
The worry lines in Air India Flight AI171 crash preliminary report
'The Boeing Company received reports from operators of Model 737 airplanes that the fuel-control switches were installed with the locking feature disengaged,' states the 2018 FAA advisory, detailing: 'The fuel-control switch has a locking feature to prevent inadvertent operation that could result in unintended switch movement between the fuel supply and fuel cut-off positions. In order to move the switch from one position to the other, under the condition where the locking feature is engaged, it is necessary for the pilot to lift the switch up while transitioning the switch position. If the locking feature is disengaged, the switch can be moved between the two positions without lifting the switch during transition, and the switch would be exposed to the potential of inadvertent operation. Inadvertent operation of the switch could result in an unintended consequence, such as an in-flight engine shutdown.'In the case of Flight AI171, the sequence captured by the aircraft's digital flight data recorder (DFDR) and cockpit voice recorder (CVR) is tragically brief. At 08:08:35 UTC (Universal Time Coordinated)—that is around 1:38 pm IST (Indian Standard Time)—the Dreamliner rotated at 155 knots. Four seconds later, it was airborne. Then, within the span of a single heartbeat—one second—both engine fuel cut-off switches abruptly transitioned from 'RUN' to 'CUT-OFF'. Engine parameters immediately began to slip.advertisementThe CVR preserves the stunned disbelief in the cockpit. Captain Sabharwal's voice, sharp with alarm: 'Why have the engines shut down?' To which First Officer Kunder's response that 'I did not do it'. During examination of the wreckage, both thrust levers were found near idle position while the Enhanced Airborne Flight Recorder (EAFR) data shows they remained forward—at take-off thrust—until impact. It also notes that both fuel-control switches were found in 'RUN' position.What followed midair on Flight AI171 was a desperate, 30-second battle against physics. The aircraft's Ram Air Turbine (RAT) deployed automatically, a small propeller dropping into the airstream to generate minimal hydraulic and electrical power. The auxiliary power unit inlet door opened as its auto-start sequence engaged. Engine 1 managed to relight, its core speed clawing back upward. But Engine 2 stubbornly refused, its core speed continuing to plummet despite repeated automated fuel-flow commands.With insufficient thrust and altitude, the jetliner became a gliding tomb. At 08:09:05 UTC (1:39 pm IST), a terse 'Mayday' call crackled over the Air Traffic Control radio. Seconds later, Flight AI171, still heavy with fuel, slammed into a densely packed residential suburb just beyond the Ahmedabad airport perimeter. The impact and ensuing fireball were catastrophic.advertisementThe wreckage, scattered over 300 meters, told a grim story: initial contact inside an Army Medical Corps compound, shearing through trees, obliterating the northeast wall of a hostel, carving a path of destruction through five residential blocks before the fuselage disintegrated. The vertical stabiliser lay 60 meters from the first impact point; engines and landing gear were embedded in roads and buildings. All 241 people on board were killed, besides 19 people on the ground.In the charred aftermath, teams of investigators from the government's Aircraft Accident Investigation Bureau (AAIB), with assistance from the Directorate General of Civil Aviation (DGCA), the US National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB), Boeing and engine-maker GE Aviation, descended upon the site. Drones captured the extent of the damage. Critical information emerged: the flap handle was set at five degrees; the landing gear lever was in down position, as it would be during take-off. Particularly, the mechanical control levers were found jammed in full forward position.This supported the DFDR information, which indicated that full power had been activated down to the final milliseconds of the flight. Its throttle-control module had been replaced twice, once in 2019 and again in 2023, maintenance logs showed. However, there was no information in the logs about reported faults concerning the latches.advertisementMore importantly, neither throttle-control module replacement prompted the specific inspections recommended in the 2018 FAA bulletin. Since the FAA action was not a mandatory airworthiness directive, compliance was left to the operator's discretion. 'We continue to fully cooperate with the AAIB and other authorities as their investigation progresses. Given the active nature of the investigation, we are unable to comment on specific details and refer all such enquiries to the AAIB,' Air India has said in a statement.The preliminary report on the crash, adhering to the International Civil Aviation Organisation (ICAO) principle of prioritising safety over blame, carefully avoids finger-pointing. It outlines the ongoing forensic work: detailed laboratory analysis of the recovered latches and switches; fuel samples and engine components; intense scrutiny of the 49 hours of flight data and two hours of cockpit audio; simulations testing the latching mechanism's integrity under stress; studies of system behaviour during sudden, catastrophic thrust loss; and evaluations of the human-machine interface during critical phases such as take-off.For the hundreds of families whose lives were forever altered by the deaths in air and on the ground, the lack of closure to the Flight AI171 crash is a bitter truth. But it will come, eventually. Aviation safety experts, however, say the real worth of this investigation will not be in punishment but prevention.advertisementAs one former pilot acknowledged: 'If a latch failure, and such an unannounced one at that, can kill both engines at the worst time, you had better understand why and how it happened.' Because every operator of these planes and every passenger boarding them deserves to know.Subscribe to India Today Magazine- EndsMust Watch
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
&w=3840&q=100)

First Post
2 hours ago
- First Post
Southwest flight plunges after takeoff in near-miss with another aircraft; FAA launches probe
A Southwest Airlines flight from Burbank to Las Vegas plunged 300 feet seconds after takeoff to avoid a possible midair collision with a nearby fighter jet, leaving two flight attendants injured and passengers in shock. The FAA has launched an investigation read more A Southwest Airlines airplane travelling from Southern California to Las Vegas plunged dramatically shortly after takeoff on Friday in response to a warning about a plane nearby, sending several passengers flying out of their seats and injuring two flight attendants. Stef Zamorano, who was going to Las Vegas with her husband to celebrate his birthday, reported that the plane shook abruptly immediately after takeoff and seemed like it was falling. Zamorano saw a woman who wasn't wearing a seat belt shoot up and out of her seat. The man sat next to her was grabbing her arm, and she said the woman across the aisle was terrified. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD 'She was pretty much verbalizing how we all felt, saying, 'I want to get off this plane. I want to be on the ground,' " Zamorano told The Associated Press. Data from the flight tracking site FlightAware shows it dropped roughly 300 feet (91.44 meters) in 36 seconds. The Federal Aviation Administration said the flight, Southwest 1496, was responding to an onboard alert about another aircraft in its vicinity. The FAA is investigating. Southwest said the crew responded to two alerts that required the pilot to climb then descend. The flight departed from Hollywood Burbank Airport just before noon. Still in shock, Zamorano said she could hardly make out what the pilot was saying when he later addressed the passengers. Another passenger, comedian Jimmy Dore, posted on X that the pilot mentioned a near miss. 'Pilot said his collision warning went off & he needed to avoid plane coming at us,' Dore posted. The plane was in the same airspace near Burbank as a Hawker Hunter Mk. 58 just after noon local time, FlightAware shows. A Hawker Hunter is a British fighter plane. Records show it is owned by Hawker Hunter Aviation, a British defense contracting company. The company didn't immediately respond to messages seeking comment. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD Mike Christensen, an airport spokesman for Hollywood Burbank, said that neither the control tower nor the operations department, which tracks planes departing and arriving, have any record of the Southwest flight plunging in their airspace. Southwest said the flight continued to Las Vegas, 'where it landed uneventfully.' The airline said that it is working with the FAA 'to further understand the circumstances' of the event. This close call is just the latest incident to raise questions about aviation safety in the wake of January's midair collision over Washington, D.C., that killed 67 people.
&w=3840&q=100)

Business Standard
2 hours ago
- Business Standard
Air India pays interim compensation to kin of 166 Ahmedabad crash victims
The plane crash, one of the worst air disasters in India in decades, involved a Boeing 787-8 Dreamliner operating as Air India flight AI171 Press Trust of India Mumbai

Mint
3 hours ago
- Mint
AI-717 plane crash: Air India disburses interim compensation of ₹25 lakh to 166 families
Almost one and a half month after the tragic plane crash in Ahmedabad, Air India on Saturday said that they have disbursed interim compensation of ₹ 25 lakh each to 166 families affected by the AI-717 crash. Releasing an official press release on the website, Air India said that so far AI released the interim compensation to the families of 147 of the 229 deceased passengers and also the 19 who lost their lives at the accident site. "Air India has, so far, released the interim compensation to the families of 147 of the 229 deceased passengers and also the 19 who lost their lives at the accident site," Air India said in a statement. The airliner added, among other things, that the requisite documents of 52 others have been verified, and the interim compensation to those families will be released progressively. The private airliner, run by Tata Group, said that they stands in solidarity with the families affected by the AI171 accident. "We continue to mourn their loss and remain fully committed to providing support during this difficult time," Air India said. Air India also said Tata Group has also registered 'The AI-171 Memorial and Welfare Trust' which is dedicated to the victims of the tragic accident. It added that Tata Trust pledged an ex gratia payment of ₹ 1 crore in respect of each of the deceased and would support for rebuilding the B.J. Medical College Hostel infrastructure. Air India also mentioned that Tata Trust will provide aid and assistance to alleviate any trauma or distress suffered by the first responders, medical and disaster relief professionals, social workers, and governmental staff who provided invaluable institutional support and service in the aftermath of the accident. Earlier on 12 June, Air India flight AI-717 from Ahmedabad to London's Gatwick crashed moments after taking off from Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel International Airport. In the tragic crash, 241 passengers and 19 people on ground were killed.