Legal action in play after protester 'punched' in eye
Hannah Thomas was allegedly punched in the face by a male NSW Police officer in an act of "gratuitous police brutality and excessive use of force", her lawyer Peter O'Brien says.
Ms Thomas, an activist and lawyer, was among five people arrested in Sydney on June 27 outside an Australian firm reportedly linked to the manufacture of components for US fighter jets used by the Israeli Defence Force.
The arrests are being investigated by police officers from another command, with an internal review by professional standards and external oversight by the police watchdog, the Law Enforcement Conduct Commission.
Mr O'Brien has written to NSW Police and the Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions demanding the charges against Ms Thomas, 35, be dropped.
He also has instructions to proceed on a civil claim seeking compensation for the actions that led to her injury.
"Torts likely to be pursued against the state include assault and battery, false imprisonment, malicious prosecution, misfeasance in public office, and collateral abuse of process," he said in a statement on Monday.
"I am satisfied that Ms Thomas was punched in the face by a male police officer, causing extensive and serious injury to her eye ... We are further satisfied that Ms Thomas was an innocent victim of gratuitous police brutality and excessive use of force, actions that were completely and entirely unjustifiable."
Her legal team say they have watched all available footage of the incident and object to claims made by senior police officers, which they argue downplay its gravity.
NSW Police Assistant Commissioner Brett McFadden has previously said he did not observe any misconduct in the body-worn camera footage of the incident. All officers involved remained on duty.
Mr O'Brien noted the incident occurred at the same time state laws strengthening police powers to crack down on protests had been increased.
Pro-democracy groups have, in the wake of the violent arrest, argued that the controversial laws granting police powers to move protesters on from places of worship have emboldened the force to "act with impunity".
"It cannot be known what goes through the mind of a police officer who uses gratuitous violence like this, but the context and timing appear unavoidably revealing," Mr O'Brien said.
A NSW Police spokeswoman said the force cannot comment on ongoing investigations.
"As for any critical incident investigation, the circumstances of any serious injury and the conduct of police is incorporated into that investigation, and that investigation is ongoing," she said.
Protestors returned to SEC Plating in Sydney's west on Friday evening for another rally, where a statement from Ms Thomas, who remains in hospital, was read out.
"We owe it to Palestinians to escalate, to keep targeting companies like SEC Plating, which play a role in the F-35 global supply chain and enable genocide against the Palestinian people," she said.
"This company does not deserve to profit from the genocide."
Ms Thomas, who ran second to Prime Minister Anthony Albanese in the inner-west Sydney seat of Grayndler in the federal election in May, was charged with hindering or resisting police and not following a move-on direction.
Lawyers for a one-time Greens candidate who suffered a serious eye injury while being arrested at an anti-Israel protest say they are ready to sue the state of NSW.
Hannah Thomas was allegedly punched in the face by a male NSW Police officer in an act of "gratuitous police brutality and excessive use of force", her lawyer Peter O'Brien says.
Ms Thomas, an activist and lawyer, was among five people arrested in Sydney on June 27 outside an Australian firm reportedly linked to the manufacture of components for US fighter jets used by the Israeli Defence Force.
The arrests are being investigated by police officers from another command, with an internal review by professional standards and external oversight by the police watchdog, the Law Enforcement Conduct Commission.
Mr O'Brien has written to NSW Police and the Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions demanding the charges against Ms Thomas, 35, be dropped.
He also has instructions to proceed on a civil claim seeking compensation for the actions that led to her injury.
"Torts likely to be pursued against the state include assault and battery, false imprisonment, malicious prosecution, misfeasance in public office, and collateral abuse of process," he said in a statement on Monday.
"I am satisfied that Ms Thomas was punched in the face by a male police officer, causing extensive and serious injury to her eye ... We are further satisfied that Ms Thomas was an innocent victim of gratuitous police brutality and excessive use of force, actions that were completely and entirely unjustifiable."
Her legal team say they have watched all available footage of the incident and object to claims made by senior police officers, which they argue downplay its gravity.
NSW Police Assistant Commissioner Brett McFadden has previously said he did not observe any misconduct in the body-worn camera footage of the incident. All officers involved remained on duty.
Mr O'Brien noted the incident occurred at the same time state laws strengthening police powers to crack down on protests had been increased.
Pro-democracy groups have, in the wake of the violent arrest, argued that the controversial laws granting police powers to move protesters on from places of worship have emboldened the force to "act with impunity".
"It cannot be known what goes through the mind of a police officer who uses gratuitous violence like this, but the context and timing appear unavoidably revealing," Mr O'Brien said.
A NSW Police spokeswoman said the force cannot comment on ongoing investigations.
"As for any critical incident investigation, the circumstances of any serious injury and the conduct of police is incorporated into that investigation, and that investigation is ongoing," she said.
Protestors returned to SEC Plating in Sydney's west on Friday evening for another rally, where a statement from Ms Thomas, who remains in hospital, was read out.
"We owe it to Palestinians to escalate, to keep targeting companies like SEC Plating, which play a role in the F-35 global supply chain and enable genocide against the Palestinian people," she said.
"This company does not deserve to profit from the genocide."
Ms Thomas, who ran second to Prime Minister Anthony Albanese in the inner-west Sydney seat of Grayndler in the federal election in May, was charged with hindering or resisting police and not following a move-on direction.
Lawyers for a one-time Greens candidate who suffered a serious eye injury while being arrested at an anti-Israel protest say they are ready to sue the state of NSW.
Hannah Thomas was allegedly punched in the face by a male NSW Police officer in an act of "gratuitous police brutality and excessive use of force", her lawyer Peter O'Brien says.
Ms Thomas, an activist and lawyer, was among five people arrested in Sydney on June 27 outside an Australian firm reportedly linked to the manufacture of components for US fighter jets used by the Israeli Defence Force.
The arrests are being investigated by police officers from another command, with an internal review by professional standards and external oversight by the police watchdog, the Law Enforcement Conduct Commission.
Mr O'Brien has written to NSW Police and the Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions demanding the charges against Ms Thomas, 35, be dropped.
He also has instructions to proceed on a civil claim seeking compensation for the actions that led to her injury.
"Torts likely to be pursued against the state include assault and battery, false imprisonment, malicious prosecution, misfeasance in public office, and collateral abuse of process," he said in a statement on Monday.
"I am satisfied that Ms Thomas was punched in the face by a male police officer, causing extensive and serious injury to her eye ... We are further satisfied that Ms Thomas was an innocent victim of gratuitous police brutality and excessive use of force, actions that were completely and entirely unjustifiable."
Her legal team say they have watched all available footage of the incident and object to claims made by senior police officers, which they argue downplay its gravity.
NSW Police Assistant Commissioner Brett McFadden has previously said he did not observe any misconduct in the body-worn camera footage of the incident. All officers involved remained on duty.
Mr O'Brien noted the incident occurred at the same time state laws strengthening police powers to crack down on protests had been increased.
Pro-democracy groups have, in the wake of the violent arrest, argued that the controversial laws granting police powers to move protesters on from places of worship have emboldened the force to "act with impunity".
"It cannot be known what goes through the mind of a police officer who uses gratuitous violence like this, but the context and timing appear unavoidably revealing," Mr O'Brien said.
A NSW Police spokeswoman said the force cannot comment on ongoing investigations.
"As for any critical incident investigation, the circumstances of any serious injury and the conduct of police is incorporated into that investigation, and that investigation is ongoing," she said.
Protestors returned to SEC Plating in Sydney's west on Friday evening for another rally, where a statement from Ms Thomas, who remains in hospital, was read out.
"We owe it to Palestinians to escalate, to keep targeting companies like SEC Plating, which play a role in the F-35 global supply chain and enable genocide against the Palestinian people," she said.
"This company does not deserve to profit from the genocide."
Ms Thomas, who ran second to Prime Minister Anthony Albanese in the inner-west Sydney seat of Grayndler in the federal election in May, was charged with hindering or resisting police and not following a move-on direction.
Lawyers for a one-time Greens candidate who suffered a serious eye injury while being arrested at an anti-Israel protest say they are ready to sue the state of NSW.
Hannah Thomas was allegedly punched in the face by a male NSW Police officer in an act of "gratuitous police brutality and excessive use of force", her lawyer Peter O'Brien says.
Ms Thomas, an activist and lawyer, was among five people arrested in Sydney on June 27 outside an Australian firm reportedly linked to the manufacture of components for US fighter jets used by the Israeli Defence Force.
The arrests are being investigated by police officers from another command, with an internal review by professional standards and external oversight by the police watchdog, the Law Enforcement Conduct Commission.
Mr O'Brien has written to NSW Police and the Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions demanding the charges against Ms Thomas, 35, be dropped.
He also has instructions to proceed on a civil claim seeking compensation for the actions that led to her injury.
"Torts likely to be pursued against the state include assault and battery, false imprisonment, malicious prosecution, misfeasance in public office, and collateral abuse of process," he said in a statement on Monday.
"I am satisfied that Ms Thomas was punched in the face by a male police officer, causing extensive and serious injury to her eye ... We are further satisfied that Ms Thomas was an innocent victim of gratuitous police brutality and excessive use of force, actions that were completely and entirely unjustifiable."
Her legal team say they have watched all available footage of the incident and object to claims made by senior police officers, which they argue downplay its gravity.
NSW Police Assistant Commissioner Brett McFadden has previously said he did not observe any misconduct in the body-worn camera footage of the incident. All officers involved remained on duty.
Mr O'Brien noted the incident occurred at the same time state laws strengthening police powers to crack down on protests had been increased.
Pro-democracy groups have, in the wake of the violent arrest, argued that the controversial laws granting police powers to move protesters on from places of worship have emboldened the force to "act with impunity".
"It cannot be known what goes through the mind of a police officer who uses gratuitous violence like this, but the context and timing appear unavoidably revealing," Mr O'Brien said.
A NSW Police spokeswoman said the force cannot comment on ongoing investigations.
"As for any critical incident investigation, the circumstances of any serious injury and the conduct of police is incorporated into that investigation, and that investigation is ongoing," she said.
Protestors returned to SEC Plating in Sydney's west on Friday evening for another rally, where a statement from Ms Thomas, who remains in hospital, was read out.
"We owe it to Palestinians to escalate, to keep targeting companies like SEC Plating, which play a role in the F-35 global supply chain and enable genocide against the Palestinian people," she said.
"This company does not deserve to profit from the genocide."
Ms Thomas, who ran second to Prime Minister Anthony Albanese in the inner-west Sydney seat of Grayndler in the federal election in May, was charged with hindering or resisting police and not following a move-on direction.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
West Australian
an hour ago
- West Australian
Mark Latham denies abuse claims made by former partner Nathalie Matthews
Former Labor leader turned One Nation firebrand Mark Latham has been accused by a former partner of forcing her into degrading sexual acts as part of an application for a domestic violence order. The allegations, first reported by The Australian on Monday night , were made by Latham's former long-term partner and Liberal Party member Nathalie Matthews. Both The Australian and The Sydney Morning Herald reported the complaints had been detailed in documents filed with the NSW Local Court. Both mastheads reported Matthews as claiming Latham had engaged in a 'sustained pattern' of abuse, alleging he had pressured her into having sex with other people and driven his car at her. Latham took to X on Monday night to deny the allegations, which he called 'false and ridiculous'. 'The Australian newspaper has published a story based on allegations from Nathalie Matthews which are comically false and ridiculous,' he wrote. 'I have scores of documents to show that and will rely upon them to defend myself. As the old saying goes, Hell hath no fury like a woman scorned. 'The story says that Matthews went to the police and they did not do anything. They certainly haven't contacted me. 'In the current environment, that says a lot. She told me in April she had been to police seeking an AVO against another man and complained that they did nothing.' Latham become leader of the Australian Labor Party in 2003, losing the following year's federal election to John Howard. He resigned from Labor in 2005 and after a number of controversial incidents joined Pauline Hanson's One Nation party as its NSW state leader in 2018. Less than a year ago he was forced to pay NSW MP Alex Greenwich $140,000 over a series of homophobic tweets.
7NEWS
2 hours ago
- 7NEWS
Mark Latham denies abuse claims made by former partner Nathalie Matthews
Former Labor leader turned One Nation firebrand Mark Latham has been accused by a former partner of forcing her into degrading sexual acts as part of an application for a domestic violence order. The allegations, first reported by The Australian on Monday night, were made by Latham's former long-term partner and Liberal Party member Nathalie Matthews. Both The Australian and The Sydney Morning Herald reported the complaints had been detailed in documents filed with the NSW Local Court. Both mastheads reported Matthews as claiming Latham had engaged in a 'sustained pattern' of abuse, alleging he had pressured her into having sex with other people and driven his car at her. Latham took to X on Monday night to deny the allegations, which he called 'false and ridiculous'. 'The Australian newspaper has published a story based on allegations from Nathalie Matthews which are comically false and ridiculous,' he wrote. 'I have scores of documents to show that and will rely upon them to defend myself. As the old saying goes, Hell hath no fury like a woman scorned. 'The story says that Matthews went to the police and they did not do anything. They certainly haven't contacted me. 'In the current environment, that says a lot. She told me in April she had been to police seeking an AVO against another man and complained that they did nothing.' Latham become leader of the Australian Labor Party in 2003, losing the following year's federal election to John Howard. He resigned from Labor in 2005 and after a number of controversial incidents he joined Pauline Hanson's One Nation party as its NSW state leader in 2018. Less than a year ago he was forced to pay NSW MP Alex Greenwich $140,000 over a series of homophobic tweets.
Sky News AU
2 hours ago
- Sky News AU
Chinese spy ships to monitor Australian military drills during PM's China visit
Sky News host James Macpherson discusses reports Chinese spy ships will be monitoring Australian joint military exercises conducted alongside Japan and the United States. 'He bristled and he wiggled, because nothing ruins a good trade junket like being reminded that the people you are clinking glasses with are also pointing warships in your direction,' Mr Macpherson said. 'At the very same time that the prime minister is in China, the Chinese are spying on our joint military exercises with the US and Japan off the coast of Northern Australia."
