Experts call for ‘healthocide' designation after surge in attacks on doctors, hospitals in war
Most deliberate attacks on health services have taken place in Gaza since 2023, but other strikes have been recorded in Lebanon, Syria, Sudan and Ukraine, The Guardian reported. Individual medical staff have also been deliberately targeted.
International humanitarian law has explicitly promoted the longstanding principle of medical neutrality, which prohibits attacks on healthcare workers and facilities during war, enabling doctors and surgeons to perform their work on anyone in need.
Dr. Joelle Abi-Rached and his colleagues at the American University of Beirut submitted a commentary to the British Medical Journal warning of the surge in the targeting of health services.
'Both in Gaza and Lebanon, healthcare facilities have not only been directly targeted, but access to care has also been obstructed, including incidents where ambulances have been prevented from reaching the injured, or deliberately attacked,' they wrote.
'What is becoming clear is that healthcare workers and facilities are no longer afforded the protection guaranteed by international humanitarian law.'
The authors highlighted data from Israel's invasion of Gaza, which has killed at least 986 medical workers.
Healthcare Workers Watch data also shows that 28 doctors from the Palestinian enclave are being detained without charge in Israeli prisons.
Eight of them are senior consultants in surgery, orthopedics, intensive care, cardiology and pediatrics.
Gaza's health facilities, including major hospitals, have been 'turned into battlegrounds' by Israel's assault, Dr. Rik Peeperkorn, representative of the World Health Organization for the West Bank and Gaza, said in January.
Israel has also engaged in a policy to 'systematically dismantle' the health system and 'drive it to the brink of collapse,' he added.
Earlier this year, The Guardian conducted an investigative project, Doctors in Detention, to interview healthcare workers in Gaza.
They told the newspaper that their detention, along with hundreds of other medical staff held by the Israeli military, was likely due to their occupation.
In detention, they suffered torture, beatings, starvation and humiliation, The Guardian was told.
Their Israeli guards also played loud music throughout the day and night to prevent them from sleeping, and they were regularly denied food, water and showers.
Israel's war in Lebanon last year also featured similar tactics to disrupt and destroy local health services.
According to Lebanon's Public Health Ministry, 217 healthcare workers were killed by the Israel Defense Forces between Oct. 8, 2023, and Jan. 27, 2025.
A further 177 ambulances were damaged, and authorities recorded 68 separate attacks on Lebanese hospitals.
Doctors around the world must 'forsake the principle of medical neutrality' and voice their concerns over 'healthocide,' the authors of the BMJ commentary urged.
Failing to do so would only embolden future violations of the neutrality principle, they warned, adding that the documentation of attacks and abuses against health workers would help in the enforcement of justice.
The British Medical Association's medical ethics committee chair, Dr. Andrew Green, said: 'In recent years, doctors have been devastated to see the appalling increase in attacks on healthcare, patients and staff in conflict zones, and the disregard for medical neutrality and international humanitarian law.'
He called on international medical associations, NGOs, governments and the UN to 'call out when we see human and health rights abused, and hold those breaking international humanitarian law accountable.
'Those with power must use all levers at their disposal to ensure the provision of humanitarian aid and urgent healthcare to the world's most vulnerable.
'One clear step would be the establishment of a UN special rapporteur on the protection of health in armed conflict.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Al Arabiya
a day ago
- Al Arabiya
Gaza civil defense says 10 killed across territory
Gaza's civil defense agency said at least 10 people were killed across the Palestinian territory on Saturday, including civilians who were waiting to collect aid. Civil defense spokesman Mahmud Bassal told AFP that at least six people were killed and 30 wounded after Israeli troops targeted civilians assembling near an aid point in central Gaza. The spokesman said strikes also hit areas in central Gaza, resulting in multiple casualties. Media restrictions in Gaza and difficulties accessing swathes of the territory mean AFP is unable to independently verify the tolls and details provided by the civil defense and the Israeli military. Thousands of Gazans congregate daily near food distribution points in Gaza, including four managed by the US- and Israeli-backed Gaza Humanitarian Foundation. Since launching in late May, its operations have been marred by almost-daily reports of Israeli forces targeting those waiting to collect aid supplies. Israeli restrictions on the entry of supplies into Gaza since the start of the war nearly two years ago have led to shortages of food and essential supplies, including medicine and fuel, which hospitals require to power their generators. Early Friday, the Israeli security cabinet approved plans to launch major operations to seize Gaza City, triggering a wave of outrage across the globe. Despite the backlash and rumors of dissent from Israeli military top brass, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu remained defiant over the decision. In a post on social media late Friday, Netanyahu said 'we are not going to occupy Gaza – we are going to free Gaza from Hamas.' Netanyahu faces mounting pressure to secure a ceasefire to bring the territory's more than two million people back from the brink of famine and free the hostages held by Palestinian militants. Israel's arch enemy Hamas, whose October 7, 2023 attack triggered the war, slammed the plan to expand the fighting, calling it a 'new war crime.' Israel's offensive has killed over 61,000 Palestinians, according to Hamas-run Gaza's health ministry, figures the UN says are reliable. The 2023 attack on Israel resulted in the deaths of 1,219 people, according to an AFP tally based on official figures.
Asharq Al-Awsat
2 days ago
- Asharq Al-Awsat
WHO: Nearly 12,000 Children Under Five in Gaza Have Acute Malnutrition
Around 12,000 children aged under five in Gaza are suffering from acute malnutrition, and hunger-related deaths are rising, the Director General of the World Health Organization said on Thursday. "In July, nearly 12,000 children under five years were identified as having acute malnutrition in Gaza, the highest monthly figure ever recorded," Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus said at his organization's headquarters in Geneva. At least 99 people have died, including 64 adults and 35 children, of whom 29 were younger than five, from the start of this year to July 29. Between June and July, the number of admissions for malnutrition almost doubled - from 6,344 to 11,877 - according to the latest UNICEF figures available. Some 2,500 of those children are suffering from severe malnutrition. Tedros called for greater volumes of sustained aid, via all possible routes. The WHO said it was supporting Gaza's four malnutrition centers, but that supplies of baby formula and nutritional foods were very low. "The overall volume of nutrition supplies remains completely insufficient to prevent further deterioration. The market needs to be flooded. There needs to be dietary diversity," said Rik Peeperkorn, WHO's representative for the occupied Palestinian Territory, via video link. A global hunger monitor has said a famine scenario is unfolding in the Gaza Strip, with starvation spreading, children dying of hunger-related causes and humanitarian access to the embattled enclave severely restricted. The United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA) said food consumption across Gaza had declined to its lowest level since the onset of the war. Eighty-one percent of households in the tiny, crowded coastal territory of 2.2 million people reported poor food consumption, up from 33% in April.
Arab News
3 days ago
- Arab News
GHF aid distribution sites in Gaza becoming ‘laboratories of cruelty,' says medical charity
LONDON: Doctors Without Borders has accused a controversial aid initiative in Gaza of enabling the systematic targeting and killing of civilians, it was reported on Thursday. In a scathing new report, the medical charity — also known by its French acronym MSF— said aid distribution centers run by the US and Israeli-backed Gaza Humanitarian Foundation had become sites of 'orchestrated killing.' Raquel Ayora, one of the charity's general directors, said: 'In MSF's nearly 54 years of operations, rarely have we seen such levels of systematic violence against unarmed civilians. 'The GHF distribution sites masquerading as 'aid' have morphed into a laboratory of cruelty. This must stop now.' The group is calling for GHF's operations to be scrapped immediately and replaced with a UN-led system. It has urged governments and donors to 'suspend all financial and political support for the GHF.' In a report by Sky News, the channel contacted both the GHF and the Israel Defense Forces for comment. In an interview on Wednesday, IDF spokesperson Nadav Shoshani dismissed the allegations, claiming: 'I think that is completely false,' and described some reports of shootings as 'fake news.' Between June 7 and July 24, MSF says it treated 1,380 people wounded near GHF aid sites at two of its clinics. Among the injured were 71 children, 25 of them under the age of 15. The charity said 28 people were dead on arrival. Among the cases were an 8-year-old girl shot in the chest, and a 12-year-old boy hit in the abdomen. The charity described several injuries as precise and deliberate. 'The distinct patterns and anatomical precision of these injuries strongly suggests the intentional targeting of people within and around the distribution sites, rather than accidental or indiscriminate fire,' the report stated. Gunshot wounds recorded at MSF's Al-Mawasi Clinic showed 11 percent struck victims in the head or neck, while 19 percent were to the torso. In Khan Younis, injuries to the lower limbs were more common. One patient, Mohammed Riad Tabasi, said: 'We're being slaughtered. I've been injured maybe 10 times. I saw it with my own eyes, about 20 corpses around me; all of them shot in the head (and) in the stomach.' The report also documented 196 injuries caused by stampedes or chaos during aid distribution. One woman died of likely asphyxiation in a crush. Others, MSF said, were beaten or robbed after receiving food. The GHF took over much of Gaza's aid provision in May after Israel ended an 11-week blockade. But the operation has drawn mounting international criticism. A previous Sky News investigation linked GHF-led aid drops to spikes in fatalities, and UN officials have condemned the system as 'death traps.' UN experts this week called the program 'an utterly disturbing example of how humanitarian relief can be exploited for covert military and geopolitical agendas in serious breach of international law.' They reiterated calls for Israel to restore access for UN agencies and humanitarian nongovernmental organizations. MSF echoed the demand and directly urged the US to end its support. 'Despite the condemnations and calls for dismantling it, the global inaction to stop GHF is baffling,' said Aitor Zabalgogeazkoa, MSF's emergency coordinator. The IDF maintains that humanitarian access is not being obstructed. 'There is no limit of aid getting into Gaza,' Shoshani said. 'Every day, hundreds of trucks go into Gaza.' Israeli officials argue the GHF model prevents supplies being stolen by Hamas and ensures they reach civilians directly. Steve Witkoff, the US' special envoy to the Middle East, last week toured one of the sites. 'We're putting up money to get the people fed,' US President Donald Trump declared at the same time.
