Why an Aussie bloke fined $25,000 by his local council thought he was 'doing the right thing'
A Western Australian man who was fined $25,000 for clearing native trees on his property and council land without approval has argued the gardening works were done for the benefit of endangered animals.
Craig Wilson Donohue faced Mandurah Magistrates Court on May 7 charged with carrying out development in an area subject to a local planning scheme.
Mr Donohue pleaded guilty for clearing and substantially trimming native bushland on his Forrington Heights property and part of the Shire of Waroona's road reserve.
The trimming, which took place in late 2024, spanned an area of at least 1,000sqm of bushland which had been deemed an environmentally sensitive area.
Mr Donohue claimed he was trying to 'do the right thing' by removing fencing and barbed wire from the area as he believed it presented a 'danger to native animals'.
He also argued the invasive cottonbush, poisonous nightshade and South African weed watsonia had taken over the area and blocked native fauna from flourishing.
But the council's prosecutor told the court his actions would have long-lasting and significant impacts on the protected area, the Mandurah Times reported.
The Shire of Waroona claimed Mr Donohue's mechanical trimming and hot burning - an intense fire over an extensive area - had impacted the natural habitat of several endangered plants and animals.
Council argued the marri and banksia trees, which are the natural foraging habitat of the black cockatoo, split open and died due to the heat of the fire.
Native shrubs and ground covers were also substantially trimmed and cleared.
While the prosecution accepted Mr Donohue's actions were 'somewhat inadvertent' they argued he should have received clearance from the council.
On her ruling, Magistrate Leanne Atkins told Mr Donohue there would be a significant penalty for his actions as he failed to seek the appropriate approval.
He was fined $25,000 and was ordered to pay $1,500 in costs to the council.
In accepting the decision, Mr Donohue pledged to sow 200 plants over the course of two years to help with re-vegetation in the affected area.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
19 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Mystery after teen mum found dead in demountable home as her baby sleeps next door
The circumstances surrounding the death of a teen mother whose body was found at a home in Western Australia almost a week ago remain unknown. Officers received a Triple-0 call about an unresponsive 18-year-old woman at a demountable property in Calingiri, north-east of Perth, on Monday at about 8.45pm. Police and paramedics arrived at the property on Harrington Street where they carried out emergency first aid. The young woman was declared dead at the scene. Emergency services are understood to have found a baby unharmed in a nearby bedroom. 'Being a small little community town, I think a lot of people are still shocked to see what happened,' neighbour Clint Hansen told 9News on Friday. 'And you know, there's that many different stories going around, so nobody actually knows what happened.' WA Police would not confirm the condition of the baby. When ambulance staff arrived at a demountable home at the rear of Harrington Street, they did not enter the property until police arrived due to 'safety concerns'. It is understood police received the emergency call from a man in an agitated state. Neighbours have said the owners of the property were not in town regularly and that the building was built less than two weeks before the incident. Detectives have launched an investigation into the circumstances of the woman's death.
Daily Mail
21 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Aussies react to shock arrest video of young Aboriginal woman in tiny town
Aussies have questioned the use of force used by officers during the arrest of a young Aboriginal woman in Western Australia. Officers detained the 25-year-old woman from Millars Well, a town about 540km northeast of Exmouth, after she allegedly breached bail conditions on Monday. Footage of the arrest, shared on Facebook, shows the woman screaming as she is pulled from a car, handcuffed on the ground and carried by two officers to a van. As a crowd gathered outside the home, a female officer was seen gesturing with a can of pepper spray to try and stop them from approaching. Another police vehicle with more officers arrived as the woman was put in the van. At least two male officers could then be seen approaching the group and pushing them away from the police van. Shocked viewers questioned the officers' use of force in the comments. 'I legit got tears. This is very triggering,' one person wrote. 'There was no need for this kind of force,' a second said. 'If they don't know how to work with mob, why don't they talk to the elders in community and get help,' a third commented. 'This town is not far from where I live,' a fourth added. 'This behaviour by police is so unnecessary!' The woman was not injured during the arrest and no medical assistance was required, WA Police told Daily Mail Australia in a statement. The woman was arrested for allegedly breaching her bail conditions by being at a home in Millars Well. 'It will be alleged as the woman was being arrested, she obstructed police, locking herself in a vehicle,' police said in a statement. Officers were called to the home about 10:30am on Monday after an alleged physical altercation between people known to each other. Police had responded to an incident at the same location earlier that day. WA Police declined to comment on the way officers handled the incident. The woman has since been charged with one count each of obstructing public officers, common assault in circumstances of aggravation or racial aggravation and possessing a prohibited drug, methylamphetamine. She appeared in court on Monday and is next due to appear before the Karratha Magistrates Court on July 29. The arrest video came just days after the shocking death of an Indigenous man Kumanjayi White at a supermarket in Alice Springs on May 27. NT Police last week said White 'stopped breathing' after he was restrained by two officers and confirmed the death is being investigated on behalf of the coroner. It is the second death to rock the small Yuendumu community and comes six years after Kumanjayi Walker was shot dead by NT Police officer Zachary Rolfe.
Daily Mail
3 days ago
- Daily Mail
British backpacker, 24, killed pedestrian when she ploughed into him while riding an e-scooter drunk in Australia, court hears
A British backpacker allegedly killed a father after ploughing into him while riding drunk on an e-scooter, an Australian court has heard. Alicia Kemp, 24, potentially faces up to 20 years in prison after she was arrested and charged for allegedly riding the hired e-scooter on a footpath and knocking down 51-year-old engineer Thanh Phan, 51, who died of brain injuries following the May 31 tragedy in Perth, Western Australia. Kemp was told by Perth Magistrates Court that she could not be bailed out as she posed too great a flight risk. The court was told that she was in Australia with her partner on a four-month tourist visa and that she had been working at Durty Nelly's Irish pub in Perth since arriving. She had been out drinking on Saturday afternoon from 2.30pm with a friend, who was kicked out of a bar for being too drunk. Later that evening, she hired an e-scooter at around 8.30pm. Police told the court that she was the main driver, while her friend was a passenger. Prosecutors said that Kemp was driving in an 'inexplicably dangerous' manner, which as caught on CCTV, and that pedestrians were forced to 'take evasive action' as she rode down Murray Street in Perth's Central Business District. She had a blood alcohol level of 0.158 as she was riding. Western Australian law states that electric vehicle drivers must have a level lower than 0.05 to legally drive. She was also travelling at 15mph as 'she careered into his back', prosecutors said, adding that this caused Phan to fall forward and hit his head. Tragically, he suffered 'a significant brain bleed', while Kemp's friend, a 26-year-old who had not yet been identified, was thrown from the scooter and suffered a fractured skull and broken nose. Phan was taken to the Royal Perth Hospital for surgery, where he died on Tuesday. His family said in a statement following his death: 'On Saturday night, Thanh Phan – a beloved husband, father of two, brother, and dear friend – was struck by an electric scooter and critically injured. 'We received the heartbreaking news that Thanh passed away as a result of his injuries. 'We ask that the media respect the privacy of Thanh's family as they grieve their loss. 'The family has no other comment to make on the issue at this time.' The magistrate in charge of Alicia's case said that remanding the British backpacker in custody was a 'very difficult decision for the court to make. He said that the prosecution's strong case and the prospect of a long prison sentence if convicted meant that there was a risk of '[Kemp] not returning to court to answer the charges', adding: 'The temptation might be that [she] won't return. I can't manage that risk.' Kemp remains in custody and will appear before the court again on July 15.
