logo
Duck River, Tennessee waterways could see regulation rollbacks under two proposed bills

Duck River, Tennessee waterways could see regulation rollbacks under two proposed bills

Yahoo19-02-2025

John McEwan, whose family has lived on the banks of the Duck River since the 1860s, skips stones on the Duck. (Photo: John Partipilo)
Tennessee conservation groups that support the preservation of the Duck River are warily watching two bills that they say would put the state's waterways at serious risk.
One bill would strip state protections from wetlands that are no longer protected by federal law. Another would scrap a required 2-mile buffer between designated scenic rivers and landfills.
While both bills would have implications for waterways throughout the state should they pass, the Duck River has taken a central role in discussions about their effects.
The Duck River is Tennessee's longest river and the most biodiverse freshwater river in North America. It also serves as the primary water source for roughly a quarter million residents in fast-growing Middle Tennessee.
Environmentalists and advocates have fought for stronger protections for the waterway for years: through court battles, water utility permit appeals and legislative action. Gov. Bill Lee raised the Duck to a level of statewide concern in fall 2024 with an executive order shaping a new advisory committee to balance the river's health with increasing water needs.
It's not clear whether the bills' sponsors intend to pursue their passage this legislative session, and the bills may still be amended.
Collierville Republican Rep. Kevin Vaughan is back this session with another version of his 2024 bill seeking to roll back protections on hundreds of thousands of acres of wetlands.
Vaughan's original bill faced staunch opposition from environmental advocates and was ultimately sent to a legislative summer study session. The Tennessee Department of Environment and Conservation (TDEC) presented its report to the Senate Energy, Agriculture and Natural Resources Committee with recommendations for wetlands regulation updates in October.
Developers, seeking to gain from building boom tied to Ford plant, push for weaker wetland rules
Vaughan's 2025 bill appears to be substantially the same as his 2024 proposal. It would prevent TDEC from classifying property as a wetland unless that property is defined as a wetland by federal law. A Supreme Court decision in 2023 constricted the number of federally protected wetlands, cutting out wetlands that are 'isolated,' or do not have surface connections to other federally protected bodies of water.
Vaughan did not respond to requests for comment, but said in 2024 that his bill would have no impact on 'real wetlands,' only small areas created by tractors or livestock. Those, he said, should not be subjected to cumbersome regulations requiring developers to seek permits and complete mitigation efforts to build on or disturb wetlands.
George Nolan, director of the Southern Environmental Law Center's Tennessee office, said the legislation would have a far broader reach.
'That bill, if it passed, would remove all state-level protections for more than 300,000 acres of wetlands,' Nolan told the Lookout. 'That would have tremendous impact, because wetlands help keep us all safe and healthy.'
Wetlands slow down and soak up flood water — Nolan said an acre of wetlands can hold more than a million gallons of water — and they filter water as it moves into the groundwater system to replenish aquifers that provide drinking water. Wetlands also serve as ecologically diverse habitats.
The Harpeth Conservancy, working with data from mapping data firm Skytec, estimates there are roughly 16,000 geographically isolated wetlands that could lose protection along the Duck River. Around 80% of those wetlands take up less than one acre. A little more than half are a quarter acre or less.
'In Middle Tennessee, a hot spot for wetlands is in the upper reaches of the Duck River watershed. The Duck River depends on the groundwater system to recharge that water body,' Nolan said. 'If we destroy wetlands in the upper Duck River watershed, we are going to hurt the river during times of drought.'
The Duck River runs 'right smack dab through the middle' of Hickman County in Dickson Republican Rep. Jody Barrett's district. His constituents are passionate about protecting the river's natural resources and beauty.
Barrett is a real estate attorney and said he understands what Vaughan may be trying to do from a development standpoint, but Barrett still has concerns about the bill. He draws a comparison to a blank canvas. Twenty or 30 dots on that canvas may not look like much, but make it 20,000 to 30,000, and 'it starts filling in pretty quickly.'
'That's what I would fear from this bill,' Barrett said. 'Yes, on its face, it may seem innocuous — that we're only affecting a really small piece of ground — but when you do that multiple times across the entire state, then eventually that's going to really start having an impact.'
Barrett's district doesn't have the type of development that Vaughan's bill might be trying to address, but his constituents recognize that, eventually, growth will reach Hickman County. He's concerned that upstream decisions — including potential destruction of wetlands — could have negative effects for downstream counties like Hickman.
Yes, on its face, it may seem innocuous — that we're only affecting a really small piece of ground — but when you do that multiple times across the entire state, then eventually that's going to really start having an impact.
– Rep. Jody Barrett, R- Dickson
'If we're going to start touching these wetlands, which act as filters and catch basins that slow that rage of water down, what measures are we requiring to be put in their place to make sure that downstream counties, populations and farmers are still being protected,' Barrett asked.
Madison County Republican Rep. Chris Todd said he's not sure if he will advance a bill removing landfill buffers for scenic rivers this session, but he's 'leaning toward it.'
A spokesperson for Calhoun Republican Sen. Adam Lowe, the sponsor for the bill's senate version, indicated it would not run this year.
But Todd said he doesn't intend for the bill to undo protections bestowed on portions of the Duck River in 2023 as a company sought to place landfills on Maury County property that was once owned by agrochemical company Monsanto. Hohenwald Republican Sen. Joey Hensley and Culleoka Republican Rep. Scott Cepicky carried that legislation.
Trinity Business Group sought permits from TDEC to install two landfills on the property, a federally designated Superfund site containing hazardous substances from its Monsanto days. Maury County officials and residents moved quickly to block the permits, citing a law requiring local approval for landfills.
Louisiana landfill company pushes back on Duck River protections
The company sued, and the case remains ongoing.
If he does move the bill forward, he told the Lookout that he'll add an amendment grandfathering in protections approved under the existing law.
Todd's district in Madison County is dozens of miles away from the Duck River, and he said he doesn't have any concerns about a similar situation playing out on West Tennessee rivers.
Todd sees the landfill protections applied to portions of the Duck River a few years ago to be an abuse of the state's Scenic Rivers Act, which was 'never meant to be used like this,' he said. This bill has more to do with the principle than the specific river, he said.
'This bill was only related to the Duck River, maybe in a few people's minds, in that this law that I intend to change has been weaponized in the past to circumvent … our solid waste laws that are already in place and bypass the normal processes for landfill approvals,' Todd said.
Barrett said Todd's bill is 'in direct contrast' to a bill he's proposed that would classify the section of the Duck River that lies within Hickman County as a Class II scenic waterway. The classification would allow private landowners the option to participate in environmental and development protections to ensure the land stays pastoral as Middle Tennessee grows.
Barrett said he hasn't spoken to Todd about the bill and he doesn't know what Todd's motivations are, 'but certainly his bill would be contradictory to the interests of the citizens of Hickman County that are seeking to protect our river from all sorts of future development — not just landfills, but other issues that might eventually have negative impacts.'
Grace Stranch, CEO of nonprofit conservation group Harpeth Conservancy, disagrees with Todd's characterization of scenic river protections being 'weaponized.'
'The legislative intent behind the Tennessee Scenic Rivers Act was to protect rivers with outstanding qualities for present and future benefit to the people,' Strach wrote in an email to the Lookout.
The legislature added the provision prohibiting landfills within two miles of a scenic river in 1990.
'The Duck River, North America's most aquatically biodiverse river, clearly meets the criteria for designation,' Stranch wrote. 'The timing of new designations is irrelevant if they are fulfilling the legislative intent. Removing the landfill prohibition that has been in place for over 30 years erodes the purpose and necessary protections for our outstanding rivers.'
Freshwater mussel shells glisten in the sunlight in just a few inches of water in the Duck River. (Photo: John Partipilo/Tennessee Lookout)
Rep. Jody Barrett, a Dickson Republican, at right with landowner Doug Jones, is concerned potential destruction of wetlands could have negative effects for downstream counties in his district. (Photo: John Partipilo/ Tennessee Lookout)
A portion of the Duck River, Tennessee's longest river, in Coffee County. (Photo: John Partipilo)
Todd said he wouldn't have concerns about putting a landfill less than two miles from the Duck or other rivers because of the 'tight control TDEC has on landfills.'
Environmental advocates think otherwise.
Nolan said having a landfill near the river would carry 'a big risk of harmful pollution impacting the river as well as the scenic beauty of the river being harmed.'
Duck River Conservancy Chairman Doug Jones said the bottom line is 'landfills leak.' He and his group know that landfills are necessary and Middle Tennessee needs them, but said the river needs protection.
'It's just common sense,' Jones said. 'You don't build landfills by scenic rivers … or any river for that matter. You're just asking for trouble.'
Todd also rebuffed rumors that he has nefarious intentions toward the Duck River, or would renege on his pledge to amend the bill so it's not retroactive. He's heard concerns that another bill he's proposed this session that would require water and waste regulations to be based in 'sound science' is related to his proposed landfill legislation. He says that's false.
When asked, Todd said he's not aware of any standing Tennessee regulations that were not based on sound science.
'It's just a topic I've heard discussed and thought, 'That may be something we need to look at,'' he said.
Stranch said even if the bill is amended to grandfather in rivers that already have landfill buffers in place, other rivers would suffer.
'Landfills pose unique risks to our outstanding rivers; allowing them so close to our rivers will ensure future rivers designated Class II under the Tennessee Scenic River Act will not have the same necessary protections for our present and future generations,' she said.
Anita Wadhwani contributed to this story.
SUBSCRIBE: GET THE MORNING HEADLINES DELIVERED TO YOUR INBOX

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Lisa Field declares victory in Taunton state rep race — Larry Quintal calls for recount
Lisa Field declares victory in Taunton state rep race — Larry Quintal calls for recount

Yahoo

time9 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

Lisa Field declares victory in Taunton state rep race — Larry Quintal calls for recount

TAUNTON — With a razor-thin lead of 21 votes, Democrat Lisa Field claimed victory in her state representative race against Republican Larry Quintal at approximately 9 p.m. on election night on Tuesday — but Quintal has not conceded and said he will be seeking a recount. "The good news is that we won," Field said at her post-election party at the Ward 5 Club in Taunton. "It was only by 21 votes so it was within the margin of error." Larry Quintal will not be conceding the race, he told the Gazette, and will instead be seeking a recount. Voters from Taunton and Easton turned out at the polls on June 10 for a special election to choose who would replace former 3rd Bristol District State Representative, Carol Doherty. Doherty, a Taunton Democrat, was 82 when she died on Feb. 15 this year from pancreatic cancer. According to unofficial election results from Easton, Field won 1,032 votes while Quintal won 958 votes, giving Field a 74 point lead in Easton. Lisa Field won 1,542 votes in Taunton, while Larry Quintal won 1,595 votes, giving Quintal a 53 point lead in Taunton, according to unofficial results from the City's website. That was not enough to overcome Field's lead of 74 votes in Easton, making for a combined lead of 21 votes for Field. "I appreciate everything that everyone did," Field said, thanking her supporters at her victory speech at the Ward 5 Club. "It was thousands and thousands of doors that we knocked," she added. 3rd Bristol District, consists of parts of Taunton and parts of Easton. Specifically, the district consists of Precincts 4A, 5, and 6 in the south-west part of Easton, and Ward 1 Precincts A, B, Ward 2, Ward 5, Ward 7 and Ward 8 in the west side of Taunton. Quintal, a Republican, is a Taunton City Councilor and is co-owner/funeral director at Silva Funeral Home on Broadway in Taunton. Quintal won his first term on City Council in November 2021 and his second term in November 2023. He told the Gazette during his State Rep. campaign he believes his profession prepared him for politics. 'Caring for and putting people first,' and 'listening to people' come naturally to him, he said. Quintal also stated he is a small-business owner, not a lobbyist, and has no vested or special interests other than to help his community. On why he decided to run for State Rep., Quintal told the Gazette, 'I'm not doing this for fame and fortune. I feel I have a proven track record on the local level, and I feel I can get more done and help more on the state level." Quintal's campaign priorities have been to increase state aid to his district, improve affordability for residents by decreasing taxes and finding ways to reduce utility bills, and addressing the state's costly housing of migrants by amending the Right-to-Shelter Law. Lisa Field, a Taunton Democrat, comes from a family of union activists and workers, she told the Gazette. She works as associate director for the Massachusetts Nurses Association (MNA). Her role involves advocating for legislation for the MNA on beacon hill. Her position, she said, gives her insight into how the State House works. Field told the Gazette she had been encouraged by her friend, Carol Doherty, to enter state politics, and, upon her death, wanted to "continue her legacy." "I know what families in Taunton and Easton are going through because I've lived it: family and friends struggling with substance use, and the crushing weight of rising costs of living — even losing my home," Field told the Gazette. Her campaign priorities included increasing government transparency, reviewing state education funding, examining the Department of Public Health's enforcement powers, and addressing potential impacts of federal cuts on veterans' services. In June 2020 Doherty won the special election to fill the 3rd Bristol District State Rep. seat that had been vacated by Republican Shaunna O'Connell when she resigned to become mayor of Taunton. Later that year, in November, she won reelection for a full-term. For both those elections Doherty's opponent was Republican Kelly Dooner, who would go on in 2022 to become a City Councilor for Taunton, and eventual State Senator when she won the seat in November 2024. Doherty would win the 3rd Bristol District seat 2 more times before her passing. Before her political career Doherty, a retired educator, worked both as a teacher and guidance counselor at Bennett Elementary School, and then, later on, as director of professional development for the School of Education at Northeastern University for 18 years. She also served two consecutive terms as president of the Massachusetts Teacher Association, as well as five terms on the Taunton School Committee. In April of this year, the Taunton School Committee voted on and approved renaming a building located at 66 Summer St. to the Carol A. Doherty Professional Learning Center. The building will be used by Taunton Public Schools as a professional development center. With additional reporting from Emma Rindlisbacher and Rebecca Hyman This article originally appeared on The Taunton Daily Gazette: Democrat Lisa Field declares victory in Taunton state rep race

New Jersey Democrat indicted over ICE facility altercation, calls charges 'political intimidation'
New Jersey Democrat indicted over ICE facility altercation, calls charges 'political intimidation'

USA Today

time12 minutes ago

  • USA Today

New Jersey Democrat indicted over ICE facility altercation, calls charges 'political intimidation'

New Jersey Democrat indicted over ICE facility altercation, calls charges 'political intimidation' Show Caption Hide Caption Newark mayor Ras Baraka sues over arrest at ICE facility Newark mayor Ras Baraka announced he's suing two federal officials who he allege ordered his arrest at an ICE facility in New Jersey. Rep. LaMonica McIver, D-New Jersey, was indicted on three counts related to a confrontation with law enforcement last month at a Newark immigration detention center. Interim U.S. Attorney Alina Habba announced the indictment on June 10. "While people are free to express their views for or against particular policies, they must not do so in a manner that endangers law enforcement and the communities those officers serve," Habba said in a post on X. McIver was visiting the facility along with fellow Democratic Reps. Bonnie Watson Coleman and Rob Menendez. An altercation occurred after officers arrested Newark Mayor Ras Baraka, who attempted to join the trio in their visit. McIver is said to have then "slammed her forearms" into immigration officers, according to the criminal complaint against her. If convicted, she could face up to 17 years in prison for all three counts. Was it an overreaction? Trump deploys thousands of National Guard, Marines to Los Angeles The congresswoman has denied the accusations, saying they are unjustified. 'The facts of this case will prove I was simply doing my job and will expose these proceedings for what they are: a brazen attempt at political intimidation,' McIver said in a statement reacting to the indictment. Members of Congress, by law, can visit immigrant detention facilities unannounced. McIver's lawyer, Paul Fishman, who served as U.S. attorney in New Jersey during the Obama administration, said that the "legal process will expose this prosecution for what it truly is — political retaliation against a dedicated public servant who refuses to shy away from her oversight responsibilities." The indictment came the same day voters in New Jersey took to the polls to pick their Democratic and Republican nominees for governor. Baraka, whose arrest sparked McIver's standoff with officers, ran for the Democratic nomination but lost to Rep. Mikie Sherrill. Contributing: Sarah Wire, USA TODAY; Katie Sobko,

New Jersey governor's race is set as Mikie Sherrill and Jack Ciattarelli win their primaries
New Jersey governor's race is set as Mikie Sherrill and Jack Ciattarelli win their primaries

Yahoo

time13 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

New Jersey governor's race is set as Mikie Sherrill and Jack Ciattarelli win their primaries

Democratic Rep. Mikie Sherrill and Republican Jack Ciattarelli have won their parties' primaries for governor in New Jersey, NBC News projects, setting up one of the most closely watched races of the year. New Jersey is one of two states with governor's races this year, and the contest will be an early sign of how voters are responding to President Donald Trump's second term. Sherrill beat out five other Democrats for her party's nod, pitching herself as the most electable candidate — after her party struggled in the state last year compared with other recent presidential elections — and as a Democrat willing to stand up to Trump. She also leaned heavily on her background as a former Navy helicopter pilot and on criticism of Trump. "It's going to take a strong voice to cut through the noise from Washington and deliver for the people. So I stand here tonight doing just that. And as a mom of four teenagers, you guys know I'm not going to put up with the incompetent, whiny nonsense coming from aggrieved MAGA Republicans,' Sherrill told her supporters Tuesday at a victory rally. 'You probably can't do better than to quote George Washington at this moment: Fix the bayonets, I'm resolved to take Trenton,' Sherrill added. Ciattarelli, who had Trump's endorsement in the primary, defeated four other Republicans for the nomination in which he also appealed to voters' desire for electability, casting himself as the Trump ally best positioned to win the Democratic-leaning state in November. Ciattarelli came close in 2021 to defeating Democratic Gov. Phil Murphy, who cannot run for re-election because of term limits. And during his victory speech, he panned Sherrill as "Phil Murphy 2.0" and pitched a vision for an inclusive GOP that would buck years of Democratic control in the state. "We made a strong statement about what the New Jersey Republican Party stands for: A party open to anyone and everyone who is willing to work hard and play by the rules; a party of Jersey values and common sense policies; a party that believes our best days are ahead of us if, if we have the courage to think big and act boldly," Ciattarelli said. The Democratic primary featured Sherrill and five other prominent Democrats, including Newark Mayor Ras Baraka, Jersey City Mayor Steve Fulop, Rep. Josh Gottheimer, teachers union president Sean Spiller and former state Senate President Steve Sweeney. While Sherrill, the only woman in the field, was a persistent leader in limited public polling, victory was far from certain as millions of dollars flooded the New Jersey airwaves. Sherrill was winning more than one-third support with most of the expected Democratic vote tallied, holding a double-digit lead over Fulop, the next-closest Democrat. Sherrill showed early signs of strength in crucial Essex County, which is home to the most registered Democrats. The Essex County Democrats endorsed her, but the county also includes Newark, which Baraka leads. Sherrill won around 43% of the mail-in vote, followed by Baraka at 24%, Fulop at 17%, Gottheimer at 10%, Spiller at 5% and Sweeney at 1%. Sherrill proved to be a strong fundraiser, and she did have help from an aligned outside group, One Giant Leap PAC, which launched ads boosting her in the final weeks of the race. Sherrill also racked up support from the most county Democratic parties, prompting some critics to tie her to the state's Democratic political machine. Sherrill touted her military service and her success flipping a longtime Republican House district in 2018 as she made her case to primary voters. While each of the candidates presented a different path forward for the party, Sherrill said the 'obvious' path is to 'effectively govern.' 'Ruthless competence is what people in New Jersey want to see in government,' Sherrill told NBC News before she marched in the Asbury Park Pride parade. 'And that's what I've always provided, and that's what I think stands in stark contrast to the most incompetent federal government we've probably ever seen in this nation.' Ciattarelli leaned on his endorsement from Trump in the final weeks of the race, in which he faced former radio host Bill Spadea, state Sen. Jon Bramnick, former Englewood Cliffs Mayor Mario Kranjac and contractor Justin Barbera. Ciattarelli trounced his opponents, winning more than two-thirds support with most of the expected vote in. Spadea was in a distant second at 22%, followed by Bramnick, Kranjac and Barbera in single digits. Trump hosted a tele-rally as early voting kicked off this month, telling supporters that Ciattarelli is 'going to help us with a win this November and send a powerful message to the entire country that New Jersey is turning red.' But Ciattarelli did have to overcome attacks from Spadea, his chief competitor in the primary, who highlighted Ciattarelli's past criticisms of the president as proof he was not sufficiently pro-Trump. Trump ultimately backed Ciattarelli about a month before the primary, writing on Truth Social that Ciattarelli is now '100%' MAGA and is best positioned to win in November. Both Ciattarelli and Sherrill have already previewed the general election fight, sparring on social media over Trump's sweeping domestic policy bill and his recent decision to federalize California National Guard troops despite Democratic Gov. Gavin Newsom's objections. Sherrill has tied Ciattarelli directly to Trump, who lost the state by 6 points in November after he lost it by 16 in 2020. Sherrill's recent TV ad warns, 'MAGA's coming for New Jersey with Trump-endorsed Republican Jack Ciattarelli,' and she said at a primary debate last month that Ciattarelli is 'not going to stand up to Trump on anything.' It remains to be seen whether Ciattarelli will put some distance between him and Trump in the Democratic-leaning state, but he has said he would campaign with Trump this year. Ciattarelli has also previewed how he might push back against Democrats who try to tie him to Trump, often noting that the next governor must address four crises facing the state: affordability, public safety, education and overdevelopment. 'Last time I checked, this was a race for governor,' Ciattarelli said at a recent campaign stop. 'And so what is it that President Trump has to do with those windmills of our Jersey Shore? What does he have to do with the fact that we have the highest property tax in the nation? What does he have to do with the failure of our public school system, which just slipped from two to 12 on the national report card? What does he have to do with the overdevelopment of our suburbs?' 'They broke it, they own it,' Ciattarelli said of Democrats in charge of the state government. 'And we're not going to let anybody forget it over the next five months.' This article was originally published on

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store