Affirming hormone treatment poses ‘greater risk than benefit' for increasing numbers, says gender service consultant
The proportion of people for whom gender-affirming hormone treatment is a 'greater risk than benefit' is increasing, a consultant from the
National Gender Service
has said.
Representative groups for the
transgender community
have said the current system is 'failing our community' and have called for a new model of care.
Dr Yagoub Gader, consultant endocrinologist at
St Columcilles Hospital Loughlinstown
, where the national service is based, said the evidence base for transgender healthcare is 'underdeveloped' and what does exist is 'of poor quality'.
'Therefore, it is impossible to reliably quantify the potential for risk and benefit in transgender healthcare. This applies for all aspects of transgender healthcare, including hormone therapy,' he said.
READ MORE
Gender-affirming hormone therapy involves people taking hormones such as oestrogen, testosterone or hormone blockers to help achieve physical characteristics that are more masculine or feminine.
'We do not recommend prescribing gender affirming hormone therapy in the absence of a comprehensive, holistic, multidisciplinary assessment, or if, after such an assessment, the apparent risks exceed the apparent benefits.'
Dr Gader said 'clinical complexity is greater than it has ever been before', with people presenting for assessment with multiple unaddressed clinical needs.
Therefore, he said, the proportion of people who are found to have 'greater risk than benefit' at the time of assessment is 'increasing'.
'When clinical risks and/or needs are identified, they are addressed either by referral to community services, other specialist services, or by the multidisciplinary team within the NGS,' he said.
His statement was made in response to a parliamentary question from Labour health spokeswoman Marie Sherlock, who said the lack of recruitment in the area since 2020 'speaks volumes about the lack of seriousness and paralysis' with which the Health Service Executive and Department of Health are treating the National Gender Service.
According to Dr Gader, the waiting time for a first appointment is four years, which the consultant described as 'unacceptably long'.
'Further investment and service development is needed to shorten waiting times. Autism specific supports would also be needed,' he added.
Transgender Equality Network Ireland
(TENI), an advocacy group, said its position is that transgender people who want to access transgender healthcare should be able to do so in a service that is safe, informed, and in their local area.
'While the service is currently seeing individuals who were referred four years ago, the wait-list has grown considerably since,' the organisation said. As of December 2024, there were more than 2,000 people on the wait-list, and the service only took 160 people off the wait-list last year, it added.
This means individuals being referred now are facing a wait of more than 10 years before their first appointment, TENI said, adding that there has been a 'breakdown of trust' between the trans community and healthcare providers.
The group said the assessment process should be functioning to 'identify additional needs so that those needs can be met', but instead 'those needs become barriers to accessing care'.
A spokeswoman for BelongTo, a charity for LGBTQ+ youth in Ireland, said there is 'no active health service for trans young people'.
'Trans young people and their families cannot get the information, supports and referral pathways they need to understand whether accessing gender-affirming care is the right option for them or not,' the spokeswoman said.
The HSE is developing a new Model of Care for transgender healthcare.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
43 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Rapist who threatened three Sunday World journalists jailed for 11 years
A convicted rapist who threatened and harassed three female Sunday World journalists has been jailed for 11 years. Mark McAnaw (53) refused to enter a bond before a sitting of Dublin Circuit Criminal Court which would have suspended the final 12 months of the 11-year sentence imposed for the harassment of Nicola Tallant, Amanda Brunker and Deirdre Reynolds. After Judge Pauline Codd had outlined the conditions attached to the suspended portion of the sentence on Thursday, McAnaw's counsel Rebecca Smith said her client did not wish to enter the bond as he found the conditions 'onerous'. As a result, the judge imposed the full 11-year sentence. Judge Codd also ordered that McAnaw should have no contact either directly or indirectly with the women, should not approach them, go within 10 miles of their homes and workplaces or communicate with them for life. READ MORE McAnaw, previously of Letterkenny, Co Donegal, pleaded guilty to the harassment of the three women on various dates in August 2023. The court heard McAnaw repeatedly sent them emails and messages of a violent and sexually threatening nature, which escalated to him threatening to put a 'bullet' in one of them. He also referred to himself as an 'IRA Top Boy'. He also turned up at the offices of the Sunday World on Talbot Street in Dublin and, when refused entry, he went to a cafe across the road. When gardaí approached him there, McAnaw was in the process of writing an email to Ms Tallant. McAnaw is detained in the Central Mental Hospital (CMH). McAnaw does not accept his diagnosis of schizophrenia and has declined to take medication, the court was told. His previous convictions include the rape of a foreign student in Donegal in October 2010, for which he was sentenced to nine years in prison in 2012. McAnaw also has a 1989 conviction for kidnapping and convictions for assaults causing actual bodily harm from a court in Northern Ireland in 2011. He also has a conviction for aggravated assault after attacking a woman in her home in April 2018, for which he received a sentence of eight years and four months in June 2023. This sentence was backdated to 2018 when he went into custody, with the final 16 months suspended for 16 years on strict conditions. McAnaw was released from custody on this sentence in July 2023 – one month before the harassment of the three journalists took place. Ms Smith said her client instructs that he found it difficult to abide by the conditions attached to the suspended portion of the sentence imposed in 2023. A handwritten letter from McAnaw was also handed to the court, which Judge Codd described as 'concerning'. Judge Codd outlined a global sentence of 11 years, with the final 12 months to be suspended on strict conditions for five years. These included that McAnaw remain under probation supervision for five years, comply with his medical regime, refrain from the use of illicit substances and make available any internet-enabled devices when requested by gardaí. The judge backdated the sentence to August 2023, when McAnaw went into custody. Ms Brunker and Ms Reynolds were present in court when the sentence was imposed. Judge Codd commended the three women for their resilience and courage throughout the process and wished them well for the future.
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Who is Emeis and where are their Irish care homes located?
Emeis is a French nursing home group formerly known as Orpea. It entered the Irish market in 2020 through the takeover of the TLC Nursing Home portfolio and followed up with further deals. A review of all nursing homes operated by Emeis Ireland has now been requested by the Department of Health . Minister of State at the Department of Health with responsibility for Older People Kieran O'Donnell has asked the Health Information and Quality Authority (HIQA) to start the review of all nursing homes operated by the group in the wake of Wednesday's RTÉ Investigates programme. Emeis Ireland runs 27 residential homes across the State, two of which were the subject of the broadcast, which detailed alleged elder abuse and neglect , scenes described by HIQA as 'wholly unacceptable and shocking'. READ MORE Who is Emeis? The nursing home group entered the Irish market in 2020 through the takeover of the TLC Nursing Home portfolio and followed up with further deals. It reported a €70.2 million net loss in 2023, according to its latest annual financial statement, filed with the Companies Registration Office (CRO) in December 2024. That brought its accumulated losses over three years to more than €223 million. Emeis Ireland, the largest private operator in the sector, attributed most of the losses to the writing down of goodwill associated with peak-of-market acquisitions. Still, the company remained profitable at earnings before interest, tax, depreciation and amortisation (Ebitda) level throughout the period. This was helped by the fact that, unlike several operators that entered the market in recent times, it owns most of its properties. Its French parent required a bailout in 2023, led by a state-owned investment firm, in the wake of a scandal over residents' mistreatment in its home market. 'The directors' primary concern is with the health and safety of the group's residents and our employees,' Emeis said in the annual financial statement 'The directors closely monitor and assess the ongoing risks to the health and safety of all residents and employees and develop responses accordingly.'
Irish Times
3 hours ago
- Irish Times
‘Why are there all these mistakes?' Woman laments loss of daughter and unborn grandson as hospital apologises
Tipperary University Hospital has apologised to the family of a woman for shortcomings in care which led to her death and that of her unborn baby. Caroline Kavanagh was 22 weeks pregnant with her second child when she first presented at the Clonmel hospital's emergency department with chest pain. Dr John O'Mahony SC, for Ms Kavanagh's family, told the High Court the 37-year-old was misdiagnosed and her heart attack symptoms were not identified or addressed before she was discharged home. In what counsel described as a 'heartbreaking and extremely sad case', Ms Kavanagh was found unresponsive five days later in bed at her home in Kilmallock, Co Limerick and was later pronounced dead. READ MORE 'Her mother came to her home and found her daughter motionless in bed. Caroline had died and the baby she was carrying died with his mother,' counsel said. Dr O'Mahony, instructed by Ciaran O'Keeffe solicitor, said there was unfortunately a misdiagnosis at the hospital. He said there was a mistaken belief that an elevated level of the protein Troponin in the blood was due to pregnancy when it can also point to cardiovascular issues. Margaret Kavanagh holds a Mass card for her daughter Caroline and unborn grandson TJ outside the High Court in Dublin. Photograph: Collins Courts The letter of apology was read in court as Ms Kavnagh's mother Margaret Kavanagh, of Cashel, Co Tipperary, settled a High Court action against the HSE over her daughter's death on February 11th, 2015. In the letter, interim hospital manager Ailish Delaney expressed 'our profound sympathy and condolences to you on the loss of your daughter Caroline and her unborn child'. It added: 'The management and staff of the hospital apologise sincerely for the shortcomings in the care which was provided to Caroline and which led to her tragic death. The hospital wishes to acknowledge the heartache and distress suffered by her family because of her premature passing and to express our sincere sympathy and regret.' A breach of duty was admitted by the HSE in the case. Noting the settlement, and the division of the statutory €35,000 mental distress payment, Mr Justice Paul Coffey extended his deepest sympathy to the family. At the time of her death, Ms Kavanagh's daughter Megan was just nine-months-old. Speaking outside the court, Margaret Kavanagh said it had taken the family 10 years to get justice for Caroline, but the apology would not bring back her daughter or her unborn baby. 'While we acknowledge the apology from the HSE, as a family we believe that if the past mistakes that were made had had been corrected we would not be here today,' she said. She said Caroline was very much looking forward to the birth of her second child, to be named Thomas James (TJ) and was 'a great mother, daughter, sister and just a great person'. 'Why are there all these mistakes? We are in the 21st century and we seem to be going backwards,' Mrs Kavanagh added, clutching a picture of her daughter worn in a pendant around her neck. She said she dhe hoped no family would in future have to go through 'the pain and loss we have experienced in the last 10 years'. In the proceedings it was claimed a correct diagnosis of acute heart attack was not made and Caroline Kavanagh was not offered appropriate cardiac care to significantly improve her chances of survival when she attended the hospital on February 6th, 2015. She died of complications of heart attack on February 11th, 2015. It was claimed substandard care was provided and she did not have an echocardiogram. She was started on cardioprotective medication on admission to hospital but these were stopped on discharge.
