Victims of three medical products that caused 'avoidable harm' still awaiting redress
Deborah Mann has not returned to the grave of her firstborn for 30 years but today has come with her daughter, Branwen, to tell her the story. "It shouldn't have happened," she says quietly.
Ms Mann had four pregnancies. Her first two children, Trelissa and Kaverne, died shortly after birth. Ms Mann believes their deaths were caused by an epilepsy drug she was taking called sodium valproate, prescribed by her GP.
After a long gap she would go on to have two more children, both girls, who were diagnosed with what is now recognised as foetal valproate syndrome, which has left them with life-long physical and neurological problems.
Ms Mann tells Sky News: "I asked so many questions and was told 'this is just the way things are.' It can't be the way things are when you lose two babies. How can it be the way things are?"
Five years ago, valproate was among three medical products including the pregnancy test drug Primodos and medical device pelvic mesh, that were found to have caused "avoidable harm" to patients.
The report was clear that valproate could cause lifelong disabilities to the children of mothers taking the drug when pregnant.
The independent review, chaired by Baroness Julia Cumberlege, strongly criticised the industry and regulators and made a series of recommendations, including the creation of a redress scheme for victims in all three groups.
On valproate, it stated: "Nothing can undo the harm that has been done to these individuals, but steps can be taken to make their lives easier."
20,000 children exposed to drug while in womb
Five years on there is still no such scheme for any of the campaign groups. In the week of developments in the Post Office scandal and infected blood, here is another scandal no less significant.
An estimated 20,000 children were exposed to sodium valproate while in the womb.
UK regulator the MHRA says an increased risk of neonatal loss is not currently a recognised adverse reaction, but it does warn of a range of congenital problems caused by the drug that are increasingly likely the higher the dose.
Sky News has also seen a study from 1972 which shows high doses of sodium valproate could be embryo-lethal in rats. At times Ms Mann was being prescribed 5,000mg, which is double the highest recommended dose.
Ms Mann worries about the future of her surviving children. She says of the government: "It's financially better to pretend they don't even exist. So many children are harmed, so many children that will not have their needs addressed as they grow older."
At the time of birth her eldest daughter Rhonwen's medical records state "valproate levels caused foetal and patient damage," which included deafness.
Daughter worries about being a mother as she can pass condition on
Ms Mann wasn't initially told about the cause of her daughter's problems, even when she was pregnant with her next child Branwen.
The 29-year-old told Sky News: "I have tight ankles, tight legs, tight hips and I have a weak lower back. I have to wear splints every day to be sure I can keep walking, and I have to do exercises every day. I have autism, Asperger's syndrome."
She goes on to list a series of brain problems that must be scanned every two years, "to make sure nothing's grown or moved."
She was bullied at school for her appearance, and she worries about being a mother as she can pass the condition on to her children.
She said: "I feel very let down by the government. I feel let down by the people who promised they would help us, that they will help ensure that we have a better quality of life."
'Somebody at last had listened'
Others the Cumberlege review wanted to get redress for "avoidable harm" were children born with malformations after their mothers used the drug Primodos.
These hormone-packed pills were prescribed as a pregnancy test to thousands of women in the 1960s and 70s and are alleged to have caused a range of malformations to babies, from shortened limbs to heart defects, which the manufacturer denies.
Lead campaigner for the Association for Children Damaged by Hormone Pregnancy Tests (ACDHPT), Marie Lyon, told Sky News: "Our families were utterly overjoyed that somebody at last had listened, and Julia Cumberlege did a thorough review. Our expectations were wow! This is it now. An apology from the health secretary, all these years and we've finally got there, and then nothing.
"Five years and may I say, five years and 31 deaths. That's how many of our members have died since that report was published in 2020 and we've still not received justice. It's a disgrace."
Baroness Cumberlege also recommended the government create a redress scheme for women left debilitated by pelvic mesh implants.
'The government are dragging their feet'
Kath Sansom, founder of the Sling The Mesh campaign group, told Sky News: "There are women in there who can't walk any more, who need a stick or a mobility scooter - they've lost jobs, marriages, pensions. Some have had to sell their homes, and it feels really unfair that we are still waiting for a reply on redress.
"The government are dragging their feet. We keep being told that they are working on it at pace - but the phrase within the group is - a snail's pace."
The Department of Health and Social Care said: "The harm caused by pelvic mesh continues to be felt today" and "we are fully focused on how best to support patients and prevent future harm."
"Health Minister Baroness Gillian Merron met patients affected and has committed to providing a further update."
Government considering recommendations
The government says it is considering the recommendations by the patient safety commissioner last year for a redress scheme, but it's notable there is no timescale and no reference to the harm caused by valproate or Primodos in their statement.
Dr Alison Cave, chief safety officer at the Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency (MHRA), said: "Patient safety is our highest priority and no one should stop taking valproate without seeking advice from their healthcare professional.
"Valproate is a highly teratogenic medicine and there is evolving evidence for harms in males, which is why the Commission on Human Medicines (CHM) recommended new regulatory measures to reduce the known harms from valproate, including the significant risk of serious harm to the baby if taken during pregnancy and the risk of impaired fertility in male."
Sanofi, manufacturers of sodium valproate, told us: "We have always worked closely with the MHRA and fully met all our legal and regulatory obligations in relation to valproate which is an essential medicine used to treat a serious and potentially life-threatening condition.
"Sanofi has at all times provided information regarding valproate that reflects current knowledge as approved by MHRA.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
a few seconds ago
- The Independent
Hundreds of children from Gaza to be brought to UK for medical treatment
Up to 300 children could be evacuated from Gaza and given NHS treatment in the UK. The plans are reportedly set to be announced within weeks. A parent or guardian will accompany each child, as well as siblings if necessary, and the Home Office will carry out biometric and security checks before travel, the Sunday Times reported. This will happen 'in parallel' with an initiative by Project Pure Hope, a group set up to bring sick and injured Gazan children to the UK privately for treatment. More than 50,000 children are estimated to have been killed or injured in Gaza since October 2023, according to Unicef. Sir Keir Starmer said last week that the UK was 'urgently accelerating' efforts to bring children over for treatment. A Government spokesperson said: 'We are taking forward plans to evacuate more children from Gaza who require urgent medical care, including bringing them to the UK for specialist treatment where that is the best option for their care. 'We are working at pace to do so as quickly as possible, with further details to be set out in due course.' The UK and Jordan have been working together to air drop aid amid warnings of widespread malnourishment in Gaza. It comes as the UK seeks to put pressure on Israel to change course with a plan to recognise a Palestinian state in September ahead of the UN General Assembly. Sir Keir has said the UK would only refrain from recognising Palestine if Israel allows more aid into Gaza, stops annexing land in the West Bank, agrees to a ceasefire and signs up to a long-term peace process over the next two months. Concerns have been raised this could see a Palestinian state recognised by the UK without Hamas releasing the remaining Israeli hostages. British families of hostages say the Government has made clear to them that releases would 'play no part' in the UK's plans to recognise Palestine and that it could see those still held 'rot in Hamas dungeons'. Foreign Secretary David Lammy said the UK's demands for Hamas to release all hostages and play no role in the future of Gaza are 'absolute and unconditional'. He told The Sunday Times: 'The UK position on recognition is part of (a) co-ordinated international effort. It must begin with an immediate ceasefire that frees the hostages and ends the agony of their families, and which lifts the inhumane aid restrictions.'
The Sun
31 minutes ago
- The Sun
From STIs to stress – everything your discharge can reveal about your health and the urgent warning signs
ALTHOUGH it's not often talked about, vaginal discharge will affect most women at some point. But what's normal? And when could it be a sign of something sinister? 5 Discharge comes in sorts of colours and textures, and how it looks and smells can reveal a lot about your health. Dr Shazia Malik, an obstetrics and gynaecology consultant and UK medical director at Daye, tells Sun Health: 'Understanding your body's natural discharge is incredibly helpful and empowering. 'This way, when something goes wrong, you'll be able to spot it quickly. 'If you're already noticing some changes in your down-there fluids however, it might be down to one of these conditions.' 1. STIs YOU might assume that if you've got a sexually transmitted infection, you'll experience pain, itching or a rash. But did you know, STIs are often asymptomatic in women? 'Up to 70 per cent of chlamydia and 50 per cent of gonorrhoea cases show no symptoms,' says Dr Malik. 'But, when symptoms do appear, they may include abnormal discharge (yellow, green or grey), unusual odours, irritation and discomfort during urination or sex. 'In underwear, you might notice yellowish-green discharge from gonorrhea, frothy yellow-green discharge from trichomoniasis, or mucus-like discharge from chlamydia. 'It can also present with bleeding between periods, after sex or pelvic pain.' If you suspect you might have an STI, it's important not to turn a blind eye. 'Women should see a healthcare provider if they notice changes in discharge, unusual bleeding, pain, itching or genital sores,' says Dr Malik. 'Untreated STIs can lead to pelvic inflammatory disease (PID) - a serious infection that occurs when bacteria spreads from the vagina to the upper reproductive organs. 'It can cause permanent damage. Research published in the National Library of Medicine suggests it could increase your risk of infertility five-fold. 'Most conditions, when caught early, respond well to treatment. 'Help is available through GPs, sexual health clinics (many offer walk-in appointments), and home testing services.' 2. Bacterial vaginosis RENOWNED for its fishy-smelling odour, around 23 to 29 per cent of women who are of reproductive age will get bacterial vaginosis (BV) at some point. Not familiar with this common condition? Dr Malik says: 'BV produces thin, greyish-white discharge with a distinctive fishy odour that intensifies after sex.' Antibiotics prescribed by your GP can effectively treat symptoms, however, according to research published in the journal BMC Medicine, more than half of sufferers will experience a recurrence of BV symptoms within six months. Dr Malik says that this pattern 'reflects the delicate balance of your vaginal microbiome' - the collection of bacteria that live inside the vagina. You might notice white, chunky patches in your underwear, along with intense itching, redness and burning during urination or sex Dr Shazia Malik 'A healthy vagina is dominated by lactobacillus bacteria, which maintain an acidic environment that naturally defends against harmful organisms,' she adds. 'BV disrupts this balance, and even after antibiotics clear the infection, if beneficial bacteria aren't restored, the vaginal environment remains vulnerable.' You can support your vaginal microbiome by reducing stress levels, avoiding harsh soaps when washing, minimising baths and going for showers instead, and even trying vaginal probiotic supplements. 3. The monthly cycle ALTHOUGH some discharge can indicate problems with your health, some types are in fact very normal. 'Healthy discharge ranges from clear to whitish with a mild odour,' confirms Dr Malik. 'It changes throughout your cycle. 'It's minimal after menstruation, clear and stretchy before and during ovulation, and thicker and cloudier after ovulation. 'These changes reflect hormonal fluctuations affecting vaginal secretions.' Getting to know your version of normal helps you recognise when something isn't quite right. You could try tracking your monthly discharge on a note on your phone or an app such as Flo (iOS and Android). 5 4. Thrush CAN'T stop itching? If you're also noticing thick, white, cottage cheese-like discharge in your knickers, then you might be suffering from thrush. 'Thrush affects three out of four women at some point in their lives,' says Dr Malik. 'You might notice white, chunky patches in your underwear, along with intense itching, redness and burning during urination or sex.' Like BV, thrush represents another type of microbiome imbalance. 'While BV involves bacterial overgrowth, thrush occurs when candida yeast – normally present in small amounts – multiplies excessively,' says Dr Malik. 'Although antibiotics are necessary for bacterial infections, they can inadvertently disrupt your microbiome by reducing the beneficial bacteria that normally keep yeast in check, which explains why thrush often follows antibiotic treatment.' When your period pain could be a medical emergency By Isabel Shaw, Health Reporter MOST of us take period camps to be part and parcel of periods, right? It's true that pain is part of the normal mechanism of menstruation, but when they're really bad, this is not normal and could signal a problem that may land you in hospital. Dr Fran Yarlett, GP and medical director at The Lowdown, says: "Period pains can usually be managed with simple painkillers, such as paracetamol and ibuprofen. "If the pain is still not controlled or you have other symptoms such as a high fever, offensive vaginal discharge or pain that can be pinpointed to a very specific area, it's advisable to speak to a doctor. " 1. Ectopic pregnancy An ectopic pregnancy happens when a fertilised egg implants outside the womb and affects one in every 80 to 90 pregnancies, or 11,000 pregnancies every year. "The pain is typically one-sided and associated with possibly some brown spotting or bleeding with a positive pregnancy test," Dr Fran says. Other symptoms can include: vaginal bleeding, brown watery discharge, a missed period, discomfort on the toilet and pain in your shoulder. 2. Toxic shock syndrome Toxic shock syndrome (TSS) happens when Staphylococcus enters the body and releases toxins, which can lead to sepsis - a life-threatening immune response to harmful bacteria. It is sometimes associated with tampon use, but can also be linked to skin wounds, surgical incisions, nasal packing, scrapes, burns or other areas of injured skin. Symptoms include: a high temperature, muscle aches, a sandpaper-like rash and flu-like symptoms. 3. Appendicitis Appendicitis is a painful swelling of the appendix - a small pouch connected to the large intestine. The pain travels to the lower right-hand side, where the appendix usually lies, and becomes constant and severe. Pressing on this area, coughing, or walking may worsen the pain. Other appendicitis symptoms include: nausea, vomiting, loss of appetite, constipation or diarrhoea, a high temperature and a flushed face. 4. Endometriosis Endometriosis is a common but relatively unknown health condition associated with crippling period pains. It affects up to one in 10 women in the UK and causes tissue similar to that in the womb to grow in other areas in the body. Other symptoms include: heavy periods, pain when you pee or poo, pain after sex and extreme tiredness. 5. Coil perforation The copper coil is an effective, hormone-free contraceptive used by millions of women in the UK. In rare cases, it can cause perforation - when it punctures the wall of the womb. Other symptoms include: severe pelvic pain, continuous bleeding, sudden period changes, pain during sex and not being able to feel the threads. 6. Cancer In the early stages, womb and ovarian cancer can feel like period cramps. Other symptoms include: back pain, feeling feel quickly, difficulty eating and needing to pee a lot or urgently. Worried you have thrush? 'Treatment includes antifungal creams, pessaries or oral tablets,' says Dr Malik. Your pharmacist can help you choose the right treatment for you. If your thrush keeps coming back, book an appointment with your GP. Thrush can also affect men, with symptoms including irritation, burning and redness around the head of the penis and under the foreskin; a cottage cheese-like discharge; an unpleasant smell; and even difficulty pulling back the foreskin. 5. Stress WHETHER it's caused by intense work deadlines, kids or simply a schedule that means you never come up for air, stress can have a huge impact on your vaginal health, including your discharge. 'When you're under stress, your body releases the hormone cortisol, among others, that can disrupt the delicate hormonal balance controlling your menstrual cycle,' says Dr Malik. 'The science behind this is fascinating. Stress activates your hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) axis, which can interfere with the hypothalamic-pituitary-gonadal (HPG) axis. 'This regulates reproductive hormones like oestrogen and progesterone. 'This disruption can lead to changes in vaginal discharge and even cause breakthrough bleeding or spotting between periods.' Research published in the American Journal of Epidemiology also found that psychological stress can affect your immune system, making your vaginal microbiome more vulnerable to imbalances and infections. Doing what you can to reduce your stress can help to normalise your menstrual cycle. Can you devote more time to relaxing, away from technology, emails and messages? Are you able to delegate any jobs to someone else? Small changes can make a big difference. 6. Cancer ALTHOUGH your discharge-related symptoms are unlikely to be cancer, it's wise to get clued up and know what's what when it comes to gynaecological cancers. Cervical cancer is the 14th most common cancer in women, with around 3,300 new cases every year, according to Cancer Research UK. Around 7,500 women are diagnosed with ovarian cancer in the UK each year, while 9,800 women are diagnosed with womb cancer. Dr Malik says that cervical cancer can cause persistent watery, blood-tinged discharge with an unpleasant smell. 'Womb cancer often presents with watery discharge that may contain blood, particularly concerning in postmenopausal women. 'Ovarian cancer may cause discharge changes alongside abdominal bloating. 'Other warning signs include persistent pelvic pain unrelated to your menstrual cycle, pelvic pressure or fullness, changes in urinary habits, pain during intercourse, unexplained weight loss and extreme fatigue. 'It can also present with bleeding between periods, after sex or pelvic pain.' These symptoms should never be ignored. Although it may not be cancer, it's vital you book an appointment with your GP. 'Early detection through regular screening and prompt medical attention significantly improves outcomes,' Dr Malik says.
BBC News
31 minutes ago
- BBC News
Kent man to 'walk through life' for Prostate Cancer charity
A Kent man with a terminal cancer diagnosis will tackle a March Through Life by walking from the north-east of England to Kent to raise money for Prostate Cancer Dennington, who has prostate cancer, will set off from North Shields, where he was born, on 3 August and walk for 36 days before finishing in his home village of Hempstead, near the poignant walk, Paul will stop at several places with a special meaning to him, including St James' Park, the home ground of Newcastle United Football Club, which he has supported since he was a said that if caught early, prostate cancer was "very treatable" so raising awareness was "very important". Upon departure from the North East, Paul will then head to Birkenhead, where he will pay tribute to his parents, before a stop in the West Midlands at Aston University, where he previously studied. Before reaching the finishing mark, Mr Dennington will pass through Rickmansworth, where he owned his first home, and hospitals in Maidstone in Medway, to mark his cancer who has already raised £100,000 for Prostate Cancer UK, has regularly attended both during his diagnosis and four-and-a-half years of treatment including radiotherapy and hormone therapy. 'I did feel guilt' Paul's challenge is due to finish on 7 September when he reaches his current home in Kent, where he has lived for the past 27 years. By then, he is expected to have scaled 27,375 ft (8,343m), just shy of the summit of Mount said: "When I was diagnosed it felt surreal as I didn't have symptoms and thought I was pretty fit and healthy. "I did feel guilt, though, as it was my body that was the reason my family were going to have to go through this journey."Caught early, prostate cancer is very treatable."Without a screening programme in the UK we rely heavily on well informed and willing men to proactively get themselves tested. "That is why raising awareness of risk is so important."
