logo
Caster Semenya's right to a fair hearing was violated, ECHR rules

Caster Semenya's right to a fair hearing was violated, ECHR rules

Semenya was legally identified as female at birth but has a condition which means her body naturally produces higher levels of testosterone than women without the condition.
She was unsuccessful in challenging World Athletics' rules at the Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS) and the Swiss federal court, but in July 2023 a lower chamber of the ECHR found her rights had been violated by the Swiss government because it had failed to provide sufficient safeguards for her complaint to be examined effectively.
Grand Chamber judgment Semenya v. Switzerland – Complaint by international athlete concerning set of World Athletics regulationshttps://t.co/JcWLWspX33#ECHR #CEDH #ECHRpress pic.twitter.com/6hFqJzTpgv
— ECHR CEDH (@ECHR_CEDH) July 10, 2025
The Swiss government referred the case to the ECHR's Grand Chamber in November 2023 and on Thursday morning, it was announced its judges had found by a 15 to two majority that Semenya's rights under Article 6 of the European Convention of Human Rights – the right to a fair hearing – had been violated.
A press release issued by the court said the judges had found the Swiss courts had 'fallen short' in providing what they felt should have been a 'rigorous judicial review that was commensurate with the seriousness of the personal rights at issue'.
The ECHR ruling, which cannot be appealed, should mean the case returns to the Swiss federal court.
The Grand Chamber ruled by a majority of 13 to four that complaints under Article 8 (right to respect for private life), Article 13 (right to an effective remedy) and Article 14 (prohibition of discrimination) were inadmissible. It found Semenya did not fall within Switzerland's jurisdiction in respect of those complaints.
Seema Patel, an associate professor specialising in sports law at the Nottingham Law School, had said prior to the Semenya decision being handed down that it would be a 'pivotal moment for how sport engages with human rights in its rule making'.
World Athletics has not been a party to either of the ECHR proceedings but at the time of the 2023 ruling by the lower chamber it said it stood by its rules on lowering testosterone, describing them as 'a necessary, reasonable and proportionate means of protecting fair competition in the female category'.
Caster Semenya was a gold medal winner in the women's 800m at the 2016 Rio Olympics, having also won the same event at London 2012 (Martin Rickett/PA)
Earlier this year, track and field's global governing body strengthened its rules in this area further when its ruling council approved the introduction of cheek swab tests to determine biological sex.
The introduction of these tests are designed to ensure only athletes found to be biologically female can compete in the female category, effectively barring transgender women and some athletes with differences of sexual development (DSD).
Semenya's legal team and World Athletics have been contacted for comment following the Grand Chamber ruling.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

'Andy Murray annoyed me with his attitude - he ruined my tennis career'
'Andy Murray annoyed me with his attitude - he ruined my tennis career'

Daily Mirror

time7 hours ago

  • Daily Mirror

'Andy Murray annoyed me with his attitude - he ruined my tennis career'

Gilles Simon was a top-10 player and won 14 ATP singles titles, but the Frenchman has revealed that his career was 'ruined' by his rivalry with Andy Murray Former tennis world No. 6 Gilles Simon openly blamed Andy Murray for ruining his professional career. In a candid interview last year, the retired French player spoke about long-time rival Murray, whose illustrious career ended after the 2024 Paris Olympics. ‌ Simon and Murray rose through the ranks together, both debuting at Grand Slam tournaments in 2005. But although they started on similar paths, Murray soon pulled ahead, securing major championships and earning recognition as one of tennis' elite. ‌ "Andy is the guy who ruined my career the most," Simon told L'Equipe in 2024. "He became the player I wanted to beat the most. I studied him a lot in the field. Because he bothered me too much, in terms of his game but also in his attitude." ‌ Simon, who never advanced past a Grand Slam quarter-final, regarded Murray as one of the sport's most naturally gifted athletes - someone who simultaneously inspired and frustrated him. "We annoyed each other," Simon said. "We played matches where we ended up telling each other about our lives!" Simon often found himself on the losing end of their encounters, with Murray dominating their rivalry with a 16-3 record. Their first face-off was at the 2007 Italian Open, a match Simon managed to win. But Murray went on to claim the following 12 matchups, intensifying Simon's desire to finally overcome the Scottish star. With time, though, Simon began to view Murray's relentless drive with more appreciation than resentment. "He was ready to die on the court," said Simon, now 40. "He is an ultra-competitor, perhaps even more than [Roger] Federer, [Rafael] Nadal and [Novak] Djokovic. He was ready to do anything to win, whatever the way, good or bad." "Playing better than him didn't guarantee victory. He could quickly adapt his game to counter you. I always say you had to beat him three times. "He always found a solution," Simon went on. "He was constantly looking for one and often ended up finding one. Whatever his choice, he always had a full awareness of what he was doing. As he is intelligent, every time it fell right. ‌ "Andy is much more gifted than we think. One of the most gifted we've ever seen. As he was above all a solid player, who ran everywhere and made no mistakes." Though their rivalry was clearly tilted in Murray's favour, Simon savoured a final, hard-earned triumph at the 2022 Paris Masters - emerging victorious in a gruelling three-set battle, one of the last professional showdowns for both players. Simon carved out a respectable career, amassing 14 ATP singles trophies. Yet it was Murray's trio of Slam wins - and his unforgettable duels with the likes of Djokovic, Nadal, and Federer - that cemented his place among the sport's legends. ‌ Following four painful defeats in major finals, Murray finally clinched his first Slam at the 2012 US Open. The next year, he ended a 77-year British drought at Wimbledon, becoming the first male champion there since Fred Perry in 1936. He repeated the feat in 2016. Eventually, recurring injuries took their toll, limiting Murray's later years on tour. Still, the 38-year-old's status as one of the sport's most revered players remains beyond doubt. In retrospect, Simon's battles with Murray were marked not just by rivalry but by mutual respect. Murray drove him to elevate his game - even if he seldom came out on top. For Simon, Murray wasn't merely an opponent - he was the benchmark of greatness.

It feels like no-one is wearing their England shirt for the Lionesses
It feels like no-one is wearing their England shirt for the Lionesses

Metro

time10 hours ago

  • Metro

It feels like no-one is wearing their England shirt for the Lionesses

Metro journalists select and curate the products that feature on our site. If you make a purchase via links on this page we will earn commission – learn more 'It's just the same, isn't it?' my friend said, as we stood, our backs to the TV, while England took penalties in the Euro 2025 quarter-final against Sweden. It was an all-too-familiar scenario: pacing the living room, hearts racing, as another player took their position in front of the goal, soundtracked by our cries of 'I can't watch!' He wasn't referring to England's famously bad track record at penalty shoot outs though, but the fact that we were watching the Lionesses, rather than the men's squad. The highs, the lows, the utter agony of being an England fan, was just the same. I can't remember the first time I went to a football match, but I think I was about four-years-old. Watching sport was a big part of my childhood. Leeds United's anthem, Marching On Together, was preferred over nursery rhymes and my first major crush was the bleach-blonde-haired striker Alan Smith. As a woman, I've never felt that I didn't belong in the stands, and that wasn't just exclusive to football. I've cheered at the rugby, speedway, tennis, and the Olympics. I've even branched out to baseball (essentially rounders) and there was one very, very, long afternoon at an NFL match (although cricket reigns supreme as the most boring sport I've had the misfortune of bearing witness to). Don't get me wrong, I'm not a die-hard fan. Post-match analysis makes me yawn and I couldn't tell you anything about the summer transfer window. And frankly, if it gets much below 10C, I'm not going. But suffice to say, I like watching sport. And as far as I'm concerned, the experience of watching 'women's football' is indeed just the same. The adrenaline rush is just as intense; a win just as satisfying. So, when I hopped on the Tube on Tuesday night to head to the pub for the semi-final against Italy, I assumed I'd be one of a sea of England shirts. To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video Granted, I know there is still a certain variety of person (let's face it, usually men) who find the concept of a woman playing football a little too hard to comprehend. But still, this was a big deal: we're the reigning champions of Europe, a win meant reaching a third consecutive final of a major tournament (which, spoiler, we did). And yet, I soon noticed I was the odd one out, so much so that I genuinely wondered if I'd got the day wrong. On my journey across London, the only three lions I saw, were on my own T-shirt. That's not to say you have to wear the badge to be a supporter (although I've always been a sucker for merch), but it was in stark contrast to the way the streets turn red and white when the men play. Rep the Lionesses in the official 2025 home shirt from Nike. Designed with a classic look and modern performance features, it's made with breathable Dri-FIT fabric to keep you cool and comfortable. Buy Now for £84.99 Obviously, I don't condone the dangerous displays of vandalism and violence we've seen in the past – I'm not about to suggest inserting flares into unmentionable places – but not so much as a scarf, or even a flag? When the men played in the Euros final last summer, the city had whipped itself into a frenzy. Flags flew from windows and cars, and people talked of taking the following day off work, as a win would surely mean partying into the early hours. To me, the lack of enthusiasm for Leah, Lucy, Michelle and their teammates feels insulting. What is about women's football that doesn't deserve the same kind of celebration? I'm genuinely asking, because I don't understand. People love to harp on about how the games are different: women are slower, less technical. 'It's like watching lower league football' is a phrase that gets banded around. But so what? How does that make it any less of an achievement that we're in the final? Surely there's actually more cause for fanfare. Women's football was famously banned by the FA in 1921 who branded it 'quite unsuitable for females'. In particular, there was concern that its growing popularity would somehow be a threat to the men's game. More Trending The ban wasn't lifted until 1971 – that's 50 long years during which the men progressed and developed, while women were forced to wait in the wings. And yet, despite being put on pause for five decades, the Lionesses are winning titles (side note: the men have never won the Euros) and creating a culture that fosters a sense of belonging, from rainbow armbands to the campaign for darker-coloured period-proof shorts, to proving that you can still be a world-class athlete with manicured nails and lifted lashes. If you consider yourself a football fan, not supporting the Lionesses tells me all I need to know about you. The long and short of it is that England are in the Euros final, and if you'd be half-cut at the pub by midday on Sunday waiting for the men to kick off, you should ask yourself why you're not doing the same for the women. Do you have a story to share? Get in touch by emailing MetroLifestyleTeam@ MORE: Lionesses warned they must avoid 'awful' mistake to beat Spain in Euro 2025 final MORE: How Arsenal can inspire England to beat Spain in the Euro 2025 final MORE: Living by the 50/40/10 rule got me out of £40,000 debt twice

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store