
Is AI a Career Threat or a Competitive Edge for Attorneys?
As artificial intelligence promises to reshape the legal profession, much of the conversation centers on which jobs will disappear. But attorneys looking to secure their future may need to flip the script: Rather than viewing AI as a threat, successful lawyers are becoming subject matter experts in the technology itself.
'To be effective counselors, attorneys working at the forefront of innovation need to understand the relevant technology at a deep level,' said Zachary M. Briers, a partner at Munger, Tolles & Olson LLP focusing on complex technology and intellectual property issues.
'When it comes to technology companies, almost all difficult legal issues turn on granular distinctions in technological advancements. This is particularly true with new platform technologies, such as AI, which defy conventional legal analyses,' Briers added.
This need will only increase as litigation around artificial intelligence becomes more complex, according to Nathaniel L. Bach, a partner at Manatt, Phelps & Phillips, LLP.
'The more a lawsuit or advice implicates the inner workings of an AI model, the more attorneys will need to know to properly advise clients, ask the right questions of adversaries, and explain the technology to courts in both accurate and persuasive ways,' said Bach.
Having more than 'a surface-level understanding' of AI may even be a matter of professional competence, said Daniel B. Garrie, a mediator, arbitrator and special master with JAMS, an alternative dispute resolution provider. He is also a founder and partner of Law & Forensics, a legal engineering firm.
'Lawyers are ethically obligated to stay abreast of technological advancements under the ABA's Model Rule 1.1, Comment 8,' said Garrie.
'A deeper comprehension of how AI systems function, including their design, data dependencies, and operational limitations, is crucial for providing competent advice, particularly in areas like eDiscovery, data privacy and intellectual property disputes,' he continued.
Beyond helping to win cases and complying with ethical obligations, understanding AI could be a major career booster. David Lisson, the head of Davis Polk & Wardwell LLP's GenAI litigation initiative, said that the AI space represented a big opportunity for attorneys at the start of their career - a way to stand out from the pack. 'I always think the key to a successful junior associate is being an expert in something. And this is an area that you can really dig into,' he said.
'If you come and figure out what this model is doing and how it's doing it, you'll be the one that the senior attorney comes to, right? And you'll be the one that the client comes to because you're the one that understands what's actually going on.'
From a branding perspective, at least, firms appear to understand the value in highlighting the AI credentials of their attorneys. Over the past two years, a flurry of AI practice groups has emerged in California and elsewhere. But experts, including those who head up these groups, acknowledge that this strategy will need to evolve.
'This trend has begun and will continue, but these groups will almost certainly evolve to be increasingly specialized over time, as it becomes clear that 'AI' is far too broad a category to usefully define a practice,' Keith Enright, cochair of Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher LLP's Artificial Intelligence Practice Group said.
Bach said that AI practice groups were both 'a necessity and a calling card' for many firms. To be effective, these groups would need to encompass practice areas spanning intellectual property, privacy and technology.
'The AI space is too big and moves too fast for any one lawyer to know everything,' he said.
That's a sentiment shared by Peter H. Werner, co-chair of Cooley LLP's global emerging companies and venture capital practice group.
He said that the recent emergence of AI practice groups was 'similar to having an 'internet' practice group in the 1990s.'
'Some firms are forming 'AI practice groups' to signal to the market that they're focused on AI-related things. But the ubiquity of AI and related technologies will mean that the work that is done in every practice will be impacted by AI,' he said.
He added that Cooley instead has 'an interdisciplinary, interdepartmental internal task force that's intended to be a clearinghouse to coordinate our work on AI-related matters, many of which implicate multiple practices.'
Briers said that while 'most major firms now have a practice group that is dedicated to AI-related issues,' it was 'not enough that a few attorneys at each firm become familiar with this disruptive technology. It needs to be a firm-wide initiative.'
Attorneys who wish to become AI-literate have options. Law schools appear attuned to the fact that there will be an increasing demand for such knowledge.
A 2024 survey from the American Bar Association found that more than half of respondent schools now offer classes on AI. Many of these initial efforts focus on introducing students to the appropriate and ethical use of AI tools in their practice.
However, some go further: UC Berkeley, for example, will begin offering a specialization in AI law and regulation this summer as part of its executive track LLM program, including a unit on the fundamentals of AI technology. The curriculum for the new certificate was designed in consultation with an advisory group of industry leaders, including representatives from Anthropic and Meta.
Other schools are offering shorter standalone graduate certificates or programs in artificial intelligence for legal practitioners, including USC Gould School of Law and Harvard Law School.
Beyond these programs, attorneys with an existing science, technology, engineering or mathematics (STEM) background might be at an advantage to their colleagues in an AI world, though legal experts disagree on the significance of this.
'The shift to AI is indeed an opportunity for attorneys with a background in computer science, data science, or engineering areas to gain a distinct advantage in understanding the nuances of AI-related legal challenges,' Garrie said.
'As AI legal work often intersects with technical fields like cybersecurity, data analytics and software licensing, firms may increasingly value and recruit legal talent with such dual credentials. This intersectional expertise enhances both client trust and legal efficacy,' he added.
Clinton Ehrlich, a partner at Trial Lawyers for Justice who is a member of the U.S. 9th Circuit Court of Appeals Artificial Intelligence Committee and has a computer science background, said lawyers working on AI cases or issues was analogous to lawyers working in the patent space, where many attorneys have a STEM background.
'This is an area of the law where skills are required beyond those that most generalists have,' Ehrlich said.
'It doesn't mean that a generalist couldn't be involved on a team that's litigating a case involving questions about AI, but I think it's very important to have at least one team member with really deep domain knowledge of how these systems work, so that you aren't just translating everything through the medium of popular science,' he said.
Others were more circumspect, emphasizing that a willingness to learn and engage was far more important than prior education experience.
Werner said that attorneys 'don't necessarily need a technical degree for most things, but you need curiosity. The best lawyers are quick studies. We work with cutting edge technology and life sciences companies, using complex methodologies to do complicated things.'
He predicted that as the law and technology become increasingly intertwined, we could witness 'hybrid teams of people at firms that include lawyers and technologists that collectively pitch for and deliver service to clients – think e-discovery on steroids.'
According to Enright, 'Intellectual fluidity and the ability to frame questions effectively will be vastly more valuable than a STEM background.'
Vivek Mohan, the other co-chair of Gibson Dunn's artificial intelligence practice, said that whenever he talks to law students and recent graduates interested in the practice area, he tells them, 'I look for ongoing, demonstrated interest. Certainly, an undergraduate degree in a related area is a strong signal of interest.'
But he cautioned that an attorney's role is 'not to substitute ourselves for the engineers or AI researchers at our companies. It is to listen carefully, ask probing questions and then provide the best legal advice we can.'
He added that attorneys interested in AI should get comfortable with occasionally not knowing what is going on with AI models, given even their engineers are not always able to explain how a model reached a particular answer.
'Learn what you can, but you have to be able to get comfortable with operating in an environment that carries a certain degree of uncertainty,' he advised.
The other risk of overemphasizing prior education? Instilling a sense that technological stasis is acceptable, said Briers.
'An engineering background might be helpful in understanding these new technologies, but it's not necessary. In my experience, too many attorneys who lack a STEM background use it as an excuse to not learn new technological skills. They do so to the detriment of their clients' interests,' he said.
The Los Angeles/San Francisco Daily Journal is a publication for lawyers practicing in California, featuring updates on the courts, regulatory changes, the State Bar and the legal community at large.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Bloomberg
24 minutes ago
- Bloomberg
Odd Lots: This Is How Chinese Manufacturers Are Countering Trump's Trade War
President Trump has announced tariffs on basically every trading partner. However there is a real sense that the ultimate goal is to hamper the growing perceived economic threat from China. One vision, for how the trade war could be "won" in some sense is by isolating China from the rest of the world. But that's not happening. And in fact, if anything, China is deepening its relationship with other trading nations, particularly in Asia right now. On this episode we speak with Cameron Johnson, a partner at the consulting firm Tidalwave Solutions. Cameron is based in Shanghai, and has an on-the-ground perspective on the state of Chinese manufacturing, having worked alongside producers and end buyers. He talks about the scale of Chinese manufacturing dominance, what Chinese firms are doing to counteract the tariffs, and he argues that in artificial intelligence, China is already way ahead in many respects.


Forbes
24 minutes ago
- Forbes
Small Businesses Love AI — But Most Are Missing What Matters
From marketing to discoverability, AI is transforming small business — but what's happening behind ... More the scenes may matter more. It's never been easier to generate a social post, draft a newsletter, or spin up a polished website using AI like it is today. And many small businesses are embracing AI, automating marketing tasks, building faster sites and scaling campaigns that once required full teams. But according to two executives shaping AI adoption for small businesses — Itai Sadan, cofounder and CEO of Duda, and Louis Gutierrez, director of AI at Constant Contact — a more complicated picture is emerging. While the excitement about AI-powered automation is real, most SMBs are not yet ready to combat the challenges that come with using AI. Reality Versus Expectations At Duda, which powers more than a million small business websites, nearly 45% of new sites now use at least one AI assistant, according to Sadan. From SEO optimization to content generation, the tools are being adopted at a striking rate. 'We're seeing this huge uptake, especially in areas like image alt text generation or SEO automation,' Sadan said. 'What used to take hours can now be done in minutes with a single click.' Constant Contact is seeing a similar pattern. Gutierrez noted that many of their small business users are 'doing more with less' — wearing multiple hats, streamlining content workflows and using AI to personalize customer communication at scale. 'AI lets them scale, yes,' Gutierrez said, 'but it also allows them to focus on what they're passionate about and delegate the rest.' But these gains come with a shift in customer expectations. As AI makes marketing faster and more accessible, customers now expect more personalized experiences, faster turnaround and seamless execution. The pressure on small businesses to perform like enterprises — without the same resources — is growing by no small margins. Real Infrastructure Needs While AI appears magical on the surface, the infrastructure underneath is anything but. Gutierrez, who also teaches a course in explainable AI at UT Austin, likened AI models to perishable goods. 'Think of models like a can of beans,' he told me. 'There's an expiration date even if it's not visible. Over time, their performance degrades. And without infrastructure that allows you to update, retrain, or replace them, you're flying blind.' That's why Constant Contact's biggest AI bet isn't a shiny front-end feature but infrastructure. From fine-tuning pipelines to monitoring model drift, the company is building the capacity to stay agile regardless of whether today's dominant model is replaced tomorrow. Sadan sees infrastructure as equally essential. Duda recently rolled out MCP-powered AI copilots that allow users to launch, maintain and edit websites using natural language. In other words, users can now talk to the website builder like they would a human assistant — asking it to update content, fix layouts, or add features just by typing in plain language. But under the hood, it works by chaining API calls, model queries and platform logic into one coherent action layer. 'These are real agentic systems,' Sadan said. 'But if you don't have the data structures, APIs, and schema mapping in place, none of it works. The AI can't fake its way through broken plumbing.' Governance Isn't Optional Anymore Despite the impressive front-end capabilities, both leaders warn that AI without governance is a disaster waiting to happen, especially for small teams with limited oversight. 'At some point, a staff member will drop sensitive customer data into ChatGPT,' Sadan said. 'Not because they're careless but because there are no rules.' Gutierrez agreed, noting that that's why Constant Contact established an internal AI governance committee to vet AI tools for ethics, privacy, security and standardization. The challenge, he explained, isn't just performance. It's what happens when tools fail or deliver biased results. 'Everything's easy when you prototype on your laptop,' he said. 'But the second a model goes into production, it behaves in ways you never imagined. That's where governance matters most.' Without a clear policy, companies risk leaking data, overpromising capabilities, or baking systemic bias into customer-facing tools. And while governance may sound like an enterprise luxury, both executives say it's a small-business necessity. The New SEO War Perhaps the most overlooked trend in small business AI is how people find products and services in the first place. While Google still dominates traffic, Sadan said traffic from ChatGPT citations is 'growing at a staggering pace.' Duda is betting heavily on this shift. In addition to automating SEO tasks, the company is investing in AI discoverability features that optimize websites for how LLMs index and interpret them. From FAQ schemas to product data markup, the goal is to rank in the age of AI-powered search, not just traditional queries. 'This is like the early days of Facebook for businesses,' Sadan said. 'If you understand how to ride the wave early, you can grow faster than your competitors, all for less.' Gutierrez, meanwhile, is watching another shift: Vibe coding — the ability to build full software applications using natural language. 'It's turning non-coders into full-stack developers,' he said. 'In a few years, every small business could build their own CRM or booking system just by describing what they want.' Wielding AI Well Both executives agree: AI won't replace small businesses, but using it poorly could put them at risk. Gutierrez warned against the current trend of overpromising what AI can do. 'I'm in vendor meetings all the time,' he said. 'Too many pitch AI as a magic box that does everything. That's dangerous.' Sadan echoed this sentiment, adding that the biggest mistake small businesses make is adopting tools without evaluating their actual productivity gains. 'Try the tool,' he said. 'If it doesn't make your day faster or your work better, it's not worth it, no matter what the marketing says.' What's missing from many AI adoption stories is restraint. It's not enough to use AI; you have to understand what it's good at, what it's not and how to build around that reality. That means investing in infrastructure, enforcing governance and designing for a future where autonomous discovery and interaction may define who thrives and who doesn't. As Gutierrez put it: 'You don't win by adding AI to your toolset. You win by building a business that knows how to wield it.'


Forbes
24 minutes ago
- Forbes
Is Ambient AI A Commodity In Healthcare?
CHINA - 2025/02/11: In this photo illustration, a doximity logo is displayed on the screen of a ... More smartphone. (Photo Illustration by Sheldon Cooper/SOPA Images/LightRocket via Getty Images) Ambient AI is one of the most prominent trends in healthcare technology, particularly among frontline healthcare providers. Tools that can listen in the background and auto-generate clinical notes are reshaping how physicians, NPs, and PAs manage documentation. Until recently, most of these solutions came with steep price tags or complex integrations. Now, Doximity has entered the game with Doximity Scribe, its own AI-powered ambient listening tool—and it's offering it completely free to verified U.S. clinicians. Of course, nothing in this world is truly free. However, in this case, there are no subscriptions, no hidden fees, and no audio data retention—just a strategic move by Doximity to establish itself as the go-to digital platform for clinicians. How It Works Users can access Doximity Scribe on both desktop and mobile. Open the Doximity app and look under the "AI Tools" tab, or go to on your browser. Start Scribe at the beginning of a patient visit. With one tap, it begins to listen securely like a second set of clinically trained ears. As the clinician speaks with the patient, the Scribe captures the clinical conversation in real-time. It filters out small talk and focuses on medically relevant information, such as new symptoms, changes in medication, and key historical points. When the clinician uses Doximity Dialer, Doximity's HIPAA-compliant telehealth tool that allows clinicians to call or video chat with patients from their devices while hiding their number, Scribe integrates directly into the workflow (currently in beta). This setup allows the clinician to conduct the visit and document it on the same screen, eliminating the need to switch between apps or devices. After the encounter, stop or pause the Scribe. It will instantly generate a draft clinical note based on what it heard. Reviewing the note is crucial. Scribe offers a solid first draft, but clinicians must ensure accuracy and completeness. Ultimately, the clinician is the final editor before copying it into their EMR. Final Thoughts Doximity Scribe doesn't replace clinical judgment, but it is free, and it will be interesting to see whether this "free" product will increase adoption. The biggest hurdle is simple: Scribe doesn't integrate with the EMR. Clinicians have to copy and paste notes, which is a challenge. How will the clinician transfer the final note, which is text data from their personal phone or laptop, to a hospital laptop or desktop? It is not an open network where files can be easily air-dropped or connected within the enterprise. The lack of EMR integration remains the most significant hurdle, which is precisely why large health systems tend to opt for fully integrated solutions. Still, smaller healthcare organizations could see real value in using Scribe to save costs without sacrificing quality. The bigger question now is who's next. As Doximity sets the bar by offering a free ambient AI tool, it's only a matter of time before other vendors follow suit.