carlton captain Patrick Cripps joined Hawks assistant coach and former Blues teammate Kade Simpson in hoisting Docherty onto their shoulders. "It's nice to be able to enjoy something like tonight," Curnow said. "It was a pretty awesome moment with Kade Simpson coming off at the boundary. It was pretty good to watch." Carlton star Charlie Curnow has declared he isn't going anywhere, emphatically shutting down AFL trade speculation. Curnow has this week been linked to Gold Coast, Sydney and Geelong as the Blues limp towards the end of a horror season. But the 28-year-old on Thursday night denied reports he had sought a move away from Ikon Park. "I obviously want to be here," Curnow told reporters after the Blues' 13.7 (85) to 9.7 (61) defeat to Hawthorn. "I don't really want to make this about me right now, but I'm playing at Carlton next year. There you go. Done." A two-time Coleman Medal winner, Curnow has another four years left to run on his lucrative deal with Carlton. Blues coach Michael Voss said the spearhead's future had not been a talking point internally this week, while Curnow rubbished reports he had told the club he is keen to explore his options. "No, nothing has happened," Curnow said. "I'm just putting all of my time into playing footy at this club for the next year and the future years." Carlton will miss the finals for the first time since 2022, sitting 12th with a 7-12 record. The slide down the ladder has cast doubt over Voss' future as coach, and comes in a year when long-suffering Blues fans had dared to dream of the club ending a 30-year premiership drought. Curnow said he appreciated the frustration Carlton supporters are feeling, but urged them to stay the course. "It's a hard one to cop for them, I know," Curnow said. "Just grow with us, have fun with us. We're trying hard out there. "We do really want to have a crack for them. Just stick with us and something good will happen." Curnow has kicked 32 goals in 18 games this year, failing to reclaim his best form after undergoing knee and ankle surgeries during the pre-season. "That probably lingered around at the start of the season for me," he said. "I tried to find my feet, but I feel like as a team we haven't really found our feet also. That's been obvious." Curnow had a brief moment of enjoyment after the Hawthorn loss, when retiring stalwart Sam Docherty and 200-game defender Jacob Weitering were chaired off the MCG. Carlton captain Patrick Cripps joined Hawks assistant coach and former Blues teammate Kade Simpson in hoisting Docherty onto their shoulders. "It's nice to be able to enjoy something like tonight," Curnow said. "It was a pretty awesome moment with Kade Simpson coming off at the boundary. It was pretty good to watch." Carlton star Charlie Curnow has declared he isn't going anywhere, emphatically shutting down AFL trade speculation. Curnow has this week been linked to Gold Coast, Sydney and Geelong as the Blues limp towards the end of a horror season. But the 28-year-old on Thursday night denied reports he had sought a move away from Ikon Park. "I obviously want to be here," Curnow told reporters after the Blues' 13.7 (85) to 9.7 (61) defeat to Hawthorn. "I don't really want to make this about me right now, but I'm playing at Carlton next year. There you go. Done." A two-time Coleman Medal winner, Curnow has another four years left to run on his lucrative deal with Carlton. Blues coach Michael Voss said the spearhead's future had not been a talking point internally this week, while Curnow rubbished reports he had told the club he is keen to explore his options. "No, nothing has happened," Curnow said. "I'm just putting all of my time into playing footy at this club for the next year and the future years." Carlton will miss the finals for the first time since 2022, sitting 12th with a 7-12 record. The slide down the ladder has cast doubt over Voss' future as coach, and comes in a year when long-suffering Blues fans had dared to dream of the club ending a 30-year premiership drought. Curnow said he appreciated the frustration Carlton supporters are feeling, but urged them to stay the course. "It's a hard one to cop for them, I know," Curnow said. "Just grow with us, have fun with us. We're trying hard out there. "We do really want to have a crack for them. Just stick with us and something good will happen." Curnow has kicked 32 goals in 18 games this year, failing to reclaim his best form after undergoing knee and ankle surgeries during the pre-season. "That probably lingered around at the start of the season for me," he said. "I tried to find my feet, but I feel like as a team we haven't really found our feet also. That's been obvious." Curnow had a brief moment of enjoyment after the Hawthorn loss, when retiring stalwart Sam Docherty and 200-game defender Jacob Weitering were chaired off the MCG. Carlton captain Patrick Cripps joined Hawks assistant coach and former Blues teammate Kade Simpson in hoisting Docherty onto their shoulders. "It's nice to be able to enjoy something like tonight," Curnow said. "It was a pretty awesome moment with Kade Simpson coming off at the boundary. It was pretty good to watch."