
Disney Didn't Copy ‘Moana' from a Man's Story of a Surfer Boy, a Jury Says
A jury on Monday quickly and completely rejected a man's claim that Disney's 'Moana' was stolen from his story of a young surfer in Hawaii.
The Los Angeles federal jury deliberated for only about 2 ½ hours before deciding that the creators of 'Moana' never had access to writer and animator Buck Woodall's outlines and script for 'Bucky the Surfer Boy.'
With that question settled, the jury of six women and two men didn't even have to consider the similarities between 'Bucky' and Disney's 2016 hit animated film about a questing Polynesian princess.
Woodall had shared his work with a distant relative, who worked for a different company on the Disney lot, but the woman testified during the two-week trial that she never showed it to anyone at Disney.
'Obviously we're disappointed,' Woodall's attorney Gustavo Lage said outside court. 'We're going to review our options and think about the best path forward.'
In closing arguments earlier Monday, Woodall's attorney said that a long chain of circumstantial evidence showed the two works were inseparable.
'There was no 'Moana' without 'Bucky,'' Lage said.
Defense lawyer Moez Kaba said that the evidence showed overwhelmingly that 'Moana' was clearly the creation and 'crowning achievement' of the 40-year career of John Musker and Ron Clements, the writers and directors behind 1989's 'The Little Mermaid,' 1992's 'Aladdin,' 1997's 'Hercules' and 2009's 'The Princess and the Frog.'
'They had no idea about Bucky,' Kaba said in his closing. 'They had never seen it, never heard of it.'
'Moana' earned nearly $700 million at the global box office.
A judge previously ruled that Woodall's 2020 lawsuit came too late for him to claim a piece of those receipts, and that a lawsuit he filed earlier this year over 'Moana 2' — which earned more than $1 billion — must be decided separately. That suit remains active, though the jury's decision does not bode well for it. Judge Consuelo B. Marshall, who is also overseeing the sequel lawsuit, said after the verdict that she agreed with the jurors' decision about access.
'We are incredibly proud of the collective work that went into the making of Moana and are pleased that the jury found it had nothing to do with Plaintiff's works,' Disney said in a statement.
Musker and Disney's attorneys declined to comment outside the courtroom.
The relatively young jury of six women and two men watched 'Moana' in its entirety in the courtroom. They considered a story outline that Woodall created for 'Bucky' in 2003, along with a 2008 update and a 2011 script.
In the latter versions of the story, the title character, vacationing in Hawaii with his parents, befriends a group of Native Hawaiian youth and goes on a quest that includes time travel to the ancient islands and interactions with demigods to save a sacred site from a developer.
Around 2004, Woodall gave the 'Bucky' outline to the stepsister of his brother's wife. That woman, Jenny Marchick, worked for Mandeville Films, a company that had a contract with Disney and was located on the Disney lot. He sent her follow-up materials through the years. He testified that he was stunned when he saw 'Moana' in 2016 and saw so many of his ideas.
Along with her testimony saying she didn't show 'Bucky' to anyone, messages shared by the defense showed she eventually ignored Woodall's queries to her and had told him there was nothing she could do for him.
Disney attorney Kaba argued there was no evidence Marchick ever worked on 'Moana' or received any credit or compensation for it.
Kaba pointed out that Marchick, now head of features development at DreamWorks Animation, worked for key Disney competitors Sony and Fox during much of the time she was allegedly making use of Woodall's work for Disney.
Woodall also submitted the script directly to Disney and had a meeting with an assistant at the Disney Channel, which Marchick arranged for him, to talk about working as an animator. But jurors agreed that this didn't give them reason to believe that 'Bucky' made its way to Musker, Clements or their collaborators.
Lage, Woodall's attorney, outlined some of the similarities of the two works in his closing.
Both include teens on oceanic quests.
Both have Polynesian demigods as central figures and shape-shifting characters who turn into, among other things, insects and sharks.
In both, the main characters interact with animals who act as spirit helpers.
Kaba said many of these elements, including Polynesian lore and basic 'staples of literature,' are not copyrightable.
Shape-shifting among supernatural characters, he said, appears throughout films including 'The Little Mermaid,' 'Aladdin,' and Hercules, which made Musker and Clements essential to the Disney renaissance of the 1990s and made Disney a global powerhouse.
Animal guides go back to movies as early as 1940's 'Pinocchio' and appear in all of Musker and Clements' previous films, he said.
Kaba said Musker and Clements developed 'Moana' the same way they did the other films, through their own inspiration, research, travel and creativity.
The lawyer said thousands of pages of development documents showed every step of Musker and Clements' creation, whose spark came from the paintings of Paul Gaugin and the writings of Herman Melville
'You can see every single fingerprint,' Kaba said. 'You can see the entire genetic makeup of 'Moana.''
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Saudi Gazette
03-06-2025
- Saudi Gazette
Disney lays off hundreds more as it cuts costs
ORLANDO — Disney says it is laying off several hundred more people around the world, with workers in its film, television and finance departments impacted. The entertainment giant has been under pressure as viewers move away from cable TV subscriptions in favor of streaming platforms. "As our industry transforms at a rapid pace, we continue to evaluate ways to efficiently manage our businesses while fuelling the state-of-the-art creativity and innovation that consumers value and expect from Disney," a spokesperson told the BBC. The latest job cuts follow major layoffs announced in 2023, when around 7,000 workers were let go as part of a drive by chief executive Bob Iger to save $5.5bn (£4.1bn). The cuts will impact multiple teams including marketing departments for its film and television units. Workers in Disney's casting and development and corporate finance departments will also be affected."We have been surgical in our approach to minimize the number of impacted employees," said a spokesperson. The company also said that no teams will be closed down California-based firm employs 233,000 workers, with just over 60,000 of those based outside the owns a host of companies across the entertainment industry including Marvel, Hulu and firm reported stronger than expected earnings in May, with overall revenue of $23.6bn for the first three months of the year. That was a 7% increase from the same period in said the growth was fuelled by new subscribers to its Disney+ streaming company has released a number of new films this year including Captain America: Brave New World and Snow latest release, Lilo & Stitch, broke box office records in the US for the Memorial Day holiday animated film has seen global ticket sales of more than $610m since its release in May, according to industry data firm Box Office Mojo. — BBC


Asharq Al-Awsat
01-06-2025
- Asharq Al-Awsat
‘Lilo & Stitch' Passes ‘Sinners' to Become 2nd Highest Grossing Film of 2025
'Lilo & Stich' and 'Mission: Impossible—The Final Reckoning' dominated the box office charts again after fueling a record-breaking Memorial Day weekend. Theaters in the US and Canada had several new films to offer this weekend as well, including Sony's family friendly 'Karate Kid: Legends' and the A24 horror movie 'Bring Her Back.' According to studio estimates Sunday, it added up to a robust $145 million post-holiday weekend that's up over 115% from the same timeframe last year. Disney's live-action hybrid 'Lilo & Stitch' took first place again with $63 million from 4,410 locations in North America. It was enough to pass 'Sinners' to become the second-highest grossing movie of the year with $280.1 million in domestic ticket sales. Globally, it's running total is $610.8 million. 'Sinners,' meanwhile, is still going strong in its seventh weekend with another $5.2 million, bumping it to $267.1 million domestically and $350.1 million globally. The eighth 'Mission: Impossible' movie also repeated in second place, with $27.3 million from 3,861 locations. As with 'Lilo & Stitch,' that's down 57% from its opening. With $122.6 million in domestic tickets sold, it's performing in line with the two previous installments. But with a reported production budget of $400 million, profitability is a ways off. Internationally, it added $76.1 million (including $25.2 million from China where it just opened), bringing its global total to $353.8 million. Leading the newcomers was Sony's 'Karate Kid: Legends,' with an estimated $21 million from 3,809 locations. The movie brings Jackie Chan and Ralph Macchio together to train a new kid, the kung fu prodigy Li Fong (Ben Wang). Chan starred in a 2010 reboot of the 1984 original, while Macchio has found a new generation of fans in the series 'Cobra Kai,' which just concluded a six-season run. Reviews might have been mixed, but opening weekend audiences gave the PG-13 rated film a strong A- CinemaScore and 4.5 stars on PostTrak. It also only cost a reported $45 million to produce and has several weeks until a new family-friendly film arrives. Fourth place went 'Final Destination: Bloodlines,' which earned $10.8 million in its third weekend. The movie is the highest-grossing in the franchise, not accounting for inflation, with $229.3 million globally. The weekend's other big newcomer, 'Bring Her Back' rounded out the top five with $7.1 million from 2,449 screens. Starring Sally Hawkins as a foster mother with some disturbing plans, the film is the sophomore feature of twin filmmakers Danny and Michael Philippou, who made the 2023 horror breakout 'Talk to Me.' It earned a rare-for-horror B+ CinemaScore and is essentially the only new film in the genre until '28 Years Later' opens on June 20. A new Wes Anderson movie, 'The Phoenician Scheme,' also debuted in New York and Los Angeles this weekend, where it made $270,000. It expands nationwide next weekend. The summer box office forecast remains promising, though there's a long way to go to get to the $4 billion target (a pre-pandemic norm that only the 'Barbenheimer' summer has surpassed). The month of May is expected to close out with $973 million – up 75% from May 2024, according to data from Comscore.


Asharq Al-Awsat
26-05-2025
- Asharq Al-Awsat
Demi Lovato Marries Singer-Songwriter Jordan ‘Jutes' Lutes in California
She's more than just cool for the summer — Demi Lovato is officially married. The musician-actor, 32, tied the knot with Canadian singer-songwriter Jordan 'Jutes' Lutes, 34, on Sunday in California, as first exclusively reported by Vogue. The couple met while working on Lovato's last album that was released in 2022, and dated for nearly two years before Lutes proposed in December 2023. Lutes co-wrote a few of the songs, including 'Happy Ending,' 'City of Angels," and the pop-punk single, 'Substance.' Lovato wore a white Vivienne Westwood dress and Lutes wore a Saint Laurent suit. Representatives for Lovato did not immediately respond to The Associated Press' request for comment. Lovato, a former child star, began her entertainment career on 'Barney & Friends' before becoming a staple of Disney Channel in the 2000s for her role in the 'Camp Rock' films and as the star of 'Sonny with a Chance.' Beyond her acting, Lovato has long been celebrated for her gifted soprano and has released eight albums across her career. Lutes, an independent artist whose hybridist music marries elements of emo, pop-punk and trap, was previously signed to Capitol Records. Prior to her relationship with Lutes, Lovato was engaged to the actor Max Ehrich in 2020. They called off their engagement after two months.