Ford accuses law firms of fraudulent overbilling, including a 57-1/2 hour workday
In a complaint filed in Los Angeles federal court against nine defendants, Ford called the alleged improper billings a 'magical mystery tour' of bogus work and time entries, spread across thousands of cases against several auto makers so they would go undetected.
Ford said the law firm Knight Law Group anchored the scheme, regularly bringing in other law firms to overstaff cases, sometimes with 10 to 15 lawyers.
The Dearborn, Michigan-based auto maker said it lost at least $100 million from the scheme over five years. It is seeking at least $300 million in damages for alleged violations of the federal anti-racketeering law known as RICO.
Requests for comment on behalf of the defendants were not immediately returned.
The complaint identified 'numerous' alleged instances of lawyers billing more than 24 hours in a single day.
Ford said the 57-1/2 hours that Knight partner Amy Morse allegedly billed on November 30, 2016 included 12.9 hours on 'requests for admission,' where parties ask opponents to admit that facts are true or documents are authentic.
The auto maker said another lawyer allegedly billed 29 hours to prepare for, travel to and attend two trials on the same day in Los Angeles and near San Francisco, about 400 miles apart.
California's Lemon Law, the Song-Beverly Consumer Warranty Act, lets lawyers collect legal fees based on reasonably incurred time spent representing vehicle owners.
The case is Ford Motor Co v. Knight Law Group LLP et al, U.S. District Court, Central District of California, No. 25-04550.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
National Post
29 minutes ago
- National Post
Acuity Knowledge Partners Appoints Emma Crabtree as Chief Revenue Officer
Article content LONDON & NEW YORK — Acuity Knowledge Partners (Acuity), a leading provider of bespoke research, analytics, staffing and technology solutions to the financial services sector, has appointed Emma Crabtree as Chief Revenue Officer (CRO). Article content Crabtree has more than 25 years of leadership experience in client engagement and commercial strategy, having held senior roles at global financial institutions including BNP Paribas Securities Services, and RBC Investor & Treasury Services. Most recently, she served as Group Chief Commercial Officer at IQ-EQ, where she led the firm's commercial, segment strategy and marketing efforts across a broad suite of investor services and played a central role in strong organic growth and expanding client relationships. Article content Crabtree will join Acuity's Executive Committee and lead global sales, client engagement and marketing. She will work closely with Acuity's leadership to shape and execute the firm's growth agenda, including expansion and go-to-market of Acuity's research, data, analytics, and a wide set of bespoke technology and agentic AI solutions into existing and new client segments, geographies and product offerings. Article content 'Emma is a commercial leader with a deep understanding of how data and technology platforms support global financial services firms,' said Robert King, Chief Executive Officer, Acuity Knowledge Partners. 'She brings with her a track record of building high-performing teams, delivering sales growth, and deepening strategic client partnerships. As Acuity continues its growth trajectory, her experience and insight will be invaluable in helping us deepen client impact and sharpen our commercial focus.' Article content 'I'm truly excited to join Acuity at such a pivotal point in its growth journey. The company has built a strong reputation for delivering exceptional value to its clients through deep domain expertise, technology-led solutions, and a culture of innovation. Article content 'I look forward to working with our talented teams to drive commercial excellence, opening new avenues for growth, and continuing positioning Acuity as a trusted partner to our clients worldwide. Together, we'll look forward to building on the strong foundations already in place and helping to unlock the next phase of growth,' said Emma Crabtree. Article content At BNP Paribas, Crabtree held several senior sales leadership roles, including Global Head of Sales for Asset Managers and Alternatives, and Head of Sales for EMEA and Continental Europe. Prior to that, she spent nearly two decades at RBC, where she served as Managing Director, Global Client Coverage, focused on institutional client growth. Article content About Acuity Knowledge Partners Article content Acuity Knowledge Partners (Acuity) is a leading provider of bespoke research, data management, analytics, talent, and technology solutions to the financial services industry, including asset managers, corporate and investment banks, private equity and venture capital firms, hedge funds and consulting firms. Its global network of over 6,500 analysts and industry experts, combined with proprietary technology, supports more than 650 financial institutions and consulting companies to operate more efficiently and unlock their human capital and transforming operations. Acuity is headquartered in London and operates from 16 locations worldwide. Article content Acuity was established as a separate business from Moody's Corporation in 2019, following its acquisition by Equistone Partners Europe (Equistone). In January 2023, funds advised by global private equity firm Permira acquired a majority stake in the business from Equistone, which remains invested as a minority shareholder. Article content Article content Article content Article content Article content Contacts Article content Media contact: Article content
CBC
30 minutes ago
- CBC
Canada is running out of runway for its F-35 review
Social Sharing There was an interesting — albeit brief — recent eruption of clarity in the ongoing saga of whether Canada intends to proceed with the full order of American-made F-35 fighters. It was courtesy of the U.S. ambassador to Canada, Pete Hoekstra, who perhaps spoke the quiet part out loud last week in an interview with Canadian independent podcaster Jasmin Laine. Hoekstra, a no-nonsense Republican from Michigan, was asked about the Liberal government's review of the $27.7-billion purchase of stealth fighters and the possibility that after delivery of the first tranche of jets, Canada could decide to fill the rest of its order with another type of aircraft. "You can't afford two fighters, two different fighter jet programs," said Hoekstra. "Canada should just decide what they want. Do they want F-35s? Do they want some other product? That's your decision to make, but you can't afford both of them." But then, he added that the ongoing review is "an irritant that makes it harder to get to a [trade] agreement." It's not much of a stretch to suggest that few Canadian tears would be shed over the notion that the Trump administration is irritated by the uncertainty. But the fact he's said so publicly is significant and it represents an interesting escalation from earlier remarks that suggested not buying the F-35s would endanger NORAD, the binational defence pact with the United States. What's even more potentially entertaining is the lengths to which everyone on the Canadian side has twisted themselves into pretzels to downplay the notion that the fighter jet program is being used as a significant piece of leverage in negotiations with Washington. Speaking on CBC Radio's The House last weekend, the country's top military commander, Gen. Jennie Carignan portrayed the review as a prudent, business-as-usual, due diligence exercise. "With the new government coming into place, it's perfectly normal," Carignan said. "There's a request to ensure that our processes are still valid, that we are getting what we need." With any other major defence purchase, that might be a reasonable argument. But the F-35 has been — over 15 years of political drama — the subject of enormous study. Parliamentary watchdogs, an independent panel and a legion of experts have lined up to analyze, slice, dice and dissect the plan. One wonders what more can be said that couldn't be found in a ministerial transition briefing book. The review has been going on since the early spring and with so much information already at their fingertips, the question of what the political impact might be only gets larger as time goes on. Retired vice-admiral Mark Norman, also speaking on The House last weekend, said there's obvious "trepidation" and consideration of "what kind of blowback reaction" there could be in Washington should Canada opt to shop elsewhere. Others argue that the tantrums of Trump and the irritation of his administration shouldn't dictate Canadian defence policy. "I think the Trump administration will decide if they wish to punish us or not based on whatever current thought of the moment is in the heads of the president and his key advisers," said Wendy Gilmour, a Canadian former assistant secretary general for defence investment at NATO. "I think Canada needs to make the best decisions it can for our own interests." And that's what makes the specifics of what, precisely, the Department of National Defence has been told to review so crucial. When you ask for the terms of reference or even the obstacles and costs of running two fleets of fighters, more often than not, you get boilerplate responses about spending wisely and the scope of the enormous investment. "The nature of aerial combat, the nature of warfare, the nature of our responsibilities, the scale of our investment — all of those elements have changed over the course of recent years," Prime Minister Mark Carney said a couple of weeks ago, while announcing a military pay increase. "We also need the appropriate air capabilities for the Arctic, for the runways in the Arctic, for the threats that we're faced in the Arctic … is the F-35 best suited for that?" The security risks for Canada The contract to buy the F-35 was announced in January 2023 and one would hope the debate about Arctic operations would have been long settled before that. It's important considering, as the Ottawa Citizen reported last month, construction of new hangar and infrastructure facilities to house the F-35s is about to get underway at the military's principal fighter bases in Cold Lake, Alta., and Bagotville, Que. Interestingly, the one non-political aspect of the F-35 deal that would provide an important, logical rationale for a review is the one nobody wants to discuss publicly: the potential national security risks to Canada. Buying the F-35 makes the Canadian air force dependent on the U.S. for software and repair, which has the potential to create delays in deployment and affect operational readiness. It was an issue that raised its head briefly after U.S. President Donald Trump returned to office last winter and suggested allies could end up with less capable versions of the aircraft. It could also be argued that the escalating costs (with the purchase estimate for 88 aircraft, including weapons and training, going from $19 billion to $27 billion), would justify an urgent review. Defence Minister David McGuinty, however, suggested last week the government would take its "lead from the experts that performed the review, both in the Department of National Defence and the Canadian Armed Forces." WATCH | Cost of F-35 program balloons: F-35 costs skyrocketing, not enough pilots to fly them: AG report 2 months ago A new Auditor General's report finds the cost of buying U.S.-made F-35 stealth fighter jets has ballooned almost 50 per cent from an estimated $19 billion to $27.7 billion — and that's without the additional cost of weapons and infrastructure. The program is also facing a shortage of trained pilots. As if there was any doubt about where the military stands, there was a pretty clear indication with a recent report by Reuters, based upon sources, which said the air force was recommending sticking with the F-35. Carney was clear that no decision had been made and that it would be sometime in the late summer or early fall before the review would be considered. Playing politics with defence purchases is nothing new in Canada, but Norman argues that given the state of the world, the military can't afford games and uncertainty, especially with the current CF-18s rapidly approaching the end of their useful life. "What we need to be careful of is that we don't inadvertently — or perhaps for superficial political reasons — make what I would characterize as dumb decision," Norman said.
CBC
30 minutes ago
- CBC
Ont. truckers used secret compartment to smuggle cocaine for fugitive Ryan Wedding
Two truckers have agreed to plead guilty in connection with a scheme to smuggle loads of cocaine from California to Ontario on behalf of fugitive Ryan Wedding's criminal enterprise, CBC News has learned. Iqbal Singh Virk and Ranjit Singh Rowal from the Toronto area are the first Canadians to sign plea deals with U.S. prosecutors following the FBI's sprawling investigation revealed last fall, dubbed "Operation Giant Slalom." The probe — named after Wedding's previous career as an elite snowboarder — sought to dismantle his alleged drug trafficking network, which uses commercial transport trucks to move tonnes of cocaine and fentanyl across North America. The group has also been linked to at least four murders in Ontario. In August 2024, suspected cocaine and heroin was found in a secret compartment in a Canada-bound truck on the Blue Water Bridge, linking Ontario and Michigan. (U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan) Wedding, who competed for Canada at the 2002 Olympic Games in Utah, is listed as one of the FBI's most-wanted fugitives, with a $10-million US reward offered for information leading to his capture. According to documents filed this month in U.S. District Court in L.A., Virk and Rowal have each committed to plead guilty to charges including conspiracy to distribute cocaine. The charges carry a maximum sentence of life in prison. They were both arrested in August 2024 as they tried to cross the Blue Water Bridge from Michigan to the Sarnia, Ont., area, while carrying 95 kg of cocaine bricks and 20 kg of heroin in a secret compartment in their truck's trailer. They concealed the drugs by carrying legal goods and documentation to show the products were meant to be hauled from the U.S. to Canada. U.S. border agents, however, pulled over the truck for a secondary inspection, where an X-ray scanner and a sniffer dog revealed the "non-factory" compartment. In August 2024, U.S. border agents seized 95 kg of cocaine and 20 kg of heroin, as Iqbal Singh Virk and Ranjit Singh Rowal sought to smuggle the drugs across the Blue Water Bridge, from Michigan to Ontario. ( U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan) A search of Ontario licence plate records by CBC News indicates the trailer was registered to a Brampton, Ont.-based company linked to Rowal, 65. A U.S. grand jury indictment unsealed last October named Virk and Rowal — Indian citizens who hold permanent resident status in Canada — and 14 others as members of Wedding's drug ring. The indictment said the pair worked on behalf of a transportation network that handled Wedding's shipments to Canada. However, the transnational criminal operation didn't always go smoothly. Court documents reveal an internal dispute in May 2024 led to one big drug shipment being called off. Virk and Rowal's plea agreements recount how the pair pulled over at a rest stop in southern California, expecting to receive a 347-kg load of cocaine. Their truck, however, only had room for 250 kg. Through an intermediary, Wedding purportedly offered to pay $150,000 Cdn to move the reduced shipment — instead of the agreed upon rate of $220,000. But Gurpreet Singh , allegedly a leader of the transportation network, wouldn't agree to the cut rate. Before he was convicted in a cocaine trafficking conspiracy, Ryan Wedding competed for Canada at the 2002 Olympic Games in Salt Lake City, Utah. (Andre Forget/The Canadian Press) The shipment was called off. Singh and his uncle, Hardeep Ratte, who are accused of co-ordinating cocaine shipments to Canada for Wedding, both remain in custody in Ontario while facing extradition to the U.S. They're scheduled to appear in a Toronto court on Wednesday. U.S. prosecutors have said Wedding — whose aliases include Public Enemy, Giant and "El Jefe" or "The Boss" — is still trafficking drugs while on the run , and has access to a "network of hitmen." WATCH | Where was this picture of Ryan Wedding taken? We found out: Tracking the Canadian on the FBI's most wanted list CBC News visual investigations team, in partnership with international researchers from the Bellingcat Discord community, located the exact spot where one of the last images of Ryan Wedding was taken. Wedding, an alleged Canadian drug lord, is among the FBI's top 10 most-wanted fugitives. CBC is the first to report and confirm these findings. Earlier this month, the FBI told CBC News it was seeking to gather tips on Wedding's whereabouts from people in a region of central Mexico. Investigators have suggested Wedding may be living in the country, under the protection of the murderous Sinaloa cartel. CBC News recently reported that a historic drug bust in Peel Region, west of Toronto, mirrored the smuggling route used by Virk and Rowal. Peel police said it's highly likely Wedding's network remains active in the area. CBC senior reporter Thomas Daigle has reported extensively on the case of fugitive alleged drug kingpin Ryan Wedding. Send news tips to
