The British political class have shown themselves at their worst
The welfare reform Bill was finally passed with a majority of 75, about 100 less than Labour's notional majority. But there is something missing from ministers' and MPs' reactions to this 'victory': the cheers, such as they were, sounded forced. The smiles were wan. The congratulations looked half-hearted. Because this is a Bill whose passage means many losers and zero winners – a rare achievement in parliamentary politics.
Of course, the real losers are those future claimants of Personal Independence Payments (PIP) who, depending on the detail of the latest concessions granted by Keir Starmer, will find it much more difficult to have their claims approved. But there are many more political losers. There are the rebels themselves, at least some of whom might have hoped for personal advancement in their political careers and who must now face years of being nominated for the crummiest, dullest standing committees – the traditional punishment for those who won't take their whips' advice.
Then there are the Conservatives, who voted against a measure many of them clearly supported. There was even a shadow cabinet meeting last week at which Kemi Badenoch asked each member how the party should vote. That such a question even needs to be asked suggests there was at least some support for a more principled, less cynical stance.
Then of course there is the Government, which, before this debate and vote, was in a slightly stronger, slightly more popular position than this evening and which now has achieved the passing of a measure that even ministers can no longer see the point of. It has spent a lot of its political credibility in securing a Bill that was originally sold as a genuinely reformist measure (it is not) and which would save the Treasury billions (it will not).
Not the Commons' finest moment. A damaged legislature, a damaged government and, most importantly, a damaged prime minister. Happy anniversary, Sir Keir.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sky News
15 minutes ago
- Sky News
Emotional Reeves a painful watch - and a reminder of tough decisions ahead
It is hard to think of a PMQs like it - it was a painful watch. The prime minister battled on, his tone assured, even if his actual words were not always convincing. But it was the chancellor next to him that attracted the most attention. Rachel Reeves looked visibly upset. It is hard to know for sure right now what was going on behind the scenes, the reasons - predictable or otherwise - why she appeared to be emotional, but it was noticeable and it was difficult to watch. Her spokesperson says it was a personal matter that they will not be getting into. Even Kemi Badenoch, not usually the most nimble PMQs performer, singled her out. "She looks absolutely miserable," she said. Anyone wondering if Kemi Badenoch can kick a dog when it's down has their answer today. The Tory leader asked the PM if he could guarantee his chancellor's future: he could not. "She has delivered, and we are grateful for it," Sir Keir said, almost sounding like he was speaking in the past tense. It is important to say: Rachel Reeves's face during one PMQs session is not enough to tell us everything, or even anything, we need to know. But given the government has just faced its most bruising week yet, it was hard not to speculate. The prime minister's spokesperson has said since PMQs that the chancellor has not offered her resignation and is not going anywhere. But Rachel Reeves has surely seen an omen of the impossible decisions ahead. How will she plug the estimated £5.5bn hole left by the welfare climbdown in the nation's finances? Will she need to tweak her iron clad fiscal rules? Will she come back for more tax rises? What message does all of this send to the markets? If a picture tells us a thousand words, Rachel Reeves's face will surely be blazoned on the front pages tomorrow as a warning that no U-turn goes unpunished.
Western Telegraph
15 minutes ago
- Western Telegraph
No 10 says Starmer backs Reeves after Chancellor's tears in Commons
The Chancellor was visibly tearful in the Commons, as her position came under intense scrutiny after the welfare U-turn which put an almost £5 billion black hole in her plans. But allies said she was dealing with a 'personal matter' and No 10 said she had Sir Keir's 'full backing'. Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer tripped as he left 10 Downing Street for the Commons (Lucy North/PA) Sir Keir, who stumbled on his way out of Downing Street for Prime Minister's Questions, faced questions over his handling of a welfare reform package which has been stripped of key elements to limit the scale of a Labour revolt. Tory leader Kemi Badenoch said Ms Reeves looked 'absolutely miserable' and challenged the Prime Minister to say whether she would keep her job until the next election. Sir Keir dodged the question about whether Ms Reeves would be in place for the remainder of the Parliament, saying Mrs Badenoch 'certainly won't'. Changes to restrict eligibility for the personal independence payment (Pip) were abandoned on Tuesday just 90 minutes before MPs voted on them, wiping out the savings that Ms Reeves had counted on to help meet her goal of funding day-to-day spending through tax receipts rather than borrowing. Mrs Badenoch said: 'Today the Prime Minister refused to back his Chancellor, leaving her humiliated. Chancellor of the Exchequer Rachel Reeves crying as Sir Keir Starmer spoke during Prime Minister's Questions (House of Commons/PA) 'She is the human shield for his expensive U-turns. How can anyone be a chancellor for a man who doesn't know what he believes and who changes his mind every other minute?' As the Chancellor left the Commons after Prime Minister's Questions her sister, Ellie Reeves, took her hand in an apparent show of support. Asked about her tears, a spokesman for the Chancellor said: 'It's a personal matter which, as you would expect, we are not going to get into. 'The Chancellor will be working out of Downing Street this afternoon.' Reports suggested Ms Reeves had been involved in an altercation with Commons Speaker Sir Lindsay Hoyle shortly before Prime Minister's Questions. A spokeswoman for the Speaker said: 'No comment.' Asked why Sir Keir did not confirm in the Commons that he still had faith in Ms Reeves, the Prime Minister's press secretary told reporters: 'He has done so repeatedly. Govt was planning to save ~£5bn in 2029-30 through welfare cuts – would have risen to ~£11bn in long run Now, govt will save nothing this parliament (2029-30 savings from cutting health element of UC (£1.7bn) roughly offsets cost of raising basic UC (£1.8bn)) — Helen Miller (@HelenMiller_IFS) July 2, 2025 'The Chancellor is going nowhere. She has the Prime Minister's full backing. 'He has said it plenty of times, he doesn't need to repeat it every time the Leader of the Opposition speculates about Labour politicians.' Asked whether the Prime Minister still had confidence in Work and Pensions Secretary Liz Kendall, the press secretary said: 'Yes.' Labour has promised that income tax, employee national insurance contributions and VAT will not be increased, restricting Ms Reeves' options for raising money if she does look to hike taxes. The Institute for Fiscal Studies' incoming director, Helen Miller, said: 'Since departmental spending plans are now effectively locked in, and the Government has already had to row back on planned cuts to pensioner benefits and working-age benefits, tax rises would look increasingly likely. 'This will doubtless intensify the speculation over the summer about which taxes may rise and by how much.' Sir Keir declined to rule out tax rises later this year, telling MPs: 'No prime minister or chancellor ever stands at the despatch box and writes budgets in the future.'
Times
16 minutes ago
- Times
10 expert firms for finance, business and legal matters
From innovative investment platforms to specialist advice, these companies support entrepreneurs, managers and savers navigating complex markets In an ever-changing landscape of tech innovation, financial markets and legal compliance, business managers and entrepreneurs know that there are times when they need to call in the specialists. This financial and legal checklist looks at ten exciting companies offering a range of expert services that deal with the details. From dedicated wealth management and easy-access savings to advanced investment platforms and automated bookkeeping at scale, there are a range of financial organisations to meet an array of needs. For legal services, including contract disputes, family law and multi-jurisdiction support, this article also includes profiles dynamic firms whose client approach has earned them distinction in their fields. JH&P provides investment and wealth management services to UK and international private clients, charities, not-for-profits and professional advisers. The firm structures its business around a long-term growth investment philosophy, with a multi-generational planning ethos. For over a decade, it has seen outstanding year-on-year returns and earned numerous awards, with an extremely low turnover of clients and more than £7 billion of assets under management. Building strategies to balance its clients' long-term wealth ambitions and short-term needs, JH&P's team works with each client on an individual basis, so complex subjects are easy to understand and informed decisions can be made with confidence. Its team's expertise allows JH&P to offer support across all areas of wealth planning, including tax-efficiency, cash-flow analysis, risk management, protection and passing on wealth. As an 88 per cent staff-owned business, with robust succession arrangements in place to ensure reliable continuity, the company invests in its own enduring success. This ethos is also reflected in the long-running client relationships it has already established – proud to serve generations, for years to come. Visit to find out more Venture X directly serves the new generation of professionals and creatives looking for exceptional workspaces through its premium tech-enabled office facilities in west London. With excellent Tube, rail, bus and road connections, the Venture X Chiswick Park and Venture X White City locations provide stylish, modern office settings for clients across London and beyond, receiving a total of more than 300 reviews on Google, with an average score of 4.9 stars. The company elevates office space, ensuring every convenience is available when it's needed, for as much or as little time as required. This flexibility is key to its appeal in the hybrid working era. Whether businesses are looking for fully furnished, ready-to-move-in rooms, 24/7 hot-desking options or virtual office services, Venture X offers ergonomically designed workstations and furniture, reliable IT support and high-speed connectivity as standard. With added essentials such as meeting rooms on demand, private booth spaces and a customer service team, every detail of a first-class workspace has been designed with purpose. Visit to find out more The dispute resolution team at Ronald Fletcher Baker LLP provides specialist legal advice at the highest level. Working with high-net-worth clients, property investors and developers, asset managers, financial institutions and borrowers, and sportspeople (including Premier League footballers), the team draws on its extensive and varied experience to focus on a range of key areas where successful dispute resolution outcomes are paramount. Led by senior litigation partner David Burns, cited by Legal 500 as a 'leading partner', the department tackles disputes in high-value bridging loans, joint ventures, and between shareholders and directors, as well as landlord and tenant litigation, possession proceedings, commercial lease renewals, and a range of disputes related to commercial and residential properties. As highly skilled litigators with County Court, High Court, Tribunal and Court of Appeal experience, the team appreciates that such action is often a client's last resort and it focuses on alternative dispute resolution, including resolving matters at a pre-action stage, engaging in mediation, expert determination and arbitration. Visit to find out more or contact senior litigation partner David Burns at or 020 7467 5751 For over 150 years, Loughborough Building Society has helped people to save for their future and buy homes. As a mutual – owned by its members, not shareholders – everything the society does is guided by its set of values, trust and personal service. With a focus on what customers really need from a building society, its portfolio of varied savings accounts is designed to suit all savers, from young to old, from those studying to working or retired, and from families to community organisations. Placing value on choice, and understanding the breadth of life experiences and circumstances, Loughborough Building Society ensures that its accounts can be opened in the way each customer wants – in branch, over the phone or by post using a downloadable form. And, true to the founding principles of a good building society, it has a small number of community savings accounts. These give members the chance to contribute to local causes through their everyday saving. Reliable and accessible, Loughborough Building Society continues to serve present and future generations. Visit to find out more or visit in branch or call 01509 610707. All savings products available subject to terms and conditions, and eligibility From contract disputes and financial and cyber risks to health and safety liability and the intricacies of employment law, legal issues – both expected and unforeseen – affect organisations of all sizes every day. But for SMEs and mid-sized corporations, keeping a full in-house legal team to cover all these complex areas of law simply isn't feasible. Ranked as one of The Times Best Law Firms 2025, rradar is an award-winning specialist legal enterprise with products and services that provide advice, guidance and representation. With a network of offices around the UK, a sophisticated in-house digital infrastructure and a growing portfolio of specialist firms within its rradar group, it serves over 135,000 clients – and that number is growing fast. rradar works with clients to identify, manage and minimise potential legal risk before it becomes a problem. Through a combination of first-class legal advice, representation and the latest technology, it helps businesses stay on the front foot in an everchanging regulatory environment. Visit to find out more about this unique proposition, and connect with rradar via LinkedIn to stay on top of legal and regulatory updates. As a regulated law firm, rradar is bound by the Solicitors Regulation Authority and the Law Society of Scotland in respective jurisdictions Increasingly, businesses of all sizes are seeing the benefits of streamlining their bookkeeping. Saving working hours and ensuring that accounts are compliant with the latest legislation and rate changes can be a gamechanger. But with so many automated systems available, it is not always easy to identify the right system for your company's needs. A leading provider of bookkeeping automation, Dext has created an easy-to-navigate platform that helps businesses thrive. Using innovative AI and machine learning technology that simplifies accounting tasks, it is suitable for processing the relevant data for operations of all sizes. Through its advanced technology, Dext can deliver financial data extraction accuracy at 99.5 per cent, making it a valuable tool for smarter, more timely financial decisions. Trained on more than a billion receipts and invoices, Dext has saved bookkeepers over 35 million hours of manual data entry to date. Able to seamlessly integrate with most major accounting software and connecting to over 11,500 banks, suppliers and marketplaces worldwide, it is no wonder Dext is trusted by 700,000 businesses. Visit to say goodbye to tedious bookkeeping tasks Enyo Law is a leading disputes-only law firm based in the City of London. Its team assists with complex and sensitive international disputes for a client base that includes corporations, states, state-related bodies and private individuals. Private wealth matters are a core practice area for Enyo Law, such as high-value and multi-jurisdictional trust disputes. Its team of 20-plus partners has the expertise to manage trust-related litigation on a global scale, acting for both claimants and defendants, including high-net-worth individuals, trust companies, family businesses and private banks. Often working with an integrated team of foreign lawyers and other experts, it has earned respected recognition in cross-border disputes where differing compliance laws require layered knowledge. Enyo Law's team represents clients in the English court and provides strategy and management of claims in overseas jurisdictions, including the Cayman Islands and Bermuda, Switzerland, Jersey, Singapore and Hong Kong, among many others. Independent and focused solely on disputes, Enyo Law offers a fast, innovative and flexible approach for each client. Visit to find out more, including a detailed look at Enyo Law's private wealth disputes work Heligan takes a client-centric approach to portfolio management. While boutique in size, its proprietary market research and deep network – particularly in high-growth sectors such as technology, national security and public safety – enable it to deliver a client experience on par with much larger firms. From investment management and wealth structuring to bespoke debt and liquidity solutions, the firm offers high-net-worth individuals, families and entrepreneurs a fully tailored experience – covering everything from tax and cash management to intergenerational wealth planning, all under one roof. The Heligan Corporate Finance department extends the wealth management team's offering so that it can also guide its high-net-worth and ultra-high-net-worth clients through business sale transitions and connect wealth planning to corporate exit strategy. With offices in Birmingham and London, a nationwide client base, and expertise in cross-border and multi-jurisdictional matters, Heligan leverages its full capability and reach to help clients plan for long-term wealth preservation. Visit to explore full services and insights, and to book a private consultation with client director Kieran Duffy. Receive regular thought-leadership updates across the Heligan Group on LinkedIn Kuflink is an award-winning online property investment platform, helping the alternative investment community diversify and maximise returns. Established in 2016, the company has a Trustpilot rating of 4.4 (excellent) from over 1,000 reviews. To date it has lent over £420 million on a variety of secured bridging and development loans, enabling clients to take advantage of higher interest rates and to get the most from their investments through select and diversified account options. In addition to this, the Kuflink Innovative Finance Isa (IFISA) currently offers a rate of up to 9.13 per cent for a two-year term, significantly outperforming traditional savings accounts. E-signature functionality makes it easy to sign up for an IFISA, and thanks to smart tech, it offers a great range of returns. Investors have the flexibility to choose which type of product they wish to use their allowance for – from self-selecting to auto diversifying across approximately 400 loans at any one time. Visit to sign up. Kuflink is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. Do not invest unless you are prepared to lose money. This is a high-risk investment. You may not be able to access your money easily and are unlikely to be protected if something goes wrong Headquartered in Scotland, this UK law firm advises high-net-worth individuals, professional trustees and services firms on all aspects of inheritance, trust and business succession disputes. Focused on private wealth disputes either via court litigation or alternative dispute resolution, Brodies LLP assists in cases between trustees and beneficiaries where there is, for example, a contested will, a contentious tax issue or an issue related to a family investment company. The nature of such disputes can be distressing and highly sensitive, so the team draws not only on its professional legal skills but on emotional intelligence to handle each step with care, focused on successful outcomes for its clients – personally and financially. Ranked Band 1 in the Chambers & Partners High Net Worth Guide for Private Wealth Disputes, the firm has a UK-wide client list. With deep expertise in the legal distinctions across UK jurisdictions and a strong grounding in private international law, Brodies LLP is well equipped to handle matters that cross borders or span multiple legal systems. Visit the dedicated private wealth disputes page on to learn more about what Brodies LLP can offer This is a commercial article paid for by our advertising partners If you've enjoyed reading this article and are interested in more inspiration in everything from food and drink to luxury living , travel to health and wellbeing, why not follow Checklist on Facebook, X and Instagram @ChecklistSocial, or sign up to the newsletter? Checklist provides the best free online competitions too – discover amazing new services and products when you visit the website today.
