Do students who use ChatGPT learn less?
'They weren't even coming up with their own anecdotal stories about their own lives,' she told AFP. Leitzinger estimated that around half of her 180 students used ChatGPT inappropriately at some point last semester — including when writing about the ethics of artificial intelligence (AI), which she called both 'ironic' and 'mind-boggling'. So she was not surprised by recent research which suggested that students who use ChatGPT to write essays engage in less critical thinking. The preprint study, which has not been peer-reviewed, was shared widely online and clearly struck a chord with some frustrated educators. The team of MIT researchers behind the paper have received more than 3,000 emails from teachers of all stripes since it was published online last month, lead author Nataliya Kosmyna told AFP.
For the small study, 54 adult students from the greater Boston area were split into three groups. One group used ChatGPT to write 20-minute essays, one used a search engine, and the final group had to make do with only their brains. The researchers used EEG devices to measure the brain activity of the students, and two teachers marked the essays. The ChatGPT users scored significantly worse than the brain-only group on all levels. The EEG showed that different areas of their brains connected to each other less often.
And more than 80 percent of the ChatGPT group could not quote anything from the essay they had just written, compared to around 10 percent of the other two groups. By the third session, the ChatGPT group appeared to be mostly focused on copying and pasting. The teachers said they could easily spot the 'soulless' ChatGPT essays because they had good grammar and structure but lacked creativity, personality and insight. However Kosmyna pushed back against media reports claiming the paper showed that using ChatGPT made people lazier or more stupid.
She pointed to the fourth session, when the brain-only group used ChatGPT to write their essay and displayed even higher levels of neural connectivity. Kosmyna emphasized it was too early to draw conclusions from the study's small sample size but called for more research into how AI tools could be used more carefully to help learning. Ashley Juavinett, a neuroscientist at the University of California San Diego who was not involved in the research, criticized some 'offbase' headlines that wrongly extrapolated from the preprint. 'This paper does not contain enough evidence nor the methodological rigour to make any claims about the neural impact of using LLMs (large language models such as ChatGPT) on our brains,' she told AFP.
Leitzinger said the research reflected how she had seen student essays change since ChatGPT was released in 2022, as both spelling errors and authentic insight became less common. Sometimes students do not even change the font when they copy and paste from ChatGPT, she said. – AFP
But Leitzinger called for empathy for students, saying they can get confused when the use of AI is being encouraged by universities in some classes but is banned in others. The usefulness of new AI tools is sometimes compared to the introduction of calculators, which required educators to change their ways. But Leitzinger worried that students do not need to know anything about a subject before pasting their essay question into ChatGPT, skipping several important steps in the process of learning. A student at a British university in his early 20s who wanted to remain anonymous told AFP he found ChatGPT was a useful tool for compiling lecture notes, searching the internet and generating ideas. 'I think that using ChatGPT to write your work for you is not right because it's not what you're supposed to be at university for,' he said.
The problem goes beyond high school and university students.
Academic journals are struggling to cope with a massive influx of AI-generated scientific papers. Book publishing is also not immune, with one startup planning to pump out 8,000 AI-written books a year.
'Writing is thinking, thinking is writing, and when we eliminate that process, what does that mean for thinking?' Leitzinger asked. – AFP
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Kuwait Times
a day ago
- Kuwait Times
With waters at 32C, Mediterranean topicalization shifts into high gear
When Murat Draman went scuba diving off the coast of the southern Turkish province of Antalya and saw the temperature in the depths was pushing 30C, it didn't surprise him. 'We were at a depth of 30 metres (100 feet) this morning and the water was 29C,' said Draman, a diving instructor in an area which is experiencing firsthand the rapid 'topicalization' of the Mediterranean Sea. Encouraged by increasingly warm waters, hundreds of species native to the Red Sea have moved through the Suez Canal and into the eastern Mediterranean, disrupting ecosystems, scientists say. The threat is facing the entire Mediterranean, one of the fastest-warming seas, which this year saw its hottest June and July on record, figures from the Mercator Ocean International research centre show. Draman, who remembers when the water temperatures were 25C in August in the early 2000s, said he had seen dozens of Red Sea species colonizing the clear waters of Antalya, where surface temperatures reached nearly 32C this week. The striking but highly venomous lionfish (Pterois miles) with its long spotted fins that measure around 26 centimetres (10 inches), is now at home in such warm temperatures and wreaking havoc in the local ecosystem. 'About a decade ago, we saw one or two of them. Now we're talking about 15 or 20 per dive - even more than when we go to the Red Sea,' Draman told AFP. 'They are big predators. Small fish like gobies suffer a lot, we hardly see them anymore. Tourist sit by the sea at Kaleici marina in Antalya, in southern Turkey on March 12, 2022. A freediver cuts the spines off a caught lionfish (Pterois miles), typically native to Indo-Pacific waters and currently invading the eastern Mediteranean sea, near the surface underwater off the shore of Lebanon's northern coastal city of Qalamun on August 11, 2021. This photograph shows an empty beach at Lara district in Antalya, a popular holiday resort in southern Turkey, on June 20, 2020. A lionfish (Pterois miles), typically native to Indo-Pacific waters and currently invading the eastern Mediteranean sea, swims some 17 meters underwater off the shore of Lebanon's northern coastal city of Qalamun on August 11, 2021. 'A warning' Such invasive species are disrupting ecosystems across the eastern Mediterranean, the warmest area of the sea and the area that is heating up fastest, explained Professor Gil Rilov, a researcher at the Israel Oceanographic and Limnological Research institute (IOLR), who also lectures at Haifa University. 'The invasion started almost immediately after the opening of the Suez Canal in 1869,' he said. 'But now it's getting warmer, and also (in 2015), the canals got deeper and wider, so more and more new species move in every year,' the marine biologist told AFP, admitting some new arrivals could also be beneficial in waters that are becoming too warm for the native species. And many of these species - which have become ubiquitous off the coasts of Turkey, Lebanon and the Zionist entity - are now moving further west, he said, pointing to the rabbitfish (Siganus rivulatus) which has recently colonized the waters off Malta, more than 1,700 kilometres (over 1,000 miles) from the Suez Canal. What is happening in the eastern Mediterranean, where many native species have already disappeared, 'is a warning', Rilov added, pointing to two possible causes for their disappearance: excessively warm waters and fierce competition with these invasive species. 'What is happening here will happen in five, 10 or 20 years in the north and west of the Mediterranean,' he predicted. Last week, Mercator figures showed the sea had registered its warmest July on record with an average surface temperature of 26.68C - a figure that is worrying experts. 'Absence of predators' This 'topicalization' could also occur in the coming years through the Strait of Gibraltar at the far end of the Mediterranean basin, according to a study published in the prestigious US science journal PNAS (Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences) in April 2024. In it, the authors warned that even in an intermediate climate scenario, the warming of the Atlantic Ocean could see certain species migrate from the southern coasts of west Africa to the western Mediterranean by 2050. A more pessimistic scenario could even see the Mediterranean 'entirely tropicalized' by 2100, they warned. Faced with such a threat, Draman said invasive species must be kept as far as possible from protected marine areas 'in order to preserve biodiversity'. 'It is clear that with the absence of Mediterranean predators, species such as lionfish are very comfortable here and their population is increasing year on year,' he said. 'In the Red Sea, lionfish have predators. There are sharks and barracudas. Here, we have none of that.' — AFP
Kuwait Times
2 days ago
- Kuwait Times
Fireball lights up Japanese skies
TOKYO, Japan: A flashing fireball dashed across the skies of western Japan, shocking residents and dazzling stargazers, though experts said it was a natural phenomenon and not an alien invasion. Videos and photos emerged online of the extremely bright ball of light visible for hundreds of kilometres shortly after 11:00 pm (1400 GMT) local time on Tuesday. 'A white light I had never seen before came down from above, and it became so bright that I could clearly see the shapes of the houses around us,' Yoshihiko Hamahata, who was driving in Miyazaki Prefecture, told NHK. 'It seemed like daylight. For a moment, I didn't know what had happened and was very surprised,' he told the public broadcaster. Toshihisa Maeda, head of Sendai Space Museum in the Kagoshima region in southwestern Japan, said that it was a fireball, an exceptionally bright meteor. It seemed to have gone into the Pacific, he added. 'People reported feeling the air vibrate,' he told AFP. 'It was as bright as the Moon.' Objects causing fireball events can exceed one metre (three feet) in size, according to NASA. Fireballs that explode in the atmosphere are technically referred to as bolides, although the terms fireballs and bolides are often used interchangeably. — AFP
Arab Times
2 days ago
- Arab Times
OpenAI rolls out India-exclusive ChatGPT Go at $4.57 per month
NEW DELHI, Aug 19: ChatGPT maker OpenAI on Tuesday unveiled ChatGPT Go, a new India-exclusive subscription plan priced at 399 rupees ($4.57) per month, marking its most affordable paid option to date as the Microsoft-backed startup seeks to accelerate growth in one of its largest markets. India, home to nearly one billion internet users, has become a critical testing ground for global tech firms that often roll out lower-cost offerings to appeal to its highly price-sensitive consumer base. By launching a localized plan, OpenAI aims to broaden access to its AI assistant while competing more aggressively in the region. The new plan offers up to ten times more messages and images compared with the free tier, along with faster response speeds, according to the company. OpenAI noted that message limits scale higher with premium tiers, giving users the option to choose based on their needs. 'ChatGPT Go is designed for Indians who want greater access to advanced AI tools without a steep price barrier,' OpenAI said in a statement. OpenAI currently offers three subscription levels in India. The flagship ChatGPT Pro costs 19,900 rupees ($227) per month, while its mid-range ChatGPT Plus is priced at 1,999 rupees ($23). The launch of ChatGPT Go significantly lowers the entry point for paid access to the service. The move highlights the growing importance of India to OpenAI, which has been expanding global access to ChatGPT since its debut in late 2022. With competition intensifying from rivals such as Google's Gemini and Anthropic's Claude, OpenAI's India-first pricing strategy signals a push to secure early dominance in the fast-growing AI adoption market.
