Carter Holt Harvey proposes 5-7% timber price rises in October but biggest builder hits back
He said the rise was entirely justifiable due to input cost increases.
He cited labour costs, but other factors too.
Porteous was talking to Herald NOW host Ryan Bridge today about house construction costs and new home prices.
'Despite this price stability, we're pushing back on some of the supply chains. We do have some comfortable duopolies in supply that are wanting to put prices up and, I'll be honest, one of those is Carter Holt Harvey with timber, and we're saying 'no'.
'The consumer can't sustain that at this moment. We don't see that your input costs have increased. You need to hold your prices for the good of New Zealanders and our industry at the time.'
Carter Holt Harvey proposes timber price rises.
Asked what response came from Carter Holt Harvey, Porteous said his business was awaiting that.
'It's a live debate and negotiation, but I think all builders need to have the confidence to be able to challenge any suppliers. What are these input costs that have gone up?'
Porteous cited the housing downturn as having an effect on businesses like his.
'You'll never build cheaper than you will today,' he said, referring to the house sales downturn and land prices not rising at the levels they had been.
'The cost of building a home isn't our supply chain or manufacturers. It's more bureaucracy, red tape, councils, and honestly, MBIE [Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment] at times over-reaching with the building code.'
Staff at the national chain of Carter's retail outlets are telling builders of the planned price rises. The directive has come from the head office.
Rotorua-headquartered Red Stag Timber is the other dominant timber supplier in New Zealand.
Denver Simpson, Carter Holt Harvey's general counsel and company secretary, said he had no comment on the timber price rises.
Rotorua-headquartered Red Stag Timber is the other dominant force in the sector in New Zealand.
Red Stag says it employs about 300 staff and has an annual revenue of more than $220 million.
It was established in 2003 to operate the Waipā Mill, in Waikato, which was founded by the Government in 1939 and then privatised in 1996.
Carter Holt Harvey is privately owned by Rank Group, owned by one of the country's wealthiest men, Graeme Hart.
Graeme Hart's Rank owns Carter Holt Harvey. Photo / Getty Images
CoreLogic's Cordell Construction Cost Index out this month showed a growth rate of 0.6% for the three months to June, for an annual rate of 2.7%, the strongest since the third quarter of 2023.
At the peak of the pandemic, building costs surged 10.4% and the long-term average was 4.2%.
Spare capacity had since increased in the sector as the number of houses being built fell sharply from more than 50,000 to around 33,000 annually.
The report showed varying price moves among key materials, with weatherboard 6% higher but decking timber and ceiling insulation 1% cheaper.
The index is based on the cost of building a standard single-storey, three-bedroom house with two bathrooms, in brick and tile.
Anne Gibson has been the Herald's property editor for 25 years, written books and covered property extensively here and overseas.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NZ Herald
19 minutes ago
- NZ Herald
Domestic tourism surges in Rotorua as Aucklanders return
The mayor praised the 'Robe Trip' marketing campaign, which was aimed at highlighting Rotorua's standing as a destination for luxury and relaxation. The campaign ran over six weeks in February and March across multiple media, including a television ad featuring Tapsell. According to figures the council released to the Taxpayers' Union in March, the ad cost just under $94,000 to produce and broadcast. RotoruaNZ chief executive Andrew Wilson said they were very pleased with the results of the Robe Trip campaign. About three-quarters (73%) of Aucklanders surveyed would consider Rotorua for a holiday or breakaway after the campaign, up from 34% pre-campaign. 'This was a bold and deliberate move to reposition Rotorua in the minds of New Zealanders – especially young and mid-life Auckland couples – as a destination for luxury, relaxation and indulgence.' Over the course of the campaign, there was a 9.4% increase in visitor spend by Aucklanders in the city and a 5% year-on-year rise on hotel occupancy. In comparison, there were 1.4% and 4.4% decreases respectively across the nation. RotoruaNZ chief executive Andrew Wilson. Photo / Laura Smith Spending by domestic visitors from across the whole of New Zealand, not just Auckland, went up 14.3% year-on-year in Rotorua in May – compared to a 0.1% drop nationally. In addition, 76% of New Zealanders surveyed rated Rotorua as appealing to visit, with 35% intending to do so in the next 12 months. Traditionally, Rotorua's heritage has marked it as the birthplace of Kiwi tourism, but it had also grown into a mecca for adventure seekers, Wilson said. 'The push towards luxury and relaxation is not about abandoning our adventure roots. 'It's about expanding our narrative. Rotorua has always been a place of restoration and manaakitanga [hospitality]. We're simply reminding Kiwis of that in a fresh, relatable way,' Wilson said. The recent rise in domestic tourism has also been noticed by those in the industry. Rotorua Canopy Tours general manager Paul Button said he has seen an improvement domestically compared to 12 months ago. Last year, the country was in the grip of the cost-of-living crisis as households tightened budgets and went without getaways, he said. Rotorua Canopy Tours general manager Paul Button. Photo / Andrew Warner 'I don't think there's one silver bullet,' said Button. 'Last year, domestically, it fell off. We had an abrupt drop in May and our research suggested it was economy-related. 'It's definitely still tough out there and I am not going to pretend it's not but interest rates have dropped and things might be getting better.' Button said Rotorua's desirability had also returned. The pandemic had a major impact on the city, while the subsequent period of emergency housing compounded the city's tourism struggles, he said. Emergency housing motels in Rotorua are being wound down by the Government, with a plan to stop contracting motels by the end of 2025. Hennessey's Irish Bar owner Reg Hennessey. Photo / Andrew Warner 'A lot less use of motels for social housing has really helped,' said Reg Hennessey, owner of the locally famous Hennessey's Irish Bar on Tutanekai St. 'This school holiday was good and domestic tourism has definitely picked up, it's taken quite a bump this year. 'Now we are just getting the good word back out to New Zealand that it's a safe town and people can always feel safe here because of the way it's operated.' Tapsell also highlighted new efforts to attract more international visitors, as Rotorua Lakes Council funded promotion through an economic development rate on short-term accommodation providers. 'Tourism and hospitality contribute significantly to jobs in Rotorua,' she said. 'Attracting visitors can be very competitive, not just to get them to our district, but also to our country. It's important that we don't get complacent, so we've put a lot of effort and smart investment into unique initiatives to promote Rotorua.' She said the council was excited to continue to see the results of this. Mathew Nash is a Local Democracy Reporting journalist based at the Rotorua Daily Post. He has previously written for SunLive, been a regular contributor to RNZ and was a football reporter in the UK for eight years. – LDR is local body journalism co-funded by RNZ and NZ On Air.
NZ Herald
19 minutes ago
- NZ Herald
Opinion: NCEA changes must build on what works, not destroy it
NCEA supports student success by recognising diverse talents and allowing personalised learning pathways. Photo / Monkey Business Images THE FACTS As serious conversations about the future of NCEA get under way, it's important to stay focused on what matters: supporting student success, recognising diverse talents, and ensuring every learner has the opportunity to thrive. At its core, NCEA (National Certificate of Educational Achievement) reflects values that New Zealanders
Otago Daily Times
2 hours ago
- Otago Daily Times
A prescription for dismay, disbelief
Everything is going up. The costs of butter, milk and cheese, fruit and vegetables, rents, rates and electricity are rising, some of them faster than belief. Annual inflation has lifted to 2.7%, according to the consumer price index. There can be no doubt New Zealanders are grappling with the escalating cost of living. The government says it is all about cutting costs for Kiwis, something we have seen with its policies and its energetic drive to cut the public service and put thousands of skilled workers out of jobs. However, despite its much-vaunted approach to trim things, some of which didn't need much pruning, the coalition is still releasing big pots of money for projects which have its favour and tickle its fancy, or the fancies of its cadres. As a consequence of that favouritism, something else is going up. Advice be blowed, let's have a third medical school in New Zealand at a time when the government has been doing everything it can to minimise the importance of, and squeeze the life out of, Dunedin's desperately needed new hospital. Until Monday afternoon's announcement that the University of Waikato's persistent and somewhat personal bid for a medical school had been approved, there had been perhaps a hope that surely common sense might prevail and the government wouldn't, after all, go along with the proposal. Such sanguine thinking, however, was always held in check by the knowledge that this government has already shown several times that logic, facts and evidence to the contrary will not stop it supporting something which it is hell-bent on delivering for its followers. At the heart of Waikato's proposal was something few could disagree with — that the country urgently needs to do something about the state and delivery of rural healthcare. Access to timely and effective medical services for those communities has been a big concern for many years, one which has only continued to grow. But does it take a spanking new medical school costing several hundred million dollars, and growing, to ensure rural targets will be met? No. There is no reason why the medical schools at the University of Otago and the University of Auckland could not have been funded to train more doctors at a significantly lower cost than launching a new school, a point they clearly made to the government. Even the Treasury advised against the wisdom of proceeding with this pet project, as did the Ministry of Education and the Tertiary Education Commission, warning that the expense, the duplication and the logistical challenges raised red flags for them. In spite of that, the government and Waikato University forged on regardless. Health Minister Simeon Brown announced a development with costs which have changed significantly from those pledged by the National Party before the last election. Then, National said it would provide $280 million for the new school and the university would need to find $100m. Now, the government will disburse $82.85m towards it, and Waikato will have to stump up more than $150m. The final cost, of course, is bound to be higher than current expectations. A lot has been written about links between National and the university and its vice-chancellor Neil Quigley, and also with consultant Steven Joyce, a former National government minister. Without getting too deeply into that, we are concerned that this is little more than an overt example of pork-barrel politics. We are also troubled and disappointed, yet again, at the lack of transparency around the government's decision-making, particularly over health matters. Whenever it makes pronouncements which it knows are likely to be contentious, the accompanying documents seem to take ages to surface — if they ever do. That in itself probably speaks volumes about the consideration of the evidence. It's difficult to stay calm and reasoned and attempt to rise above the feeling this government cares not a jot for the South. When one sees what a charmed life this Waikato proposal has apparently had through the coalition's approval process, and compare that with the absolute shambles it has promulgated with the new Dunedin hospital and its obvious level of disinterest in the project, it is hard to remain philosophical. Once again, this government has let us down.
