MAGA-inspired outrage machine has a new target in this election
'Never make predictions, especially about the future,' New York Yankees manager Casey Stengel famously said. In the sport of politics we are in peak prediction mode this week – and Saturday night will reveal what surprises are in store.
I've been part of many elections where the polls have got it spectacularly wrong – most shockingly in Labor's 2019 loss and most painfully in Donald Trump's 2016 win.
Both were a result of the fact that while we obsess about the number of people who report a certain opinion at a given moment in time, we pay much less attention to the strength of that opinion. Large and unpredicted swings between polls and actual results are usually a reflection of the 'softness' of the opinions held by those being polled – the likeliness they will change their mind. Too often we report public opinion as if it is chiselled in stone.
We experienced this collectively as a nation in 2023. The prime minister, encouraged by polls that showed up to 75 per cent support for an Indigenous Voice to parliament, ploughed ahead with a referendum to enshrine it even after Peter Dutton's denial of bipartisanship.
As we found out, in the face of a barrage of unprecedented disinformation and a sophisticated MAGA-inspired outrage machine, that support turned out to be very soft. Over the course of the campaign it evaporated – on polling day the Yes vote garnered less than 40 per cent.
Similarly, we have in recent years taken the same levels of support for renewable energy as if they are chiselled in stone. More than 70 per cent of Australians support the transition to renewables, and more ambitious climate targets. Most pundits take broad social licence for a transition to clean energy – a fancy way of saying the community is on board – as a fait accompli.
Loading
But renewable energy is right now facing a barrage of unprecedented disinformation and a sophisticated MAGA-inspired outrage machine, akin to what we saw during the Voice. Its very purpose is to undermine the social licence under which renewable energy projects operate. Having lost the argument on the existence of climate change, as the world proceeded to burn before our eyes, opponents quickly pivoted instead to undermining support for renewables.
While the Voice had to withstand a torrent of misinformation-based attacks on social media, from 'say NO to save Australia Day' to 'farmers will need a permit to put up a fence', renewables face the same.
Social media is ripe with anti-renewables outrage. Hysteria over offshore wind farms killing whales (they don't). Hysteria over solar fields ruining pristine farmland (they don't). Hysteria over vehicle fuel-emissions standards banning utes (they don't) or ruining the weekend (they don't).
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
West Australian
26 minutes ago
- West Australian
Anthony Albanese's Government to convene at roundtable to hatch plan to propel Australia into stronger future
Business groups are cautiously optimistic about a productivity roundtable Treasurer Jim Chalmers will host but will head in eyes wide open after feeling like they were burned by the outcomes of Labor's first-term jobs and skills summit. Prime Minister Anthony Albanese announced on Tuesday the Government would convene the roundtable in August to hear ideas from all quarters about how to tackle stagnating productivity and propel Australia into a stronger future. 'We want to build the broadest possible base of support for further economic reform to drive growth, boost productivity, strengthen the budget and secure the resilience of our economy, in a time of global uncertainty,' he told the National Press Club in a speech laying out his second-term agenda. 'We will be respectful. We want people to participate in the spirit of goodwill in which we're making this suggestion.' Dr Chalmers has labelled flatlining productivity one of the biggest challenges Australia faces. He's already tasked the Productivity Commission to do a sweeping review of how best to tackle the long-run challenges, with 15 priority areas now under closer exploration. Business groups have welcomed the focus, with Ai Group chief executive Innes Willox lamenting the fact boosting productivity was barely mentioned during the election. 'Current policy settings at both national and state levels are clearly not working. This summit is therefore ideally timed, and needs to focus on immediate reforms that can promptly turn our productivity performance around,' Mr Willox said. But there is caution after the September 2022 jobs and skills summit was used to rubber-stamp industrial relations changes that industry says are now hampering productivity. Mr Albanese said that, as a Labor prime minister, he would always support unions existing but he respected the role of business too, pointing out there wouldn't be any union members without successful employers. He insisted he wasn't pre-empting any outcomes but wanted genuine discussion around where there were win-wins on productivity. 'I want people to be able to have a discussion … without screaming headlines saying, you know, this is going to happen because someone has raised it,' he said. Business Council of Australia head Bran Black said his organisation was already working with groups across society on ideas to boost productivity in order to drive up living standards for Australians. 'These policies include red tape reduction, faster approvals on major projects, harnessing the potential of AI, advancing research and development, undertaking broad tax reform, unlocking more trade and investment and delivering the energy transition,' he said. 'At the same time, we will continue to be very clear about policies that the business community believes will be counterproductive to improving productivity.' Shadow treasurer Ted O'Brien and shadow productivity minister Andrew Bragg said the proposal sounded like a talkfest and came after the Prime Minister had 'saddled the economy with thousands of new regulations in the last Parliament'. 'If this change of heart by Labor is true, it will be akin to turning around the Titanic,' they said in a joining statement, while insisting they were open to being constructive. Senator Bragg has already written to major industry associations seeking suggestions for deregulation as the Coalition shapes its policy agenda in the new term. It's unclear yet if the Coalition will be invited to the roundtable. HOUSING A key sector where the productivity stagnation is hurting Australians is housing, where the slowdown in construction has led to a supply and affordability crisis. Mr Albanese said plainly it was 'too hard' to build houses and governments had to work together to make it easier. 'Developers say that it's just too complex, (that) adds to costs as well,' he said, taking aim at 'unnecessary regulation'. 'I want to make sure that housing is fit for purpose and all of that. But if we can cut through on some of the red tape, then that will reduce costs.' Across the board, governments had to do the basics better, target duplication of processes and remove barriers to investment. But Mr Albanese also said there were some challenges where governments had to step up, not back, such as speeding up infrastructure builds and investing more in education and skills. DEFENCE Mr Albanese travels to Fiji, the US and Canada later this week for the G7 leaders' summit and an anticipated meeting with US President Donald Trump. Ahead of the expected discussions, he has faced repeated questions about Australia's spending on defence after the Trump administration made it clear it wants its partners to step up. The Prime Minister has resisted nominating a target level of GDP but insisted on Tuesday he would always support any requests for more money for specific capabilities. 'Arbitrary figures … lead to a cul-de-sac. And we want to make sure as well that every single dollar that Defence spends results in actual assets,' he said. 'We will always provide for capability that's needed.' He reiterated his red lines in any discussion with Mr Trump, saying he wouldn't budge on the under-16s social media ban, biosecurity, subsidised pharmaceuticals or plans to make large tech companies pay for news content. POLITICAL CULTURE Mr Albanese also urged people to 'chill out' about old social media posts made by aspiring political candidates. He revealed Labor doesn't go through its candidates' old posts, saying it was up to individuals to be accountable for what they had said or done in the past but also there had to be a recognition that the world had changed with the advent of social media. 'If people are held to account for what a 21-year-old has on social media in 10 years' time, then we won't have anyone willing to put their hand up in public life,' he warned. 'I understand the pressures that young people are under, which is very different from the pressures that were on (older generations)... I wouldn't particularly appreciate everything being documented when I was in young Labor, let me tell you.' Mr Albanese said he was focused now on delivering what Labor had promised people at the election because he believed ensuring people's interactions with government went smoothly was key to boosting faith in democracy. To aid this delivery, he announced Steven Kennedy would move from Treasury to head up his department while Jenny Wilkinson, who has been running the Finance Department, will become the first female Treasury secretary. He pledged to continue a consultative style in Parliament, revealing he had already met with new Opposition Leader Sussan Ley and Nationals leader David Littleproud. 'We have 94 votes, but that actually doesn't make a difference compared with 78 – because 78 wins and 94 wins (in the lower house),' he said. 'You don't win bigger, you win, you pass legislation.'
Perth Now
44 minutes ago
- Perth Now
State on edge over potential snap election call
Tasmania is in a state of political limbo, with the island's governor considering "all available options" before potentially approving a snap election. Embattled Liberal minority Premier Jeremy Rockliff on Tuesday evening visited Governor Barbara Baker to formally request an early poll. Mr Rockliff lost a no-confidence motion in parliament on Thursday, but has refused to stand down as convention dictates, instead vowing to take Tasmania back to the ballot box. In a statement, Ms Baker's secretary said she would take "the time necessary to give due consideration to all available options". "By the end of the week the premier will meet with Her Excellency again. Further statements will be made in due course," the secretary said. Mr Rockliff said he respected Ms Baker's stance and he remained committed to serving the people of Tasmania. The Liberals, who hold 14 of 35 lower-house seats, have governed in minority since being returned to power at the March 2024 poll. Ms Baker could direct the Liberals to find another leader to avoid an election, or ask Labor opposition leader Dean Winter to try to form a workable government. However, Mr Winter's party, which holds just 10 seats, has ruled out an alliance with the Greens to form a minority. Labor brought forward the no-confidence motion in Mr Rockliff because of his budget "mismanagement" and delays and cost blowouts to new Bass Strait ferries. The motion was passed with support from the Greens and three crossbench independents. Battle lines for an election have already been drawn, with the Liberals abandoning potential state asset sales and announcing former federal MP Bridget Archer was prepared to run. If an election is called, it would be Tasmania's fourth in the space of seven years.
Perth Now
an hour ago
- Perth Now
Ambassador to talk trade amid renewed EU negotiations
Increasing trade ties with Australia will be front and centre in a major address by the European Union's leading diplomat. EU ambassador Gabriele Visentin will speak to the National Press Club on Wednesday, as Australia and the trading bloc revive negotiations for a sweeping free-trade agreement. Long-stalled talks have resumed following the global uncertainty caused by US President Donald Trump's tariffs on exports to America, which have up-ended long-standing relationships. While negotiations began in 2018, they stalled over the EU's issues with geographic indicators. The trading bloc had been concerned by Australian producers using terms like prosecco or feta for products that didn't come from specific regions in Europe. Trade is expected to be a key point of Mr Visentin's speech, which will centre on the EU as a crucial world power. The EU is Australia's third-largest trading partner, with 450 million people in the European bloc, and is worth more than $150 billion a year. Trade Minister Don Farrell met with his European counterparts while in Paris for the OECD summit last week. He said he was confident a deal could be reached. "We've got lots of things that we can sell to the Europeans," he said. "I believe now that there's an appetite to reach an agreement on both sides. The world has changed."
