Future of Israel's plan to force Gazans to southern city hangs in balance
Gaza
ceasefire
and hostage release deal, the future of
Israel
's planned 'humanitarian city' in Rafah hangs in the balance.
The plan, outlined by defence minister Israel Katz, envisages the forced transfer of Gaza's population to a tent city to be built on the ruins of the southern city of Rafah, now largely destroyed, beginning with the approximately 600,000 war refugees from the adjacent Muwasi humanitarian zone.
Israel hopes international aid agencies will provide food, water and medical supplies to the area while the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) will secure the approach routes.
The residents will be screened on entry and will not be allowed to leave. Israel argues that the plan will separate innocent civilians from Hamas fighters in other areas, who will no longer be able to surround themselves with civilian human shields.
READ MORE
At a tense security cabinet meeting on Sunday night, prime minister
Binyamin Netanyahu
and several other ministers criticised the IDF plan to establish the humanitarian city after military planners warned that it could take up to a year to build and cost €3.5 billion.
Mr Netanyahu told IDF chief of staff Ltn Gen Eyal Zamir: 'I asked for a realistic plan,' telling him to draw up an alternative plan that would be faster and cheaper.
Israeli experts in international law and the laws of war have warned that the humanitarian city constitutes a war crime and a crime against humanity, claiming that under certain conditions, it could also be considered genocide.
Unrwa, the United Nations agency for Palestinian refugees, says the plan would create 'de facto massive concentration camps at the border with Egypt'.
Hamas
negotiators have rejected the idea as part of an Israeli plan to continue the war after an initial 60-day ceasefire, leading to a forced transfer of Gaza residents to Egypt or other countries.
IDF officials have warned that Hamas opposition to the plan could topple a ceasefire deal and endanger the lives of the 20 hostages still believed to be alive.
The Palestinian foreign ministry also rejected the plan, saying: 'The humanitarian city has nothing to do with humanity.'
Israel's opposition leader Yair Lapid termed the plan an expensive fantasy of Mr Netanyahu's far-right coalition partners, who favour the re-establishment of Israeli settlements in Gaza. Former prime minister Ehud Olmert described the humanitarian city as a 'concentration camp'.
The Israeli military launched a campaign to destroy Hamas in response to an unprecedented cross-border attack on October 7th, 2023, in which about 1,200 people were killed and 251 were taken hostage. More than 58,000 people have been killed in Gaza since then, according to the territory's Hamas-run health ministry.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RTÉ News
33 minutes ago
- RTÉ News
Netanyahu under growing political pressure as party quits coalition
A religious party has quit Israel's ruling coalition in a dispute over military service, leaving Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu with a razor-thin majority in parliament but still enough political support to secure a potential Gaza ceasefire. Six members of United Torah Judaism (UTJ) handed in resignation letters overnight from posts in parliamentary committees and government ministries, in protest against lawmakers' failure to guarantee future exemption from military conscription for ultra-Orthodox religious students. Shas, a second ultra-Orthodox party closely allied with UTJ, may follow and leave the government with no parliament majority. The UTJ lawmakers said their walkout would come into effect after 48 hours, giving Mr Netanyahu two days to try and resolve the crisis which has dogged his coalition for months. Even if that fails, parliament goes on summer break at the end of July, which would give the prime minister a further three months to seek a solution before any loss of his majority could threaten his position. Mr Netanyahu is also facing pressure from far-right parties in his coalition over ceasefire talks under way in Qatar. The indirect negotiations between Israel and Palestinian militant group Hamas aim to halt fighting in Gaza for 60 days to allow half of remaining hostages held by Hamas to be released and aid to flow into the enclave. It would also open a further phase of talks on ending the war entirely. National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir and Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich want Israel to press on with the war, but Mr Netanyahu would still be likely to have enough cabinet votes to secure a ceasefire without them. "As soon as the right deal is on the table, the prime minister will be able to pass it through," a close aide to Mr Netanyahu, Topaz Luk, told Army Radio on Tuesday. Military exemptions Israelis have become increasingly weary of the 21-month war in Gaza, which began with a surprise attack by Hamas on 7 October, 2023 that led to Israel's single deadliest day with 1,200 killed and 251 taken hostage by the Palestinian militants. Israel's subsequent offensive against Hamas has since killed more than 58,000 Palestinians, according to health officials, displaced almost the entire population of Gaza, led to a humanitarian crisis and left much of the enclave in ruins. It has also exacted Israel's highest military death toll in decades, with around 450 soldiers killed so far in Gaza combat. This has added fuel to an already explosive debate over a new conscription bill at the center of Mr Netanyahu's political crisis. Ultra-Orthodox seminary students have long been exempt from mandatory military service. Many Israelis are angered by what they see as an unfair burden carried by the mainstream who serve. Ultra-Orthodox Jewish leaders say full-time devotion to holy scriptures study is sacrosanct and fear their young men will steer away from religious life if they are drafted into the military. Last year the Supreme Court ordered an end to the exemption. Parliament has been trying to work out a new conscription bill, which has so far failed to meet UTJ demands.
The Journal
3 hours ago
- The Journal
Divided EU to discuss '10 options' over Israeli trade deal but are unlikely to agree on any
EU FOREIGN MINISTERS will today discuss a raft of options for action against Israel over the war in Gaza — but likely will not agree on any. The bloc's foreign policy chief Kaja Kallas has put forward 10 potential steps after Israel was found to have breached a trade deal between the two sides on human rights grounds. The measures range from suspending the entire accord or curbing trade ties to sanctioning Israeli ministers, imposing an arms embargo and halting visa-free travel. But despite growing anger over the devastation in Gaza, EU states remain divided over how to tackle Israel and diplomats say there appears to be no critical mass for any move. 'I was asked to give the inventory of the options that could be taken and it's up to the member states to discuss what do we do with these options,' Kallas said Monday. The tone of discussions will be shaped strongly by how Israel is implementing a promise to the EU to improve humanitarian access to Gaza. Kallas said last week that she had struck a deal with her Israeli counterpart, Gideon Saar, to open more entry points and allow in more food. This deal has been criticised by several Irish MEPs, who point to UN figures which say that more than more than 800 people in Gaza have been killed by the Israeli Defence Force while attempting to get aid since May alone. Gaza's two million residents are facing dire humanitarian conditions as Israel has severely limited aid during its devastating war with Palestinian militant group Hamas. 'We see some good signs of more trucks getting in,' Kallas said Monday. Advertisement 'But of course we know that this is not enough and we need to push more (so) that the implementation of what we have agreed also happens on the ground.' At a meeting of EU and neighbouring countries in Brussels on Monday, Jordanian foreign minister Ayman Safadi said the situation in Gaza remained 'catastrophic'. 'No justification' Israel's Saar, speaking at the same meeting, sounded confident his country would avoid further EU action. 'I'm sure not any of them will be adopted by the EU member states,' said the foreign minister. 'There's no justification whatsoever.' While the EU appears unable for now to take any further moves against Israel, just getting to this stage has been a considerable step. The bloc only agreed to review the cooperation deal after Israel relaunched its devastating operation in Gaza following the collapse of a ceasefire in March. Until then deep divisions between countries backing Israel and those more favourable to the Palestinians had hamstrung any move. Israel's war on Gaza has now killed at least 57,762 people since October 2023, most of them civilians, according to the territory's health ministry. The war was sparked by Hamas's 7 October, 2023 attack on Israel, which led to 1,219 deaths, most of them civilians © – AFP 2025
RTÉ News
6 hours ago
- RTÉ News
EU to discuss action against Israel over Gaza war conduct
EU foreign ministers will discuss a raft of options for action against Israel over the war in Gaza - but likely will not agree on any. The bloc's foreign policy chief Kaja Kallas has put forward ten potential steps after Israel was found to have breached the human rights obligations of the EU-Israel Association Agreement due to its conduct in Gaza. The measures range from suspending the entire accord or curbing trade ties to sanctioning Israeli ministers, imposing an arms embargo and halting visa-free travel. However, despite growing anger Israel's destruction of Gaza, EU states remain divided over how to tackle Israel and diplomats claim there appears to be no critical mass for any move. "I was asked to give the inventory of the options that could be taken and it's up to the member states to discuss what do we do with these options," Ms Kallas said yesterday. The tone of discussions will be shaped strongly by how Israel is implementing a promise to the EU to improve humanitarian access to Gaza. Ms Kallas said on Thursday that she had struck a deal with her Israeli counterpart, Gideon Saar, to open more entry points and allow in more food. Gaza's two million residents are facing dire humanitarian conditions as Israel has severely limited aid during its devastating war with Palestinian militant group Hamas. "We see some good signs of more trucks getting in," Ms Kallas said yesterday. "But of course we know that this is not enough, and we need to push more (so) that the implementation of what we have agreed also happens on the ground." At a meeting of EU and neighbouring countries in Brussels yesterday, Jordanian foreign minister Ayman Safadi said the situation in Gaza remained "catastrophic". 'No justification' Mr Saar, speaking at the same meeting, sounded confident his country would avoid further EU action. "I'm sure not any of them will be adopted by the EU member states," he said. "There's no justification whatsoever," he claimed. While the EU appears unable for now to take any further moves against Israel, just getting to this stage has been a considerable step. The bloc only agreed to review the cooperation deal after Israel relaunched its devastating war in Gaza after it collapsed the ceasefire in March. Until then deep divisions between countries backing Israel and those more favourable to the Palestinians had hamstrung any move. Israel's war was sparked by Hamas's 7 October 2023 attack on Israel, which led to 1,219 deaths, according to an AFP tally based on official figures. Of the 251 people taken hostage by militants that day, 49 are still held in Gaza, including 27 the Israeli military claims are dead. Gaza's health ministry said that at least 58,386 Palestinians, most of them civilians, have been killed by Israel. The UN considers the figures reliable.
