Perth fire service cuts could put lives at risk, union warns
Lives could be at risk if the number of Perth frontline firefighting appliances are cut according to the Fire Brigades Union (FBU).
Their warning comes as Scottish Fire and Rescue Service (SFRS) chiefs announced a public consultation into changes at Perth Community Fire Station in the city.
In 2023 the Scottish Fire and Rescue Service cut Perth appliances from three to two, with a reduction of 15 firefighters – a move which they want to make permanent.
But the Fire Brigade Union (FBU) point out that firefighters who attended recent Perth blazes - the tragic fire in Scott Street in which a man lost his life and at Balhousie School now facing demolition – reported being under pressure while waiting for help from other fire stations.
If the 2023 changes are approved, the FBU said, it would mean the permanent removal of the third pumping appliance at Perth and 15 firefighter posts.
SFRS chiefs said Perth operational demand for the city's three wholetime appliances is lower than most fire stations with two wholetime appliances.
But Perth-based FBU official Colin Brown said: 'As we have seen in recent weeks the speed and weight of response to fires and other emergencies is crucial to save life and property.
'Crews who attended the fires at Scott Street and Balhousie School have reported being stretched too thin in the early stages of these incidents whilst they awaited additional crews coming from county stations – Dundee's and Fife.
'Perth crews were also deployed to support and provided fire cover into Aviemore during the recent spate of wildfires.
'Cutting firefighter numbers and fire appliances removes resilience from the service when incidents do occur, this has the potential to put lives at risk and the FBU would encourage members of the public to fully engage in the ongoing SFRS consultation and let both SFRS and the Scottish Government know they don't want to see their fire and rescue service cut even deeper.
'The changes in Perth, if approved, would mean the permanent removal of the third pumping appliance and 15 firefighter posts.'
Perth MSP Murdo Fraser criticised the move, particularly given the two devastating blazes in the city last month.
He said: 'These proposed cuts to Perth Fire Station have been feared for a while and I understand the concerns that these will leave the brave firefighters who work there extremely short of much needed resources.
'The spate of recent fires we have seen in Perth underlines the need for a properly resourced fire and rescue service in our community.'
SFRS head of service delivery for the east and the north of Scotland deputy assistant chief officer Andrew Girrity, said: 'Our modelling has shown that two appliances would align better with risk and demand.
'Currently, the third vehicle at Perth is a combined aerial rescue pump, and we want to change this to a dedicated high reach appliance.
'Since 2023, the dedicated high reach appliance has been temporarily crewed, and we need to find a permanent solution.'
Speaking about the service delivery review Mr Girrity added: 'We have an opportunity for the first time since the national SFRS was formed in 2013 to review how we provide our emergency service across Scotland.
'I would encourage as many people as possible to take part in the public consultation process and attend the public meetings.'
A drop-in public meeting will take place tomorrow, Wednesday July 23, from 3pm to 7pm at AK Bell Library in Perth.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scotsman
an hour ago
- Scotsman
Shocking footage shows huge flames engulfing Edinburgh flat block as firefighters tackle blaze
This video More videos A huge blaze which has ripped through a block of flats in Edinburgh has been caught on video. Keep up with the latest new videos with the Shots! Newsletter. Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to Edinburgh News, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... The shocking footage, taken by Lisa Cameron, shows huge orange flames coming from the top of a three-storey building in Loganlea Terrace, Craigentinny. The roof appears to have been destroyed in the blaze, which saw police and fire crews race to the scene shortly after 6pm on Thursday, August 7. Police taped off the road and have urged members of the public to avoid the area. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad The video shows the fire being hosed down by crews, with around 20 firefighters and police officers at the scene. The fire has destroyed the roof of the block of flats in Loganlea Terrace. | Lisa Cameron A Scottish Fire and Rescue Service spokesperson said: 'We were alerted at 6.14pm on Thursday, 7 August, to assist emergency service partners at an incident on Loganlea Terrace, Edinburgh. 'Operations Control have mobilised seven fire appliances and a number of other resources to the scene where a fire is affecting a three-storey property. Crews remain at the scene.'
Wales Online
6 hours ago
- Wales Online
Elderly mum and son stuck in Travelodge living off Pot Noodles after eviction
Elderly mum and son stuck in Travelodge living off Pot Noodles after eviction Paul Maddocks, 43, and his 73-year-old mum Susan Weatherman have been living in a hotel room since July 21 after being made homeless - and are forced to share a double bed Paul Maddocks and his mother have been living a hotel room for weeks A mother and son from Stockport have been residing in a hotel room for weeks following their eviction - without facilities to prepare meals or wash their clothing. Read here about Wales plans to stop people becoming homelessness Paul Maddocks, 43, and his 73 year old mum Susan Weatherman say they've been surviving on Pot Noodles and snacks at the hotel since July 21, and were forced to share a double bed for over a week before securing a twin room. Read here about the government's plan to scrap a law that outlaws rough sleeping and begging Stockport Homes relocated them to the Travelodge on Upper Brook Street in Manchester after they were evicted from their previous residence in Edgeley. Read here about the couple who donated two homes for the homeless Paul and his mum Sue, want to be placed closer to their family and friends in Stockport "We've been here for three weeks now, it's really playing on my mental health," Paul said, reports the Manchester Evening News. For our free daily briefing on the biggest issues facing the nation, sign up to the Wales Matters newsletter here "We've not got a fridge in the room, a microwave, or a cooker, so we're having to eat Pot Noodles and takeaways every day, and there's no laundry here. "We spent two weeks in a room with just one double bed. We're running out of cash, we're getting no support with food. We're trying to budget but we're really worried about when our money runs out. " His mum Susan said: "It's a nightmare, it's doing my head in being here and we're far away from our family and friends." Stockport Homes said it is "deeply sorry for the distress" the family is experiencing. A spokesperson said: "Losing your home through no fault of your own is incredibly hard, and we understand how much tougher it is to manage health issues while staying in a hotel. "No one wants families to be in this situation, and we know it's far from what anyone would consider a home. "Like many areas across the country, we're facing pressures on housing, with far more families needing permanent homes than there are properties available. Sadly, that means some people do have to stay in temporary accommodation while we work to find something more suitable." The statement further assured that efforts will continue to secure a stable home for the family. The pair only have a table top as a kitchen area The Edgeley-based family found themselves without a roof over their heads when their previous landlord, Gary Fildes, sold the property they were renting. Gary explained that he was forced to sell due to mounting financial strains and had reached out to Stockport Homes in March to facilitate a seamless transition to social housing. He has since been assisting the family in liaising with Stockport Homes. Gary expressed his disbelief, stating: "To put a 73-year-old in a hotel for nine days in one room [with her adult son] is mental, I have never heard anything like that. There's been absolutely no message on time frames from the council. I just do not get where the compassion is from them." The necessity of spending on ready meals and takeaways has left Paul and Sue anxious about depleting their funds and having to budget meticulously. A Travelodge spokesperson commented: "We understand the pressure local authorities are under and how difficult this is for them and for the people who desperately need a home. Like many other hotel providers, Travelodge works with local authorities to support them with their temporary accommodation needs. "Travelodge's focus is on ensuring all of our customers have a high quality experience across our hotels and we recognise that a hotel room is not a substitute for a home." The firm also noted that the booking was made on behalf of the guests and that they had no say over the choice of room type. Paul has considered private renting but finds nothing affordable in Stockport. Paul and his mother cannot cook a hot meal anywhere in the room He's currently off work due to illness and has struggled with mental health issues. With rents in the borough averaging £1,000 a month, an 8 per cent increase from last year as reported by the Office for National Statistics, affordability is a challenge. Paul expressed his disappointment with the lack of support from Stockport Homes in their dire circumstances. "My head is just burned out, we feel really let down by Stockport Homes, this is not good enough. "I just want them to give us an update to know what's happening. We have absolutely no idea how long we could be here for. We just do not feel they are trying to help us out of this. "We've tried the private rental market and we just couldn't afford it. We're miles away from our family and friends and other things like GPs." Article continues below Stockport Council is poised to allocate approximately £2m on emergency housing this year, in response to an escalating demand for hotel accommodation and increasing homelessness rates within the borough. Stockport Homes, which is under the council's ownership, oversees the social housing stock in the area, with a register that currently includes about 8,000 individuals on the register.
Scotsman
6 hours ago
- Scotsman
Moderator visits ruin of 'iconic' church devastated by fire
The Moderator of the General Assembly of the Church of Scotland visited the ruins of an iconic church destroyed by fire to stand in solidarity and support the devastated congregation. Sign up to our daily newsletter – Regular news stories and round-ups from around Scotland direct to your inbox Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to The Scotsman, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... Rt Rev Rosie Frew stood shoulder to shoulder with visibly upset members of the former St Mungo's Church in Cumbernauld yesterday as they surveyed the wreckage of what was an iconic landmark at the heart of the town. Struggling to contain her own tears, she said they are "grieving" the loss of a beloved gathering place and the thoughts and prayers of the wider Church of Scotland family were with them. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad With its pyramid shaped roof, the B-listed building is in the town centre and has been an important landmark since it was built in the 1960s, designed by notable Scottish architect Alan Reiach. Rt Rev Rosie Frew outside St Mungo's Church in Cumbernauld that was ravaged by a fire on 2 August, 2025. The alarm was raised around 7.30pm on Saturday, August 2, that the building and connecting halls, was well alight. The emergency services attended the scene but unfortunately the complex could not be saved. There were no reports of injuries and an official investigation into the cause of the fire is underway. Speaking at a gathering outside what is left of the building, Mrs Frew said: "How often do we hear it said and sung that the 'church is not a building, the church is people?' Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad "But people need a gathering place and this has been your gathering place since 1966. Devastated - Susan Cassidy, Kathryn Ross, Rt Rev Rosie Frew and Morag Rusk. "A building described as iconic, a landmark – a building that holds a special place in the lives and the memories of so many." St Mungo's Church is now part of Trinity Parish Church, a union formed from Cumbernauld Old Church and Kildrum and St Mungo's churches on 15 August, 2024. Mrs Frew said: "I'm conscious that there has been much change in recent times with the coming together of the churches that make up Cumbernauld Trinity. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad "I've read of your plans and hopes and dreams, the St Mungo's Hub was, is, a big part of your vision for the future. "Following this awful fire, so much will be on hold, time will be needed to grieve, to re-think, to re-imagine, to seek God's guidance. "You are very much in the thoughts and prayers of members and congregations across the Church of Scotland." Mrs Frew led those gathered, including members of the congregation, Rev Dr Grant Barclay, Clerk to the Presbytery of Glasgow, and her chaplain Rev Dr Karen K Campbell, in prayer. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad "Loving God, gathered here today we give thanks for this church building A place of worship where God has been glorified in word and music, in beauty and creativity A place of gathering for this community, the people of this parish A place where the good news of Jesus Christ has been preached faithfully Sunday by Sunday Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad A place of joy where life and love have been celebrated in the happiest of times A place of refuge where tears have been shed and anguished prayers uttered in the hardest of times A place of comfort where the peace of God has been felt in heart and mind Gathered here today we pray For this congregation and this community Past and present As they grieve this loss As they come to terms with this tragedy As they share memories As they make plans for the future Gathered here today we ask That you would be their comfort That you would give them strength That you would be their guide In the days and months ahead In Jesus' name we pray. Amen. Among those gathered was Morag Rusk, the Session Clerk of Cumbernauld Trinity Church and she was the Session Clerk of St Mungo's Parish Church before the union. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Reflecting on Saturday night, she said: "I was alerted just after 8pm by a member of the congregation who was hysterical and told me 'St Mungo's is on fire, it's terrible, I'm heartbroken'. "I immediately went up to the church and just stood looking at the scene for an hour or two with people from the congregation. "We are absolutely devastated and still coming to terms with it, it is such a well-loved and unique building for the congregation and people in the town. "It was an iconic landmark for Cumbernauld and the pyramid tower be seen as you drive into the town from whatever direction, Glasgow, Airdrie and Falkirk." Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Ms Rusk said the building was used every day of the week by a range of community groups including a Gaelic choir and was the base of a well-used free café for tackling poverty that was set up after the COVID-19 pandemic. "Amidst our shock and grief, we are trying hard to find a positive and we know there will be one day," she added. "Cumbernauld Trinity Parish Church's web page refers to a passage from the Book of Isaiah about new beginnings and we have to cling onto that hope. "Looking forward in to the future after the cause of the fire is known, I would hope that we can recreate something on the site. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad "I don't know what that will be yet and I don't know how long it will take but the bell is still there in the tower and we have retrieved some plaques. "We have to get through our grief but we hope to honour this special place and recreate something in its memory as there is so much history for people – the scene of so many funerals, weddings and family events. "You can see from the huge outpouring of shock and sadness in the community that it is such a loved building." Rev Alastair Duncan, Interim Moderator of Cumbernauld Trinity Church, said he felt "deep sadness" over what has happened. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad "St Mungo's was a place that has seen many, many important occasions for 60 years so it's just deeply, deeply distressing and devastating for the congregation," he added. "Although it wasn't the principal place of worship of the united Cumbernauld Trinity congregation, it was still very much in use. "To lose all of that, the history, the memories, the associations, as well as to lose the capacity for all the community groups that were using it and the possibility of what might have been in the future, is utterly devastating." Mr Duncan said the congregation is "very much in mourning for what it's lost". Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad "It's early days but the hope is that there'll be something new as Cumbernauld is to be extensively redeveloped for the next 10 to 15 years, new houses are to be built very close to the site," he added. "This church and all the artistic impressions of the future was very much in the plan so it would be tragic if there wasn't something fit-for-purpose built to replace it in the years to come. "That remains to be seen and decided but at the moment it is a time to grieve, a time to mourn, a time for lament."
