Cull order on B.C. ostriches a ‘one-size-fits-all' approach, federal appeals court hears
A lawyer representing Universal Ostrich Farms, Umar Sheikh, argued at a hearing held by the Federal Court of Appeal that the Canadian Food Inspection Agency plans to apply a 'one-size-fits-all' approach to execute its 'stamping out policy' on the flock. The policy sees birds exposed to avian influenza killed. The virus is a public health concern that scientists fear could develop into a human pandemic.
Since April, 2022, the CFIA has killed more than 8.7 million birds in B.C. and 14.5 million nationally in an attempt to contain further spread of the virus. The agency says its approach is consistent with federal legislation and aligns with guidelines from the World Organisation for Animal Health, which co-ordinates animal disease control measures.
B.C. farmers appear in court to get reprieve for ostriches ordered culled over avian flu concerns
Opinion: Canada wants to kill 400 ostriches. Sadly, it's the right thing to do
Tuesday's hearing, which is the result of a challenge to a May Federal Court decision that upheld the CFIA's position to cull the ostriches, is the latest development in a tussle over the flock's fate.
The birds have a wide net of supporters who want to see them saved, including the highest-ranking health officials south of the border. On the other hand, they are of particular concern to the Canadian government: the National Centre for Foreign Animal Disease identified the birds as having a genotype not otherwise seen in Canada, linked to a human infection of an Ohio poultry worker.
In December, an outbreak began on the farm in Edgewood, a remote community in B.C., and 69 ostriches in the flock of 468 died. In late January, the CFIA said the surviving members would be depopulated, meaning they would be killed.
Mr. Sheikh told the court only two surviving ostriches have been tested and 93 per cent of the flock has survived since their exposure to avian influenza. Ostriches differ from chickens and have a greater chance of surviving the virus, he added, noting the birds are still alive today.
Lawyers representing the CFIA's position also made submissions to court Tuesday, including on the agency's stamping out policy, which the Federal Court determined to be reasonable. Counsel said the two ostriches tested were positive for avian influenza and the agency's policy is designed to mitigate the spread of the virus.
The lawyers also told court that failing to adhere to the policy carries negative trade implications and the agency has considered, but ultimately rejected, a different approach after conducting an analysis.
The flock's supporters are not backing down.
On the weekend, a fundraiser was held that included a musical performance made by Tamara Lich. She was the central organizer of the 2022 Ottawa convoy, where demonstrators with big-rig trucks stayed in the city for more than three weeks and vocalized opposition to COVID-19 vaccination mandates. Ms. Lich, found guilty of mischief in April in connection with those events, posted on X that she was thrilled to play a small part in the fundraiser.
The birds also received backing from Robert F. Kennedy Jr., the U.S. Secretary of Health and Human Services, who wrote to CFIA President Paul MacKinnon earlier this year. He said the birds could offer insight for new vaccines and therapeutics. Dr. Mehmet Oz, a former TV personality who now leads medicare in the U.S., also offered sanctuary for the birds on his Florida ranch.
The farm's owners say the ostriches are like family and they wish to keep them in B.C. Some, such as one named Q-Tip because of his big, fluffy head, have been with them for more than two decades. In recent weeks, dozens of supporters have travelled to the site.
One supporter is a 13-year-old teenager from Fraser Valley, B.C., who became Canada's first domestically acquired case of avian flu last fall. She visited the farm with her parents in May.
'They don't deserve to die,' said the young woman, only identified as Joselynn, in an appearance captured by B.C. television reporters.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBC
an hour ago
- CBC
Ontario announces funding for Windsor physicians providing care to the unhoused in shelters
The Ontario government has committed up to $3.8 million to a physician group in Windsor that provides health-care services to people in homeless shelters in the city and to some people who have housing but require support. The money has allowed Windsor Shelter Health Associates to expand from two physicians working a total of around nine hours a week to 11 physicians working six days a week, said medical director Jennifer Bondy. It's also allowed them to build a team of family physicians, addiction medicine physicians, palliative care physicians, an infectious disease physician and psychiatry, Bondy said. "I used to see a lot of wound care at the very beginning before we were funded in any way," Bondy told reporters at an event Wednesday announcing the funding, which she said began flowing at the start of 2024. "Now we are able to regularly see people for their continuous care needs like diabetes, for example. Or if they might have a primary psychiatric diagnosis, we can see them for their schizophrenia, for example, and really make a dent in the care delivery." Bondy began providing services to unhoused people in 2021, partly as a volunteer and partly while working for the Canadian Mental Health Association, she told CBC. New funding model Another physician joined a couple of years ago, she said. Then at the start of 2024, Bondy's service received recognition under a new provincial funding model called the Homeless Shelter Alternate Payment Plan, which does not require patients to roster with physicians and which compensates physicians both for their time and for the complexity of their patients' needs, she said. "We've been able to go from three half-day clinics a week to multiple half-day clinics across five different sites," she said. Shelter Health serves people at the Salvation Army Men's Emergency Shelter, the Homelessness and Housing Help Hub (H4), the Welcome Centre Shelter for Women and Families, the Downtown Mission of Windsor, and Journey Home Hospice, according to a news release from the province. It also provides services to people who have housing but require support. Shelter Health secured Interprofessional Primary Care Team Funding through Ontario Health in the spring of 2024 to supplement the physician funding, Bondy said. That funding flows through the Canadian Mental Health Association (CMHA), she added. CMHA Windsor CEO Nicole Sbrocca said providing health care in shelters isn't just compassionate; it's evidence-based. "When care meets people where they are at, we prevent crises," she said at the news conference. "We build trust, and we contribute to healthier individuals and a stronger community." Program getting results: mental health association CEO Over the past fiscal year, the interprofessional team has provided more than 5,000 visits across the shelter sites, Sbrocca said. Physicians see an average of 200 unique patients per month. What's more, she said, there has been a reduction in emergency department use for issues that are being addressed on site in the shelters, and doctors are seeing an improvement in medication adherence. There have also been success stories, Sbrocca said. "We have attached nearly 200 people to primary care," she said. "We've achieved housing for individuals, and we have made meaningful steps forward in terms of wellness and recovery on an individual basis." Asked what the funding means to the program, Bondy told reporters it means "sustainability." "It means that we are going to be able to continue to provide services," she said. "We know we can future plan, and we can ensure that we have programs that are developed with our partners knowing that we're going to be able to continue to do the work that we're doing." Last month, the Windsor Essex By-Names Prioritized List for housing showed 899 households were experiencing some form of homelessness, of which 682 households, or 75.8 per cent, were experiencing long-term or chronic homelessness, according to data provided by the City of Windsor.
CTV News
an hour ago
- CTV News
M.D. of Opportunity offering to pay AHS to transport the dead as bodies lay on the side of the road for hours
The M.D. of Opportunity, a remote municipal district in northern Alberta, is penning a letter to Alberta Health Services (AHS), offering to pay for ambulances to transport people who die in the community to the hospital. They figure this will cost the M.D. around $500 per person and be well worth it. Coun. Darlene Jackson added the item to council's July 9 meeting agenda, because two young men had died in the community recently near a main road in Wabasca. Their bodies lay there, she said, covered with a blanket with their shoes sticking out for six hours. Jackson said she drove past with her grandchildren, who were traumatized. It was also hard on her, she told her council colleagues, and she can't imagine what it was like for the family. 'It's sad and unacceptable,' she said. The reason the bodies lay there for so long, Jackson explained, is that AHS ambulances are no longer allowed to transport dead people. In the past, the ambulance would transport the body, the staff would clean them up, and the family would be allowed to view the body. Viewing the body is important for Cree culture, she added. Reeve Marcel Auger had also driven past the scene as described and could see the effect that seeing the bodies had on his young nephews, who were in the car. 'They get traumatized by it,' he said. 'They know what they are seeing.' The only people allowed to touch the bodies are undertakers or coroners, said Kimball Newberry, Opportunity's acting chief administrative officer. However, the nearest undertakers are in Slave Lake, Athabasca and High Prairie. Slave Lake and Athabasca are both about an hour and half. High Prairie is two hours and forty minutes. Neither case was suspicious, so the body didn't have to stay there for the police to investigate, Jackson said. One died from health reasons by the fishing dock. The other died in a quadding collision. The families weren't even allowed to see the bodies. 'That's been a thing for a number of years,' said Coun. Tahirih Wiebe. In 2018, when her step-father was dying at home (which is what he wanted), the hospital told the family they would be responsible for transporting the body to the hospital. Thankfully, he didn't die at home, she said, otherwise she'd never have used her car again, after transporting him. 'I don't even know if the hospital will take them,' said Wiebe. Council agreed that something needed to be done about the situation. Coun. Gerald Johnson said he knew of a woman who cradled her dead child in the ditch after an accident for hours, waiting for the coroner. The police kept her safe with their vehicles, but couldn't move the body. Coun. Robin Guild suggested writing a letter to AHS. 'It's not right for the bodies to sit there for six hours,' he said. 'I don't understand why,' said Wiebe. 'If you're waiting for an investigator it is one thing.' She mentioned a man who froze to death in another community who was left there for hours. As a temporary measure, Auger suggested that the M.D. ask police if they have a pop-up tent they could put over people and maybe a fan to keep the body cool when it is hot. Wiebe said the M.D. fire department responds to calls, so they could maybe set up the tent. Pearl Lorentzen, Local Journalism Initiative Reporter, Lakeside Leader
CTV News
an hour ago
- CTV News
Blue-green algae warning issued for Pigeon Lake
Signs have been posted around Pigeon Lake, south west of Edmonton, warning residents and visitors to avoid the water, due to a blue-green algae advisory. Monday, July 30. Alberta Health Services (AHS) has issued a blue-green algae advisory for Pigeon Lake. Exposure to blue-green algae, also known as cyanobacteria, can cause skin irritation, rash, sore throat, sore red eyes, swollen lips, fever, nausea, vomiting and/or diarrhea. It can be fatal to pets. AHS says that visitors should avoid all contact with blue-green algae blooms and to wash with tap water as soon as contact occurs. It is advised not to swim or wade or to allow pets to do so in areas where blue-green algae is visible. While it is recommended to limit human consumption of whole fish or fish trimmings from the lake, filets are still safe. Do not feed whole fish, fish filets or fish trimmings from the lake to pets. Blue-green algae is naturally occurring and can often look like scum, grass clippings, fuzz or globs on the surface of water. It can be blue-green, greenish-brown, brown and/or pinkish-red, and often smell musty or grassy. Waters of Pigeon Lake can still be used for recreational purposes where blue-green algae blooms are not visible. Pigeon Lake is located about 70 kilometres southwest of Edmonton.
