Senate stands by decision to cut some arts groups' funding, give more to others
A controversial bill to support arts programs but that left more than a dozen without expected funds passed a near-final hurdle in the Senate on Monday.
On a 29-21 vote, the Senate approved House Bill 9, with a reminder from Sen. Ellie Boldman, D-Missoula, of the source of the funds for the programs.
'These projects are powered by coal,' said Boldman, who carried the bill in the Senate.
HB 9 appropriates $953,500 for cultural and aesthetic grants, including money for museums, at least one library, a history project, dance company and other arts groups.
Originally, around 75 groups asked for grants of $12,500 to $13,000 each, but that's not how legislators allocated the dollars.
Earlier this session, sponsor Rep. John Fitzpatrick, R-Anaconda, sparked criticism from people in the arts community after he suggested groups whose representatives didn't testify at the Capitol about their programs were 'slackers' and shouldn't get funding.
'They're running a business, and they can't even take five minutes for a 'give-me' check?' Fitzpatrick, chairperson of the subcommittee, said earlier.
Some arts leaders said they didn't know their appearance was mandatory.
Staff from the Montana Arts Council, which administers the program for the state, told lawmakers that they had mistakenly communicated to the groups that their attendance was not required, and attendance would not impact funding.
Nonetheless, legislators in the subcommittee unanimously agreed to cut funding from groups that didn't show up in person to testify and reduce funds for groups that submitted only written testimony.
Lawmakers subsequently made only slight adjustments to the bill, and on the Senate floor Tuesday, Boldman stressed that the funding allocations are up to legislators, who are not a rubber stamp.
'It's not a lot of money, but it's still public money, so we do take that seriously,' Boldman said.
She said if groups didn't appear either remotely or in person, then their applications weren't funded, and 17 fell into that category.
However, Boldman described the funded projects as 'awesome' and representing counties across Montana.
She described the process in response to a question from Sen. Jacinda Morigeau, D-Arlee, about how funding decisions were made.
Morigeau said some of her constituents had reached out to tell her the process wasn't clear this year.
'I just wanted to stand up on their behalf and say that it is a real detriment to some of these small rural, rural, rural programs, that they weren't funded,' Morigeau said.
However, Morigeau also said she would encourage them to apply again in two years.
Sen. Bob Phalen, R-Lindsay, wanted to know if some of the establishments that received funding were 'still displaying obscenities.'
Phalen said he wasn't referring to any specific project but to a bill he sponsored in 2023 to curb obscenity.
In response, Boldman said she wasn't aware of any establishments showcasing obscene material.
Earlier reporting by the Daily Montanan found the applicant for one group requesting money was Fitzpatrick's wife, and it was among those that received more money than originally proposed, and the only one to receive more than twice its original request.
Fitzpatrick, though, earlier told the Daily Montanan that he didn't have a conflict of interest to disclose, at least not any more than he could be seen to have one with any other number of groups in his district.
On the Senate floor, Boldman said she too is connected with some of the groups, such as a children's theater in which her son participates.
Sen. Christopher Pope, D-Bozeman, said he supported the bill, but he also didn't want to see arts organizations stricken from the bill in the future, having seen 'quality organizations being crossed off.'
However, Sen. Denley Loge, R-St. Regis, said the grants help small communities such as his, and he appreciates the idea that those who want support show up.
'It shows that they have to have a little skin in the game of time and involvement,' Loge said.
The bill earlier passed the House on a 58-39 vote, and it needs to pass another vote in the Senate.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Axios
an hour ago
- Axios
Scoop: ActBlue makes it easier for independents to tap donors
ActBlue, the online donation platform that makes it easy for Democratic candidates to hoover up small-dollar donations, is making it easier for independents to do the same. Why it matters: The new rules allow ActBlue to include independent candidates on a "case-by-case" basis. That change can give independents access to ActBlue earlier in the campaign cycle—and even if a declared Democrat is in the race. Republicans both fear and admire ActBlue for the ease with which it allows candidates to translate online enthusiasm into real-world dollars. President Trump also wants to investigate it for "illegal 'straw donor' and foreign contributions in American elections." A spokesperson for ActBlue confirmed the changes, which were made earlier in August. Zoom out: In the 2026 cycle, three independent candidates are seeking to challenge GOP senators in deep red states, but without a "D" next to their name. Two of them are former Democrats. The third, Dan Osborn, who has always been registered "unaffiliated," gave Sen. Deb Fischer (R-Neb.) a scare in 2024 by running as an independent. He's plotting a second run, this time against Sen. Pete Ricketts (R-Neb.). Earlier this summer Todd Achilles, a former Democratic Idaho state representative, declared himself an unaffiliated voter and announced a challenge to Sen. Jim Risch (R-Idaho). And in South Dakota, Brian Bengs, who ran for the Senate as a Democrat in 2022, is challenging Sen. Mike Rounds (R-S.D.), as an independent. Zoom in: ActBlue will now review independent or third-party candidates for inclusion on a "case-by-case basis, with the following criteria as major factors," according to its website. "Whether a Democratic candidate is in the race." "Whether the candidate has a Democratic Party endorsement." "Whether the candidate can demonstrate they align with Democratic policies and priorities." The old guidelines had stricter requirements. Independents could qualify by having a "proven record of caucusing with Democrats," which would have covered former Sen. Kyrsten Sinema (I-Ariz.). The old rules did allow for independent candidates to access the platform if no other Democrat were in the race and if they received an "official Democratic Party endorsement." Between the lines: The old rules would have prevented independents like Beng and Achilles from tapping the platform, given that there are already Democrats in both races. What they're saying: Republicans are convinced the change is a ruse to give incognito Democrats access to progressive donors without admitting they're Democrats.
Politico
an hour ago
- Politico
The other bills keeping lawmakers up at night
DRIVING THE DAY: Gavin Newsom and Democratic lawmakers today in Los Angeles rallied behind their campaign for a ballot measure asking voters to allow political gerrymandering to counter a Donald Trump-led GOP effort in Texas. Lawmakers are expected to approve a package containing the initiative next week. More on that below. NEGOTIATING TACTICS: Even as redistricting consumes Sacramento, state lawmakers have been working behind the scenes to push their other big bills through the final weeks of session. Lawmakers return Monday after using the four-week break to negotiate with their colleagues, lobbyists and Gov. Gavin Newsom's office. Legislation around ICE agents' use of masks, rideshare unionizing, antisemitism in schools, cap and trade and affordable housing funding remains in play. Here are the latest developments on legislation that saw a good deal of action during lawmakers' time away. Cap and trade: Before the redistricting push, extending the state's carbon auction system was poised to dominate the end of the session. And it's still one of the heaviest political lifts on the Legislature's docket. Business interests such as CalChamber that once opposed creating a system in which emitters can purchase and trade a capped number of carbon credits are now backing a 'clean' reauthorization — in which the system would continue functioning as it does now. But environmental groups are lobbying for changes including changing how auction proceeds are spent, eliminating free allowances that keep major polluters' costs down and putting emissions caps on individual facilities'. The slow pace of negotiations — the Assembly and Senate aren't yet on the same page with weeks to go — has fueled speculation that the program may not be renewed until next year. But talks are in for a serious jolt Wednesday, the date of the state's next carbon auction. With the cap-and-trade system still set to expire in 2030, emitters have been bidding less on carbon credits, leaving state lawmakers with less revenue to put toward climate and transit programs. The pain of dwindling revenue could speed discussions along as California faces the prospect of multi-billion dollar deficits in the coming years. Housing bucks: As we reported earlier this week, Assemblymember Buffy Wicks' $10 billion housing bond hasn't made much progress in the Senate after advancing from the Assembly. Wicks told Playbook she's having 'ongoing conversations with a lot of different folks' about the measure, which would go before voters in 2026. The assemblymember said she's still negotiating the final dollar figure and where the money will go, although there's 'widespread support' for asking voters to set aside most of the funding for multifamily housing, especially subsidized units for low-income Californians. Masking up: Proponents of state Sen. Scott Wiener's proposal to ban the use of identity-concealing masks by ICE and other law enforcement agencies are still trying to soften opposition from powerful state and local police and sheriffs' groups. Wiener said they've 'tried to constructively engage' on the legislation, although he's not sure whether he can get the law enforcement lobby to neutral 'while still producing a strong bill that puts a stop to extreme masking.' The senator needs the groups to temper their opposition if he wants to win over skeptical moderate Democrats and secure the two-thirds vote required to put the legislation in place right away. He can also try to pass the bill by a simple majority vote, though it wouldn't take effect until January. 'If we can get a two-thirds vote with a strong bill, that's absolutely the path we'll take,' Wiener said. 'If getting a two-thirds vote means we damage the bill, then I would rather have a strong bill take effect Jan. 1, than a weakened bill take effect immediately.' The bill is part of a larger slate of immigration legislation lawmakers hoped to take up quickly after the recess, although the redistricting package will likely cause some delays. Refineries: Newsom's proposal to increase California's crude extraction made the rounds during recess and is gaining traction with lawmakers scared of a spike in gas prices if they don't avoid more refinery closures. Even state Sen. Henry Stern, a climate hawk, has said more drilling in Kern County is necessary to stabilize in-state fuel supply. But environmentalists are bristling at Newsom's 'drill one new well, plug two old ones' proposal, which they say could open up drilling statewide. The oil and gas industry, meanwhile, isn't too fond of some of the other measures in the draft legislation, which would ban fracking and increase safety oversight related to offshore drilling. Wildfire fund: Newsom has also proposed reupping the state's wildfire liability fund, meant to prevent utilities from going bankrupt when their equipment sparks wildfires, with a $9 billion extension of a surcharge on ratepayer bills (and $9 billion from shareholders). There's a sense of urgency: Southern California Edison alone could drain the fund with its potential liability from the Eaton Fire, leaving nothing to cover any new utility-sparked wildfires that emerge during the upcoming months, which are typically the most dangerous for wildfires. The proposal is a bitter political pill, however, during a year supposed to deliver on affordability. Ride-hailing benefits: Labor leaders backing Wicks' and Assemblymember Marc Berman's bid to guarantee Uber and Lyft drivers can organize for better pay and benefits have yet to find common ground with the ride-hailing companies. SEIU and labor allies want to keep existing language that would require the companies to recognize bargaining groups formed by drivers (who are classified as 'independent contractors' thanks to Prop 22, an industry-funded ballot measure voters approved in 2020). Uber and Lyft are open to benefits packages for drivers, but they're fiercely opposed to full-fledged organizing rights, which they see as a clear attempt at circumventing Prop 22. The two sides met for talks over recess, three people familiar with the conversations told Playbook. An agreement that provides drivers with some benefits isn't out of the question yet, though there aren't any clear signs a deal is imminent. 'Until drivers have a union, they will not have a seat at the table,' SEIU Executive Director Tia Orr told Playbook. Antisemitism debate: Senate President Pro Tem Mike McGuire has gotten deeply involved in trying to save a proposal aiming to address antisemitism in schools. The bill hit an impasse heading into the recess, with legislative leadership agreeing to delay a measure that would penalize schools that create antisemitic learning environments and restrict what they teach about the Israel-Gaza conflict. The proposal faces fierce opposition from the California Teachers Association, school administrators and progressive groups that claim it is overly punitive, censors criticism of Israel and creates standards that do not exist for other active conflicts. But it is the Legislative Jewish Caucus' only priority bill this year, and McGuire pledged to pass it before the end of session. Negotiations are continuing between the teachers' union, legislative ethnic caucuses and Jewish advocates as proponents try to address broad concerns that include complaint procedures and how antisemitism is defined. Dueling charter bills: Lawmakers backing competing measures aimed at increasing oversight of non-traditional charter schools are continuing to hash out a compromise, meeting regularly over the recess. Assembly Education Chair Al Muratsuchi's union-backed AB 84 seeks sweeping regulations on non-classroom charters, but was pared down before the break as charter schools pushed state Sen. Angelique Ashby's SB 414, which would implement fewer restrictions. Charter school advocates have been lobbying lawmakers over recess to chip away at Muratsuchi's broad proposal, specifically around an effort to require credentialed employees to approve funding for enrichment activities. The bill currently calls for increased auditing and financial reporting requirements and would create a new Office of the Education Inspector General. Ashby said in a committee hearing that she would reject a final measure that is 'so punitive that all charter schools take a haircut.' — with help from Eric He, Emily Schultheis, Tyler Katzenberger, Blake Jones, Camille von Kaenel and Alex Nieves IT'S THURSDAY AFTERNOON. This is California Playbook PM, a POLITICO newsletter that serves as an afternoon temperature check on California politics and a look at what our policy reporters are watching. Got tips or suggestions? Shoot an email to lholden@ WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW TODAY OFF AND RUNNING: California's leading politicians and its most prominent labor unions put on a show of unity today as they gathered to launch a campaign for a new House map, our Jeremy B. White and Emily Schultheis report. 'We can't stand back and watch this democracy disappear, district by district, all across this country,' Newsom said. 'We need to stand up. Not just California: Other states need to stand up.' The themes of that likely special election came into focus today: Rally attendees spoke at a podium emblazoned with an 'Election Rigging Response Act' sign and held 'defend democracy' placards. Details also emerged about the campaign's backers. A newly unveiled campaign website lists House Democrats' principal super PAC and Democratic megadonor Bill Bloomfield as initial funders. But victory at the ballot box is far from assured. Newsom's pollster has circulated an internal survey showing the measure starting with only a narrow majority, and polling from POLITICO-Citrin Center-Possibility Lab found voters overwhelmingly support keeping the state's independent redistricting commission. (The nascent ballot measure would leave the commission in place but effectively override its work by creating new maps to boost Democrats through 2030.) CA V. TRUMP OF ALL PLACES: Border Patrol agents turned up this morning outside the downtown Los Angeles venue where Newsom and other Democrats were rallying behind the redistricting campaign and denouncing Trump. 'Right outside at this exact moment are dozens and dozens of ICE agents … people are scared,' Newsom said during the event. 'People are fearful.' A video taken by witnesses shows bystanders yelling at masked agents in military fatigues standing inside a white unmarked van. Newsom's press office shared an X post with a video showing dozens of Border Patrol agents walking around on the street alongside Sector Cmdr. Gregory Bovino, who has taken a leading role in the Los Angeles immigration crackdown. 'BORDER PATROL HAS SHOWED UP AT OUR BIG BEAUTIFUL PRESS CONFERENCE! WE WILL NOT BE INTIMIDATED!' the post said, continuing Newsom's mocking use of Trump's trademark all-caps missives. Bovino told NBC LA that agents were conducting roving patrols and that they had taken one person into custody. The incident drew a quick response from Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass, who showed up to the scene and answered questions from reporters. 'There's no way this was a coincidence,' she said. 'This was widely publicized that the governor and many of our other elected officials were having a press conference here to talk about redistricting, and they decided they were going to come and thumb their nose in front of the governor's face.' — with help from Melanie and Jeremy WHAT WE'RE READING TODAY — Some local officials and advocates are concerned that Trump, who has appointed himself head of an Olympics task force, will take action against homeless people when Los Angeles hosts the event in 2028. (Los Angeles Times) — The Trump administration's tariff on Indian imports has led to increased prices at restaurants and grocery stores in the Bay Area. (San Francisco Chronicle) AROUND THE STATE — The Vista City Council voted to spend $3.5 million to increase annual maintenance of Wave Waterpark through 2035. (San Diego Union-Tribune) — Increased surveillance in the majority Latino neighborhood of Oak View in Huntington Beach has left residents with mixed feelings behind the city's motives. (LAist) — Some Palo Alto residents are pushing back on a plan to replace a former restaurant with an apartment building. (The Mercury News) — compiled by Juliann Ventura
CBS News
3 hours ago
- CBS News
DFL state Sen. Tou Xiong arrested on suspicion of drunken driving for second time
A Minnesota state senator says police arrested him early Thursday morning on suspicion of driving while intoxicated. Sen. Tou Xiong, DFL - Maplewood, said in a statement he had been driving home after attending a family gathering when he was pulled over near his residence. "I take full responsibility for my actions, and sincerely apologize to my constituents and the people I've let down," Xiong said. "I want to thank law enforcement for doing their job to keep the roads safe. Today, I have begun the work of talking to my family and to my Senate colleagues about the situation." Ramsey County Jail records show Xiong, 35, was booked shortly before 4 a.m. and released nearly three hours later. Xiong has yet to be formally charged with any crime. This is Xiong's second DWI arrest. In 2022, he pleaded guilty to driving under the influence. Court documents say he had a blood alcohol content of .11 when he was pulled over in Blaine while returning from a community gathering. He was sentenced to one year of probation. Xiong was elected to the Minnesota Senate in 2023. Previously, he was a state representative from 2019 to 2022 for District 53A. He is part of the Minnesota Housing Finance Agency and Minnesota Council on Asian Pacific Minnesotans.
