Federal judge dismisses lawsuit over Flamin' Hot Cheetos origin story
Richard Montañez had sued Frito-Lay and its parent company PepsiCo last year, alleging they defamed him and hurt his career by denying his role in creating the popular snack.
Federal Judge John W. Holcomb of the U.S. District Court in Los Angeles wrote in his Wednesday ruling that Montañez's accusations of fraud and defamation were insufficient or lacked 'factual support.'
But the battle over the origin story of the spicy junk food will remain in play for now.
Montañez will have the opportunity to amend his lawsuit because 'he may be able to cure the deficiencies in his pleading by alleging additional facts," the judge wrote.
Montañez will have until June 13 to submit an amended complaint.
Read more: The man who didn't invent Flamin' Hot Cheetos
His lawsuit came in the aftermath of a 2021 Los Angeles Times investigation that questioned his rags-to-riches story that had long circulated the internet and captured the hearts of fans of the snack and immigrant communities.
The story goes that Montañez was working as a janitor at Frito-Lay's Rancho Cucamonga plant when he dreamed up a version of the Cheeto that would appeal to the Latino community and had the gumption to pitch his idea to an executive.
The Times article cited chronological inconsistencies in Montañez's story, archival proof of the release of test products and comments by Frito-Lay executives.
According to Montañez's lawsuit, he grew up in a Southern California migrant labor camp sharing an 800-square-foot, one-bedroom apartment with his parents and 10 siblings. He got the janitor job in the mid-1970s, and a decade later he and his wife experimented in their kitchen to create the new snack.
Read more: He says he invented Flamin' Hot Cheetos. He didn't, said Frito-Lay. Now he's suing
In his lawsuit, he explained that he met resistance working with the research and development team while creating a spicy seasoning for mass production.
'Dissatisfied that Mr. Montañez — a poor, uneducated Mexican plant worker and janitor — had successfully developed a new product, Frito-Lay's R&D personnel completely shut out Mr. Montañez from the development process,' the lawsuit said.
Montañez climbed PepsiCo's ranks, becoming the company's vice president of multicultural marketing and sales before retiring in 2019.
In his lawsuit, Montañez said that the companies had sent him touring the country delivering inspiring talks in elite academic and business settings, and that as a result PepsiCo had "reaped tremendous benefits by affirmatively holding [Montañez] out as the inventor of Flamin' Hot Cheetos."
But Holcomb, the judge, wrote that Montañez could not argue that PepsiCo and Frito-Lay's profiting off the premise that he invented the snack was unjust since Montañez "mutually benefitted from Defendants' decades-long support."
Montañez's attorneys did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
Times staff writer Sandra McDonald contributed to this report.
Sign up for our Wide Shot newsletter to get the latest entertainment business news, analysis and insights.
This story originally appeared in Los Angeles Times.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
3 hours ago
- Yahoo
Woman's body found dumped in SoCal forest. Her husband fled the country with their kids, authorities say
The body of a missing Southern California woman was found this weekend at the bottom of an embankment in the Angeles National Forest, according to authorities. Officials are now searching for her husband, whom they say fled to Peru with the couple's three children. The remains of 33-year-old Sheylla Cabrera, also known as Sheylla Lisbet Gutiérrez Rosillo, were found Saturday by the Montrose Search and Rescue Team, according to a statement from the Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department. Her body was discovered wrapped in some sort of material, though the department did not elaborate. A precise cause of death has not yet been established and is being investigated by the L.A. County medical examiner's office, authorities said. Read more: Mother of missing 7-month-old refused a polygraph test but is cooperating, lawyer says The department's Lancaster station took a missing person's report regarding Cabrera on Aug. 12, authorities said. The next day, deputies found video surveillance footage allegedly showing a man authorities identified as her husband, Jossimar Cabrera, dragging an object "in a large piece of material" from an apartment complex in the 500 block of Lancaster Boulevard, where the couple lived with their three sons. Authorities in L.A. County cast a wide net to search for Jossimar Cabrera, 36, and the three boys. Homicide investigators also reached out to Mexican and Peruvian consular officials to alert them of their interest in Jossimar Cabrera. On Saturday, the children were recovered unharmed in Peru after they entered the country with their father, according to the Peruvian Ministry of Women and Vulnerable Populations. The whereabouts of Jossimar Cabrera, however, remain unknown. Read more: L.A. police reserve officer took part in home invasion, kidnapped man for ransom, prosecutors say The ministry has since come under fire because officials questioned Jossimar Cabrera at the airport in Lima and took the children into protective custody, but didn't detain him, according to several Peruvian media sources. He is believed to still be in the country, L.A. County officials said. The ministry also posted about the death of Sheylla Cabrera on social media, which it later deleted, before alerting her family. 'We deeply regret its publication, as it has jeopardized the investigation underway in the United States and also the work being done in Peru,' Jessy Gutiérrez, Sheylla Cabrera's sister, told the outlet Latina Noticias. "I ask the Ministry to exercise greater care and consideration when reporting, out of respect for my sister's memory." Read more: Woman fires at co-workers in O.C., then dies in police shooting in L.A. Peru's foreign ministry confirmed Saturday via social media that it had repatriated the children back to Los Angeles via Mexico City to be reunited with their mother's family. Sheylla Cabrera's mother, Helga Rocillo, told Latina Noticias that her daughter was intent on filing a criminal report against her husband due to alleged psychological and physical abuse. 'She told me that Jossimar Cabrera Cornejo hit her, mistreated her, and even slapped my youngest grandchild, who is 3 years old,' Rocillo told the outlet. Both the L.A. County Sheriff Department's public information officer and the Montrose rescue squad declined to answer questions from The Times. They directed all inquiries to Sheriff's Department detectives, who did not return a call Tuesday. Read more: Man is abducted from Cheviot Hills home, released in Glendale, in a case of mistaken identity, police say Sheriff's detectives are in the process of presenting the case to the L.A. County district attorney's office for filing consideration, and plan to seek a murder charge against Jossimar Cabrera, authorities said. Sign up for Essential California for news, features and recommendations from the L.A. Times and beyond in your inbox six days a week. This story originally appeared in Los Angeles Times. Solve the daily Crossword
Yahoo
3 hours ago
- Yahoo
Julio César Chávez Jr. deported to Mexico for alleged cartel ties and drug trafficking
MEXICO CITY (AP) — Boxer Julio César Chávez Jr. has been deported to Mexico, where he's wanted for alleged cartel ties, following his arrest in the U.S. for overstaying his visa and lying on a green card application. Chávez was handed over by authorities and admitted to a prison outside of the city of Hermosillo, in the northern state of Sonora, an official told The Associated Press on condition of anonymity Tuesday because they were not authorized to speak publicly about the matter. Mexican President Claudia Sheinbaum confirmed the news at her daily press conference. 'I understand he was deported. I don't know if it was yesterday or this morning, but we were informed that he was arriving in Mexico," Sheinbaum said. Chávez, 39, had a warrant for his arrest in Mexico for alleged arms and drug trafficking and ties to the Sinaloa Cartel. Alejandro Gertz Manero, Mexico's attorney general, said the investigation into Chávez started in 2019. The boxer, who is the son of legendary Mexican boxer Julio César Chávez, was arrested July 3 days after his high-profile fight with Jake Paul in California. Sheinbaum said after the arrest she hoped the boxer would be deported to face his charges. Chávez's father was a massive celebrity in the 1980s and '90s who mixed social circles with drug dealers and claimed to have been friends with drug lord Amado Carrillo Fuentes. The iconic fighter defended his son following his arrest, but has not spoken since the deportation. The younger Chávez has battled drug addiction for much of his boxing career, failing drug tests, serving suspensions and egregiously missing weight while being widely criticized for his intermittent dedication to the sport. Chavez won the WBC middleweight title in 2011 and defended it three times. He shared the ring with generational greats Canelo Álvarez and Sergio Martinez, losing to both. In 2012, he was convicted of drunken driving in Los Angeles and sentenced to 13 days in jail. In January 2024, he was arrested on gun charges. Police said he possessed two AR-style ghost rifles. He was later freed on a $50,000 bond and on condition he went to a residential drug treatment facility. The case is still pending, with Chávez reporting his progress regularly. ___ AP boxing: Solve the daily Crossword
Chicago Tribune
4 hours ago
- Chicago Tribune
Boxer Julio César Chávez Jr. deported to Mexico for alleged cartel ties and drug trafficking
MEXICO CITY — Boxer Julio César Chávez Jr. has been deported to Mexico, where he's wanted for alleged cartel ties, following his arrest in the U.S. for overstaying his visa and lying on a green card application. Chávez was handed over by authorities and admitted to a prison outside of the city of Hermosillo, in the northern state of Sonora, an official told The Associated Press on condition of anonymity Tuesday because they were not authorized to speak publicly about the matter. Mexican President Claudia Sheinbaum confirmed the news at her daily press conference. 'I understand he was deported. I don't know if it was yesterday or this morning, but we were informed that he was arriving in Mexico,' Sheinbaum said. Chávez, 39, had a warrant for his arrest in Mexico for alleged arms and drug trafficking and ties to the Sinaloa Cartel. Alejandro Gertz Manero, Mexico's attorney general, said the investigation into Chávez started in 2019. The boxer, who is the son of legendary Mexican boxer Julio César Chávez, was arrested July 3 days after his high-profile fight with Jake Paul in California. Sheinbaum said after the arrest she hoped the boxer would be deported to face his charges. Chávez's father was a massive celebrity in the 1980s and '90s who mixed social circles with drug dealers and claimed to have been friends with drug lord Amado Carrillo Fuentes. The iconic fighter defended his son following his arrest, but has not spoken since the deportation. The younger Chávez has battled drug addiction for much of his boxing career, failing drug tests, serving suspensions and egregiously missing weight while being widely criticized for his intermittent dedication to the sport. Chavez won the WBC middleweight title in 2011 and defended it three times. He shared the ring with generational greats Canelo Álvarez and Sergio Martinez, losing to both. In 2012, he was convicted of drunken driving in Los Angeles and sentenced to 13 days in jail. In January 2024, he was arrested on gun charges. Police said he possessed two AR-style ghost rifles. He was later freed on a $50,000 bond and on condition he went to a residential drug treatment facility. The case is still pending, with Chávez reporting his progress regularly.
