The Troubles: Supreme Court to hear Paul Thompson inquest disclosure challenge
The Supreme Court will hear a case later which campaigners believe has implications for state secrecy around several killings during the Northern Ireland Troubles.The case has been brought by the Northern Ireland Secretary Hilary Benn.He is appealing a decision in which a coroner intended to release some intelligence information about the loyalist murder of Paul "Topper" Thompson in 1994.The 25-year-old was travelling in a taxi which was fired upon by the Ulster Freedom Fighters (UFF) at Springfield Park in west Belfast.
His family believes the case involves state collusion.Coroner Louisa Fee had planned to disclose a "gist", or summary, of intelligence at his inquest in March 2024, but Benn's predecessor, Chris Heaton-Harris, began a legal challenge which will now culminate in a two-day hearing in London.Judgement will be delivered at a future point.
'Critical questions'
Amnesty International, Relatives for Justice and the Committee on the Administration of Justice (CAJ) are supporting Mr Thompson's family.They said the case raised "critical questions" about the government's Neither Confirm Nor Deny policy, which is used "to prevent the disclosure of information on national security grounds".CAJ director Daniel Holder said: "This case has wide implications for numerous bereaved families and the rule of law."National security cannot surely be invoked to conceal state wrongdoing or the involvement of state agents in killings or other human rights violations."Mr Thompson's inquest was one of several halted under the last government's Legacy Act.Labour has pledged to reinstate inquests under a replacement act.The act was passed by the Conservative government in September 2023 despite opposition from Labour, all Northern Ireland parties, several victims' groups and the Irish government.It created a new legacy body known ICRIR to take over all Troubles-era cases from 1 May 2024, including those on the desk of the Police Service of Northern Ireland.The act shuts down all historical inquests.The act's most controversial element, the offer of conditional immunity to suspects, has been disapplied following legal action by bereaved families.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
6 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Trump accused of 'lobbing grenade' into US-UK security pact as president orders review of nuclear sub deal intended to tackle Chinese aggression
Donald Trump has been accused of 'throwing a hand grenade' into the transatlantic security alliance by ordering a review of a major nuclear submarine pact between the UK, the US and Australia. The president has ordered officials to look into Aukus, which was signed by his predecessor Joe Biden and is intended to secure the Pacific against Chinese aggression. It involves multi-billion-pound commitments to build new nuclear-powered submarines, with the Ministry of Defence already announcing its intention to build up to 12 submarines in last week's Strategic Defence Review. But these plans have been thrown into doubt after the US defence department announced a probe to ensure Aukus meets the President's 'America First' agenda. The review is being led by Elbridge Colby, who is close to President Trump and is a long-term sceptic of the agreement. A UK Government spokesman sought to play down the prospect of an American withdrawal from the deal today, saying Aukus was 'one of the most strategically important partnerships in decades'. They added: 'It is understandable that a new administration would want to review its approach to such a major partnership, just as the UK did last year.' But Helen Maguire, the Liberal Democrat defence spokeswoman, said: 'Trump's decision to review the AUKUS submarine pact has thrown another grenade into our security partnership. 'Even in the face of an imperial Putin and the rising threat posed by China, this White House simply can't be relied upon to support our collective defence. 'Our national security demands that we ramp up talks with our Commonwealth friends and work to plug the gap that the US is threatening to leave in European and global security. 'Starmer must meet urgently with Prime Minister Albanese to develop contingency plans for AUKUS if Trump withdraws from the treaty.' Announced in 2021, Aukus involves the three nations building a new generation of nuclear-powered attack submarines and cooperating in other areas of advanced defence technology. The deal will also see Australia buy three Virginia-class submarines from the US ahead of the new vessels being built. That provision has led some in Washington, including Mr Colby, to question the deal on the grounds that the US may need those submarines if it finds itself in a war with China over Taiwan. But last month, the new US ambassador to London used his first major speech in the job to back Aukus. Warren Stephens told an audience in Parliament, including Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer, that the US was 'proud to stand alongside Britain and Australia, two of our closest allies, as we deepen our collaboration to respond to a changing world'. Relations between the US and Australia have soured over tariffs. America has also demanded Australia increase defence spending and wants to sell older submarines to Australia on favourable terms. Last night former head of the Royal Navy, Admiral Lord West said: 'Aukus is extremely important for the strategic situation in the Pacific and very important for Britain as a way of us moving into our next generation of submarines. 'The US had had concerns about selling its submarines to Australia, so it is not entirely unexpected that President Trump would want to look at this. Hopefully this can be resolved and we all move on together as part of the alliance.' The deal is regarded as a pillar of security co-operation. But concerns have been raised in the US over the rate of submarine production and Australia's reluctance to commit to a 'no holds barred' response to a Chinese attack on Taiwan. The US is committed to selling up to five boats to Australia, vessels which many in the US believe should be retained by the US Navy.
The Sun
12 minutes ago
- The Sun
Watch shock crash that finally landed ‘feral' teen in jail – just weeks after he got cop who rammed him off ebike sacked
THIS is the crash that finally got a "goading" teen locked up - just weeks after he got a cop who rammed him off an e-bike sacked. Mason McGarry was first riding with pal Dominic Mizzi when they were clipped by ex-PC Tim Bradshaw in his police car. 6 6 Footage showed the teens being catapulted across the wet road in Bognor Regis, West Sussex, before McGarry attempted to flee. Veteran officer Bradshaw was cleared of causing serious injury by dangerous driving but was forced to leave his job after 22 years. Then just one month later, serial offender McGarry was involved in another police chase - this time in a friend's car. The yob, who has 42 previous convictions - including for robbery, theft and dangerous driving - was captured dangerously trying to evade police. Footage shows McGarry trying to edge out of a t-junction with no regard for other motorists' safety. The teen then mounted the pavement at 60mph before smashing into a lorry - causing more than £1,000 worth of damage. He was sent to a young offender's institution for 12 months after he admitted dangerous driving, aggravated vehicle taking, driving whilst disqualified, failing to stop and driving without insurance. Portsmouth Crown Court Vauxhall when his friend called police to say the car had not been returned. Officers began a pursuit through Chichester as the teen drove at 60mph in a 40mph zone in a bid to shake them off. The court heard his list of previous convictions was "unenviable" and includes offences of drug possession, trafficking and two dangerous driving convictions. Moment cop rams into e-bike rider & passenger with police car sending both flying Sentencing, Judge Jodie Mittell said: "The concern I obviously have is that the fifth time he will kill someone. "That could be his sister." At PC Bradshaw's trial in February, the court heard the crash took place while the officer was driving a marked Ford Focus. He said he tried to follow the e-bike after it rode past his car on the pavement in an attempt to "goad" him. Bradshaw said the same bike later pulled in front of him which is when he chose to make "tactical contact" at around 30mph. But he claimed only he "nudged" the electric bike with the bumper of his vehicle and that it was Mizzi's "own stupid fault". Bradshaw, who is now retired, added: "It was light contact, it was light enough, there was not a blemish on my police car. "I believed it was a justified, necessary action." During a voluntary interview with police, he also branded McGarry a "feral" teenager and someone who "just doesn't get it, just doesn't stop". A jury took just over an hour to reach their verdict and clear Bradshaw of causing serious injury by dangerous driving. He was also found not guilty of a charge of causing serious injury by driving without due care and attention. The retired cop later claimed his colleagues are now fearful of taking direct action in dangerous situations because of the potential consequences. 6 6
BBC News
16 minutes ago
- BBC News
British sovereignty over Gibraltar sacrosanct, says David Lammy
British sovereignty over Gibraltar remains "sacrosanct", the foreign secretary has said, after the UK agreed a deal with the European Union over the territory's post-Brexit Lammy told the House of Commons the agreement included a clause "explicitly protecting our sovereignty".The deal removes checks on people and goods crossing the Gibraltar-Spain some MPs raised concerns Spanish border officials would be able to deny entry to UK citizens flying into the British Overseas Territory. For travellers arriving at Gibraltar airport, passport checks will be carried out by both Gibraltarian and Spanish is similar to the system in place for Eurostar passengers at London's St Pancras station, where travellers pass through both British and French passport control before boarding international means it will be possible for arrivals to continue their travel from Gibraltar into Spain and the rest of the EU without further Lammy insisted Gibraltar would not be joining the Schengen free travel area - 26 European states that have abolished passport control at their mutual border so people can travel freely. Schengen countries also have common rules on asylum and countries whose nationals require visas. Lammy said it was "fake news" that Gibraltar would be joining Schengen and "this was never on the table". "Immigration, policing and justice in Gibraltar will remain the responsibilities of Gibraltar's authorities," he added. Talks on the rules governing the border between Spain and Gibraltar - a 2.6 square mile headland to the south of the country - have been ongoing since the UK left the EU in issue had been a key sticking point, which has remained unresolved since broadly welcomed the deal, which has been hailed as "historic" by Gibraltar, Spain and the EU. Giving a statement in the Commons, Lammy said Labour was "solving the problems leftover from the last [Conservative] government and their thin Brexit deal". He added that the deal "removes another obstacle to closer ties with our EU friends" and "provides much needed certainty for people and businesses in Gibraltar". An estimated 15,000 people cross the Gibraltar-Spain border every day for work and Gibraltar residents can cross using residence cards without needing to have their passports stamped, while Spanish citizens can cross using a government ID there were concerns this would end with the introduction of the EU's Entry/Exit system later this year, causing huge delays at the said without a deal every passport and all goods would need to be checked leading to "chaos and backlogs, endangering livelihoods of British citizens in Gibraltar, wrecking the territory's economy and possibly costing hundreds of billions of pounds a year, placing pressure ultimately on the UK taxpayer to pick up the bill". The next step is for a full legal text to be finalised, which Lammy said all parties were "committed to completing as quickly as possible". The Conservatives have said they will examine the the final treaty to ensure it meets their red lines, including that it safeguards the sovereignty and rights of foreign secretary Priti Patel also questioned whether Spanish officers would be able to stop British citizens coming to stay in Gibraltar. Lammy insisted the only difference to what Conservative ministers had previously been negotiating was the sovereignty clause, which he said would ensure there was no question over Gibraltar's UK has had sovereignty over Gibraltar since 1713, although this is disputed by Spain, who claim the territory as their opinion in Gibraltar, which has a population of around 32,000, is in favour of keeping British sovereignty. The most recent referendum, held in 2002, saw almost 99% of voters reject a proposal to share sovereignty with UK said there would also be full operational autonomy for the UK's military's facilities in Gibraltar, where the airport is run by the Ministry of Defence and hosts an RAF Democrat spokeswoman Helen Maguire welcomed the agreement, while calling for Parliament to get the opportunity to scrutinise and vote on Reform UK have described the deal as a "surrender". Deputy leader Richard Tice raised concerns Spanish border officials would have "an effective veto" on British citizens from the UK landing in clarified that if there was an alert in relation to an arrival Spanish border guards and police would work alongside Gibraltarian police. An individual would have the right to legal advice and be able to either return to their country of origin or go to Spain to face questions. Sign up for our Politics Essential newsletter to keep up with the inner workings of Westminster and beyond.
