Man, 39, died from single stab wound and death would have been rapid, court told
Valeriu Melnic (24) with an address at Calliaghstown Lower, Rathcoole, Co Dublin is charged with murdering Ion Daghi (39) at The Close, Sallins Park, Sallins in Co Kildare on May 12, 2024.
Mr Melnic has pleaded not guilty to murder but guilty to Mr Daghi's manslaughter.
Assistant State Pathologist Dr Margaret Bolster today told Carl Hanahoe SC, prosecuting, that she conducted a postmortem on Mr Daghi's remains on May 12, 2024 after he had been pronounced dead around 5am that morning.
Dr Bolster said she was informed that a physical altercation had occurred between two men. The witness said she was told a struggle took place and ultimately Mr Daghi was stabbed to the left side of the chest and collapsed almost immediately.
The witness testified that there was a stab wound on the left side of Mr Daghi's chest around the nipple area, which was 5.9cm from the midline.
Dr Bolster said it was almost a vertically situated stab wound to the top left side of the chest, which extended through the intercostal muscle between the fifth and sixth ribs.
The stab wound had gone through the pericardial sac and there was 250ml of blood present in that area, which meant the heart couldn't beat properly. The stab wound measured 2.5cm in length.
Dr Bolster said the stab wound had extended into the outer lower aspect of the right ventricle. The stab wound, which measured 13cm in depth, had not gone right through the heart but into the chamber of the heart.
She said 73 milligrams of ethanol was detected in the deceased's system, which is just over 2.5 pints. This was indicative that Mr Daghi had been drinking up to the time of his death.
The Irish Mirror's Crime Writers Michael O'Toole and Paul Healy are writing a new weekly newsletter called Crime Ireland. Click here to sign up and get it delivered to your inbox every week
In her evidence, Dr Bolster said there were a number of blunt force injuries to the body including bruising to the back of both hands and the knuckles, which indicated offensive or defensive injuries during the altercation.
The expert witness said Mr Daghi would have collapsed and death would have been very rapid. There was no evidence of the deceased trying to ward off the knife.
Dr Bolster said the blade of a knife recovered from the scene measured 19.5cm in length, which was consistent with having caused the stab wound to the deceased.
The witness said Dr Daghi's cause of death was hemorrhage and shock with bleeding into the pericardial sac after a single stab wound to the chest.
Under cross-examination, Dr Bolster agreed with Brendan Grehan SC, defending, that the deceased was of muscular build and it was obvious from an examination of his hands that he was a manual labourer.
Asked whether the deceased had a number of "fighting injuries" to his hands, Dr Bolster agreed, saying it "was in keeping with the offensive or defensive" injuries.
Dr Bolster also agreed that the blade of the knife was 19.5cm long whereas the injury she noted was 13cm, which meant the knife had not "gone in the whole way".
"The knife was not plunged to the hilt?" asked Mr Grehan, which Dr Bolster said was the case.
The witness also agreed that 13cm was only "an approximate measurement" and it didn't mean the blade "went 13cm, depending on the movement of the body".
She said she couldn't comment on the dynamics of how the blade "went in" in terms of the struggle taking place between the two men.
In his opening address, Carl Hanahoe SC, for the Director of Public Prosecutions, said it was the State's case that the accused 'armed himself with a kitchen knife' and stabbed Mr Daghi once in the chest following an altercation after the pair had spent the night drinking together.
The trial continues tomorrow before Mr Justice David Keane and a jury of eight men and four women.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Daily Mirror
7 hours ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
'Conor McGregor posted a rant about us - It's time to debunk him... again'
Disgraced fighter Conor McGregor has once again posted misinformation - this time targeting our publication. Sadly, in this era of social media, where a person has 10.6m followers and an army of fans and bots alike, it has become necessary to further rebut misleading posts that he freely and without question uploads to social media. McGregor, who was found liable by a civil jury for rape and recently lost his appeal of that decision, has taken to targeting this journalist and now our publication for reporting nothing but factual information - albeit information he does seem to like. READ MORE: Conor McGregor wants to become the next President of Ireland - could it really happen? READ MORE: Conor McGregor makes series of misleading claims in rant about failed Nikita Hand case appeal On Tuesday he posted a long rant naming me, the Irish Daily Star, and levelled a series of unfounded accusations that he has now since deleted - as he has every other post directed at us. But not before they were read by his millions of followers. On Tuesday we factually and accurately reported about a rape investigation which is now before the courts. It is the case that gardai believe the attack was random in nature - meaning the alleged injured party was not known to the alleged attacker beforehand. This was stated as fact and was not in any way intended to minimise the alleged incident - if anything it was to properly reflect the grim reality of it. As is the law of the land - we cannot identify the alleged attacker - nor information that has not been heard in court. In general when a person is ultimately convicted of a rape offence - it may be the case then that they can then be identified - so long as a victim is not identified, or if a victim decides to waive their anonymity. McGregor, who has blocked me on social media platform 'X', nonetheless took it upon himself to repost screenshots of our story on this issue, in order to attack our reporting. The Irish Mirror's Crime Writers Michael O'Toole and Paul Healy are writing a new weekly newsletter called Crime Ireland. Click here to sign up and get it delivered to your inbox every week Calling me 'an absolute disgrace' for merely informing the public about the incident in the first place, McGregor then went on to falsely state that I 'first ignored and then mocked the stabbing of a Garda on active duty in broad daylight.' He further falsely claimed that I was 'acting' like I 'didn't know the details,' and that I was 'here again playing to the agenda of government elite in deceiving the public despite the dangers now faced by the people of Ireland.' Normally these kinds of allegations are best left ignored. But McGregor, who claims he's running for the Irish presidency, enjoys a large platform that I believe should not go unchallenged. I resent and totally reject his allegation that I ignored or mocked a garda. I would never do so, nor would I mock or make light of any victim. The UFC fighter is referring to a now deleted post by me on 'X' in which I reposted a statement he made about an incident that is now before the District Court. My intention behind this post was to state that at that point he had been 'radio silent' about the Court of Appeal decision upholding a High Court civil jury finding that he raped Nikita Hand - and that instead he was posting about this. Noting in hindsight that his post was about an incident now before the courts, I decided it best to delete it. Sadly however, that was not the end of it, and a pile of accounts leapt on the opportunity to allude to some sort of conspiracy as to why the post was deleted. My post at no stage mocked or ignored what was a widely covered major news event - that was not only extensively reported by this publication - but virtually every other outlet in the land. Conor McGregor invites Donald Trump to Ireland and drops wild AI image Once again, this is a matter now before the courts - which severely limits how publications such as ourselves can comment on such matters for the moment. We the media have to follow the law. But that is clearly something McGregor doesn't seem to understand. Or perhaps, he doesn't care. Finally, he made further misleading claims that our publication, the Irish Daily Star, is a 'sponsored rag of government,' alluding to a €100,000 payment by the government which he claims was to aid us in propagating 'the public full of misdirection and diversion.'He also called this 'criminal behaviour.' Once again, there is no conspiracy here. I certainly haven't seen a cent of government money personally, and no one controls our editorial direction or that of any of the free press here in Ireland. McGregor is referring to a €100,000 payment given to our company 'Reach PLC' as part of the 'Global Ireland Media Challenge Fund.' The Department of Foreign Affairs backed fund is awarded to media outlets in order to help fund international coverage that would otherwise be impossible in this challenging time for all media. The funding is not, and never has been used to control our editorial direction - which has often challenged and been critical of the government of the day. The fund has only ever been used to enhance our international reporting - for example allowing our reporters to cover our brave Irish soldiers helping keep the peace between Syria and Israel in the Golan Heights. It was further utilised to send us to Lebanon to cover the important work being done by Irish peacekeepers there and the demand for justice for the murdered soldier - Private Sean Rooney. It is also utilised and open to any media outlet to avail of - and does not in any way impact or get used for our domestic coverage. We would absolutely abhor and never sign up to being used by the government to spread any agenda. These are words that normally should go without saying. But sadly, this is no longer the case in a world of unchecked social media - where any thick with a blue tick can have such a large platform. Subscribe to our newsletter for the latest news from the Irish Mirror direct to your inbox: Sign up here.
Irish Daily Mirror
9 hours ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
'Non-binary' Syrian learns fate after 'unprovoked' attack on female jogger
A woman was the victim of a random "unprovoked" attack where she was kicked in the stomach, knocked to the ground and left in pain after she went jogging in Dublin, a court has heard. Hoyda Hamad, a Syrian national of no fixed abode who has used multiple identities, was jailed for three months on Wednesday over the incident at East Wall Road, Dublin 3, on the morning of July 26 last. It happened 18 days after he was handed a suspended sentence for an earlier theft crime. The 35-year-old, a barber by trade, was charged with a section 2 assault, which carries a six-month sentence, as well as with providing a false or misleading name and address to a member of An Garda Síochána and with using threatening, abusive, or insulting words or behaviour. "This was an unprovoked attack on a female member of the community who was going about her own business, out for a jog, and was attacked by someone who was unknown to her, and suffered pain and suffering," said Judge Patricia Cronin at the sentence hearing at Cloverhill District Court. Cloverhill District Court Hamad pleaded guilty last week, and the case was adjourned until Wednesday for facts and a victim statement. The woman did not have to attend the hearing or give evidence because of the guilty plea. Court Sergeant Olyn Murphy outlined the prosecution's evidence on behalf of investigating officer Garda Ruth Redmond. Judge Cronin heard that the incident happened at around 10.05 am when the defendant assaulted the woman "by kicking her in the stomach, causing her to fall back on the ground," and Hamad was verbally abusive toward her. She also suffered a back injury, a swollen finger, and her head was "throbbing" after being attacked by Hamad. Gardai attended the scene and Hamad gave a false name and date of birth before being arrested and brought to a station to be charged. Judge Cronin noted that he had two sets of prior convictions, one under the name Hamad with two theft convictions which led to the imposition of a two-month sentence, suspended for one year, in Wexford District Court on July 8. That term could now be activated. The Irish Mirror's Crime Writers Michael O'Toole and Paul Healy are writing a new weekly newsletter called Crime Ireland. Click here to sign up and get it delivered to your inbox every week He also committed several other crimes under a different name: three for vehicle theft and driving offences, one for drug possession, another for burglary, one trespass and another for failing to provide a passport as required. That resulted in a 10-month prison sentence from Cork District Court on July 31 last year. In a mitigation plea, the defence counsel asked the judge to heed that he had pleaded guilty at an early stage, which was valuable given the moving victim impact statement, which was not read aloud during the hearing. The defence stressed that Hamad did not prolong the ordeal for the woman who did not have to testify, and that he had no prior assault convictions, and should be given significant credit for those factors. Later in the hearing, the defence described Hamad as non-binary and originally from Syria, having come through France. Over recent months, the accused had a transient living situation and was in a transient relationship with a supportive partner, counsel said. Hoyda Hamad. (Image: Irish Mirror) Pleading for leniency, the defence described the situation as a "chaotic set of circumstances". Hamad's recollection of events was minimal, and he was apologetic, and his expression of remorse was evidenced by his early guilty plea, the barrister submitted. The accused had been remanded in custody on the date of the incident. Hamad did not testify and spoke only to instruct his barrister that he wished to have the case finalised. Judge Cronin remarked how the victim's statement was eloquent and outlined the psychological and physical injuries, "significant impact", and the life changes the woman made since the attack. The judge found her account to be honest and not exaggerated, and she took notice of the fact that her employer was assisting her in getting counselling. Sentencing, the judge took into account Hamad's plea and prior convictions and that he had none under the Non-Fatal Offences Against the Person Act or similar public order matters. The early guilty plea meant the victim did not have to come to court, she noted. However, she had to take into account all the circumstances and the mitigating factors. The sentence was backdated to July 26, and the judge expressed her wish for the woman to know that she was well in her recovery. The three-month term was handed down on the assault charge, with the two remaining offences taken into consideration. Subscribe to our newsletter for the latest news from the Irish Mirror direct to your inbox: Sign up here.
Irish Daily Mirror
12 hours ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
Man arrested as gun and €153k in cash seized after gardai stop vehicle in Dublin
A man has been arrested after gardai seized a semi-automatic pistol and more than €153,000 in cash following the interception of a vehicle in Co Dublin earlier this week. As part of an ongoing regional operation led by the Dublin Crime Response Team to tackle serious criminal activity, Gardaí carried out a planned car stop in Balbriggan on Monday (August 4). On searching the car, Gardaí located and seized a semi-automatic pistol, rounds of ammunition and €153,305 in cash. The sole occupant of the car, a man aged in his 40s, was arrested at the scene and brought to a Garda Station in Dublin where he is currently detained under the provisions of Section 30 of the Offences Against the State Act, 1939 as amended. Gardai subsequently carried out a number of follow-up searches in Dublin city where further evidence has been recovered. A semi-automatic pistol and rounds of ammunition were also seized during the gara operation (Image: An Garda Síochána) Commenting on the investigation, Assistant Commissioner Cliona Richardson said: "The seizure of this firearm and ammunition has no doubt saved lives, and the removal of significant amounts of cash not only removes ill-gotten gains from the hands from criminals, but deprives them of money they would have used to fund further criminal activity in our communities.' A garda spokesperson said that investigations are ongoing. For the latest news and breaking news visit Get all the big headlines, pictures, analysis, opinion and video on the stories that matter to you. Follow us on Twitter @IrishMirror - the official Irish Mirror Twitter account - real news in real time. We're also on Facebook/irishmirror - your must-see news, features, videos and pictures throughout the day from the Irish Daily Mirror, Irish Sunday Mirror and Subscribe to our newsletter for the latest news from the Irish Mirror direct to your inbox: Sign up here. The Irish Mirror's Crime Writers Michael O'Toole and Paul Healy are writing a new weekly newsletter called Crime Ireland. Click here to sign up and get it delivered to your inbox every week
