logo
SOPHIE GANNON: Why Harley Reid should not sign a long-term, $20 million deal to stay at West Coast Eagles

SOPHIE GANNON: Why Harley Reid should not sign a long-term, $20 million deal to stay at West Coast Eagles

West Australian22-07-2025
It's the kind of rumour that makes West Coast fans cling to hope: Harley Reid willing to sign a huge contract that would keep him at the club beyond the next decade.
I don't think he should do it.
In fact, I think it might be time for him to follow Jason Horne-Francis' lead and, as he so aptly put it to the Port star, 'go back to mummy' by returning to Victoria.
The latest twist in the Reid saga is that his management and the Eagles are considering an 11-year deal — beginning with a two-year contract and the potential to extend for another nine — that would see the 20-year-old star paid $20 million.
And, in what should be music to Eagles fans' ears, Reid and his family have made it clear they do not want the teenager to go to a struggling club in Victoria like St Kilda or Essendon, according to The Agenda Setters' Caroline Wilson.
But while he may not want to move to another sinking ship, how long is he prepared to stay on the one he finds himself at the wheel of already?
As it stands, West Coast are a mess. A historically bad mess.
I don't blame Reid if he's impatient to play in a competitive and relevant football team. After all, he entered the league in a truly unique circumstance.
He was a household name six months before being drafted and the most recognisable person in Perth at the age of 18. He's had to put up with more than anybody else in the league. And for what? Six wins in his first two years.
And with rumours continuing to swirl around Reid going to Hawthorn — a club on the rise that oozes the same brash attitude that is Reid's trademark — they loom as the most obvious destination for a player reportedly keen to join a team that's not mired in a long rebuild.
The Hawks are reportedly willing to offer Reid a contract of eight to ten years at $1.7 to $1.8 million per season, making them his most likely landing point if he leaves Perth.
In February, Reid was pictured sharing a laugh with Hawthorn coach Sam Mitchell at ex-Eagles star, now Hawk, Tom Barrass's wedding, which had tongues wagging that Reid was already being fitted out for his brown and yellow jersey.
So if Reid can get pretty much the same money at Hawthorn for the same period, why would his management put forward the idea of a long-term deal for their star client to stay at a club that has only won one game this season, sits last on the ladder, and doesn't have a quick fix coming?
If history is anything to go by, the Eagles' rebuild is likely to take a decade. If Reid wants to follow Patrick Cripps's example and wait until he's 28 to play his first final, then he should stay an Eagle.
But I just can't see that happening. There are some young superstars who may have the temperament to see out a rebuild this brutal.
It's clear that Reid is not one of them.
He is a fierce competitor. We know this. We've known since the first day he stepped onto an AFL field. He plays right on the edge—and often goes over it.
It's when he plays his best, when the lights are brightest. Problem is, the Eagles aren't going to be playing when the lights are brightest in September for a long time.
Eagles coach Andrew McQualter said after their loss against Richmond that Reid carries their midfield—a clear message to the rest of the team that also puts more pressure on Reid.
Reid, like Horne-Francis, is at his best when he's pushing the boundaries, as their recent fiery battle showed. But Reid's passionate approach on the field is only turning into frustration.
Champion Data recently revealed that Reid was the lowest-rated player in the AFL over the last six weeks prior to Round 19 — not because he is the worst football player, but because of turnovers and 50-metre penalties.
For a player with his talent and ability, this is outrageous. It is clear that the football environment in WA is getting the worst out of Reid, despite a season-best game against the Power this month.
This season he has already racked up 54 free kicks against — the most of any player — and in his 38-game career, he's been fined 13 times.
I know Eagles fans won't like it, but Reid doesn't owe them a career. He came, gave them hope, and provided a spark few of his teammates have been able to make the most of.
The club is not in the state to foster his generational talent. It looks as if it's burning it out.
A long-term deal holding Reid to the club for most of his career is probably not in his best interest, and he may want to be traded a few years into it. So West Coast are probably best to cash in his trade value this off-season.
It just might be the right time for Reid to go home to mummy.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Shane Crawford fights back tears as he opens up on death of his brother
Shane Crawford fights back tears as he opens up on death of his brother

News.com.au

timean hour ago

  • News.com.au

Shane Crawford fights back tears as he opens up on death of his brother

Hawthorn legend Shane Crawford was left fighting back tears as he spoke about his younger brother's suicide. Justin died in 2022 at the age of 45 in a moment that left the entire Crawford family heartbroken. FOX FOOTY, available on Kayo Sports, is the only place to watch every match of every round in the 2025 Toyota AFL Premiership Season LIVE in 4K, with no ad-breaks during play. New to Kayo? Join now and get your first month for just $1. As he looks to shine a light on mental health struggles, the 305-game player spoke about the struggles he has endured since losing his brother. 'It's just like a wild storm that's just thrown into your face and you just don't know how to sort of move through it,' Crawford told Mike Amor on 7News. 'When I heard the news from my mother, and it took a full day for my mother to communicate with me. 'You have days where...,' he says before pausing as the emotion hits. '... where you look for answers and they're not there.' The two brothers shared their childhood dream of running out for an AFL game together when Justin joined Shane at Hawthorn in 1997. Those memories are ones Shane often reflects on and says he has a simple message if his brother was still around. 'I was very proud of him and probably needed to tell him more,' he said. 'I'd tell him he's always been loved and cherished and to grow into an old man.' Shane said Justin had left notes behind explaining everything that he was going through. 'We were lucky because we had a few little notes that were left and, it doesn't make it easier, probably not, but there were a few things there that explained a little bit about how he was feeling and a little of him explaining how much loved and thanked everyone for helping. 'He adored his son and it was such an unbelievable relationship, to know he didn't feel worthy enough to be around for that. He was obviously well and truly over the cliff.' Justin played four seasons in the AFL after being selected by the Swans before the 1994 AFL Draft, he went on to tally a total of 46 games for the Swans and Hawks were he kicked a total of 32 goals.

One top pick out, one top pick in! Chesser set for return
One top pick out, one top pick in! Chesser set for return

Perth Now

time3 hours ago

  • Perth Now

One top pick out, one top pick in! Chesser set for return

Out-of-contract West Coast midfielder Campbell Chesser will play his first AFL game of the season this weekend when the one-win Eagles take on Melbourne at Marvel Stadium. It comes as the Eagles prepare to take on seven-time All-Australian ruckman Matt Gawn without their No.1 man Matt Flynn who has been dropped leaving Bailey Williams as the solo ruck. The West Australian revealed Chesser would be named in Saturday's line-up to take on the Demons, having featured in the past seven games for the club's WAFL outfit after an ankle injury in February hindered his start to the season. Chesser had 20 disposals in Sunday's defeat to Peel to put his hand up for his first senior game this season. After being West Coast's top draft selection at pick 14 in 2021, Chesser has been luckless throughout his career at West Coast, playing only 32 games in his four seasons. The 22-year-old midfielder last featured at AFL level in round 24 last year. Chesser's most recent AFL win — and one of only six for his career — came against Melbourne at Optus Stadium last May. 'He's had some challenging years and he's been able to build a platform of eight or 10 games of WAFL football and given himself a chance to finish off the year really strongly so yeah, he gets his opportunity,' Eagles coach Andrew McQualter said. Chesser in action last season. Credit: Quinn Rooney / Getty Images 'There was a period where he just had to play, that was important for him just to string some games together. And then, you know, when he started mid-year, he hadn't played under the way that we're playing our wing roll at the moment. 'So he's learnt that, he's improved in that understanding of the game, and it was a bit about continuity and then building up his form from there.' It comes as top draftee Tom Gross is also set to return to the side to help cover the loss of superstar Harley Reid after his season was ended by a syndesmosis injury he sustained in the western derby. Gross has played six games since he was drafted with pick No.46 last season, with the last of those coming in the round 11 defeat to Adelaide. The 18-year-old is coming off a strong game in the WAFL, kicking two goals from 23 disposals as well as recording five clearances in the loss to Peel. Chesser's pending inclusion means the Eagles will have used 37 players this year. Just three players on West Coast's list are yet to debut at the top level: Lucca Grego, Coen Livingstone and mid-season draftee Jacob Newton. He was joined on the plane by out-of-contract pair Jack Petruccelle and Loch Rawlinson however, both have been named as emergencies. Instead, Hamish Davis and 200cm defender Harry Edwards, who was a late out from the derby on Saturday because of a hamstring concern, have returned to the line-up. Jack Petruccelle is back in the Eagles squad. Credit: Justin Benson-Cooper / The West Australian It will be Davis' first game since round seven while defender, Sandy Brock and Jack Hutchinson, join Reid out of the team that lost the western derby to Fremantle. WEST COAST v MELBOURNE Saturday, Marvel, 11.20am EAGLES B: R Ginbey H Edwards T Cole HB: L Duggan R Bazzo T McCarthy C: R Maric B Hough C Hall' HF: J Cripps J Shanahan E Hewett F: T Borckman A Reid L Ryan FOLL: B Williams T Kelly L Baker I/C: M Owies C Chesser T Gross H Davis T Dewar EMG: J Petruccelle M Flynn L Rawlinson IN: H Edwards C Chesser T Gross H Davis OUT: S Brock (omitted) J Hutchinson (omitted) M Flynn (omitted) H Reid (injured) DEMONS B: J Bowey T McDonald J McVee HB: C Windsor D Turner B Howes C: K Chandler C Petracca H Langford HF: J Viney B Fritsch T Sparrow F: J Melksham H Petty K Pickett FOLL: M Gawn T Rivers E Langdon I/C: J van Rooyen C Salem C Oliver H Sharp J Culley EMG: X Lindsay J Adams T Campbell IN: H Sharp J Culley OUT: X Lindsay (managed) C Spargo (omitted)

Carlton announce Charlie Curnow's season ended by another knee operation
Carlton announce Charlie Curnow's season ended by another knee operation

West Australian

time4 hours ago

  • West Australian

Carlton announce Charlie Curnow's season ended by another knee operation

Carlton have announced Charlie Curnow's season is over after it was decided the key forward required 'necessary' knee surgery. The 28-year-old, who has a long history of knee troubles, reported soreness after last Thursday's loss to Hawthorn. Curnow was adamant last week that he would not require surgery despite his issues this year. But the call to go under the knife comes after he missed the start of the 2025 campaign following a knee operation in December last year. In a statement on Thursday night, Carlton football boss Brad Lloyd said Curnow 'wanted to finish the season' but the club overruled the key forward. 'We would have loved to have him out there for the remaining games,' Lloyd said. 'After further consultation this week it became clear that this would give Charlie the best chance to get himself right, recover fully over the off-season and be ready for when we return for the start of pre-season. 'Waiting until the end of the season could have impacted that, so we've taken the sensible approach.' Curnow was already expected to miss Carlton's clash with Fremantle in Perth on Sunday prior to the surgery decision. Curnow missed two years of football across 2019-21 with knee injuries before he returned to become a dual Coleman medallist. But his 2025 campaign ends with 32 goals to his name from 18 appearances for a struggling Blues side that has long been out of finals contention. Curnow recently shut down speculation that he could request a trade, following reports he entertained the idea of moving to the Gold Coast Suns. 'I obviously want to be here,' Curnow said. 'I don't really want to make this about me right now, but I'm playing at Carlton next year. There you go. Done.' Curnow is under contract until 2029. His commitment, should it hold through the trade period, would be a boost with the Blues still uncertain if Tom De Koning will stick fat or take up a monster offer to join St Kilda. Pundits have also previously suggested Carlton should consider trading Curnow's partner in crime Harry McKay, who is locked in until 2030, at the end of the season.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store