Two-Tier Test Cricket Model: ICCs Proposal Faces Resistance From ECB And CA Over WTC Reforms
Speaking during the England-India Test at The Oval, ECB chairman Richard Thompson voiced strong reservations about a two-tier structure, especially one that risks traditional rivalries such as the Ashes or contests against India. His concern: relegation to Division Two could potentially sideline England from marquee bilateral series, leading to significant commercial fallout.
'We wouldn't want, as England, to fall into Division Two and not play Australia or India. That couldn't happen,' Thompson told BBC's Test Match Special. 'There has to be a sense that common sense needs to play out here.'
Thompson acknowledged the WTC has injected meaning into the Test calendar but believes improving the current system may offer more promise than restructuring it entirely. He cited South Africa's triumphant underdog story in the 2023-25 WTC final against Australia as proof that lesser-resourced teams can compete and win—if supported adequately.
Cricket Australia: Open to Change, But with Caveats
Cricket Australia CEO Todd Greenberg struck a more flexible tone but echoed similar concerns. In an interview with SEN Radio, Greenberg emphasized the shared responsibility among top-tier nations to strengthen Test cricket globally, particularly in traditional strongholds like the West Indies, Pakistan, and South Africa. 'My open mind is in reference to: if [the two-tier model] helps grow the opportunities for other countries to be stronger in Test cricket, then I'm open to it,' Greenberg said. 'But if it has the opposite effect, I wouldn't be supportive.'
Greenberg noted that many CEOs from Full Member boards are aware that some level of reform is inevitable if Test cricket is to retain its value amid a saturated international calendar and the rise of white-ball dominance.
The ICC's Dilemma: Meaningful Reform vs Market Realities
The ICC's working group is expected to make recommendations soon, though details remain under wraps. Sanjog Gupta, the newly appointed ICC CEO, is likely to play a key role in steering the discussions, especially with media rights negotiations for the 2027-31 cycle looming.
The challenge is multifaceted:
How to ensure competitive balance across all Test-playing nations? Can relegation and promotion be fairly implemented without punishing teams going through a temporary slump?
Will top-tier broadcasters and sponsors support a model where iconic rivalries may no longer be guaranteed?
Olympics 2028: Another Hurdle for Red-Ball Cricket
Richard Thompson also flagged a looming scheduling clash with the 2028 Los Angeles Olympics, where cricket will make its debut. 'What happens when our best 11 cricketers have to go to LA for two weeks in the middle of July?' he asked, underlining how a congested international window could further strain bilateral Test engagements.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
India Today
a few seconds ago
- India Today
England not in favour of two-tier World Test Championship and their reason is bizarre
England and Wales Cricket Board (ECB) chairman Richard Thompson has voiced his opposition to the proposed two-tier structure in Test cricket, expressing concerns that relegation could prevent England from competing regularly against top sides such as India and Australia. The International Cricket Council (ICC) is expected to make a decision soon on whether to adopt a two-tier format for the World Test Championship (WTC).advertisementEngland's long-standing rivalry with Australia remains one of cricket's most iconic contests, and recent Ashes series have delivered substantial financial returns for both nations. The 2023 Ashes, hosted in England, drew some of the largest crowds in recent memory, with gripping on-field action capturing the imagination of recently, England played host to India in a thrilling five-Test series for the Anderson-Tendulkar Trophy. All five matches went the full distance, with the final Test at The Oval reaching Day 5. Despite the absence of marquee Indian players such as Virat Kohli and Rohit Sharma, the series was a commercial and broadcasting success, with stadiums packed throughout and a young Indian side led by Shubman Gill fighting valiantly to draw the series 2-2. "There's a lot of options that we've got to look at - tiers would be one of them," Richard Thompson told BBC Test Match Special."We wouldn't want, as England, if we go through a fallow period, to fall into Division Two and not play Australia or India. That simply couldn't happen. Common sense needs to prevail."Thompson instead called for improvements in scheduling bilateral Test series to enhance the competitive balance and overall structure of the WTC, suggesting that a two-tier model might not be the optimal solution."The reality is, if the World Test Championship is improved upon and certain changes are made, perhaps you don't need two tiers of Test cricket. What's essential is a schedule that makes more sense than the current one. That includes better balance between white-ball and red-ball cricket, and acknowledging the upcoming challenge of the Olympics from 2028 onwards."So what happens in 2028, when we have an Olympics and our best eleven cricketers are expected to be in Los Angeles for two weeks in mid-July? That's going to create serious complications."To date, nine teams have featured in the first three cycles of the WTC. If the two-tier system is approved, the WTC will expand to 12 teams, divided into two groups of the WTC has brought added significance to bilateral series, many have raised concerns over the uneven distribution of fixtures, particularly the dominance of the so-called 'Big Three' - England, India, and Australia - who play the lion's share of high-profile July 2025, the ICC formed an eight-member working group to assess the feasibility of introducing a two-tier WTC. The committee is headed by ICC's newly appointed Chief Executive Officer Sanjog Gupta and was formed during the ICC's annual general meeting in Singapore, which was presided over by Chair Jay Shah. ECB Chief Executive Richard Gould and Cricket Australia's CEO Todd Greenberg are also part of the IN FAVOUR?Greenberg recently stated he was open to the idea - but only if it added meaningful development to global Test cricket."My open mind refers to whether it helps grow opportunities for other nations to become stronger and better resourced in Test match cricket. If it achieves that, then I'm open to it," Greenberg told SEN Radio on Wednesday, 6 August."But if it fails to achieve that and instead has the opposite effect, then I wouldn't support it."Any changes to the format of the WTC would only come into effect for the 2027-2029 cycle. The 2025-2027 cycle has already begun, with bilateral series agreed under the current ICC Future Tours Programme. However, the ICC is expected to arrive at a decision promptly, with media rights for the 2027-2031 cycle scheduled to go on sale next year.- EndsYou May Also Like
India.com
a few seconds ago
- India.com
Chris Woakes Reflects On Final-Day Grit Of The 5th Test At Oval: ‘Wouldn't Have Lived With Myself'
In one of the most dramatic finales in recent Test cricket history, England all-rounder Chris Woakes has opened up about his courageous decision to bat on Day 5 at The Oval despite suffering a dislocated shoulder, saying, "I wouldn't have been able to live with myself if I didn't at least try." The fifth Test between India and England ended in favor of India, with England falling just six runs short of what would have been a miraculous chase. But it was the sight of a wounded Woakes walking out to bat, shoulder limp, unable to lift his arm, that became a defining image of the series, and a powerful testament to grit and team spirit. Walking into Pain and Uncertainty Speaking after the match, Woakes admitted he was genuinely terrified. 'Thank God I didn't face a 90mph bouncer one-handed,' he joked with a tinge of seriousness, recalling the fear that came with potentially having to defend himself without the use of his top hand. Despite his injury, the 35-year-old made the selfless choice to pad up and walk out, knowing the game, and possibly the series, was on the line. 'You just feel a duty to the team, the fans, the crowd, and yourself. I wouldn't have been able to live with myself if I hadn't gone out there," Woakes told reporters post-match. He never faced a ball, with Gus Atkinson falling at the other end shortly after his arrival. But the symbolic weight of his effort resonated far beyond the scoreboard. Emotional Weight and 'What Ifs' Woakes, who had played a key role earlier in the series, admitted to feeling 'gutted' that England couldn't complete the fairytale. 'It was devastating. We were so close. It felt like it was written in the stars. To fall short by just a few runs, it'll haunt me for a while.' Yet, he said he'd make the same decision again, even knowing how it ended. 'You don't know what might happen out there. A run-out, a no-ball, a misfield, anything. I had to be there.' Support from Both Camps The cricketing world quickly rallied behind Woakes. Indian batter Shubman Gill, who witnessed the moment from the field, reportedly told Woakes afterward that he was 'genuinely worried' seeing him walk out injured. "That's the kind of moment that goes beyond rivalries. It's about respect," said Gill, praising Woakes for his bravery. Even the Oval crowd, mostly stunned by the tense finish, erupted into applause when Woakes walked onto the pitch. That ovation was, perhaps, the loudest of the day. A Defining Image for Test Cricket While the result meant that the England-India series ended 2-2, the final Test was a reminder of why Test cricket still matters. Woakes' decision to bat, risking further injury, spoke volumes about the emotional depth and sporting spirit that defines the longest format of the game. In an age of fast-paced T20 leagues and white-ball dominance, Chris Woakes showed that courage, loyalty, and tradition still have a place in modern cricket.
&w=3840&q=100)
First Post
a few seconds ago
- First Post
Chris Woakes reveals Shubman Gill, Rishabh Pant's touching gesture towards him: 'I obviously said sorry'
Chris Woakes, who came out to bat despite injuring his left hand at the Oval, has revealed how Indian stars Shubman Gill and Rishabh Pant acknowledged his heroics and his replies to them. read more With Chris Woakes injured and in no shape to bat, it was virtually over for England on Day 5 of the Oval Test when Mohammed Siraj and Prasidh Krishna had taken three of the four wickets required to win the match. However, in what could be defined as an anti-climax for India, an injured Woakes, with his left hand in a sling, made the long walk to the middle. The crowd at the Oval stood up and hailed the player as he decided to step up for his country, when it was in dire need. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD While India went on to win the match by six runs, the courage that Woakes showed will remain etched in the minds of fans who witnessed it. Moreover, the players also realised that they were witnessing something exceptional, and hence, despite the tense situation in the match, the Indian team did not forget that it is a gentleman's game in the end, and acknowledged the valour displayed by Woakes. Shubman Gill and Rishabh Pant's grand gesture for Chris Woakes Indian captain Shubman Gill made sure to praise Woakes for the bravery he showed in trying to take his team past the finish line. 'Shubman said something like: 'That was incredibly brave,'" Woakes told The Guardian. 'I told him: 'You've had an unbelievable series, well played, and credit to your team.'" Not only Shubman, but Rishabh Pant also hailed the effort of Woakes by dedicating an Instagram story to him. Upon noting the post made by Pant, Woakes replied with a 'thank you' to him and, in turn, wished him a speedy recovery. Notably, Pant suffered a toe fracture after being hit by a delivery bowled by Woakes in the fourth Test and did not feature in the fifth and final Test. 'I saw Rishabh had put an image of me on Instagram with a salute emoji, so I replied, thanking him: 'Appreciate the love and hope the foot is OK' etc. He then sent me a voice note saying: 'I hope all is OK, good luck with the recovery, and I hope we meet again out there some day.' I obviously said sorry for the broken foot," he further added. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD Thus, while the series saw many occasions where tempers flared between the players of both teams, in the end, the spirit of cricket ruled large.
