US appeals court upholds Arkansas law banning youth transgender care
The 8-2 decision, opens new tab by the St. Louis-based 8th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals overturns a lower court ruling. It also follows the U.S. Supreme Court's June ruling holding that Tennessee's similar ban did not discriminate based on sex or transgender status.
Citing that ruling, the 8th Circuit's majority agreed with Arkansas' Republican attorney general that the law did not violate transgender minors' equal protection rights under the U.S. Constitution.
The 8th Circuit also went further than the Supreme Court, which has a 6-3 conservative majority, by deciding an unresolved legal issue of whether such bans violate parents' rights to provide appropriate medical care for their children.
Lawyers for the plaintiffs -- a group of minors, parents and healthcare professionals -- argued the Arkansas law violated parents' due process rights under the U.S. Constitution's Fourteenth Amendment.
But U.S. Circuit Judge Duane Benton, writing for the majority, cited a lack of historical support for the argument that parents have a right to obtain medical treatment for their children that a state legislature deems inappropriate.
"This court finds no such right in this Nation's history and tradition," Benton wrote in an opinion joined by seven fellow appointees of Republican presidents.
U.S. Circuit Judge Jane Kelly, an appointee of Democratic former President Barack Obama, dissented along with another judge, citing a "startling lack of evidence connecting Arkansas' ban on gender-affirming care with its purported goal of protecting children."
"This is a tragically unjust result for transgender Arkansans, their doctors and their families," said Holly Dickson, executive director of the American Civil Liberties Union of Arkansas, which represented the plaintiffs.
The decision overturns a ruling by a lower-court judge in 2023 who had declared the law unconstitutional after previously blocking it from taking effect in 2021.
That year, Arkansas became the first U.S. state to ban gender-affirming care for minors. The Republican-led legislature passed the ban over the veto of then-Governor Asa Hutchinson, also a Republican.
Since then, a slew of other Republican-led states have passed similar laws. Such policies are now in place in 25 states. The 10th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals last week upheld Oklahoma's own ban, citing the Supreme Court's ruling.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
2 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
John Oliver says Trump has given him 'anxiety' about being an immigrant even though he's now a US citizen
John Oliver told Monica Lewinsky Tuesday that Donald Trump 's immigration policies have him worried for his own safety, despite the fact that he's a US citizen and has been for nearly six years. The British-born host of HBO 's Last Week Tonight made the claim on Lewinsky's podcast. The two had been discussing the recent ICE raids and how they have caused hysteria throughout much of the country. Oliver, 48, insisted the stress he felt prior to getting his citizenship has now resurfaced in spades. 'I finally got my citizenship in 2019 - at the end of 2019,' the late night host recalled. 'But I realized - I thought about it every day. 'Somewhere at the back of my head, was my immigration status,' he continued. 'At no point was it not somewhere in my mind.' 'And I have to remind myself now, with all these stories going on… it brings something out of you. 'Like it's there – that anxiety that I thought I'd moved past that day that I got my citizenship. I thought it would be gone then [with the] citizenship.' 'I didn't feel that,' he declared. 'Like the relief, didn't feel enough.' Lewinsky, a former White House intern, said she also empathized with immigrants' experiences. 'Just of feeling hunted, of feeling unsafe, of something can happen any moment,' she said, before comparing the fears immigrants face to those of women. 'Whether it's being recognized or a paparazzi or there's, there's something, a feeling of unsafety wherever you are - and probably a lot of women feel that in general.' Oliver agreed, telling the part-time motivational speaker: 'It feels like there's a lot of crossover there.' The two spoke for more than an hour. At one point, Lewinsky - whose affair with then-president Bill Clinton in the late 1990s became a national scandal - asked whether Oliver's immigrant status made him 'feel differently about what's happening.' 'I don't know,' Oliver replied, before providing an anecdote about him 'talking to the parents of a little kid that [he] know[s] yesterday.' 'We very quickly ended up like talking about forms, experiences, [and] interviews,' he claimed 'It's really hard - and so I can get sent back to the anxiety that I felt for a long time very quick.' He added how scrutiny into immigrants' backgrounds 'does feel personal. 'It's one of the things I get really mad about, and therefore want to use on our show to show Americans who may have heard things like, "Come in the right way, just do things the right way," and not fully understand just how antithetical that is to the process that actually exists.' ICE raids and arrests have seen roughly 185,000 immigrants deported from the US just this year. ICE has faced widespread backlash as a result. Advocates - many of them US citizens - have been swept up and at times arrested while documenting the raids. In LA, nurse Amanda Trebach was arrested Friday morning while recording ICE operations in the city. She was released the following day without ever being hit with charges. Other incidents of profiling from federal agents have also spawned criticism - and tension - across the country. ICE raids and arrests have seen roughly 185,000 deported just this year. The Trump administration recently asked to halt a court order that would limit ICE agents' ability to arrest suspected illegal immigrants based on the language they speak or where they work Late night host Jimmy Kimmel touched on this last week, telling Sarah Silverman on her podcast how he had obtained Italian citizenship amid such fears. Days before, the president panned Kimmel on Truth Social, predicting his and Jimmy Fallon's show 'were next' - after the decision to cancel the Late Show with Stephen Colbert for what was billed as financial reasons. The Trump administration recently asked the Supreme Court to halt a court order that would limit ICE agents' ability to arrest suspected illegal immigrants based on the language they speak or where they work, as claims of profiling continue.
Reuters
2 minutes ago
- Reuters
Trump wins appeal over freeze on foreign aid payments
WASHINGTON, Aug 13 (Reuters) - A federal appeals court on Wednesday lifted an injunction that required the U.S. State Department to continue making foreign aid payments, handing a victory to U.S. President Donald Trump. In a 2-1 decision, a three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit said a lower court erred by ordering the Trump administration to restore foreign assistance payments that had been previously approved by Congress.
The Guardian
2 minutes ago
- The Guardian
Of course Mark Zuckerberg is still doing good works – he's just switched up the definition of ‘good'
If you put it in a novel – a ham-fisted satire of tech overlord hypocrisy, say – it would look too contrived to fly. But here we are, absorbing a story from the New York Times this week in which Mark Zuckerberg and his wife, Priscilla Chan, are discovered to have been running a private school out of their compound in Palo Alto, California, in violation of city zoning laws. More pertinently, the school of 14 kids, which includes two of the couple's three daughters, is less than a mile from the school for low-income families that the couple founded in 2016. Guess which school the world's second-richest man and his wife are shutting down? Say the word 'zoning infraction' to a certain stripe of American and the effect is equal to using 'queue jumper' on a Briton, but of course the broader point here isn't one about permits. (A spokesperson for Zuckerberg and Chan told the newspaper that the family was unaware about the zoning laws and that the private school, or 'pod of home schoolers' as they put it, is now moving to another location.) It is, rather, about Zuckerberg's perceived retreat from progressive social causes, starting with the shuttering of the school and ending with the announcement in May this year that the pair's charitable foundation, the Chan Zuckerberg Initiative (CZI), will be pulling funding from almost all the affordable housing and homeless charities it supports in the San Francisco Bay Area, as well as slashing diversity programmes. Officially, the reason for these changes is that after a decade spent learning the ropes of effective philanthropy, CZI has decided that its money is best allocated to science and medical funding. Unofficially, of course, the switch from a mission statement about 'advancing human potential and promoting equality' to a foundation that now calls itself a 'science-first philanthropy' seems in keeping with more localised changes in the Zuckerberg household. Namely: the Meta head's swing from the kind of guy who, during the Biden administration, might have worn a This Is What A Feminist Looks Like T-shirt, to his Trump-era guise as someone who goes on Joe Rogan to argue for more 'masculine energy' in the workplace and appoints a Trump ally to the Meta board. Zuckerberg's politics are clearly as flexible as the next tech leader's, but I suspect there are other things in play here, too. Unlike science research, the specimens in philanthropy-funded social experiments have a nasty habit of talking aback. In 2010, when Zuckerberg gave $100m to overhaul the Newark public school system, some educators called him out for what they saw as the application of startup values and glib quick fixes – charter schools, anyone? More 'parental choice'? – to the vast, interlinked challenges of the US's struggling public school system. You can imagine how this might have gone down at HQ. We're trying to help them; why are they giving us shit? Why aren't these nobodies tugging their forelocks like a billionaire at an autocrat's inauguration? Another thing about billionaires: they get bored very quickly. One of the alleged reasons that Zuckerberg and Chan are shutting their charitable school in East Palo Alto, is that, reportedly, Chan was frustrated by the slow pace of progress. It is baffling, isn't it, given the geniuses involved; and yet these kids seem determined to stay poor and not get into Harvard. The rock-solid certainty among certain tech leaders that their skills are infinitely transferable is, however, a hard one to unseat. Consider the Bezos Day 1 Academies Fund, in which the world's third-richest man promises to 'operate a network of tuition-free, Montessori-inspired preschools in under-resourced communities', rather than, say, compel his $2.36tn company to pay its fair share of taxes to fund state education coffers. Meanwhile, back in the Zuckerbergs' Crescent Park community, things are getting a bit tense. In an area popular with Stanford professors, the Zuckerbergs bought 11 properties, turned them into a compound, and like low-rent oligarchs in Holland Park, west London, promptly put in a pickleball court and dug out the basement. Years of noise, construction and traffic from the school – oh, boy, were neighbours ready when the New York Times reporter came calling. 'No neighbourhood wants to be occupied,' said one, whose home is surrounded on three sides by Zuckerberg properties. 'But that's exactly what they've done. They've occupied our neighbourhood.' Substitute 'neighbourhood' for 'world' and he's summed it up nicely. Emma Brockes is a Guardian columnist
