Child-care centres are popping up all over Edmonton. But not everyone is in favour
When Wanda Johnston first learned that a home in her quiet Canossa neighbourhood in north Edmonton would be converted into a child-care centre, she was upset.
The approved permit allows for a facility serving up to 34 children inside a 1,486-square-foot home. But Johnston worries about the extra traffic in a community she says is already strained for space.
"We're a quiet neighbourhood, you've got 26 houses, 13 on each street. Parking is already an issue," Johnston said in an interview.
"You can't have 40-plus vehicles plus eight staff trying to find parking, you just can't."
Johnston filed an appeal against the development, citing major concerns over traffic, noise, waste disposal, and parking congestion. That appeal was denied last month by the Subdivision and Development Appeal Board.
CBC reached out to the owner of the proposed daycare site but he declined to comment.
Zoning bylaw renewal
The number of child-care centres approved for residential neighbourhoods in Edmonton has sharply risen in 2024, due in large part to the city's zoning bylaw renewal, which came into effect in January 2024.
Under the new bylaw, child-care services are now permitted use in most standard zones — including small-scale residential areas. That marks a major shift from the previous bylaw, which treated such developments as discretionary, subject to longer review times and more opportunity for resident objections.
In 2024, the city approved 26 child-care centres in residential buildings in small-scale residential zones. The city said in total, 204 development permits were approved for child-care services last year, which is about double the number approved in each of the previous five years
'We need more spaces'
Coun. Michael Janz, who chairs the city's urban planning committee, said expanding neighbourhood-based child care is essential to meet demand.
"We've been short child-care spaces," Janz said in an interview last week. "Some families have been having to go outside of their neighbourhood to find child care."
Janz supports smaller, locally rooted options as opposed to massive "mega-centres."
"Eventually, what I hope we get towards is less of the big mega child-care centres, and more small neighbourhood-based opportunities so that wherever you are in Edmonton, wherever your family is, there can be a child-care option that's accessible and affordable and close to you," he said in an interview.
Krystal Churcher is the co-chair of ACE National — a movement that promotes and advocates for affordable and accessible child care. She said the province has a big need for more child-care spaces.
"Alberta has seen substantial growth," she said in an interview last month. "I believe that there are families desperately needing child care."
Parking, noise, and waste: a growing debate
Johnston's concerns go beyond parking and traffic. According to a proposed site plan, waste bins for the child-care centre may be located along the side of the property, right by her walkway to her backyard.
She also worries about noise from outdoor play disrupting neighbours, especially those who work from home or do shift work.
Erin Rutherford, city councillor for the Ward Anirniq, which includes the Canossa neighbourhood, said the property follows the guidelines needed to develop the centre.
"That one was specific to what was allowed in our zoning bylaw and what we have done is we said that those child-care centres when they're in residential areas are really limited in size so that is where the mitigation factor has come in," she said.
The city commissioned a traffic study, conducted as part of a one-year review of child care services.
It found that "less than half of pick-up and drop-off spaces were used during peak periods", and that "17 per cent of trips to and from centres were made by walking or cycling".
Still, the report noted that corner lots are the most suitable for day homes due to traffic flow.
Limited options for appeals
Under the new bylaw, many child-care centres that meet zoning regulations are considered permitted use, leaving residents with fewer avenues to formally oppose them.
Once Johnston had filed her appeal, she typed up a newsletter and went door-to-door to residents in her neighbourhood, encouraging them to appeal or submit their comments.
"There's not one person I spoke to that was in favour of this child care, simply the parking, the noise, the waste, it's just too big."
Johnston said Edmontonians need to have their voices heard on these types of developments.
"To say in that [zoning] renewal that they want to give Edmontonians what they want, how can you give Edmontonians what they want if you're now having all these permitted uses which takes away the voice of Edmontonians, so how do you know what they want?"
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CTV News
24 minutes ago
- CTV News
N.B. industry to resume some operations on crown land
Some businesses will be permitted to re-enter New Brunswick's Crown lands to resume operations under strict conditions. Earlier this month the government implemented a burn ban for the entire province and closed all Crown lands. As of Tuesday afternoon, there are 28 active wildfires burning in the province, five of which are deemed out of control. Each business will now require a permit to operate, and must follow all rules regarding location of work, operating hours and conditions, as well as enhance fire safety measures. One example provided by the province in a news release says tree cutting will only be allowed between the hours of 8 p.m. and 10 a.m. No activity will be allowed in any active fire zone. 'While our top priority continues to be safety, we recognize the need to support the return of operations by industry on Crown lands,' said Natural Resources Minister John Herron in the news release. 'Many New Brunswick businesses rely on our Crown forests. These firms employ many New Brunswickers. We have struck the right balance between assisting these companies and protecting our forests. Starting today, specific industry activities – with appropriate conditions to mitigate fire and safety risks – will be permitted to operate. This will ensure certain industries will not face a full shutdown.' While industry will resume some operations, restrictions on all other activities remain on Crown lands. That includes all recreational activities such as campfires and the use of all-terrain vehicles. Speaking to reporters Monday, Herron said roughly 2,500 hectares of land have been lost, or are at risk, which translates to about $4 million in royalty revenue. He said timber would represent about $10.5 million in direct and indirect tax revenue to the government from the forest sector value chain. 'That timber would represent roughly $42.5 million in lumber revenue to sawmills and overall, from a GDP perspective, it would be about $77.5 million,' said Herron, noting those figures are on the higher end as they assume every hectare is comprised of merchantable wood. The news to resume activities is welcomed by woodlot owners in the province. President of the New Brunswick Federation of Woodlot Owners Rick Doucett says the past few weeks have been very challenging for the forestry sector. 'We just sort of got up off the floor from a punch in the face with the new anti-dumping fees,' says Doucett. 'And we got punched in the face again with our weather conditions that are making things that are inoperable for us.' 'Basically we live in a world where no production, no pay, and there's no provision to try to help people bridge that gap.' He notes some private woodlots owners did sustain damage to their property from recent fires in the province. With the allowed resumption of work in the woods, woodlot owners will once again be able to supply mills with timber. Some mills in the province were running low on wood according to Herron. While the shutdown was challenging, Doucett says those who own woodlots understand and support the decision for a brief halt of operations. 'I own 500 acres of woodland in this province, and it's not insured,' he notes. 'That's like having your bank account out there and then having somebody set it on fire. So, it's a big financial risk to woodland owners to have anything happen and there are no provisions for forest fires.' Once the fires fizzle out in the province, Doucett would like to see the province reevaluate its forest plan. He says the last time the plan was looked at was back in 2014. With files from CTV's Andrea Jerrett. For more New Brunswick news, visit our dedicated provincial page.
CTV News
24 minutes ago
- CTV News
Goh Ballet Academy proposes 25-storey student accommodation tower for Vancouver
Goh Ballet have proposed a new 25-storey tower to the City of Vancouver. (Courtesy: Goh Ballet Academy rezoning application) Vancouver's prestigious Goh Ballet Academy might soon have an even more prominent presence on Vancouver's urban landscape and arts and culture scene, if a request for expansion is given the green light. The arts organization has submitted a rezoning application to the City of Vancouver for a 25-storey, mixed-use highrise building that will expand upon its current site at 2345 Main Street. The current building has been occupied by the dance company since 1985. 'As Goh Ballet looks to the future, it is clear that its current home requires redevelopment, not only to grow but also to stay in place,' Goh Ballet says in the application. Goh Ballet proposes building expansion in Vancouver The building will expand on Goh Ballet's current Main Street location. (Courtesy: Goh Ballet Academy rezoning application) The expansion will allow the academy to essentially double its operations, raising the number of students it would be capable of serving annually from 450 to 890, and increasing the number of performances it can host at the site. The vast majority of those students, 85 per cent, are from Canada, with most of those from the Vancouver area. Chan Hon Goh, general and artistic director of the Goh Ballet, says the intake of international students averages between 20 to 30 students a year. The amount of international and out of town students that enroll typically depends on what accommodation opportunities are available, with students often battling it out for rental properties or already minimally available homestays, he says. 'Cities along the west coast of North America and Vancouver, in particular, suffer from an acute shortage of student housing that has broader implications for their housing markets,' says Hon Goh. 'In Vancouver, there is currently no dance academy offering accredited vocational studies that also provides residences for students. Goh Ballet will be the first, though most other major Canadian cities - Montreal, Toronto, Winnipeg, Calgary - already have this.' Goh Ballet proposes building expansion in Vancouver The upgrade will preserve heritage elements of the building alongside incorporating contemporary design and seismic upgrades. (Courtesy: Goh Ballet Academy rezoning application) According to the application, the proposed student housing will be entirely rental, available at market rates to students, staff, and faculty, for the duration of their studies. Alongside over 300 units of student housing, the building will also include a fitness centre, amenity lounge, an outdoor rooftop terrace and street level retail, alongside additional dance rehearsal studios and performance spaces. The arts organization promises to conserve the building's historic facades, specifically the decorative pilasters and the matte, terracotta panels that have fronted both Main Street and East 8th Avenue since the building was first built, as a branch of the Royal Bank of Canada in 1912. The new tower, however, has been designed to 'clearly distinguish itself' from the restored heritage facade that will sit below it, the application says. Led by Align Architecture, the building will incorporate elements of Chinese design that pay homage to the faculty's founders, principal dancers with the National Ballet of China, Choo Chiat Goh and Lin Yee Goh. Circular portal windows and moongate door entries, also inspired by the soft movements of ballet, will feature alongside local artworks in the form of two, large scale murals. 'Because the design integrates the existing heritage building at grade that has already been part of its neighbourhood for many years, the project effortlessly blends with the current and future condition of Mount Pleasant,' says Hon Goh. 'The design further incorporates murals as a way of building on Mount Pleasant's tradition of transforming blank walls into vibrant public art, contributing to the neighbourhood's established mural culture.' Located approximately 100 metres from the planned Mount Pleasant SkyTrain station, expected to open late 2027 after a push back last year, the proposed building will fall within the city's Broadway Plan. While its expected height of 223 feet is greater than the limit permitted in the plan, the proposal is in keeping with it as far as everything else is concerned, the academy assures in the application. It notes how the redevelopment of the building will aid in the retention and growth of the arts and culture sector, will address housing concerns, provide heritage value, and will provide jobs. 'Goh Ballet has been an important cultural institution in Vancouver for almost 50 years and this redevelopment will help us continue to contribute to arts and culture and education in our city for many more years,' says Hon Goh.
CBC
25 minutes ago
- CBC
Ontario signals changes to fund that helps municipalities get housing built
Ontario is planning to make changes to a housing fund for municipalities that many have said unfairly measures their progress on building, the minister signalled in a speech Tuesday. Rob Flack told the Association of Municipalities of Ontario conference in Ottawa that he will consult with mayors and the association to "extend and improve" the Building Faster Fund. "That includes ensuring the fund reflects the new market we are in, as well as encouraging municipalities to cut development charges and get shovels in the ground faster on key infrastructure projects," he said. The fund rewards municipalities that achieve at least 80 per cent of a housing target the provincial government assigns and gives them money to put toward housing-enabling infrastructure — often coming by way of a novelty cheque from Flack or Premier Doug Ford. This past year, just 23 of the 50 municipalities with assigned targets hit their thresholds, down sharply from 32 the previous year. Ontario using 'faulty data' to count units: Clarington mayor Some municipalities say rewarding or leaving out cities and towns based on when construction starts is unfair, because while municipalities are responsible for approvals, they can't control when a builder starts a project. Clarington, Ont., missed qualifying for what the mayor said would be $4 million in funding by just 13 housing units. "All of the big city mayors have the same concern," Mayor Adrian Foster said in a recent interview. "I think Clarington has something like 7,000 permits that could be pulled, or very easily pulled by developers with a minimal amount of work. We can't force developers to pull the permits even after we've approved those permits. So there are a variety of problems with using starts. "We're being held accountable for something we can't control, and not getting credit for the stuff that we can control." Foster said Clarington actually surpassed the 80 per cent threshold, but Ontario is using faulty data based on an undercount by the Canada Mortgage and Housing Corp. He is hopeful that discussions about it with the province will remedy the issue, but is frustrated because the same issue happened last year, with Clarington not qualifying for the funding at first. "It is deja vu all over again," he said. The fund is one of many ways the government has been trying to spur home building, as Ontario is well off the pace of home building that's needed to achieve Ford's goal of getting 1.5 million homes built by 2031. Ontario only reached about 75 per cent of its interim target for getting 125,000 homes built in 2024, even after it tacked on about 20,000 long-term care beds, retirement home suites, post-secondary student housing beds and additional residential units to its count of traditional housing starts. CMHC figures released Monday show the country's annual pace of housing starts in July rose four per cent year-over-year, but in Ontario there was a decline of 28 per cent. Ford announced Monday at the conference that the province is putting $1.6 billion more toward the Municipal Housing Infrastructure Program, which helps municipalities get housing built.
