CIA's Chinese Recruitment Ads: A Psychological Operation Against the CCP?
Commentary
What may appear as clumsy CIA recruitment videos to some could actually be a calculated strike in the psychological war against the Chinese Communist Party (CCP).
The CIA on May 1 released two professionally produced Mandarin-language videos titled 'Why I Contacted the CIA:
The agency distributed the videos on platforms like YouTube, Facebook, and Instagram, offering detailed instructions on how to make secure contact through encrypted channels and dark web portals.
This highly public recruitment effort is part of a broader campaign that began in October 2024, aimed at rebuilding the CIA's intelligence networks in hard-to-penetrate states such as China, Iran, and North Korea. The initiative follows a string of past recruitment successes in Russia and a renewed U.S. focus on China, which
The effort also responds to historic losses; in the early 2010s, Chinese counterintelligence dismantled a major CIA spy ring, resulting in the arrests and executions of numerous informants. Since then, China has become one of the most difficult environments in the world for espionage. By going public with recruitment efforts, the CIA may be seeking to bypass traditional barriers and reestablish contact with potential sources inside the regime.
Related Stories
5/1/2025
5/2/2025
The CCP has yet to issue a formal statement addressing the CIA videos. However, the Ministry of State Security (MSS) has recently ramped up public warnings against foreign espionage. The MSS has accused foreign agencies of posing as romantic partners or job recruiters to lure citizens into providing sensitive information.
The Chinese spy agency also alleges that U.S. intelligence services buy Chinese social media accounts and SIM cards to bypass national ID systems and reach targets online. On platforms like WeChat, the MSS has increased its messaging, urging citizens to report suspicious behavior and even offering rewards to those who reinforce Beijing's counter-espionage culture.
Reactions on Chinese social media have largely ridiculed the CIA campaign. Users mocked the videos as amateurish, unrealistic, or simply laughable, and many questioned whether any serious individual would risk contacting the CIA given China's strict surveillance. Parodies quickly circulated online, turning the recruitment videos into memes. The dominant sentiment on Chinese platforms is that the CIA underestimates both Beijing's ability to control information and the average citizen's loyalty, or fear, of the regime.
Despite online ridicule, the CIA's recent video campaign—though seemingly ham-handed, hokey, and easy to mock—may have been deliberately crafted that way. According to CIA
The style and tone of the videos align closely with established
There is a longstanding precedent for this type of information warfare. During the Cold War, the CIA covertly
In this case, the CIA videos appear tailored to exploit rising disillusionment within the CCP. Under Xi Jinping's anti-corruption campaign, thousands of officials have been purged, often without warning or due process. The dramatizations in the recruitment videos mirror this reality, portraying mid-level bureaucrats living in fear of arbitrary punishment and ambitious professionals frustrated by career stagnation and inequality.
According to former CIA China analyst Dennis Wilder, the campaign marks a shift from passive intelligence collection to active engagement. It may also serve as a form of psychological disruption, with the video targeting the CCP's internal cohesion.
The campaign may also serve as a global signal. It tells U.S. allies and the American public that the intelligence community is once again taking the CCP threat seriously, following years of setbacks. It also projects a message to the Chinese diaspora, particularly professionals in academia, technology, and business: We're watching, and we want you on our side.
According to the CIA's 'Psychological Operations in
First, the videos show paranoia inside the CCP, forcing the regime to divert resources to internal surveillance.
Second, they highlight internal corruption and dissatisfaction, amplifying fractures within the bureaucracy.
Third, the campaign targets Chinese nationals abroad, positioning them as potential long-term intelligence assets.
Fourth, its public nature reasserts the presence of U.S. intelligence and challenges the narrative of American decline.
Finally, the operation may be designed to provoke an overreaction from Beijing, such as mass purges, heightened censorship, or crackdowns on foreign media, which could backfire diplomatically and further expose the CCP's authoritarianism. A heavy-handed response could also fuel internal dissent, increasing the likelihood that public officials or Chinese citizens might choose to cooperate with the CIA.
The world of espionage is built on layers of lies and disinformation. The mere fact that the CIA released this video may be as significant—if not more so—than whether it actually recruits anyone. Xi Jinping now knows the CIA is targeting CCP members and Chinese citizens, and regardless of public mockery, he will be forced to respond, diverting resources at a time when he's already facing President Donald Trump in the White House and an escalating trade war.
Views expressed in this article are opinions of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of The Epoch Times.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CNBC
40 minutes ago
- CNBC
Cramer says 'be ready for disappointment' as the White House continues to shape market action
CNBC's Jim Cramer reviewed Monday's market action, chalking up the day's performance to expectations about the White House's next move. He advised that investors prepare for turbulence, even as some on Wall Street continue to have optimism about President Donald Trump's impact on big business. "We have to be ready for disappointment, because we've seen it over and over and over again," he said. "This administration is perfectly willing to disappoint the stock market…to advance their agenda, and it's foolish that you should believe otherwise." According to Cramer, the past two sessions have been shaped by changing notions of trade relations between the U.S. and China. After opening lower on Monday, stocks managed to finish in the green by close. Cramer said Wall Street was encouraged after a senior White House official told CNBC that Trump is set to meet with Chinese President Xi Jinping very soon. Cramer remarked that with one report, "the market did an entire 180." He speculated about whether the president is content to have "a genuine trade peace with China," even as investors are largely hopeful Trump will change course and loosen restrictions on semiconductor exports to the country. But Cramer noted that there are still broader fears pushing a number of stocks down. Dell reported a strong quarter last week. According to Cramer, shares later dipped in part because investors worried about the administration's push to squeeze federal contractors — many of whom buy equipment from the company. Government contractor Booz Allen Hamilton has also seen its stock get crushed, he continued. New tariffs have also spurred the declines of many U.S. outfits with major suppliers abroad, including Gap and Apple, Cramer added. "We're always one posting, one whisper away from rallying or declining," Cramer said. "As long as we recognize that the President's in control of the stock market — at least, when he wants to be — we can make sense of this tape." The White House did not immediately respond to request for comment. Click here to download Jim Cramer's Guide to Investing at no cost to help you build long-term wealth and invest
Hamilton Spectator
41 minutes ago
- Hamilton Spectator
Removing Chinese tariffs on Canadian agriculture products a priority, says Carney
SASKATOON - Prime Minister Mark Carney says he plans to work urgently to remove Chinese tariffs on Canadian agriculture and seafood products. Carney says Ottawa is speaking with Chinese officials at the ministerial level and that the issue is a top priority for the federal government. The commitment comes after a meeting the prime minister had with the country's premiers in Saskatoon. A statement released after the meeting says premiers want Canada's trading relationship with China to improve. Beijing imposed retaliatory tariffs of 100 per cent on Canadian canola oil and meal, peas and seafood after Ottawa slapped levies on Chinese-made electric vehicles, steel and aluminum. Saskatchewan Premier Scott Moe has said China's tariffs threaten the province's canola industry. This report by The Canadian Press was first published June 2, 2025.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
China's Rare Earths Grip Gives Xi Leverage in US Trade Duel
(Bloomberg) -- After the US and China agreed in Geneva to lower tariffs from astronomical heights, tensions are now surging over access to chips and rare earths. And Beijing increasingly appears to have an edge. Billionaire Steve Cohen Wants NY to Expand Taxpayer-Backed Ferry Where the Wild Children's Museums Are The Economic Benefits of Paying Workers to Move Now With Colorful Blocks, Tirana's Pyramid Represents a Changing Albania At London's New Design Museum, Visitors Get Hands-On Access President Donald Trump on Friday accused China of violating the agreement struck last month, and sought a call with Xi Jinping to sort things out. The main sticking point appears to be critical minerals, with US officials complaining Beijing hadn't sped up exports needed for cutting-edge electronics. The US has said the decision to reduce tariffs hinged on a Chinese agreement to lift controls on some rare earths. 'It's going to require a discussion between the presidents of the two countries,' Deputy US Treasury Secretary Michael Faulkender said Monday in a brief interview with Bloomberg Television. As China keeps constraints on metals critical to America's national security, Washington is ramping up its own tech restrictions. Over the past three weeks, the US has barred the shipping of critical jet engine parts to China, throttled Beijing's access to chip-design software and slapped fresh curbs on Huawei Technologies Co. chips. That's sparked anger in world's second-largest economy. Chinese officials on Monday vowed to respond and accused the US of undermining the Geneva consensus, dimming the chance of a leaders call. For years, Washington was believed to have the advantage over China in the fight for technological dominance thanks to its grip on semiconductor supply chains. Xi has shown he's ready to fight back, in part by tightening controls over critical minerals in a bid to force the US into easing its restrictions. While the Trump administration has shown little sign of relenting on chip curbs, it has discovered replacing China as a supplier of rare earths could take years and cause pain for key industries. The Asian nation produces almost 70% of the world's metals crucial for making fighter jets, nuclear reactor control rods and other critical technology. China is gaining ground in the standoff, according to Cory Combs, associate director at consultancy Trivium China who specializes in supply chains. Washington is still a decade away from securing rare earths independently from Beijing, while Chinese firms have developed capable alternatives to most US chips, he said. 'China's leverage is more durable than a lot of the US leverage at this stage,' he added. 'I'm not sure if this works out well for the US.' The dispute has the potential to endanger the fragile trade truce between Washington and Beijing. In theory, tariffs could snap back to more than 100% after the 90-day negotiating period. Trump has incentive to avoid that, after the US economy shrank at the start of the year and markets panicked under the weight of huge tariffs. Supply-Chain Warfare As part of the agreement struck in Switzerland, China promised to remove or suspend 'non-tariff countermeasures taken against the United States' after Trump announced punitive duties in April. The Chinese government did not elaborate on what that entailed. Rare-earth exporters must apply for permits from the Ministry of Commerce. That process is opaque and difficult to verify, allowing officials to turn it on and off again with little visibility from the outside world. The paperwork involved has caused hold-ups, which are only now showing signs of easing. 'We are seeing some approvals come through — certainly slower than industry would like,' said Michael Hart, president of the American Chamber of Commerce in China. 'Some of the delay is related to China working through their new system.' For some US firms, the metals can't flow fast enough. Ford Motor Co. temporarily shuttered a factory in Chicago last month because it ran short of rare earth components. At a long-running US defense aviation conference Combs recently attended, rare earths were a top talking point. Attendees took the threat 'very seriously,' he said. Such concerns show why export controls have become a central pillar of China's supply-chain warfare: They can hurt US industries while causing little harm at home. Tariffs, in comparison, can be costly both for Chinese manufacturers and consumers. Giving Xi even greater leverage, the impact of China's rare earths controls aren't limited to American importers. India's largest electric scooter maker, Bajaj Auto Ltd., warned last week that the country's vehicle production will take a hit as early as July if China doesn't resume shipments. 'Supplies and stocks are getting depleted as we speak,' said the firm's executive director Rakesh Sharma. Over 30 such applications have been made for shipping to Indian companies — and none have been approved so far, Sharma added. Companies from another large Asian importer only started getting permits last week, according to an official from the country who asked not to be named. China's squeeze on all countries highlights another risk for Trump: Strategic US sectors, such as batteries and semiconductors, depend on South Korea and Japan for components. If Beijing cuts off those US allies from rare earths, American firms could face even more pain. Japan's top trade negotiator Ryosei Akazawa called rare earths 'undoubtedly a critical theme for economic security,' after emerging Friday from his latest round of trade negotiations with US counterparts. Next Battleground Critical minerals were flagged as the next battleground in US-China ties at the height of Trump's first trade war, when Xi visited one of his country's biggest permanent magnet producers — a trip widely seen as an implied threat. In July 2023, Beijing followed through by slapping export curbs on gallium and germanium — minerals used to make semiconductors — after the US sought to restrict China's access to artificial intelligence chips. Recognizing the danger, the US Department of Defense has pledged to develop a complete mine-to-magnet rare earth supply chain for all domestic defense needs by 2027. A lack of commercially viable natural reserves, few engineers trained in the extraction process and limited numbers of companies able to compete at the industry's thin price margins are just some of the challenges the department faces. The US national security establishment has known about its dependency on China for years yet hasn't come up with a solution at scale, according to Liza Tobin, managing director of risk advisory firm Garnaut Global. Despite that, she said, the Trump adminstration isn't making concessions. 'Over the last couple of weeks, you've seen them doubling down with this empowered Commerce Department strengthening and broadening the export controls,' she told Bloomberg Television. Catching up will depend on how deeply Washington is willing to spend. Trump is already tapping foreign capital. During the president's trip last month to the Middle East, MP Materials Corp. — the sole US producer of rare earths — signed a deal with Saudi Arabia's top mining firm to develop a supply chain. The US could also intensify cooperation with Australia's Lynas Rare Earths Ltd. — the largest producer of separated rare earths outside of China, although that operation still sends some of its oxides to the Asian nation for refining. While capacity is building in Brazil, South Africa, Japan and Vietnam, they can't offer an immediate fix for US firms. Beijing hasn't exhausted its leverage. Restrictions so far have targeted medium- and heavy-rare earths, which are concentrated in defense applications. Weaponizing light rare earths — such as neodymium and praseodymium — could deal an even bigger blow to the US economy, as they're more widespread in consumer goods. For now, Xi is unlikely to pursue the most extreme options as it could invite blowback from vulnerable industries, said Neil Thomas, a fellow for Chinese politics at the Asia Society Policy Institute's Center for China Analysis. 'Beijing's controls on rare earths are a warning against further escalation,' he added. 'But if US-China tensions worsen again, then Beijing may start to inflict real pain on US defense supply chains.' --With assistance from Lucille Liu, James Mayger, Mackenzie Hawkins, Yoshiaki Nohara, Keith Naughton and Caroline Hyde. (Updates with analyst quote.) YouTube Is Swallowing TV Whole, and It's Coming for the Sitcom Millions of Americans Are Obsessed With This Japanese Barbecue Sauce Mark Zuckerberg Loves MAGA Now. Will MAGA Ever Love Him Back? Trump Considers Deporting Migrants to Rwanda After the UK Decides Not To Will Small Business Owners Knock Down Trump's Mighty Tariffs? ©2025 Bloomberg L.P.
