Sycamore Gap trial live: Video filmed by defendant shows tree being chopped down, prosecutors tell court
Daniel Graham and Adam Carruthers are both charged with two counts of criminal damage relating to the tree and a section of the Roman-built wall it fell on on the night of 27 September 2023.
The pair are accused of driving from Carlisle to the beauty spot in Northumberland, where one used a chainsaw to cut down the tree, while the other filmed the act.
At their trial at Newcastle Crown Court on Wednesday, police analyst Amy Sutherland talked through a video to jurors which apparently shows the moment the tree was felled.
In the footage, an outline of a figure can be seen next to the trunk of a tree before it crashes to the ground. Ms Sutherland said the two-minute and 41-second video was in darkness but that sounds of a chainsaw could be heard.
Opening the case to jurors on Tuesday, prosecutor Richard Wright KC said: 'Whoever filmed the cutting down was as much responsible for the damage to the wall and the tree as the man wielding the chainsaw. They were in it together, and they were Carruthers and Graham.'
Graham, 39, from Carlisle, and Carruthers, 32, from Wigton in Cumbria, deny all the charges against them.
Defendant became a father for the second time less than two weeks before tree was felled, jury told
A series of agreed facts are now being out by Rebecca Brown, junior prosecution counsel.
These are details agreed by all legal parties that can be shared with the jury.
They include the defendants' date of births, and also their children's.
They reveal that Adam Carruthers, 32, became a father for the second time only 12 days before the tree was felled.
Miss Brown says Carruthers had no previous convictions, reprimands, warnings or cautions.
Alex Ross30 April 2025 15:42
Defendant searched 'police statement Sycamore Gap'
As well as searching for the initial suspect, Amy Sutherland, the police analyst, said Daniel Graham also used YouTube to look up 'police statement Sycamore Gap'.
He also did several searches for 'Sycamore Gap', she tells the jury.
Ms Sutherland said Graham looked up an online article about the National Trust creating a replica of the fallen tree using a 3D scan.
She said that the defendants were arrested on October 31 2023 and again on November 3.
Alex Ross30 April 2025 15:13
Accused searched for earlier suspect in Sycamore Gap investigation, jury told
The jury is now being given more information on the what was found on Daniel Graham's phone.
Graham, along with Adam Carruthers, are accused of felling the Sycamore Gap tree.
Police analyst Amy Sutherland tells the jury that Graham's phone showed numerous Google searches for an earlier suspect in the police investigation who was later released with no further action.
She said that between October 3 and October 5 searches were made on Graham's phone for 'Water Renwick' and 'Walter Renwick Plankey Mill'.
Mr Renwick was arrested on September 29 2023 but was later told he would face no further action.
Alex Ross30 April 2025 14:44
Back underway after lunch
Following an adjournment for lunch, the trial is back underway with policy analyst Amy Sutherland giving evidence.
Alex Ross30 April 2025 14:40
'It's on Sky News', defendant tells co-accused, jury told
Following the felling of the tree, the court heard how Daniel Graham sent a voicenote to Adam Carruthers using his nickname, saying: 'Jeffrey, it's gone viral, it's gone worldwide, it will be on ITV News tonight.'
Later, Graham sent another message saying: 'Jeffrey, it's on f****** Sky News as we speak.'
Alex Ross30 April 2025 14:00
'Not a bad angle on that stump' - defendants' messages shared after tree felled
Now we're hearing more on the messages shared between the defendants the day after the Sycamore Gap tree came down on the night of September 27, 2023.
The jury is told by police analyst Amy Sutherland that in one message Graham said to Carruthers: 'Not a bad angle on that stump', adding: 'That's clearly a professional.'
One screenshot sent by Carruthers to Graham showed Facebook comments with a circle around one that said: 'Judging by the quality of the cut and size of tree I would say whoever it was has knowledge of how to fell large trees.'
30 April 2025 13:47
CCTV clip shows vehicle leaving Sycamore Gap tree car park
Another video has now been shown to jurors, this time a CCTV clip taken from the Twice Brewed Inn close to the Sycamore Gap.
It shows vehicle headlights coming from Steel Rigg car park, often used by people visiting the Sycamore Gap tree, at 12.58am on September 28.
Police analyst Amy Sutherland has also said that Daniel Graham's phone connected to the network at 1.29am after being detached at 11.41pm.
Jurors at Newcastle Crown Court are then shown images of a chainsaw and a piece of wood taken at around 2am, with metadata showing they were taken at Graham's home.
Yesterday, it was prosecutor Richard Wright said it was likely the piece of wood was the wedge from cutting the tree, and it could have been kept as a trophy.
Alex Ross30 April 2025 13:28
Full report: Mobile phone video showing 'Sycamore Gap tree felled'
Footage played to the jury of the Sycamore Gap tree allegedly being felled has been released to the media.
You can read our full report on the video here:
Watch: Sycamore Gap video footage of 'tree being chopped down'
Prosecutors say the video was filmed on the mobile phone of Daniel Graham, who is accused alongside Adam Carruthers of felling the Sycamore Gap tree
Alex Ross30 April 2025 13:24
Chainsaw heard buzzing in enhanced version of felling video
The video clip lasts two minutes and 40 seconds and recovered from Graham's phone was played to Newcastle Crown Court twice.
Once showing the dark, raw footage, and a second time after it had been enhanced by a police specialist.
In the enhanced black and white version, with audio of wind blowing and a chainsaw buzzing, a figure can been seen working at the trunk of the tree, before it finally crashes to the ground.
Richard Wright KC, prosecuting, said the original video was enhanced by changing the contrast, putting a border around the frame and brightening the film 'so it could be seen more clearly'.
30 April 2025 12:59
Jury shown video of 'Sycamore Gap tree being felled'
Analyst Amy Sutherland introduced a video to jurors at Newcastle Crown Court which apparently shows the felling of the Sycamore Gap tree.
She said it was taken from a phone which was taken from Daniel Graham's jacket pocket, and was two minutes and 40 seconds long.
She said it was 'in darkness' but that 'sounds of a chainsaw' could be heard.
Ms Sutherland told the court the video was in the downloads on Graham's phone and she had been able to get the coordinates of where it was filmed from the metadata. She said the coordinates were for Sycamore Gap.
30 April 2025 12:31
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Press and Journal
an hour ago
- Press and Journal
'Cam girl' and pal avoid prison after trying to extort £4,000 from man
A 'cam girl' and her friend have avoided a prison sentence after they tried to extort £4,000 from a man to buy Christmas presents. Brooke Olsen, 32, and Louise Graham, 29, appeared outside the man's home and tried to kick the door down before hiding behind his bins at the back of his property in a sneaky attempt to get inside. Olsen and Graham – who the court was told both worked as escorts – repeatedly demanded he stump up thousands of pounds in cash or they would send men round to collect. Aberdeen Sheriff Court heard that following this, the pair appeared outside his home in Torry after sending a chilling message that stated: 'Get me my money'. In a final attempt to get him to pay up, Graham asked him: 'Do you want me to kill you?' Fiscal depute Emma Petersen told the court that at around 1am on December 17 2023, Louise Graham called the man and invited him around. Due to not knowing her very well, he refused and she terminated the call. A short time later, Brooke Olsen called him on Facebook with Louise Graham present and repeatedly demanded £4,000 from him. She said he owed her money, that she owed other people money, and needed money for Christmas presents. He advised that he had around £3,000 in his account and could help Olsen out if she was struggling financially. They made threats of violence towards him and he ended the call. Shortly before 5am, the man started to receive text messages from an unsaved number claiming to be from another male, stating that he would attend at the complainer's address to collect the money if he didn't hand it to Louise Graham. The man called the number, and it was answered by Louise Graham. Following that call, he received a message stating: 'Get me my money' At 8am, the man was still in his flat when he saw two people walking past his window and soon after heard a knock at his door and the sound of Brooke Olsen's voice. He told Olsen and Graham to leave and informed them he was calling the police. The pair responded to this by kicking and pushing at his front door, with the man having to stand against his door to stop the pair from gaining entry. A neighbour overheard banging and shouting in the communal hallway, which she described as sounding like someone trying to kick a door. The man called 999 and the accused left. However, soon after, he looked out of the window and saw Olsen and Graham hiding behind bins directly behind his property. As he opened his window to take a picture of them with his phone, they ran at him and tried to stop him closing it and tried to climb through the open window. The man managed to close the window, however, Olsen started to repeatedly kick it as Graham banged it with her fists. The court heard Graham stated: 'Do you want me to kill you? Do you want me to stab you?' While at the window the pair continued to demand £4,000 and remained there for a while before getting into a car driven by a male and driving off. In the dock, Olsen and Graham pleaded guilty to one count of threatening their victim with violence, sending threatening messages, and attempting to enter his property to rob him. Defence solicitor for Olsen, Alex Burn, told the court that his client had been 'foolish' to get involved in this incident, but admits her culpability and accepts behaving in a threatening manner. 'She did try to gain money', he said, adding that she had 'difficulties from a young age'. 'Ms Olsen has worked as an escort in the past and sometimes works as a cam girl,' he added. Louise Graham's solicitor, Liam Mcallister said his client had experienced 'tragic life circumstances' that had resulted in her becoming addicted to illegal substances. 'She has had some harrowing trauma in her life, but she has turned things around in terms of substance misuse,' he said. Mr Mcallister added: 'I don't say that as an excuse for her actions, but it does perhaps explain why someone with no record of offending would get involved in such behaviour.' As an alternative to a prison sentence, Sheriff Ian Wallace made Olsen, of King Street, Inverurie, subject to a community payback order and ordered her to carry out 108 hours of unpaid work. He also made Graham subject to a community payback order with supervision and ordered her to carry out 198 hours of unpaid work as an alternative to a custodial sentence.
The Independent
11 hours ago
- The Independent
Benefits misinformation spreads online as millions grapple with cost of living
Misinformation about benefits, money and government policy has likely been seen by hundreds of thousands of people as fake news has been allowed to feature amongst Google's top-ranking search results. The web giant's rotation of articles featured on its search engine and most prominent recommendation services has included several peddling incorrect information on crucial financial news relating to UK readers. Many of these sites falsely claim that the Cost of Living Payment that was administered by the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) between 2022 and 2024 is returning this year, which is not true. The authors of the articles even falsely state that people on certain commonly-claimed benefits, such as Universal Credit and Pension Credit, can expect automatic payments worth up to £500 in the coming months. Another fake story sees WASPI campaigners told that they can expect a 'one-off, tax-free compensation payment' worth thousands, while yet another claims that next years' planned state pension age increase to 67 has been cancelled. The owners of these web pages are likely carrying out this activity with the aim of attracting as many readers as possible to their sites with sensational and false headlines. Using knowledge of Google 's website-ranking system to manipulate search results, they also focus content on topics that its open-source data shows is highly searched for. Visitors are shown hundreds of intrusive ads on the pages, the revenue from which becomes more valuable to the site owner the more a website is visited. The Independent has identified several sites that have been sharing false information that has been highly-ranked by Google's algorithm. None of those uncovered are based in the UK. Anna Stevenson, Benefits Expert at Turn2us, said: 'These sites prey on people's worries at a time when so many of us are feeling the pressure of the cost-of-living crisis, and that's really unfair. 'If you see a headline about a new payment or benefit, take a moment to check where it's coming from. Just because it's displayed on Google doesn't make it trustworthy, stick to established and authentic sources like . websites or reputable charities; if you can't find the same information there, it's unlikely to be legitimate.' A spokesperson for Google said: 'We see billions of search queries every day and we design our ranking systems to surface high quality information at the top of Search. Our spam-fighting systems aggressively fight mass-produced, low-quality content, keeping Search 99% spam-free and we take appropriate action against pages that violate our policies.' The owners of all websites shown in this article were approached for comment. Only one, 'Tamil Nadu Weatherman', has removed its article, which carried false information about the Cost of Living Payment, saying it was 'never [their] intention to spread false information.' A spokesperson said: 'Thank you for reaching out and bringing this to my attention. After carefully reviewing the articles you highlighted, I acknowledge that the information published may not have been accurate. This was an oversight on my part, and I sincerely regret any confusion it may have caused. 'Going forward, I will ensure that all such content is cross-checked with official government websites before publication. Accuracy and trust are very important to me, and I appreciate you raising this issue so I could address it promptly.'
STV News
11 hours ago
- STV News
Police investigating banner at anti-asylum hotel protest
Police are investigating a banner at a demonstration outside a hotel used to house asylum seekers in Falkirk on Saturday. Two demonstrators outside the Cladhan Hotel were seen carrying a banner that read: 'Kill 'em all, Let god sort 'em out.' Two men were arrested after around 1,000 people attended a demonstration outside the Cladhan Hotel. Organisers from the Save Our Future & Our Kids Futures group said they were 'concerned citizens' who were 'standing against uncontrolled illegal immigration'. Photos and video from the protest showed one man doing a Nazi salute and another wearing a t-shirt bearing the logo of Britain First – the far-right fascist political party. Other demonstrators were caught on video making lewd and sexually aggressive comments and gestures toward counter-protesters on the other side of the road. The Stand Up To Racism campaign group called the demonstration 'a danger to us all' and said it should be a 'wake-up call for Scotland'. Stand Up to Racism said approximately 250 counter-protesters stood on the other side of the road, separated by police. Responding to the photos of the demonstrators shared by Stand Up to Racism Scotland, Save Our Future organiser Connor Graham said the group would like to make it 'absolutely clear' that it does not condone any form of 'racist, extremist, or aggressive behaviour'. 'The images and behaviour highlighted, including Nazi salutes, inappropriate banners, and lewd gestures, are appalling and are not representative of who we are or what we stand for,' Mr Graham said. 'Unfortunately, as these are public gatherings, individuals can turn up uninvited, and we cannot always control who attends. The small minority who behaved inappropriately were not part of our organising team, and their actions go completely against the principles of Save Our Future.' 'Moving forward, we will continue to make it clear that Save Our Future stands only for peaceful, lawful demonstrations. Anyone attempting to hijack our events with extremist or hateful behaviour will not be welcome.' Police Scotland said officers arrested two people during the demonstrations on Saturday. 'We received a report of indecent exposure in the Kemper Avenue area of Falkirk around 3.10pm on Saturday, August 16, 2025,' a spokesperson said. 'A 23-year-old man has been arrested and charged in connection and is due to appear at Falkirk Sheriff Court on Monday, August 18, 2025.' A 26-year-old man was also arrested and charged with obstructing police. He was issued a recorded police warning. Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
