‘Troubling' courts service IT bug ‘extremely serious'
The BBC has reported that it took HM Courts & Tribunals Service (HMCTS) several years to react to the bug, which is said to have caused evidence to go missing, be overwritten or appear lost, resulting in judges in civil, family and tribunal courts making rulings on cases when evidence was potentially incomplete.
HMCTS said there is no evidence to suggest any case outcomes were affected as a result of the issues.
The bug was found in case-management software used by HMCTS and the Social Security and Child Support (SSCS) Tribunal, which handles benefit appeals, is thought to have been most affected, the BBC said.
Referred to as Judicial Case Manager, MyHMCTS or CCD, the BBC said the software is used to manage evidence and track cases, and is used by judges, lawyers, case workers and members of the public.
Documents seen by the BBC show the bug caused data to be obscured from view, meaning some evidence was sometimes not visible as part of case files used in court.
The BBC said a leaked internal report said HMCTS did not know the full extent of the data corruption, including whether or how it had affected cases.
Alex Chalk, former lord chancellor and former justice secretary, said what has happened is 'incredibly serious' and could have involved cases which determine whether a child is taken into care.
'So unbelievably serious. And, so the whistle blowers indicate, it could potentially have bled into other tribunals as well, whether it deals with divorce and so on.
'And the thing that is so troubling is that this report evidently got on to the desk of the senior leadership of HMCTS in March 2024 when I was in office, and it was never brought to my attention.
'And I am incredibly troubled by that, because any lord chancellor, of any stripe, if they discover that there's potentially a situation in the courts which is leading to injustice, then you will immediately want to investigate that, and yet in effect that was covered up and I'm afraid I think that is extremely serious,' Mr Chalk told BBC Radio 4's Today programme.
The BBC said several sources within HMCTS have likened the situation to the Horizon Post Office scandal.
Mr Chalk was asked on the Radio 4 Today programme if what has happened could be compared to the Post Office scandal, and he said: 'It could be.'
An HMCTS spokesperson said: 'Our internal investigation found no evidence that any case outcomes were affected as a result of these technical issues.
'The digitisation of our systems is vital to bring courts and tribunals into the modern era and provide quicker, simpler access to justice for all those who use our services.
'We will continue to press ahead with our important modernisation.'
It is understood that while the bug resulted in some documents not being accessible to users on the digital platform, they were in fact always present on the system.
It is also understood that because of a number of 'fail-safes', parties and judges involved in these cases always had access to the documents they needed.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
23 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Bid to increase sentence of Bhim Kohli's teenage killer to be heard next week
A bid to have the sentence of a teenage boy who killed elderly dog walker Bhim Kohli increased is due to be heard at the Court of Appeal on Wednesday. Mr Kohli, 80, was punched and kicked, slapped in the face with a shoe and racially abused in an attack in Franklin Park, Braunstone Town, near Leicester, on September 1 last year, and died the next day. The teenager, who cannot be named for legal reasons, was convicted of manslaughter and sentenced to seven years' custody in June, when he was aged 15. The Attorney General's Office (AGO) announced in July that the Solicitor General, Lucy Rigby, had referred the sentence to the Court of Appeal under the unduly lenient sentence scheme. Court listings show that the bid to increase the sentence is due to be heard at the Court of Appeal in London on Wednesday, with the boy also seeking to appeal against his sentence at the same hearing. The boy was convicted of manslaughter, but cleared of murder, following a trial at Leicester Crown Court. He was convicted alongside a 13-year-old girl, who encouraged the attack by filming parts of it while laughing. The girl had filmed a series of video clips in which Mr Kohli was hit with the shoe by the balaclava-clad boy and another where the elderly man lay motionless on the ground. Mr Kohli's children found him lying on the ground in agony when he told his daughter that he had been called a 'P***' during the attack. The girl, who also cannot be named, was sentenced to a three-year youth rehabilitation order by Mr Justice Turner, but her sentence has not been referred to the Court of Appeal. After the sentencing, Mr Kohli's daughter, Susan Kohli, said she was 'angry and disappointed' at the sentences, stating that she believed they did not 'reflect the severity of the crime they committed'. Mid Leicestershire MP Peter Bedford and the MP for South Leicestershire, Alberto Costa, also wrote to the AGO asking for the sentences to be reviewed. A spokesperson for the AGO said last month that Ms Rigby was 'appalled by this violent, cowardly attack on an innocent man'.
New York Post
25 minutes ago
- New York Post
JD Vance goes fishing — for trout — with UK's Lammy
Vice President JD Vance on Friday cast a few lines out when trout-fishing with British Foreign Secretary David Lammy while in England to discuss US-UK relations, Gaza and Ukraine. While the veep and Lammy didn't catch any fish, Vance's three kids were with him — and they all did. 'Unfortunately, the one strain on the special relationship is that all of my kids caught a fish, but the foreign secretary and I did not,' the VP quipped. 3 Vice President JD Vance and British Foreign Secretary David Lammy fish in the grounds of Chevening House in England on Friday. POOL/AFP via Getty Images 3 Vance and Lammy have been friends for years. REUTERS Vance said he and Lammy first became friends when he was a US senator and Lammy took the time to visit with him during a trip to DC. 'Obviously, we come from sort of different political spectrums, but he was, he was kind enough to make time on a visit to DC,' the veep told reporters. 'We got to know each other a little bit then and just kept on seeing each other. And our families enjoy each other's company very much, which always helps.' The US-UK relationship has been blooming under President Trump. The UK was the first country to strike a trade deal with the US, and Trump recently went to Scotland to golf and meet with Prime Minister Keir Starmer to iron out more details of the deal. Trump is set to go back to the UK in September to attend his second state dinner there at the invitation of King Charles. But Starmer also indicated in July that the UK would move to recognize a Palestinian state in September if Israel doesn't change its humanitarian treatment of Gaza — creating tension with the Trump administration, which has said it would not recognize Palestine. 'Obviously, the United Kingdom is going to make its decision. We have no plans to recognize a Palestinian state,' Vance said. 'I don't know what it would mean to really recognize a Palestinian state, given the lack of a functional government there.' 3 Vance and Lammy last saw each other on the VP's trip to Rome. Getty Images Vance also doubled down on his commitment to free speech, saying the West got 'too comfortable with censoring' under the Biden administration. 'I've raised some criticism because concerns about our friends on this side of the Atlantic,' he said of censorship. 'But the thing that I'd say to the people of England or anybody else, to David, is many of the things that I worry most about were happening in the United States from 2020 to 2024. I just don't want other countries to follow us down what I think was a very dark path under the Biden administration.' Vance is also expected to visit US troops on his trip to the UK, a source familiar told The Post.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Man dies after 'falling from building' at MediaCity
A man has died after reportedly falling from a building at Salford Quays. Emergency services rushed to MediaCityUK earlier this afternoon (Friday) following the tragic incident at around 12:15pm. Police blocked off a road called Blue, which runs from Broadway into the centre of the MediaCity complex. READ MORE: MediaCity incident: Huge emergency service presence after 'person falls from building' READ MORE: Man carried out horrific morning attacks minutes apart on three random women A stretch inside the road was then taped off, with screening initially being put up around the scene. Never miss a story with the MEN's daily Catch Up newsletter - get it in your inbox by signing up here That was later replaced by a blue police forensic tent. Eyewitnesses said a person fell from a building. Site security staff are said to have begun the first lifesaving attempts before paramedics arrived on the scene. Greater Manchester Police (GMP) confirmed a man sadly died. Join the Manchester Evening News WhatsApp group HERE The incident is not being treated as suspicious, they added. A spokesperson for the force said: "We responded to an incident at a car park at Media City at 12:15pm today. 'We can confirm a man has died and there are no suspicious circumstances involved. 'Next of kin have been informed and are being supported by specially trained officers.' A cordon remained in place this afternoon.
