CDC denies Milwaukee's request for help with unsafe lead levels in public schools
The US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention has denied a request from Milwaukee's public health department for assistance in managing unsafe lead levels in the city's public schools, citing the loss of its lead experts in mass firings last week across federal health agencies.
'I sincerely regret to inform you that due to the complete loss of our Lead Program, we will be unable to support you with this EpiAid request,' Aaron Bernstein, director of the National Center for Environmental Health/Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry at the CDC, wrote late last week to Milwaukee officials, according to a letter obtained by CNN.
EpiAid is a CDC program providing a short-term loan of an officer from the public health agency's Epidemic Intelligence Service, or EIS. These 'disease detectives' are sent to state and local health departments to investigate urgent public health problems.
In Milwaukee's case, the city requested the CDC's help March 26 with the investigation of lead exposure in its public schools, after the health department identified hazardous levels of lead contamination in multiple school buildings. CNN reported last week that Milwaukee's health commissioner, Dr. Michael Totoraitis, had been working with the CDC for two months to address the threat.
Lead is toxic to the brain, and no levels of exposure are considered safe. It can be present in buildings constructed before 1978, when it was still legal to use lead in paint.
On April 1 – the day about 10,000 federal health employees lost their jobs as part of a massive Reduction in Force across the US Department of Health and Human Services – Milwaukee officials received an email from a CDC epidemiologist telling them 'my entire division was eliminated today,' apologizing that she wouldn't be able to continue working with the city on the response and referring them to other points of contact within the agency.
'The new points of contact were essentially unable to say what level of support they would provide us moving forward,' Totoraitis told CNN at the time.
Two days later, asked about the cutting of the CDC's lead poisoning prevention and surveillance branch, US Department of Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. suggested that the program might be reinstated.
'There are some programs that were cut that are being reinstated, and I think that's one of them,' he said April 3, noting that 'there were a number of instances where … personnel that should not have been cut were cut.'
A spokesperson for HHS told CNN that day that 'HHS is planning to continue the important work of the lead poisoning prevention and surveillance branch that works to eliminate childhood lead poisoning under the Administration for a Healthy America,' a newly created organization within the agency.
But that same evening, Milwaukee received the email from the CDC denying its EpiAid request.
'While we're disappointed, [the Milwaukee Health Department]'s work has not stopped,' Caroline Reinwald, a spokesperson for the department, told CNN by email Friday. 'This only underscores the importance of the role local public health plays in protecting communities – and the challenges we now face without federal expertise to call on.'
A spokesperson for HHS didn't immediately return CNN's request for comment. CBS News first reported that the CDC had denied the request.
Milwaukee's health department, Reinwald said, 'remains committed to moving this work forward and finding solutions locally.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Axios
an hour ago
- Axios
Vaccine board purge stokes talk of CDC alternatives
By gutting the expert panel that's advised the government on vaccine policy for more than 60 years, Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. earned the condemnation of virtually every medical society, as well as former public health officials and local practitioners. What became immediately clear is that no outside group can immediately step in and fill the vacuum if the public won't trust the reconstituted Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices. The big picture: The distress and lack of organization apparent in health circles on Tuesday was a sign that a new independent body that could act as a "shadow CDC" to truth-squad the Trump administration isn't close to materializing. "We are clearly working on it and we think it's very important, but I don't think anyone has an answer yet," said Michael Osterholm, director of the University of Minnesota's Center for Infectious Disease Research and Policy, who's behind one ad hoc effort. "Right now, we're in such uncharted territory." The medical establishment has floated ideas such as state-appointed boards or medical specialty associations serving as clearinghouses for information on vaccine safety and efficacy for clinicians. California Gov. Gavin Newsom (D) during the pandemic created a state entity to review the safety of federally approved COVID-19 vaccines before distributing them to the public. But it would be difficult to replicate the professional clout of ACIP, whose recommendations can influence whether insurers cover vaccines. That would leave Kennedy's handpicked successors controlling the narrative — a prospect many researchers and physicians think will bring a radical departure from ACIP's evidence-based deliberations on safety and efficacy. Friction point: Kennedy and other Trump health officials' assertions that ACIP has been a rubber stamp for vaccines have infuriated public health officials, who say the physicians, infectious disease experts and researchers constituted a vital body of nongovernmental health leaders who took their jobs seriously. Panel members were carefully vetted for conflicts and had their professional credentials scrutinized. Discussions took place in a high-profile public forum that would be difficult, if not impossible, to replicate. "Many of us can provide a read of the science, and we can convene formally or informally to create consensus around vaccine recommendations," said Megan Ranney, dean of the Yale School of Public Health. "But I suspect that it won't be sufficient for insurers, for Medicaid, for the Vaccines for Children program, and it's unclear how pediatricians and primary care physicians and pharmacies across the country are going to be able to respond," she said. The other side: Kennedy wrote on X Tuesday night that he would announce new ACIP members in the coming days. "None of these individuals will be ideological anti-vaxxers. They will be highly credentialed physicians and scientists," Kennedy wrote. He added he would detail instances of "historical corruption at ACIP to help the public understand why this clean sweep was necessary. "Kennedy cited the panel's "stubborn unwillingness to demand adequate safety trials before recommending new vaccines for our children" as the most "outrageous example." What to watch: All eyes are on the new appointees for the board, including their scientific backgrounds, track records when it comes to defending vaccines and any potential conflicts of interest. HHS has indicated it has every intention of moving forward with ACIP's next meeting, scheduled for June 25-27. The agenda includes recommendation votes for COVID–19, HPV, influenza, meningococcal and RSV vaccines. "If nothing else, I think [the committee] may have trouble functioning because you've just lost a whole lot of institutional memory," said Adam Ratner, a member of the American Academy of Pediatrics' Committee on Infectious Diseases. "That agenda has the committee voting on real things that matter to real people, and I don't know how they're possibly going to do that in any kind of way that is based on science or evidence," he said.
New York Times
an hour ago
- New York Times
It's Code Red for Vaccines
The number of changes to vaccine policy in the United States in recent weeks is dizzying — and we've just hit Code Red. The federal government has sown confusion by changing recommendations for Covid-19 vaccines, ending contracts for mRNA technology research and firing the entire congressionally authorized panel that guides the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention's vaccine decisions. Robert F. Kennedy Jr., the secretary of health, is a longtime vaccine conspirator. Though he most likely couldn't unilaterally revoke vaccine licenses or rewrite the children's vaccination schedule, there has been concern that he will spur an insidious unraveling of vaccine infrastructure, starting with his destruction on Monday of the C.D.C.'s Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices. With so much happening, it can be difficult to know what's truly concerning and what changes are probably fine — or even worthwhile. As an expert in vaccines and public health, I'm looking at the shifting landscape like this: What keeps me up at night 1. The firing of the A.C.I.P. members: The ousting of all 17 members is a warning of what might be coming. The committee has served for decades as the C.D.C.'s independent scientific body on immunization. Removing its entire membership in one day, under the guise of restoring 'public trust,' destroys the firewall between science and politics. There's no clear plan for its new makeup, but all signs point to a committee aligned with Mr. Kennedy's longstanding antagonism toward vaccines — and unlike him, a reconstituted committee will be in a position to more directly rearrange, alter or dismantle the national vaccine schedule as it sees fit. 2. Canceling mRNA vaccine development: Mr. Kennedy's Department of Health and Human Services recently canceled a $766 million contract with the pharmaceutical company Moderna to develop next-generation mRNA flu vaccines that use the same technology that made the Covid-19 vaccines so effective. This is despite promising early data on the effectiveness of the company's bird flu vaccine, and an urgent need for more pandemic response tools. This is not fiscal prudence. It's sabotage of a platform that helped end the worst of the Covid pandemic and remains our best defense should a deadlier one emerge. 3. Politicizing autism research: Mr. Kennedy has appointed the longtime vaccine critic David Geier to lead a government study on autism. Mr. Geier, who has been disciplined for practicing medicine without a license, has promoted debunked links between vaccines and autism. The mission of this research isn't scientific discovery; it's laundering fringe ideas through federal legitimacy. Want all of The Times? Subscribe.
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
CDC firings: Former director, fired vaccine panelist on RFK Jr's changes
(NewsNation) — While Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. says he wanted to restore public trust by firing the entire vaccine advisory panel at the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, one person he fired says Kennedy did the opposite in the academic community. The Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices members was made up of medical and health professionals who made recommendations on the safety and use of vaccines. One of the 17 panelists fired is Dr. Noel Brewer, who joined NewsNation's 'CUOMO' on Tuesday night. 'My concern is that we've taken 60 years of efforts to build trust among health care providers in the recommendations of the advisory committee through CDC, and that trust just evaporated overnight,' Brewer said. 'It is going to be hard to get that back.' The committee was set to meet in two weeks to discuss COVID-19 and other vaccines. Judge determined OPM broke law with DOGE access to data 'I don't think most Americans even care that much about it. And now that there's all this news and people like me out from our ivory towers, it's generating interest,' Brewer said. 'But I don't think that the impact here is going to be primarily among the general public.' Dr. Robert Redfield was CDC director under the first Trump administration, and he said the public lost trust in the power of vaccines. 'I believe vaccines are the most important gift of science to modern medicine. When I was CDC director, I was very disturbed that over half of the population didn't get the flu vaccine,' he said. 'Then, the COVID pandemic came, and I have to say, although I have a lot of respect for Noel and the other people on the committee, the reality is the guidance that came out of the ACIP for COVID vaccines, I think in general, was ill-advised.' Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
