Don't question our commitment to player welfare, World Rugby tells Joe Schmidt
Schmidt, a former World Rugby director of rugby and high performance, was left seething following his team's 29-26 second-Test defeat at the Melbourne Cricket Ground last Saturday. His anger was directed at the match officials' decision not to award a penalty, when Lions back-rower Jac Morgan cleared out Australia's Carlo Tizzano at a ruck in the build-up to Hugo Keenan's last-minute winning try that secured the series victory for the tourists.
TMO Eric Gauzins and referee Andrea Piardi decided there was no foul play in Morgan's actions, though Schmidt and his players felt the Lions player made high contact above the shoulder line on the back of Tizzano's neck as he jackaled over the ball.
In his post-match media conference, the former Ireland boss cited rugby's law 9.20b: 'A player must not make contact with an opponent above the line of the shoulders. Sanction: Penalty.'
'I think everyone can make their own decision on that,' Schmidt had said. 'You just have to read law 9.20 and you just have to listen to the description from the referee and then watch the vision when two players are described as arriving at the same time. Just watch the footage.' Asked how a referee and officials could get such a decision wrong, as the Australia head coach suggested, Schmidt replied: 'Because they are human. Players make errors. Match officials make errors.
'Our perspective is we felt it was a decision that doesn't really live up to the big player safety push that they are talking about. You cannot hit someone above the levels of the shoulders and there's no bind with the left arm, his hand is on the ground. That's what we have seen.'
UNHAPPY: Wallabies head coach Joe Schmidt
Gilpin was speaking as World Cup 2027 hosts Australia launched their ticketing plan for the tournament and opened his official speech at the event by attempting to draw a line under the Morgan-Tizzano incident.
'Emotions understandably run very high when a compelling and fiercely contested match such as the one we saw goes down to the wire,' the World Rugby CEO said. 'In those tight contests, decisions made in crucial moments inevitably drive a lot of scrutiny.
'While, from a World Rugby perspective, we always say we do not publicly comment on match officials' decisions, given the nature of the commentary surrounding last weekend, we just want to express our support for the match officials involved.
'There is no other position on the field that is under the scrutiny our match officials are under, and yet they do an incredible job under that pressure they are under in a live environment. I think it is fair to say that when the refereeing groups review decisions, they review them with the coaches and across the game.
'We are always proud to support our officials in that review process and that is what we are doing now and in the coming days with our colleagues from Australia and the Lions. So suffice to say we won't be taking any further questions.'
Yet Gilpin did speak to media after the event and said: 'I think it is disappointing when the reaction is one of, 'this means player welfare isn't taken seriously', because we have worked really hard on that narrative.
'Everyone knows we are putting player welfare, in its broadest sense, at the top of the agenda. You can see that from what we are doing with the instrumented mouthguards, all the research, the science, the investigations.
'The way the laws of the game have evolved in the last few years is all about, 'How do we have this great physical contest, but make it as safe as possible?'. That part is challenging, in terms of the player welfare statements (by Schmidt), but we have a fantastic sport, played in front of an amazing crowd; an amazing game – it's going to create talking points. We know that. As long as that continues to be a respectful debate then we've all got to lean into it.'
As for whether Schmidt had said enough to warrant disciplinary action from the sport's governing body, Gilpin said: 'No, look, I think Joe....there's a lot of emotion, understandably. The Wallabies had a chance to win an amazing Test match, so we understand the emotion involved in that.
'Joe's comments have continued to respect the fact that the match officials have got a tough job to do. He might disagree with the decisions that were made, but I don't think he's called the integrity of our match officials into question.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Extra.ie
an hour ago
- Extra.ie
Lions player ratings after Wallabies win third test
In what was a mad game with a lightning stoppage and biblical rain in Sydney, the Wallabies won 22-12 to make sure the series didn't end in a whitewash for the British and Irish Lions. The Wallabies were up for it from the start and the heavy rain suited them perfectly, with the likes of Will Skelton and Taniela Tupou able to throw their weight around to huge effect. The game went a bit towards the messy side with rucks resembling a wrestling match at points. It's the first Lions series win since 2013 and they can all now celebrate it. They'll quickly forget about today no doubt. Tadhg Furlong. Pic: Brendan Moran/Sportsfile Andrew Porter 5 Tough one in the rain but Lions as a whole lost the physical battle. Dan Sheehan 6 Lineouts went awry once Itoje and Ryan were off unfortunately. Andrew Porter. Pic: DAVID GRAY/AFP via Getty Images Tadhg Furlong 5 A historic ninth test start in-a-row but wasn't to be. Maro Itoje (C) 5 Hard one for Itoje as he went off with HIA but was part of the pack that was losing physical battle. James Ryan 6 He was probably the Lions' best chance of stopping Skelton but an unfortunate collision ended his game. Tom Curry Pic: INPHO/Dan Sheridan Tadhg Beirne 7 Went until the very end. Undoubtedly one of the best players this series. Tom Curry 7 Not far behind Beirne, Curry answered all critics this series, fair play to him. Maro Itoje getting tackled. Pic: Brendan Moran/Sportsfile Jack Conan 7 Another solid display, with 6 tests starts now Conan has to be considered a Lions great. Jamison Gibson-Park 7 Was a tough one in conditions but some crucial defensive plays kept Lions in it. Finn Russell 5 Not the night for a player like Russell, but he's been great this tour. Jamison Gibson-Park. Pic: Steve Christo/Sportsfile Blair Kinghorn 5 Rough night out there for wingers. Hard to do much when the ball is so tight to ruck. Bundee Aki 5 Some poor handily but understandable in the miserable conditions. Bundee Aki on the attack Pic: INPHO/Billy Stickland Huw Jones 5 Shifting out onto the wing didn't help but held his own out there. Tommy Freeman 4 Wasn't a game for wingers with the weather and was also unfortunate with HIA. Hugo Keenan. Pic: Brendan Moran/Sportsfile Hugo Keenan 6 Did very well aerially, especially considering conditions. Some of his catches helped Lions stay in the game. Substitutes 7 Jac Morgan and Ellis Genge were particularly impactful when they came on. Some big shifts from Ollie Chessum and Owen Farrell having to come on in the first half. Andy Farrell. Pic: Brendan Moran/Sportsfile Andy Farrell 6 Tour was already won so doubt Farrell will be too upset about the result. 6/2 split bit the Lions and choosing to keep with Freeman who came into the game with an injury probably wasn't wise in hindsight, though his substitution was unrelated to his injury but a HIA. He could still be in contention for the next tour but who knows for now. A deserving reward after all his great work with Ireland.
Irish Daily Mirror
an hour ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
British and Irish Lions player ratings as they finish with a whimper
The British & Irish Lions have won their first Test series in 12 years but failed in their attempt to achieve a clean sweep on Australian soil. Andy Farrell's side were second best by a country mile, and the 22-12 final scoreline flattered the tourists in a game which was stopped for 30 minutes after a lightning strike 10 kilometres from the stadium, reports Wales Online. Tries from Dylan Pietsch, Max Jorgensen and Tate McDermott along with a combined seven points from the boots of Tom Lynagh and Ben Donaldson got the Wallabies over the line. The Lions did score two tries courtesy of Jac Morgan and Will Stuart, with Finn Russell kicking two points. Here are our player ratings. 15. Hugo Keenan 6 One of the Lions' better players and he was outstanding under the high ball in horrific conditions. Keenan also looked composed with ball in hand but his kick out on the full after the Lions had just scored was costly as it handed momentum back to the Wallabies. 14. Tommy Freeman 5 Only lasted 38 minutes but was solid enough in the first-half. Strong under the high ball and in defence, while there was one powerful carry into the Wallabies 22. 13. Huw Jones 4 Started well enough in the centre but moved out to the wing after Tommy Freeman's injury forcing a reshuffle in the backline. Struggled in a position he hasn't played in for a long time and one kick out on the full when there was an unmarked guy on the inside summed his evening up. 12. Bundee Aki 3 Offered himself as a carrier but the Australia defence was more than a match for the Ireland centre. A number of significant errors, in particular one where he spilled the ball forward just metres out from his own line to put the Lions under pressure. His timing was also off and another split ball allowed Max Jorgensen to intercept and score. 11. Blair Kinghorn 5 A quiet game for the talented Scotland star who wasn't helped by the terrible conditions. Did well under the high ball and in defence but little opportunity to show his worth with ball in hand. 10. Finn Russell 5 Looked flustered during the first-half and the biblical rain forced the Lions playmaker to spill a couple of passes. Missed a tackle on Taniela Tupou early in the second-half and looked out of sorts despite the odd moment of class. 9. Jamison Gibson-Park 5 Not his finest game but was behind a beaten pack and was forced to play on the back foot. Had a solid enough game but a scrum-half is only as good as the pack in front of him. Outshone by his opposite number Nic White. 8. Jack Conan 5 Conan didn't lack effort, putting in 14 tackles and made more carries than any other Lions forward with nine. But there was very little impact in his carry and struggled to make enough post contact metres. 7. Tom Curry 6 What a shift the Englishman has put in over the course of this Test series. Curry finished the game as the top tackler with 20 and put his body on the line throughout. But there were no trademark turnovers and he failed to slow down the speed of Australia's ruck ball. 6. Tadhg Beirne 6 (Star man) The 33-year-old showed up well, winning a crucial penalty at the breakdown to relieve pressure in the first-half and played a crucial role in stopping Australia's maul metres short of the Lions line. Beirne made 16 tackles and eight carries. One of the Lions' better players. 5. James Ryan 5 The Irish lock was relentless in defence putting in 12 tackles and put his body on the line throughout. Stood up well to the powerful Australia pack but was stretchered off the field after 43 minutes. 4. Maro Itoje 5 Put his body on the line during his 28 minutes on the field, putting in 12 tackles and leading from the front. Struggled with the physicality of Australian second-rows Nick Frost and Will Skelton. Led from the front but a failed HIA resulted in an early departure. 3. Tadhg Furlong 4 This was a special day for the Irish prop who made his ninth consecutive Test start for the Lions but he was very much second best at the scrum. Made 13 tackles but did not make a single carry. Will go down as a Lions legend but is on the wane. 2. Dan Sheehan 4 Sheehan was world class in the first two Tests and is undoubtedly one of the best hooker's on the planet but he was well below par in Sydney. The lineout had been close to perfect in Brisbane and Melbourne but it fell apart in Sydney. A hooker is primarily judged on the set-piece and he was fortunate not to receive a card for a dangerous clearout on Tom Lynagh. 1. Andrew Porter 4 Got given a torrid time at the scrum at the hands of the powerful Taniela Tupou. He did put a big defensive shift in making 11 tackles but came second best at his primary job - the scrum. Replacements 16. Ronan Kelleher 4 Lineout continued to struggle once he came onto the field and received a yellow card 17. Ellis Genge 6 Once Genge replaced Andrew Porter the scrum improved while there were a couple of powerful carries. 18. Will Stuart 6 Did well in the scrum and claimed a consolation try for the Lions 19. Ollie Chessum 4 Worked hard putting in 12 tackles after replacing Maro Itoje midway through the first-half. But has to take some of the blame for the lineout woes and failed to physically assert himself. 20. Jac Morgan 7 The Welshman made a big impact with one superb turnover while he showed his power to crash over for a try. 21. Ben Earl 7 The 27-year-old made a big impact with a couple of explosive carries and one impressive line break. Should have been brought on sooner. 22. Alex Mitchell N/A Not enough time on the field to judge. 23. Owen Farrell 4 Had to play on the backfoot but his combination with Bundee Aki malfunctioned badly.
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Wallabies fight back to deny the Lions series whitewash
Lions tour, third Test: Wallabies 22 British & Irish Lions 12 This series finale was never going to scale the heights of last week's epic second Test, bouts of monsoon-like rain ensured that, but it sure was different, unique even, certainly eventful, and even a little farcical. At the end of a long night in Sydney's Accor Stadium, there was no doubting that the Wallabies were the hungrier and more deserved winners in salvaging something from the series. The patience and good humour of the 80,312 crowd was remarkable, and although many had abandoned a game that resumed after a 37-minute suspension due to lightening in the vicinity, the vast majority were still there when the game finally finished at 10.38pm local time, two hours and 38 minutes after it started. It was both an eventful and tough watch as four players went off with HIAs, with a prolonged treatment for James Ryan after his head was caught by Will Skelton's knee, at which point the players were led off due to warnings of possible lightening within 10 kilometres of the stadium. Who is Ireland's greatest ever Lion? Listen | 26:49 The Lions had to go through reshuffles in the back five of their pack and backline, while Dan Sheehan and finally Tadgh Beirne , who was magnificent again, took over the captaincy. But at least all the players who departed with head knocks could be seen on the sidelines afterwards, including Ryan. READ MORE During the break, spectators in rows one to 18 were advised to move to the stadium's concourse while the remainders joined in a rendition of Zombie, among other stadium classics. They also cheered on four Lions fans who took it in turn to invade the pitch before being hunted down by half a dozen or so security staff, despite warnings that entry on to the pitch could result in fines of up to Aus$5,500. James Ryan gives a thumbs up as he is taken from the pitch. Photograph: Tom Maher/Inpho From the outset thousands shivered inside rain ponchos, which must have done a roaring sale, while the players aquaplaned on the sodden turf. Although both sides took turns to build up a head of steam, overall the Wallabies carried a tad harder off Nic White in his farewell. The hosts were also a little more ferocious at the breakdown and, perhaps most of all, put the ball through the hands better in tightly-knit patters, using Joseph Suaalii's deft handling to find space on the edges in a way that the Lions failed to do. Nick Frost & Co also did a number on the previously potent Lions lineout. There was also plenty of needle, with Will Skelton as ever the chief agent provocateur and White not far behind, but on a difficult night for all concerned Nika Amashukeli further enhanced his reputation. Inevitably, grubbers in behind were a fiendishly difficult tactic for those defending in the backfield to manage, and when Tom Wright did so in the outside channel, there was nothing Hugo Keenan could do except slide and gather the ball before being dragged over the line by the Wallabies' fullback and the recalled Dylan Pietsch. The Wallabies carried relentlessly in the ensuing power play before Suaalii took White's pass and used his footwork to attack Jamison Gibson-Park 's outside shoulder and draw in Tommy Freeman to feed Pietsch, and he finished superbly by the left corner flag. After Blair Kinghorn retrieved a towering Gibson-Park up-and-under, Russell weighted a lovely kick on the run which forced Wright to concede an attacking lineout. [ Lions player ratings: Tadhg Beirne and Tom Curry best of the tourists in Sydney washout Opens in new window ] But the Wallabies rolled up their sleeves and after Pietsch put in a monstrous hit on Freeman, Fraser McReight was quickly over the ball to earn a penalty. The Wallabies kept winning little moments, stealing just a second Sheehan throw in the entire series before Tom Hooper executed a choke tackle on Bundee Aki , and the hosts winning a scrum penalty. The momentum stayed with Australia, who looked like they erred in turning down a kickable three points by going to the corner, at which point captain Maro Itoje was taken off for a HIA and not to return. Tom Curry and Beirne, burrowing through the maul in trademark fashion, were at the heart of the Lions' resulting turnover, but from their own defensive scrum, the tackles of White and Len Ikitau forced the slightest of knock-ons from Aki. Max Jorgensen showed some sharp footwork on the right flank after he too was deftly released by Suaalii before Lynagh tapped over a penalty for offside to make it 8-0, a lead which seemed big given the conditions. Owen Farrell in action for the Lions against the Wallabies' Len Ikitau and Joseph-Aukuso Suaalii. Photograph: David Gray/AFP via Getty Images Lynagh and Freeman would also follow for HIAs and not return, Russell tapped quickly rather than kick to the corner. After Hooper was quickly over the ball and Sheehan was penalised for a side entry, the Wallabies closed out the half with another lineout steal, a second of six on the night. But the players were barely back on the pitch when play was stopped for Ryan to receive treatment before both teams were led off due to the lightning warning. On the second resumption, as it were, the Lions won a couple of penalties only for Frost to nick a couple more Sheehan throws. Huw Jones also kicked out on the full after being picked out by Russell's crosskick before Aki was choke tackled by Ikitau. The game slipped further away from the Lions when they coughed up a turnover try. There seemed to be good shape on their attack off a superb take by Keenan, but Farrell took slightly too much out of the ball and Aki over-ran Kinghorn's tip-on; Max Jorgensen snaffling the ball to sprint clear from halfway and score under the posts. The Lions were put on the front foot by Keenan brilliantly reclaiming a Russell bomb and from a quick tap by Rónan Kelleher, they pounded the Wallabies line before Jac Morgan, with help from Ollie Chessum, burrowed over and Russell converting. Tate McDermott scores a try for the Wallabies. Photograph: James Crombie/Inpho But Tate McDermott, as he does, ignited the Wallabies with his running game, earning a penalty off Morgan for a high tackle. Kelleher stopped Ikitau just short of the line and Gibson-Park tackled Jorgensen before Keenan forced a spillage from Pietsch. But Kelleher paid the price for repeated Lions' offsides and McDermott dummied before diving under tackles from Genge and Will Stuart to seal the Wallabies' deserved win, rendering the latter's last-minute close-range finish a minor consolation. It's tough to complete a series whitewash, and history will still adjudge these Lions as winners. Scoring sequence – 8 mins: Pietsch try 5-0; 34: Lynagh pen 8-0; Half-time 8-0 ; 55: Jorgensen try, Donaldson con 15-0; 62: Morgan try, Russell con 15-7; 71: McDermott try, Donaldson con 22-7; 80: Stuart try 22-12 AUSTRALIA: Tom Wright (Brumbies); Max Jorgensen (Force), Joseph-Aukuso Suaalii (Waratahs) Len Ikitau (Brumbies); Dylan Pietsch (Waratahs); Tom Lynagh (Reds), Nic White (Force); James Slipper (Brumbies), Billy Pollard (Brumbies), Taniela Tupou (Waratahs), Nick Frost (Brumbies), Will Skelton (La Rochelle), Tom Hooper (Brumbies), Fraser McReight (Reds), Harry Wilson (Reds, capt). Replacements: Ben Donaldson (Force) for Lynagh (34 mins), Angus Bell (Waratahs) for Slipper (58), Tate McDermott (Reds) for (59), Zane Nonggorr (Reds) for (61), Jeremy Williams (Force) for Skelton (64), Brandon Paenga-Amosa (Force) for Pollard (73), Langi Gleeson (Waratahs) for (78). BRITISH & IRISH LIONS: Hugo Keenan (Leinster/Ireland); Tommy Freeman (Northampton Saints/England), Huw Jones (Glasgow Warriors/Scotland), Bundee Aki (Connacht/Ireland), Blair Kinghorn (Toulouse/Scotland); Finn Russell (Bath/Scotland), Jamison Gibson-Park (Leinster/Ireland), Andrew Porter (Leinster/Ireland), Dan Sheehan (Leinster/Ireland), Tadhg Furlong (Leinster/Ireland); Maro Itoje (Saracens/England, capt), James Ryan (Leinster/Ireland); Tadhg Beirne (Munster/Ireland), Tom Curry (Sale Sharks/England), Jack Conan (Leinster/Ireland). Replacements: Ollie Chessum (Leicester Tigers/England) for Itoje (28 mins), Owen Farrell (Saracens/England) for Freeman (38), Jac Morgan (Ospreys/Wales) for Ryan, Ellis Genge (Bristol Bears/England) for Porter (both 43), Rónan Kelleher (Leinster/Ireland) for Sheehan, Will Stuart (Bath/England) for Furlong (both 58), Ben Earl (Saracens/England) for Conan (63), Sheehan for Curry (69-79), Alex Mitchell (Northampton Saints/England) for (72). Yellow card: Kelleher (69-79 mins). Referee: Nika Amashukeli (GRU)
