Ontario city facing 2nd legal challenge over arrest of women holding signs in meeting
The two legal threats stem from a June meeting in the city of Niagara Falls, where advocates from the Women of Ontario Say No were arrested by police for holding signs inside the council chambers.
The dramatic meeting followed the city's decision not to allow the advocacy group to make a presentation about changes to municipal conduct laws in Ontario, which city staff said could interfere with an ongoing legal case.
Banned from presenting, the group sat in council chambers with signs on their lap. They were told to remove them and ultimately arrested by police, who were called to the chamber by city officials.
Story continues below advertisement
Now, the Canadian Constitution Foundation is backing a lawsuit directed at Niagara Falls from one of the advocates to declare its bylaw banning any signs unconstitutional.
Get daily National news
Get the day's top news, political, economic, and current affairs headlines, delivered to your inbox once a day. Sign up for daily National newsletter Sign Up
By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy
A notice of application lodged by Lauren O'Connor, one of the advocates arrested in June, asks a court to rule Niagara Falls' decorum policy — which bans the display of all symbols and signs — unconstitutional.
The constitutional advocacy group has agreed to work with O'Connor and the Women of Ontario Say No to take legal action to force Niagara Falls to change its policy, after twice writing to the city and receiving no reply.
'We were deeply disturbed by this completely disproportionate and heavy-handed reaction to people peacefully exercising their right to freedom of expression,' Christine Van Geyn, the litigation director for the Canadian Constitution Foundation, told Global News.
She said the fact the signs sat in the women's laps while they caused no disruption shows the policy goes further than managing decorum.
'This involved people silently holding signs in their laps,' she said. 'There's already case law that says a total ban on signs inside council chambers is an unjustified violation of the right to freedom of expression.'
The tension around the June meeting, which led to arrests, came at least partly from the topic on which the group wanted to present.
Story continues below advertisement
The Women of Ontario Say No initially contacted Niagara Falls council, hoping to present about municipal conduct, specifically advocating for the province to create a rule where municipal councillors charged with a criminal offence should be put on paid leave.
In Niagara Falls, Coun. Mike Strange was charged with domestic assault at the end of May. He says he is innocent of the alleged crime, which has not been proven in court.
With Strange's charge before the courts, staff at Niagara Falls told the Women of Ontario Say No that they could not present on the topic because it could interfere with an ongoing legal matter.
A few weeks later, Strange himself was allowed to address the charge during a council meeting, where the women were again told they could not speak.
Separate from the constitutional challenge, the Women of Ontario Say No is pursuing its own legal action against Niagara Falls, looking to be allowed to make its presentation and demanding an apology.
The group told Global News it will be moving ahead with its own litigation.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Global News
19 minutes ago
- Global News
‘On behalf of the Islamic State': Security video shows terror attack on Surrey bus
WARNING: This story contains disturbing details. Discretion is advised. Global News has obtained video surveillance entered as evidence at a recent B.C. Supreme Court trial that ended with federal prosecutors securing a terrorism conviction in a horrifying attack on a Surrey transit bus two years ago. Abdul Aziz Kawam, 30, assaulted a man with a knife at a bus stop near Fraser Highway and 156th Street before boarding a bus and slashing another passenger in the throat on April 1, 2023. Both men survived. Security video shows Kawam walking onto the bus, followed a few seconds later by his victim, whose identity is protected by a publication ban. Both stood near the rear exit doors of the bus and rode together in silence for approximately three minutes, not speaking or interacting. Kawam then suddenly pulled out a large knife and slashed at the victim's neck three times, intending to kill him, according to the Admissions submitted at trial. As bus passengers are heard screaming in the video, the victim used his body to push Kawam out of the bus. 'He was bleeding out of his neck and he still managed to throw his attacker off the bus,' said Oren Bick, general counsel with the Public Prosecution Service of Canada. Blood on the floor of the bus after the attack. Provided by BC Supreme Court The knife nicked the victim's vocal chords and missed his main artery by a millimetre, his brother-in-law, whom we are not identifying as per the publication ban, told Global News days after the attack. Advertisement 'It scared him to his core, he thought he was going to die,' he said in April 2023. Some fifteen minutes earlier on April 1, Kawam had used the same knife to attack his first victim across the street. 'Mr. Kawam initially approached him and asked are you Muslim?,' Bick told Global News in an interview. When the man replied 'No', Kawam went back to the bus stop, prayed for approximately two minutes, and then returned, taking the large knife out of his jacket and attacking the victim, aiming a slashing motion at his neck without making contact. The victim, who pushed Kawam away and ran, described the blade as being approximately 10 inches, according to the Admissions. 'Kawam chased him for some distance, knife still in hand, but (the victim) was ultimately able to escape,' stated the Admissions, and was able to call 911 from a gas station nearby. 'This wasn't a who done it, this was a why did he do it,' said Bick. 'There was really no disputing what happened.' The knife used in the attack. BC Supreme Court Justice J. Miriam Gropper was tasked with determining whether the facts amounted to a terrorist purpose and Bick said the B.C. Supreme Court justice found the Crown proved its case on all three routes. On June 30, Kawam was convicted of attempted murder and assault with a weapon for the benefit of, at the direction of, and in association with a terrorist group: the Islamic State. 'From day one of this case, within a minute of committing the attack, he took credit for it and he said it's on behalf of the Islamic State,' Bick told Global News.
Global News
an hour ago
- Global News
Ontario man who raised a pack of wolf-dogs worries government will euthanize them
When a friend asked for help to build a fenced home for his dogs, Bryton Bongard made a deal: he would lend a hand in exchange for several puppies. That is how he ended up with what is now a pack of 16 strong, black and grey wolf-dog hybrids he calls his 'babies.' The wolf-dogs that live in his backyard enclosure have never harmed anyone, Bongard said, nor have any neighbours complained since he brought the animals to his rural property in Wahnapitae, Ont., about 50 kilometres north of Sudbury, four years ago. But the provincial government is set to seize them anyway, he said, because it is against the law to keep wildlife native to Ontario as pets or in captivity, with some exceptions for places like zoos and rehabilitation facilities. 'I've spent their entire lives with them … they're just my babies, and they are basically my family at this point,' Bongard said in a recent interview. Story continues below advertisement 'And it would be devastating for me to look out my window one day and not have them there.' Bongard is prepared to surrender the pack to the Ministry of Natural Resources, but he desperately wants an answer to a question he says the province has so far refused to address: What fate awaits the wolf-dogs after they are taken from him next month? While the government hasn't explicitly said the wolf-dogs will be euthanized, it has told Bongard that if a sanctuary for the animals can't be found, one last solution is that 'the dogs have to be disposed of,' he said. The ministry said it cannot provide specific details because the case is still active. 'In general, it's against the law to keep wild animals from Ontario as pets or to hold them in captivity,' it said in a statement, noting some exceptions under the Fish and Wildlife Conservation Act. 'The government is committed to ensuring wildlife in captivity are treated with care and respect,' it said. Bongard said the enclosure he built cost him around $35,000. The fence around nearly 8,000 square metres of land is roughly eight feet tall, with dig-proof aprons buried three feet underground to make sure the wolf-dogs don't escape. The animals also have a cabin equipped with air-conditioning and a heater. Story continues below advertisement A butcher by trade, Bongard said he brings lots of meat scraps from work. The cost of feeding the pack varies between $60 and $200 weekly, depending on the season. Get breaking National news For news impacting Canada and around the world, sign up for breaking news alerts delivered directly to you when they happen. Sign up for breaking National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy His pets are smarter, bigger and very shy compared to dogs, Bongard said. 'They do bark and they do howl. But it sounds more like a choppy husky howl than it does an actual wolf.' He said wolf-dogs can sometimes get destructive when they get bored, so he and his wife are playing and engaging with them every day. Bongard said his wife – who is 'mom' to the wolf-dogs – is even more heartbroken about the situation. More than 600 people have signed an online petition calling on the government to leave the wolf-dogs under the family's care. 'These animals have done nothing wrong — they are loved, well cared for and live with competent owners who provide them with excellent treatment, proper shelter and affection,' it reads. The petition drew controversy after it was posted on the Wahnapitae community Facebook page. While some residents voiced support for Bongard, others raised safety concerns. Bongard has downplayed those concerns, saying his dogs have never breached the fence. Even if they did escape, he said, they would steer clear of humans because they're afraid of strangers. Story continues below advertisement 'You have a better chance of getting struck by lightning or a vending machine falling on you than you do one of my dogs attacking you,' he said. Bongard said he's made several suggestions to the government in an effort to save the pack, including donating his current enclosure to a conservation group or buying more land to turn it into a conservation area. However, he said the ministry has refused to engage in meaningful conversation. Bongard's troubles stared about a year ago, after firefighters showed up at his property when he had a bonfire. 'They asked me about why I had wolves in my backyard,' he said. Local bylaw officers and ministry officials then got involved, visiting the site several times, including to do DNA tests on the animals, he said. The government also seized nine wolf-dogs from Bongard's friend who had given him the puppies in 2021. All were placed at a sanctuary in Alberta, but Bongard fears his own dogs won't be able to find a home. There are few sanctuaries for such animals in Canada and far fewer in Ontario – and they are often at capacity. Kerry Bowman, an assistant professor at the University of Toronto's school of environment, said while the exact number of wolf-dog hybrids is unknown, it could be extremely high in North America and some parts of Europe. Story continues below advertisement 'Ethically, I would argue that breeding them is very, very problematic,' he said, adding that the 'romanticization' of wolves in television and media has played a significant role in creating the problem. 'There's a demand for them. They're considered quite novel.' Wolf-dogs are very different from dogs and keeping them as pets is not good for the animals and is unsafe for humans, Bowman said. 'There's always a risk with wolf-dogs, even if they can be very gentle and very loving, that the behaviour could change,' he said, adding that such canines have harmed humans and pets in some cases. Releasing them into the wild isn't ideal because they lack wolves' full hunting and survival skills, Bowman said. The wolf-dogs can also 'weaken' the gene pool of natural wolves through interbreeding. Still, Bowman said the case of Bongard's pets 'needs to be handled far more carefully than it has been so far,' as Canada is among the countries that are often too quick to turn to animal euthanasia. There are many more sanctuaries for wolf-dogs in the United States and Bowman said while he doesn't know the rules around transferring animals across the border, the owner and the government should look into it. Bongard said he knows he broke the law and he accepts the consequences, but he is speaking out to save his animals – and to educate others about adopting 'cute' wolf-dog puppies. Story continues below advertisement 'When they reach maturity, which is around two years old, their personality flips,' he warned. 'Whereas one day it's cute and fluffy, and the next day it's eating your couch.'
Global News
an hour ago
- Global News
Voyeurism added to lengthy list of charges for Winnipeg man: police
See more sharing options Send this page to someone via email Share this item on Twitter Share this item via WhatsApp Share this item on Facebook A man who was previously charged with a number of serious, violent offences is now facing a voyeurism charge, Winnipeg police said. The suspect, 35, was arrested in July after an investigation by the domestic violence unit, and charged with sexual assault, assault, assault by choking, suffocating or strangling, and mischief under $5,000. Get daily National news Get the day's top news, political, economic, and current affairs headlines, delivered to your inbox once a day. Sign up for daily National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy Police said they searched the man's electronic devices and found intimate images of the same victim, taken without consent. He was re-arrested and taken into custody.
