Claim councillors 'kept in dark' over cycleway
All three members of the Dunedin City Council's hearings committee — which heard from submitters and voted through a proposal on the Albany St Connection project — say they were not informed of the legal rationale to re-consult on the project.
"I still don't know what it's about," Cr Mandy Mayhem said yesterday.
"Completely in the dark about why there was anything wrong with the first time round."
Deputy mayor Cherry Lucas said the hearings committee asked staff if all businesses and property owners affected by the project had been approached, and had been reassured they were.
Staff had even gone door-to-door.
"I'm not sure why this has taken so long."
The council announced last week it had reintroduced nine carparks to the project's design and public consultation would take place until August 7 regarding suggested parking restrictions.
The project aims to provide a safe walking and cycling connection between the shared Te Aka Ōtākou harbour path, Dunedin's tertiary area and the CBD.
Crs Mayhem and Lucas, along with chairman Cr Jim O'Malley, were members of the hearings committee who, in late 2023, voted 2-1 to proceed with a proposal for the project which would have removed 68 carparks in the area.
But a transport report, tabled ahead of an infrastructure services committee meeting in April last year, said some property owners and local businesses had raised concern about the consultation.
Initial legal advice was the consultation process was "potentially open to challenge" and re-consultation would be "prudent", the report said.
Cr O'Malley said he had not seen the legal opinion and did not know what it was based on, which was "exceptionally extraordinary".
He did not believe the consultation process was "flawed" and said there had not been any need for re-consultation.
"I believe that everybody was informed.
"It was publicly notified, we had hearings, there was a huge amount of support for what was there.
"What was not supported was the businesses that wanted those parks back.
"Lo and behold — now the parks are back."
Council transport group manager Jeanine Benson said the legal advice was given verbally to staff, who were advised the initial consultation process could expose the council to "a risk of judicial review in the High Court".
"This followed concerns raised by an Albany St property owner that they had not been properly consulted during initial consultation and that they were considering legal proceedings as a result.
"An assessment was made that re-consultation would be a better use of ratepayer funds than potentially significant litigation costs."
Offering a version of events that differed from the one provided by Cr O'Malley, Ms Benson said Dunedin Mayor Jules Radich and Cr O'Malley were both briefed on the legal advice by council chief executive Sandy Graham in the week before last April's committee meeting.
The procurement process was still on track to start this month and construction to begin in November, she said.
tim.scott@odt.co.nz
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Otago Daily Times
6 hours ago
- Otago Daily Times
Letters to Editor: cycleways, Gaza, mining
Today's letters to the editor include criticism of Cr Jim O'Malley over reactions to a cycle way, the war in Gaza, and discussion around Santana mining. Councillor O'Malley and his lost anatomy Poor Councillor Jim O'Malley. He's facing a life ahead of him without an important part of his anatomy, his backside, having "worked his arse off" on the Albany St cycleway committee, only to have people, God forbid, disagree with him. Spectacularly tone deaf to the pleas of the business community's complaints of more disruption, the loss of 68 valuable parking spaces on campus, and the cycling community stating they don't need or want it, Jim seems mainly offended by the suggestion that his conclusions might just be wrong. He is so aggrieved he's threatening to give up politics. Yeah, right. It may be time for the councillor to realise that committees alone don't make a bad idea good, and that the everyday operation of the city may be more important than costly and damaging leisure and vanity projects for a tiny minority. Ian Pillans Dunedin Stand up Wars may be far away, but their repercussions will affect us now and into the future. New Zealand's mild remonstrances on the Gaza genocide do not reflect our strong stances in the past, where we stood up against South African apartheid, nuclear armed ships and the white supremacy of the mosque attacks. We are allowing Israel to destroy a people and a culture. It is conceivable that a Trump-like character might arise in Australia in the future, who fancies a bit of choice agriculture land across the Ditch. Who will protect us — not the US, whose leader covets Greenland among other places? There are alternatives. The Hague Group is standing up for international law with real action. BRICS is an alternative non-aligned trading group that is trying to bypass the extractive US dominated WTO and IMF. These countries are not perfect, but why are we following the US which continually dabbles in regime change and endless failed wars around the world? Peace and diplomacy are rhetorical flourishes at the moment. Building trust is a hard road which requires listening to the perspectives of others, especially when they are in danger of annihilation, and not pattern-matching our own misconceptions. Ann Mackay Oamaru [Abridged — length. Editor.] Take the offer Cole Martin lists many reasons why there's no peace in the Holy Land (14.7.25) but omits the most obvious. Solely blaming a supposed "system of domination," he ignores critical historical context, ongoing Palestinian violence, and Palestinian leadership's refusal to recognise Israel. The West Bank was occupied by Jordan from 1948 to 1967. Israel gained control of it in a defensive war. Large portions of it are governed by the Palestinian Authority (PA), created through the 1990s bilateral Oslo Accords with the goal of establishing a Palestinian state. Those hopes were dashed when Palestinian leaders rejected generous Israeli peace offers that would have given them control over most of the West Bank, Gaza, and East Jerusalem. Instead, they launched the Second Intifada, a wave of terrorism that left thousands dead and hardened attitudes on both sides. The violence and restrictions Martin laments largely stem from these actions. Palestinians were offered more opportunities for sovereignty than other Middle Eastern minorities. Yet, they squandered each one, attempting to destroy Israel rather than pursuing statehood. Real change can only come when Palestinians choose to stop the violence, recognise Israel, and build the state they were repeatedly offered. A. Levy Dunedin [Abridged — length. Editor.] Historic tale of ironclad ship battle questioned Tuesday's Today in History (8.7.25) describes in 1862 the use of the novel gun turret on USS Monitor being used "to good effect in a decisive battle with CSS Virginia". Wrong on both counts — the ships fought at close range for three hours, inflicting minimal damage on each other, then returned to their bases. Ineffective and indecisive, black-powder muzzle-loaders firing solid shot achieved little in this historic engagement, the first between ironclad vessels. Richard Lea Clough St Leonards [Today In History is based on old ODT files and is updated annually. We welcome reader feedback on omissions and possible inclusions.] Debt and Covid response RE R John Wilson's letter (15.7.25), what would he have done different so as not get into debt? Remembering every other country spent their way out of Covid. Henry Schakelaar Dunedin Saving our species but losing land Wonderful to read of the "Tireless work to save our native central species" (Central Otago News 3.7.25). Sad then to also read of the proposed Santana Minerals Open cast gold mine with its blasting, digging, trucking and carting away of hillsides to leave "open pits a kilometre wide and hundreds of metres deep" across a swathe of our outstanding natural landscapes (Opinion ODT 9.6.25). Sad as we'll lose the stunning landscape many thousands of tourists fly in to admire or millions of people view on TV. Expecting a second series of the murder mystery drama A Remarkable Place to Die to be shot here from November till the end of April, will be so incongruous with the noisy polluting open-cast gold mining and the arsenic and cyanide that'll leak from the unlined toxic sludge dam it leaves. Or maybe they can incorporate this and the waste of native habitat for native birds and lizards in the series for the German, American, Australia and New Zealand audiences? Lynne Stewart Earnscleugh Overseas plunder RE Gavin Dann's letter (18.7.25), His points re jobs, boost to local economy etc, are valid, to a degree. However, if one is to google Tui Mine Tailings Dam, there is a prime example of the perils of an overseas company mining in New Zealand. Since the days of flax and kauri, we have allowed Australian interests to plunder our resources with little return and no regard for the consequences. By all means, allow mining but not at the expense of our environment, and pay well for the privilege. Jerry Lynch Mosgiel
NZ Herald
2 days ago
- NZ Herald
NZ's largest teachers' union taking Government to court over resource teacher cuts
Education Minister Erica Stanford announced consultation on reallocating funding for literacy and Māori resource teachers. The NZEI Te Riu Roa claims she had already decided to cut the services. Photo / Mark Mitchell Listening to articles is free for open-access content—explore other articles or learn more about text-to-speech. Already a subscriber? Sign in here Access to Herald Premium articles require a Premium subscription. Subscribe now to listen. 24 Jul, 2025 01:51 AM 2 mins to read NZ's largest teachers' union taking Government to court over resource teacher cuts Education Minister Erica Stanford announced consultation on reallocating funding for literacy and Māori resource teachers. The NZEI Te Riu Roa claims she had already decided to cut the services. Photo / Mark Mitchell New Zealand's largest teachers' union is taking the Government to court over recent changes to funding resource teachers. Resource teachers work alongside teachers to help students with learning and behaviour difficulties. The latest Budget, in May, confirmed cuts to some resource teacher services. NZEI Te Riu Roa claims Education Minister Erica Stanford had already decided to scrap the services before announcing consultation on reallocating funding for literacy and Māori resource teachers. The union said it had filed for a judicial review in the High Court at Wellington this morning.
Otago Daily Times
2 days ago
- Otago Daily Times
Bath St upgrade moving on to next stage
Road surface work is the next phase of an upgrade in Bath St, central Dunedin. The most complex part of the project, replacing old underground pipes, has been completed. PHOTO: GERARD O'BRIEN The pipes have been installed in Dunedin's Bath St and the focus of an upgrade there has shifted to work above ground. All the planned Three Waters infrastructure work had been completed in the central city street as designed, the Dunedin City Council said. The programme included replacing underground pipes from the 19th century that had deteriorated badly. A water course was piped in about 1887 to allow development of the area, but there were risks of the pipe collapsing, a sinkhole forming and flooding. Ongoing maintenance costs were high, the council said. Senior project manager Susil Gunathilake said the upgrade was a complex project being delivered in challenging conditions. "With the highest-risk component now resolved, we remain on track to meet the latest timeframes and budget," he said. Two minor defects in new pipe connections were identified as part of the quality assurance process. "This is a normal part of any big project and remedying them will require only small excavations to provide access," Mr Gunathilake said. "Repairs are expected to be straightforward." A defects period applied and this meant problems could be identified and remedied by the contractor at no expense to the council. "Other than the standard defects period, work to install the new Three Waters infrastructure is now complete and we're progressing streetscape works above ground as planned," Mr Gunathilake said. "Our contractors will be able to rectify the defects identified while work on the roading upgrade continues." In September last year, the council highlighted a change of plan was necessary because of challenges that included unidentified utilities, some existing where they had not been expected to be located, archaeological finds and unexpected issues with the 326 Moray Pl building under which a pipe was being laid. The project began in April last year and is due to be completed by November.
