Scottish Greens call to abolish monarchy ahead of Edinburgh protest
Speakers at the event include National columnist Lesley Riddoch, poet George Gunn, SNP MSP Emma Roddick, Scottish Greens MSP Maggie Chapman and Greens co-leader Patrick Harvie.
Anti-monarchy campaigners protest ceremony for King and Queen on Edinburgh's Royal Mile, July 2024 (Image: Republic) Ahead of the event, Harvie said it was becoming 'increasingly unjustifiable' to maintain the monarchy in Scotland, adding that the 'outdated' institution was 'at odds' with the concerns of ordinary people.
Harvie said that while people were experiencing widespread inequality through the cost of living crisis and the UK Government's cuts to disability benefits and the Winter Fuel Payment, the royal family has 'never had it so good'.
READ MORE: Kate Forbes: This is why I will vote against assisted dying in Scotland
The Scottish Greens co-leader added that Scotland has the potential to be an 'modern independent democratic republic', and that the powers of independence would help to tackle such inequality in society.
(Image: PA) Commenting, Harvie (above) said: 'There is no place in modern Scotland for the monarchy.
'Our society is experiencing widespread inequality, with the cost of living crisis continuing to push many to the brink. However, it seems the royal family has never had it so good.
'The taxpayer-funded sovereign grant rises year on year. They don't pay capital gains tax, they don't pay corporation tax and they're exempt from stamp duty. They have received millions of pounds of income in rent from the NHS, schools and the armed forces for operating on the vast swathes of land that they own.
'It is completely at odds with the struggles faced by some of our most vulnerable communities. We should not have a system that only benefits the super-rich, while leaving the rest of us to pick up the bill.
READ MORE: David Lammy 'must explain if he misled us on Israel arms exports', MPs say
'The monarchy is a profoundly outdated and undemocratic institution. We must have a serious conversation about the country we see ourselves as.
'The idea that we should show this preference for one unaccountable family, who take far more from society than they give, is the exact opposite image of Scotland I would like to see. I believe we can do so much better for the people living in our country.
'Scotland has the potential to be a modern independent democratic republic. It can be a greener and fairer country that redistributes the wealth hoarded by monarchy and the rest of the super-rich, and uses it to the benefit of the many people who are struggling.
'Ultimately, it should be the people of Scotland who are sovereign and I will continue to make the case that with the powers of independence we can tackle the profound inequality that is highlighted by the lifestyle that the royals enjoy.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Times
14 hours ago
- Times
Heritage organisations warn PM of crippling cost of membership law
Some of Britain's leading cultural institutions including the National Trust have warned the prime minister that they face being 'crippled' by new consumer rights rules. The legislation could be catastrophic for the business models of charities and museums because it contains a 'loophole' allowing abuse of their financially important membership schemes. Charity membership schemes will be subject to a 'two-week cooling off period', allowing people to cancel them and get a refund, under the provisions of the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act (DMCCA). The heads of the National Trust, Tate, Historic Royal Palaces and other organisations wrote to Sir Keir Starmer on July 31, saying charities must be treated differently to commercial organisations. They warned Starmer in a letter leaked to The Times that the legislation puts in jeopardy the entire relationship 'between government and civil society'. When the law is enacted next year, somebody could buy an annual Tate membership on a Saturday morning for £120, which would automatically grant them and a guest free access to paid-for exhibitions even if they were sold out. That Saturday they could visit the Emily Kam Kngwarray, Do Ho Suh and Leigh Bowery exhibitions at Tate Modern — which would cost non-members £60 in total — and visit the Edward Burra show down the river at Tate Britain, costing £18, before resigning their membership the following day. They would then be refunded the entirety of their £120, having saved themselves £78 in entry fees. They could also have used a 10 per cent discount at Tate's shops and had access to its members' rooms. A National Trust annual family membership costs £168.60 and the family members could, for example, visit Waddesdon Manor and Cliveden, an hour's drive away, before resigning their membership and recouping their fee. A family of two adults and two children who were not members would normally pay £105 for these two visits. In the letter to the prime minister the leaders of the organisations said the DMCCA would create significant legal and administrative risks. 'Not only has it put at risk our ability to claim gift aid on memberships, but it creates onerous new burdens,' the signatories, led by Hilary McGrady, the National Trust's director-general, wrote. 'The proposed cooling-off period would create a loophole that could allow people to join charities as members and enjoy benefits, such as free entry to sites, for a two-week period before claiming substantial refunds for the rest of the year. 'This threatens to cripple the very future value of membership itself as a functional model of income generation for charities with visitor models — currently worth hundreds of millions [of pounds] to charities across the UK every year,' the letter, also signed by the heads of the Victoria & Albert Museum, the Royal Horticultural Society, the Royal British Legion and the Wildlife Trusts, said. The leaking of the letter indicates a growing frustration at the Labour government from within the arts and heritage sector. One insider said they had been fruitlessly battling the government for months to try to secure an exemption for charities, adding that implementation of the provisions would be 'catastrophic'. Membership schemes have become hugely important for museums and galleries during the past 15 years as state funding has decreased dramatically and corporate sponsors have been deterred by activist campaigns against private sponsors such as fossil fuel companies. • Can Britain's museums remain free for much longer? The DMCCA, introduced by the previous Conservative government and being enacted by Labour, is intended to provide protections for consumers signing up to, for example, digital media subscriptions. In September last year the government minister Justin Madders confirmed that Labour would be proceeding with the legislation, which received royal assent under the Conservatives. The provisions affecting charity memberships are intended to target so-called 'subscription traps' where people are 'misled' into signing up for a free, or reduced-price trial and then end up stuck with a costly subscription, the government said previously. Madders said it would 'protect small businesses, save consumers money, boost innovation and drive growth'. The Department for Business and Trade said of the act last November: 'Subscriptions can be for anything from magazines to beauty boxes, with many subscriptions having complicated or inconvenient cancellation processes such as phone lines with long waits and restrictive opening hours that can leave consumers feeling trapped.' • Why can't we fund the National Gallery without help from China? The letter to Starmer, also signed by the Woodland Trust and Royal Society for the Protection of Birds, states that, as charities, their work is 'in support of the wider public good' and 'not a private service that can only be purchased for the individual enjoyment of customers'. It added: 'The public benefit we deliver as a result of the relationship between us as charities and our members has long been reflected in law and by HMRC, differentiating between charitable memberships and subscriptions for commercial services such as gym memberships, and acknowledging their status as charitable donations, not subscriptions to goods or services.' The Department for Business and Trade has been contacted for comment.
The Guardian
15 hours ago
- The Guardian
Israeli government official charged with soliciting 15-year-old girl in Las Vegas
An Israeli government official charged with soliciting a minor believed he was meeting a 15-year-old girl for 'sexual contact', according to police – and brought a condom to the planned rendezvous in Las Vegas. Tom Artiom Alexandrovich, a division head at the Israel National Cyber Directorate, was arrested in a police sting operation aimed at online users seeking to sexually prey on children. The Las Vegas outlet 8NewsNow reported that Alexandrovich chatted with an officer posing as a teenager online before being arrested. 'The sexual contact included bringing a condom and taking the decoy to 'Cirque du Soleil',' which stages elaborate shows along the Las Vegas Strip, said police documents seen by 8NewsNow. Details of the arrest came as the state department denied the US government played any role in releasing the Israeli official – after Alexanderovich was able to return to Israel once he had bonded out of jail in connection with the felony charge. A swarm of commentary online, propelled in part by Republican congresswoman Marjorie Taylor Greene, speculated that Alexanderovich had been shielded by the government at a time when the Trump administration has been struggling to contain criticism over unfulfilled promises to release all files related to the prosecution of the late, disgraced financier and convicted sex offender Jeffrey Epstein. 'The Department of State is aware that Tom Artiom Alexandrovich, an Israeli citizen, was arrested in Las Vegas and given a court date for charges related to soliciting sex electronically from a minor,' the state department wrote on X. 'He did not claim diplomatic immunity and was released by a state judge pending a court date. Any claims that the US government intervened are false.' That statement came after Greene, who has recently broken with the White House over Israel's military campaign in Gaza, questioned Alexandrovich's case on Monday, claiming that the government had 'release[d] a child sex predator from Israel who works directly under the prime minister of Israel', Benjamin Netanyahu. Abramovich was arrested as he arrived at an agreed-upon location for the meet-up, 8NewsNow reported. He told police he believed he was chatting with an 18-year-old. 'Alexandrovich stated he felt the girl 'pushed' him to talk about bringing a condom, yet could not remember how many times the girl 'pushed' him,' police documents seen by 8NewsNow said. 'Alexandrovich stated he was embarrassed for being arrested.' Court records reviewed by Reuters show a $10,000 bond was posted in Alexandrovich's case at the Henderson detention center, south-east of Las Vegas, on 7 August. The records indicate he is due back in court on 27 August. A post on Israel's government website from November describes Alexandrovich as the 'head of the Technological Defense Division at the INCD [Israel National Cyber Directorate]'. A screenshot on Alexanderovich's LinkedIn page, first reported by Mediaite, describes him as the same. A post on Alexandrovich's page alluded to his having been in Las Vegas earlier in August for the Black Hat Briefings, a yearly meeting of cybersecurity professionals. 'Two things you can't escape at Black Hat 2025: the relentless buzz of generative [artificial intelligence] and the sound of Hebrew … in every corridor,' Alexandrovich wrote in part in an accompanying post. Invoking an abbreviation for large language models and referring to one of Israel's largest cities, the post continued: 'The key takeaway? The future of cybersecurity is being written in code, and it seems a significant part of it is being authored in #TelAviv and powered by LLMs. An exciting time to be in the field!' That LinkedIn page under Alexandrovich's name has since been deleted. Sign up to Headlines US Get the most important US headlines and highlights emailed direct to you every morning after newsletter promotion Israeli media reported in recent days that Alexanderovich had been released and was back in Israel, with some quoting the Netanyahu's office as denying that Alexandrovich was arrested, saying only that a 'state employee' was 'questioned by American authorities during his stay' and he had 'returned to Israel as scheduled'. The Israeli news site Ynet reported that Alexandrovich was on leave from the Cyber Directorate by 'mutual decision'. Alexanderovich was among eight men in an operation led by Nevada's internet crime against children taskforce. All of the suspects believed they were meeting minors when undercover officers instead confronted and arrested them, police said. The arrested men were all brought to jail after being detained, said the statement from the Las Vegas metropolitan police department, which participated in the operation alongside local, state and federal law enforcement officials. Among the other suspects was Las Vegas Redemption church pastor Neal Harrison Creecy, 46, 8NewsNow reported. Creecy reportedly believed he would meet a 14-year-old boy when he was arrested, and he resigned after posting a $10,000 bond for his release from jail. Under Nevada law, luring a child with a computer for a sex act can carry between one to 10 years in prison. Ramon Antonio Vargas and Reuters contributed reporting
The Guardian
15 hours ago
- The Guardian
PGA Tour ends decade-long absence from Trump-owned courses with Doral return in 2026
The PGA Tour will return to Donald Trump's Blue Monster course in Miami next spring, ending a decade-long absence from Trump-owned venues. The Miami Championship, a $20m Signature Event scheduled for the first weekend in May 2026, will mark the 56th time the Tour has played at Trump National Doral but the first since 2016, the year Trump won his first US presidential election. That year, the WGC-Cadillac Championship was pulled from the resort and relocated to Mexico City after Cadillac ended its sponsorship. At the time, then-commissioner Tim Finchem stressed that the decision was 'fundamentally a sponsorship issue' and not political, despite Trump's incendiary remarks on immigration and his insistence the Tour was punishing him for his first US presidential run. 'We value dollars for our players,' Finchem said in 2016. 'We were not able to secure sponsorship for Doral. From a golf standpoint, we have no issues with Donald Trump. From a political standpoint, we are neutral.' Trump, who had spent $250m redeveloping the Doral property, publicly lashed out at the Tour and quipped that he hoped officials had 'kidnapping insurance' for the event's new Mexican host city. For the next decade, the Blue Monster fell off the PGA calendar and instead became a regular site for the upstart LIV Golf series, serving as a centerpiece in the Saudi-backed league's schedule. Now the course returns at a moment of transition for the PGA Tour. The Miami Championship expands the roster of Signature Events to nine and sits at the heart of a crowded spring. Beginning with the Masters in April, players will face four Signature Events and two majors in a seven-week stretch, with only the Zurich Classic in New Orleans breaking the run. Next season's PGA TOUR schedule is here!2026, we're ready for you 💪 'We're excited to showcase the game's greatest players competing at golf's most iconic venues,' said Brian Rolapp, the Tour's new chief executive. 'Inspired by our players and fans, we're accelerating the Tour's evolution and ushering in a new era of innovation on and off the course.' The Miami Championship is expected to secure a title sponsor before its debut. Its addition shifts the Mexico Open into the FedExCup Fall and removes the Barracuda Championship in California, which had been played opposite the British Open. Doral has been synonymous with PGA Tour golf since 1962, when it launched as the Doral Open. It became a World Golf Championship site in 2007 but struggled to sustain sponsorship after Trump's 2012 purchase of the property. The 2016 split was, in Finchem's words, pragmatic rather than political, though it coincided with Trump's polarizing rise.
