Emails discussing nurse probe should not have been written, Peggie tribunal told
Sandie Peggie was suspended after she complained about having to share a changing room with transgender medic Dr Beth Upton at Victoria Hospital, Kirkcaldy, Fife, on Christmas Eve 2023.
She was placed on special leave after Dr Upton made an allegation of bullying and harassment and cited concerns about 'patient care'.
Ms Peggie has lodged a claim against NHS Fife and Dr Upton, citing the Equality Act 2010, including sexual harassment; harassment related to a protected belief; indirect discrimination; and victimisation.
The tribunal resumed in Dundee on July 16 after an initial set of hearings in February.
On Tuesday, Dr Kate Searle, an emergency medicine consultant, gave evidence and denied 'deliberately concealing' an email sent on January 5, 2024, by fellow consultant Maggie Currer, which included six potential witnesses plus Dr Upton.
A judicial order was made in January by the tribunal, however documentation emerged during the hearings in February and an IT trawl was commissioned which Dr Searle said all clinicians involved complied with.
Barrister Naomi Cunningham, representing Ms Peggie, said: 'I want to suggest you deliberately concealed it to conceal wrongdoing of colleagues.'
Dr Searle said: 'It would be dishonest to do that and I'm a doctor who acts as honestly as I can at all times.'
In her evidence, Dr Searle said that she had no concerns about Dr Upton's allegations as the General Medical Council requires 'honesty and integrity'. However, she said she was 'never informed' that a referral to the Nursing and Midwifery Council had been made, the tribunal heard.
She said that she emailed Dr Upton with others included later in January to give an 'update' on the investigation. But during cross-examination, Dr Searle admitted 'that we should not have written these things in a group email to witnesses'.
Ms Cunningham said the email on January 5, 2024, was 'seriously embarrassing to the respondents' and said it 'appears to be an intention to set up and co-ordinate a group who should not be talking about this as they're witnesses'.
She added: 'It says 'information must not be shared outside this group as risk of foot in mouth syndrome – it is quite a serious risk of foot in mouth syndrome'.'
Dr Searle said: 'I can appreciate that in hindsight we should not have written these things in a group email to witnesses.'
Ms Cunningham quoted from Dr Upton's evidence, including that using female changing rooms was 'a thing I have been instructed to be the most appropriate', and describing biological sex as a 'nebulous dog whistle'.
Dr Searle denied telling the junior doctor to use female facilities, and said: 'Definitely no instructions were given.'
She agreed that biological sex was 'significant', but when the term 'nebulous dog whistle' was put to her, she denied knowing what it meant.
Ms Cunningham said: 'I think it must follow that anyone who describes biological sex as a 'nebulous dog whistle' would be talking obvious nonsense.'
Dr Searle said: 'I'm not sure what that means.'
The witness said she emailed Equalities lead Isla Bumba on December 8, 2023 as Dr Upton felt 'uncomfortable' about Ms Peggie 'self-excluding' from the female changing room, but said she 'didn't recall' raising the possibility of taking it further, as mentioned in an internal investigation.
She said she Googled policies around self-identification, and added: 'I'm not a law expert – if you Google it, it comes up under Equality Act, there are many references to toilets and changing rooms. I subsequently emailed Isla Bumba who is much more expert in Equalities than me. She agreed there is no policy.'
The consultant denied that she perceived self-exclusion as 'misbehaviour'.
Dr Searle said: 'We would have discussed it if Dr Upton was very uncomfortable and it was affecting them'.
She said a discussion would have involved 'compassion and kindness', but added: 'It doesn't sound otherwise like there's anything to take further.'
Ms Cunningham said: 'At the time you discussed it with Dr Upton you considered this to be misbehaviour, she (Ms Peggie) was behaving badly and making him feel uncomfortable.'
However, Dr Searle said: 'Beth felt uncomfortable that Sandie appeared to not want to engage.'
Ms Cunningham said: 'My question was: both you and he regarded Sandie's conduct in removing herself a form of misbehaviour?'
Dr Searle said: 'I don't agree we would have classed it as misbehaviour.'
Ms Cunningham said: 'I think you've already confirmed that email to Isla Bumba on December 8 was prompted by a conversation about Sandie removing herself from the changing room when he was there, that's right?
'You ask if there's any policies around transgender staff and suggest Dr Upton might be keen to help develop some; is it fair for the tribunal to infer the possibility of developing policies to make it easier for Dr Upton to take matters further?'
Dr Searle said: 'No, I don't agree. I think there needs to be an NHS Fife policy on how everyone can feel comfortable in changing areas of their choosing.'
The tribunal continues.
Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News
Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Herald Scotland
an hour ago
- The Herald Scotland
NHS Fife: Key points as Sandie Peggie defends racist comment
The crucial evidence heard from a key witness describing Dr Upton as a 'chromosomal male', while Ms Peggie took the stand to defend comments she made which were described as racist. Here are the key points from today's hearing. 'Need to know' group Dr Currer told the tribunal she did not believe she had compromised the investigation by emailing a 'need to know' group of colleagues about the Christmas Eve incident that led to Ms Peggie's suspension. She also rejected claims that it was 'grossly improper' for her to send that email. The email referenced a desire to avoid 'foot and mouth disease' – or gossiping – about the investigation. But Naomi Cunningham, representing Ms Peggie, suggested that Dr Currer had been attempting to create a small email 'working group' to discuss the case. 'Do you not see a problem with that?' the barrister asked. Dr Currer said: "At that time the investigation had not been completed. The reported behaviour was unacceptable and one of the issues with problems and bullying and harassment is that it is impossible to help if we do not know about it." Upton 'chromosomally male' After a long discussion about chromosomes and biological sex, Dr Currer stated that Dr Upton was 'chromosomally male'. It was put to the doctor by Ms Cunningham that Dr Upton is 'quite simply biologically male'. Ms Currer told the tribunal: 'Although I've not examined Dr Upton she's also in terms of genitalia, male but I have not examined her.' But the tribunal also heard that Dr Currer did not believe the right way of approaching Upton's use of the women's changing room would have been to check if medical staff were 'comfortable'. She said: 'In hindsight I could have checked with medical staff whether or not they were going to be comfortable with Dr Upton using the female changing rooms.' Dr Currer added: 'I'm still not sure that advertising Dr Upton's trans status would have been the right thing to do.' 'Dark humour' Ms Peggie began her evidence by defending comments she shared about the devastating floods in Pakistan, which killed 1,739 people. The nurse said these were comments shared with a private group of friends "Looking at them, they're distasteful," Ms Peggie said. "At the time it was sent in dark humour, expecting a shocked reaction from the girls. I think there was one laughing emoji." Ms Peggie also told the tribunal that she used the racial term 'P***' often when growing up as it was 'normal' in the community. She was asked about her alleged comments where she said she would throw a packet of bacon at a mosque, and claims about immigrants. The nurse told the tribunal she would not treat patients or staff differently because of their race or ethnicity. Ms Peggie told the tribunal she had a fear of Muslims and Sharia law. She did however said she would not say these comments around Muslim people to avoid 'offense'. On illegal immigration, Ms Peggie defended a joke about the floods in Pakistan by stating that 'Britain has too many P***'s' if they want some back'. She was also asked whether it was offensive to refer to the aftermath of the floods in Pakistan as looking like a 'giant bowl of coco pops'. She agreed this was offensive. 'I am not homophobic' Ms Peggie also defended allegations she was homophobic. In evidence, Lindsay Nicoll said yesterday the nurse had been 'devastated' by her daughter coming out as gay. Ms Peggie told the tribunal that she was 'originally upset' and worried about the prejudice held by other people. She also said: 'I don't have any bad feelings towards trans people. I just don't think they should use the female changing room."
Telegraph
an hour ago
- Telegraph
Telling staff doctor was trans ‘would violate confidentiality'
An NHS consultant did not tell staff a transgender doctor would be allowed to use a female changing room because it would violate 'confidentiality', a tribunal has heard. Sandie Peggie was suspended after she complained about having to share a changing room with Dr Beth Upton at Victoria Hospital in Kirkcaldy, Fife, on Christmas Eve 2023. The nurse was placed on special leave after Dr Upton, a biological male who identifies as a woman, made an allegation of bullying and harassment, and cited concerns about 'patient care'. Ms Peggie has lodged a claim against NHS Fife and Dr Upton, citing the Equality Act 2010, including sexual harassment; harassment related to a protected belief; indirect discrimination; and victimisation. At an employment tribunal in Dundee on Tuesday, emergency department consultant Dr Maggie Currer was cross-examined by Ms Peggie's lawyer, Naomi Cunningham. The consultant admitted that she did not advise staff that Dr Upton would be allowed to use female changing facilities as she 'did not think it was reasonable to violate someone's confidentiality'. The consultant insisted this did not make it harder for staff to object about the medic's presence in the rooms. She said: 'In hindsight I could have checked with medical staff whether or not they were going to be comfortable with Dr Upton using the female changing rooms. 'No concerns were raised with me at the time; there are other spaces which people can use to change. 'I'm still not sure that advertising Dr Upton's trans status would have been the right thing to do.' Ms Cunningham said: 'Someone had to be the first to object, this was an environment where senior staff were insisting that trans women were women and only a bigot would deny that. Objecting is going to take real courage isn't it?' Dr Currer disputed that such terminology – 'only a bigot would deny that' – was used. Ms Cunningham put it to her that 'Dr Upton is quite simply biologically male'. Dr Currer said: 'She's chromosomally male, as far as I'm aware. 'Although I've not examined Dr Upton, she's also, in terms of genitalia, male, but I have not examined her.' Elsewhere during her cross-examination, Dr Currer admitted she had made an 'error' in writing an email to colleagues to tell that Ms Peggie had been referred to the Nursing and Midwifery Council on January 5, 2023. She accepted that doing so was 'likely' to damage someone's reputation 'in the eyes of their colleagues'.
Powys County Times
2 hours ago
- Powys County Times
Transgender doctor is ‘chromosomally male', consultant tells tribunal
A consultant has told a tribunal that a transgender doctor involved in a dispute with a nurse over single-sex spaces is 'chromosomally male'. Nurse Sandie Peggie was suspended after she complained about having to share a changing room with trans medic Dr Beth Upton at Victoria Hospital in Kirkcaldy, Fife, on Christmas Eve 2023. She was placed on special leave after Dr Upton made an allegation of bullying and harassment, and cited concerns about 'patient care'. Ms Peggie has lodged a claim against NHS Fife and Dr Upton, citing the Equality Act 2010, including sexual harassment; harassment related to a protected belief; indirect discrimination; and victimisation. At an employment tribunal in Dundee on Tuesday, emergency department consultant Dr Maggie Currer was cross-examined by Ms Peggie's lawyer, Naomi Cunningham. The consultant said she did not advise staff that Dr Upton would be allowed to use female changing facilities as she 'did not think it was reasonable to violate someone's confidentiality'. The consultant disagreed this made it harder for staff to object. She rejected a suggestion that terminology such as the word 'bigot' was used in the department regarding attitudes towards gender. Dr Currer also said it was an 'error' that she wrote in an email to colleagues that Ms Peggie had been referred to the Nursing and Midwifery Council on January 5 2023, and added: 'I was aware she hadn't been so that is indeed an error.' She added: 'In hindsight I could have checked with medical staff whether or not they were going to be comfortable with Dr Upton using the female changing rooms. 'No concerns were raised with me at the time; there are other spaces which people can use to change. 'I'm still not sure that advertising Dr Upton's trans status would have been the right thing to do.' Ms Cunningham said: 'Someone had to be the first to object, this was an environment where senior staff were insisting that trans women were women and only a bigot would deny that. Objecting is going to take real courage isn't it?' Dr Currer said: 'I don't think that terminology was ever used – that only a bigot would deny that.' Ms Cunningham put it to her that 'Dr Upton is quite simply biologically male'. Dr Currer said: 'She's chromosomally male, as far as I'm aware. 'Although I've not examined Dr Upton she's also in terms of genitalia male, but I have not examined her.'
