Jailed whistleblower David McBride loses appeal against severity of sentence
McBride pleaded guilty to theft and distributing the documents to three journalists, and was sentenced last year to five years and eight months jail, with a non-parole period of two years and three months.
The appeal had a two-pronged approach, targeting the sentence and a ruling by the judge that he could not rely on an argument that it was his duty to reveal the information in his defence.
McBride wanted to argue the duty came from the oath he swore to the Queen when he joined the military.
When the court refused to allow the argument, McBride said he had been stripped of his defence and his only option was to plead guilty.
Around 2013, McBride began copying material, putting it on his own computer, printing and taking it home in his backpack.
He ended up removing 235 documents, 207 of which held secret classifications.
The documents were stored in plastic bins in his cupboard.
He offered the material to three journalists, Chris Masters, Andrew Clarke and the ABC's Dan Oaks.
During the court hearings the details emerged.
Chris Masters and Andrew Clarke did nothing with the material. Mr Clarke told McBride in 2015 he had destroyed the documents.
Only the ABC used the material, to produce the Afghan files, which detailed allegations of unlawful killings by Australian soldiers.
But the story the ABC told was totally different to the one McBride wanted told.
He had hoped that by giving the material to the journalists he would expose his own concerns that there was too much scrutiny of soldiers.
Knowing charges were inevitable, McBride hung out in Spain for a while, before returning to Australia for an event at his daughter's school in 2018.
When he tried to leave the country again, he was arrested at Sydney Airport.
He faced the ACT Magistrates Court charged with theft and sharing the material in March 2019.
But he had already set off a chain of events with wide-ranging consequences, as the ABC was raided by Australian Federal Police officers looking for material.
And then came the pandemic.
It was years before the case reached the trial stage in 2024, with McBride unable to meet his lawyers face-to-face because of travel restrictions.
In the end the trial never really started, after ACT Supreme Court Justice David Mossop refused to allow what McBride said was his key defence: that he had a duty to release the information.
His lawyers lodged a last ditch appeal, but lost that too, and he pleaded guilty.
That decision was one of the issues raised in today's appeal.
McBride's lawyers said their proposed appeal to the High Court was necessary because of the ramifications McBride's case has for other Australians.
"We believe that only the High Court can properly grapple with the immense public interest and constitutional issues at the heart of this case," his lawyers said in a statement.
They also called for the federal government to pardon McBride.
"It is now time for the attorney-general to show leadership. To show Australians that this Labor government will no longer jail whistleblowers."
Through his lawyers, McBride said Australians would be outraged by the Court of Appeal decision.
"It is my own conscience and the people of Australia that I answer to. I have kept my oath to the Australian people," he said in the statement.
McBride has been in Canberra's jail since October last year.
His appeal was heard in March.
For each and every appearance McBride has been buoyed by a loyal group of supporters who gathered again today outside the ACT courts building.
McBride was in court in person for the ruling which threw out his appeal, with his supporters, including his wife, in the public gallery.
He has now been returned to Canberra's jail and his lawyers say they will prepare for a High Court challenge.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News.com.au
12 minutes ago
- News.com.au
NRL star questioned by police, stopped at airport
South Sydney star Brandon Smith has been stopped by Queensland police after arriving in the Gold Coast. As first reported by Code Sports, the 29-year-old was pulled aside by the police after players arrived at Coolangatta on Saturday afternoon ahead of the side's clash with the Titans on Sunday. 'Queensland Police had cause to speak to a 29-year-old male at Coolangatta Airport,' a statement from the authorities said. 'The male was later released without charge. Police have no further information to provide.' Smith is reportedly expected to play in the fixture against the Titans. Smith was expected to be presented with his jersey by Kiwi great Issac Luke ahead of his 150th NRL appearance. The Rabbitohs have made the NRL Integrity Unit aware of the incident. The reason why Smith was questioned is unclear at this stage. There is no suggestion of any wrongdoing. It has been a tumultuous period for Smith with a messy contract saga resulting in him making a mid-season move to South Sydney after a disastrous period with the Roosters.
SBS Australia
12 minutes ago
- SBS Australia
Midday News Bulletin 10 August 2025
Listen to Australian and world news, and follow trending topics with SBS News Podcasts . TRANSCRIPT Anthony Albanese and Christopher Luxon pledge cooperation on trade, defence and Gaza at annual talks The UN meeting to discuss Israel's plan to take over Gaza City Gold Coast defeat Carlton to win by 19 points New Zealand Prime Minister Christopher Luxon says his nation had no greater friend than Australia. Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese is in Queenstown for the annual leaders' meeting where the pair discussed defence, the war in Gaza and trade deals. The leaders expressed their concern at the recent turbulence in global trade, vowing to co-operate to continue global trade and investment openness. They also agreed to work together to reform the World Trade Organisation as the foundation and enforcer of global trade rules. Mr Albanese's visit continues today. Australia has joined a number of other countries to condemn Israel's plan to takeover Gaza City. The United Nations Security Council is meeting in New York to discuss Israel's plan. In a statement on Saturday Foreign Minister Penny Wong joined Germany, Italy, New Zealand and the United Kingdom to "strongly reject" Israel's decision to launch a large-scale military operation in Gaza City. Home Affairs Minister Tony Burke told SKY News that the people of Gaza should not be punished for the actions of Hamas. "We're joining with other nations and just saying, this must not happen. We are watching a humanitarian catastrophe and we have seen for a long time people being killed and the death toll involving massive numbers of people who have nothing to do with Hamas. " Israel denies intentionally targeting civilians. Israel has bombarded Gaza since Hamas' October 7 attack in 2023, in which more than 1,200 people, including an estimated 30 children, were killed and over 250 hostages taken, according to the Israeli government. More than 60,430 people have been killed in Gaza since the 7th of October 2023, according to the health ministry in Gaza. The October 7 attack was a significant escalation in the long-standing conflict between Israel and Hamas. British foreign minister David Lammy and United States Vice President JD Vance have met Ukrainian and European allies in Britain to discuss President Donald Trump's push for peace in Ukraine. President Trump says the parties, including President Zelenskyy, were close to a deal after three and a half years of conflict. Mr Zelenskyy has rejected US suggestions that a peace deal with Russia could involve land swaps, vowing not to cede territory. His remarks come as Washington and Moscow prepare for talks, with U-S President Donald Trump set to meet Russian President Vladimir Putin in Alaska on the 15th of August. Nigel Gould-Davies, Senior Fellow for Russia and Eurasia at the International Institute for Strategic Studies, says it's difficult to predict what might happen next. "There've been so many extraordinary twists and turns in this so far. All that's clear at this point is that Putin has already achieved the major victory of securing a summit meeting with the United States on American soil. And that's something that he will be working very hard to make the maximum use of in the coming week. One further question is, where is Europe in all of this? Europe must be alarmed and, in fact, appalled by this latest turn of events." Kyiv and its European allies have dismissed any plan requiring Ukraine to give up land, warning it would reward and embolden Russian aggression. Homelessness Australia says there's been a 20 per cent jump in women and girls accessing services in the past three years, with almost half fleeing abuse. A new initiative called the Little Greenhouses Project is aiming to help by building low-cost, energy-efficient homes for disadvantaged women, starting with eight in regional New South Wales by Christmas. Global Sisters is behind the initiative. Advocates welcome the move, but warn broader investment in housing is needed. Kate Colvin is CEO of Homelessness Australia. "What we need is a lot more investment in social housing, but we also need investment in emergency housing, so when women have nowhere to go that night, there's somewhere safe for them to be." The project is being trialed in New South Wales with the aim for it to become a nationwide initiative. In the AFL, Gold Coast have survived a roaring final-quarter surge from Carlton to win by 19 points, putting them closer to securing a maiden finals appearance. Leading by 45 points at three-quarter time, the Suns conceded the first five goals of the final term as the Blues threatened to pull off the second miracle at Marvel Stadium in three weeks. But with finals on the line, Gold Coast managed to steady, as Carlton also missed some gettable chances, to prevail in the game. Ben King was the star for the Suns with six goals, including the sealer with four minutes remaining. Carlton closed to within 13 points and had all the momentum, but the full-forward calmly put through the Suns' first goal of the term from a tricky spot in the pocket. Sun's Midfielder Touk Miller says it was a tough game. "Those games are going to happen you always look at what you can improve and you would rather win than go through a review and what can you learn from that. We knew they were going to come eventually. They are a really contested ball and stoppage team and they got on top of us in the last quarter. I think that was the difference."
ABC News
12 minutes ago
- ABC News
Wagin Shire considers two-cat limit per household to deal with strays
The West Australian town of Wagin has a cat problem. Like many other towns and cities, it is dealing with a flood of feral and stray felines each year. The Wheatbelt town has transferred more than 300 cats in three years to a rescue centre in Perth, about 230 kilometres away, with 80 of those this year alone. The council now wants to limit the number of cats residents can own to two in a bid to reduce cat numbers. Shire President Phillip Blight said rangers were spending more time than they should managing the problem. "Most of them are not microchipped so you can't easily find the owners of these cats, so a lot of them then don't get claimed and they end up being moved on to Cat Haven." Michelle Muller has been running the Wagin Cat Rescue with her husband Larry Stanbridge, a local ranger, for about four years and believes owners need to take more responsibility. "The lack of understanding that cats need to be sterilised, they need to be microchipped, they need to be registered to the shire," she said. "Not having your cat sterilised is the biggest issue, because they just continue to breed and we had one household alone had over 40 cats that got out." Support for containment laws among local governments in the state is strong, with at least 80 in favour of permanent containment for pet cats, according to a WA Feral Cat Working Group survey released last month. But attempts to introduce stricter local laws have fallen foul of state parliament, which has oversight of the regulation local governments attempt to introduce. Of the 26 councils that have tried to introduce containment laws under the WA Cat Act, only the shires of Northam, Narrogin and Christmas Island have been successful. The Shire of Pingelly's cat containment policy, known as the Save the Numbats Local Law, is waiting to go before the recently reformed joint standing committee after its first attempt was knocked back last year. The City of Bayswater's cat containment laws have been recommended for disallowance by the committee and are listed for the Legislative Council in September. The Wagin Shire has chosen not to go down that path, at least for now. "If we were to expand that out further, as many other shires have tried to do, they run up against some state government resistance to changes to cat local laws," Mr Blight said. "We may well go further and look at the containment part of it down the track; it will largely be dependent on if those other councils succeed or if they have not." Veterinarian Kate Clayton, who owns clinics in the nearby towns of Kojonup and Katanning, said feral cats were the real problem. "The feline AIDS virus and the feline leukaemia virus are endemic in the feral population, and those retroviruses do not have any cure and they can be life-threatening," she said. "Owned cats, if they're outside and they come in contact with a feral cat that is infected, they can become infected themselves." Further south, 145 feral cats have been culled in the past five years as part of a fauna recovery project in an area surrounding the Fitzgerald River and Stirling Range national parks. The culling of 3,500 foxes, feral cats and rabbits through baiting, trapping and shooting across 50,000 hectares involved 2,000 volunteers, 20 private landowners, a conservation group and a state agency. Project officer Jeff Pinder said the collaborative approach was needed, especially when dealing with varying landscapes. "As much as we could remove a number, we were being reinvaded by additional animals from outside, and that emphasises the importance of creating a buffer around key reserves so that you can try and add that extra layer of protection," he said. Camera footage in the final year of the project showing a chuditch, a threatened species also known as a western quoll, was positive news for the project. "We can't hang our hat on that and say, 'Yes, we've created a new population', but it does show a level of survivorship," Mr Pinder said. "There was another sighting as well in Corackerup Nature Reserve, so there's a suggestion that animal may be coming back into our landscape. "It's a sort of watch this space and hopefully through our management efforts we continue to see chuditch in our reserves."
