Misinformation resurfaces about Canadian aid to refugees
"This should make you angry at Liberals," says an April 20, 2025 Facebook post.
The post shows a photo of top Liberal Party politicians, including Prime Minister Mark Carney.
"The average canada pension recipient gets $1200/mo after working 50+ years," text over the picture says. "The average 'refugee' gets $3874/month after being in Canada for 1 day."
Image
Screenshot of a Facebook post taken April 24, 2025
The image, which also spread across X and Threads, appears to trace to a TikTok video with more than 500,000 views.
Carney won Canada's April 28 election, securing another mandate for the Liberal Party, after replacing Justin Trudeau, who resigned following a decade of power.
An open immigration policy was a pillar of Trudeau's government, fulfilling a key campaign promise by resettling tens of thousands of Syrian refugees. became scarce and rents rose, the policy became unpopular. In 2024, his government announced sharp cuts to immigration (archived here).
Polling conducted for local media showed immigration ranked seventh among issues concerning Canadian voters, in a race dominated by US President Donald Trump's tariff war and threats to the country's .
Carney's Liberal Party said it plans to stabilize permanent resident admissions at less than one percent of Canada's population annually beyond 2027, while maintaining its "global leadership in prioritizing the world's most vulnerable, including human rights defenders and refugees" (archived here).
But the figures comparing pension benefits paid to Canadian workers with aid offered to refugees are inaccurate -- and have circulated online for years.
2025 pension benefits
Canada's government administers both the Canada Pension Plan (CPP) and the Old Age Security (OAS) pension.
In Québec province, workers participate in the mandatory Québec Pension Plan in place of the CPP.
Depending on the age a person begins collecting and their average earnings throughout life, Canadians can receive a maximum of $1,433 each month from the CPP, according to the government's website (archived here). As of October 2024, the average CPP pension was $899.67 per month.
Image
Screenshot taken April 28, 2025 of average CCP benefits on the government of Canada's website (Marisha GOLDHAMER)
OAS pensions are paid to seniors 65 or older who lived in Canada for 10 years after the age of 18, regardless of whether or not they (archived here). They are calculated based on income , with the maximum monthly payment capped at $727.67 for people between the ages of 65 and 74 with a net income less than $142,609.
Canadians earning less than $22,056 also qualify for a Guaranteed Income Supplement of up to $1,086.88 (archived here).
Combined, the OAS and Guaranteed Income Supplement benefits can reach a maximum monthly payment of $1813.55.
Guaranteed Income Supplement payment amounts are reviewed quarterly to ensure that they reflect cost of living increases, as measured by the Consumer Price Index. The government does not decrease payment rates if the cost of living goes down.
Direct support to refugees
A person cannot apply directly to Canada for resettlement. Refugees are identified for resettlement by the or private sponsors (archived here).
who are processed when they ask for protection at a port of entry or after entering the country (archived here).
AFP first examined the false assertion that refugees receive $3,874 each month in 2019 and found that the number came from an invoice detailing a one-time start-up allowance and other assistance granted not to a single refugee, but to a family of five.
In all provinces except Québec, refugees receive a one-time payment to establish a household, including help to get utilities installed, purchase furniture and an allowance to obtain proper winter clothing (archived here). The funding increased in September 2024 and now ranges from $3,197.89 for an individual to $9,326.16 for a couple with four dependants (archived here).
Additional funds of $157.13 per child are also provided to families attending provincial schools.
In addition to the start-up allowance, the Resettlement Assistance Program provides refugees with monthly aid, but only for a maximum of one year (archived here). The support is based on the prevailing provincial social assistance rates and is intended to cover basic needs and shelter.
In Alberta, for example, a single adult would receive $536 to cover basic needs and $330 for shelter. If the same individual settled in Ontario, they would collect $343 for basic needs and $390 for shelter, with the shelter assistance jumping to $522 in the Greater Toronto and Hamilton Area (archived here). the monthly allowance is less than the average CPP payment.
The largest monthly allowance for an individual refugee was $1,361 in Prince Edward Island, and the smallest was in New Brunswick at $571 (archived here and here). When actual housing expenses exceed the basic shelter allowance, an addition of up to $200 per month may be provided.
Monthly aid increases based on the number of members in a family and may also include special allowances for pregnancy or to aid with a newborn baby.
also qualify for a monthly communication allowance of across jurisdictions. Adults get transportation passes in metropolitan areas such as Vancouver, Calgary, Winnipeg and Toronto, while a flat rate of $82.97 is given to those settling in communities that lack public transit.
Individuals and groups who privately sponsor refugees can also step in for the government by agreeing to support a refugee (archived here and here).
Fine more of AFP's reporting on misinformation in Canada here.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
France 24
2 days ago
- France 24
Panama launches maintenance work at contested mine
Central America's biggest copper mine, the Canadian-owned Cobre Panama pit, closed in 2023 following weeks of crippling protests over its environmental impact. Maintenance will be carried out by a subsidiary of Canada's First Quantum Minerals "to prevent environmental damage" from materials stored at the mine, Trade and Industry Minister Julio Molto told a news conference. "This decision (...) does not imply the reactivation of the mine," Molto said. First Quantum Minerals said it would finance the work by exporting 121,000 tonnes of copper concentrate stored at the site since it closed down. Panama's President Jose Raul Mulino said last month that his government was working toward reopening the mine, without clarifying how he plans to tackle legal hurdles. The country's Supreme Court ruled in November 2023 that a contract allowing First Quantum Minerals to continue operating the site was unconstitutional. Environmentalist Raisa Banfield criticized Friday's announcement as the Canadian giant "can't manage the mine." She called for an external audit to "establish the definitive closure plan." Cobre Panama, which began operations in 2019, had produced about 300,000 tonnes of copper concentrate a year, representing 75 percent of the country's exports and about five percent of its national economic output. It employed around 37,000 workers directly and indirectly.
AFP
2 days ago
- AFP
No evidence of mandatory face scans for Canadians at US border
"Facial recognition checks now mandatory for Canadians entering the U.S. by car," reads the text inside a May 19, 2025 Facebook photo. The caption accompanying the image, which was also shared on TikTok, claims new border screening procedures would include photographing travelers for the purposes of verifying their identification documents. Separate posts spread similar claims about required facial recognition scans for Canadians at land border crossings on Facebook and Instagram. Image Screenshot of a Facebook post taken May 30, 2025 With an emphasis on immigration enforcement, have been marked by concerns of potentially unlawful deportations and moves to scrap the longstanding birthright citizenship policy. The president's occupation with border security precipitated trade tensions with Canada, after he alleged his country's northern neighbor fails to stop the dangerous drug fentanyl and undocumented migrants from reaching the United States. The changing relationship between the two countries already led to misleading claims about commerce and travel, and the rumor that Canadians would now be subjected to mandatory facial recognition scans are similarly . Recent reporting from the tech magazine Wired found CBP was planning to photograph every traveler entering and exiting the United States in personal vehicles to match their face to their identification documents (archived here and here). According to the CBP website, biometric data collection, which can include face scans and fingerprinting, is currently in testing for entries by vehicles at border crossings into Buffalo, New York and Brownsville, Texas (archived here and here). Publications from the CBP about the Buffalo and Brownsville crossings, as well as a report on a testing period for the technology at entry points into Arizona and Texas, said the system would attempt to take photos of each occupant of a vehicle entering through certain marked lanes but that travelers may still opt out of the data collection by crossing the border through different gates (archived here, here and here). Image Screenshot of a US Customs and Border Control report taken May 30, 2025 Expanding biometric collection (archived here). Len Saunders, an immigration lawyer practicing in Blaine, Washington close to the border with British Columbia (archived here), said he had seen travelers prompted to take face scans at nearby crossings when entering on foot, but not by car. "Are they going to hold up a camera and take everyone's picture? Well, if they do that it's going to delay the whole process," Saunders said. Wired reported the system testing was still turning out errors and that CBP was calling for pitches from tech companies for tools which could scan the faces of people inside vehicles. US citizens have the option to refuse scans at pedestrian land and air entr (archived here). The fact-checking organization Snopes reported Canadian and Bermudian passport holders travelling to the United States for tourism are not required to provide biometric data. The Government of Canada's online travel advice states most Canadian citizens entering the United States are exempt from biometric collection except those who require a visa or documentation of their arrival and exit dates (archived here). For Saunders, new facial recognition procedures do not necessarily raise privacy concerns as travelers already consent to screening when they cross a border, but he said the addition of data collection categories could be "a slippery slope." Read more AFP's reporting on misinformation and disinformation in Canada here.
France 24
2 days ago
- France 24
Hundreds of deepfake music videos are celebrating the resident of Burkina Faso… why?
What do Beyoncé, Rihanna, R. Kelly, Selena Gomez and Eminem have in common -- besides being world famous singers? They also all appear to have recorded a version of a banger called 'God Protect Ibrahim Traoré ' and posted it on YouTube, Facebook, and TikTok. It is an ode to the glory of the president of Burkina Faso, who came to power in a coup d'état in September 2022. As gospel music plays in the background, the music video shows the president of Burkina Faso comforting a wounded man and being cheered on by a crowd of kids. 'God protect Ibrahim Traoré, stand him in your grace, give him wisdom, give him strength to lead this fragile place,' go the lyrics in the version supposedly featuring American singer R. Kelly. R. Kelly can be seen riding a motorcycle as a burst of gunfire explodes behind him. The song goes on to refer to the Islamist insurrection affecting both Burkina Faso and other countries in the Sahel: Jihadist storms have raged too long Displacing hearts and homes Oh Lord, we need your justice now In these blood-stained zones. Later on in the music video, Rihanna appears, calling for "five more years of soldier's rule', thus showing her support for keeping Ibrahim Traoré and his military junta in power. Hundreds of comments in English appear below the music video that supposedly shows R. Kelly and Rihanna, most featuring glowing messages of support for Traoré. They were written by social media users who say they are from English-speaking African nations including Kenya, Tanzania, South Africa, Nigeria, Zimbabwe, Uganda and Malawi. It is impossible to say if these messages were published by social media users or if they are part of the disinformation campaign. In total, our team counted at least fifteen different versions of 'God Protect Ibrahim Traoré' on Youtube, all in English, and all featuring deepfake celebrities singing odes to the Burkina Faso president. AI created music videos However, all of the many versions of 'God Protect Ibrahim Traoré' are deepfakes. They are poor quality, not very realistic -- in fact, they all look like video games. Aside from that, there are other clues that they were AI-generated. The face of one man in the crowd is deformed. The banner featuring Traoré's name has illegible letters on it -- AI still struggles to create legible text on a photo. If you look at these videos on YouTube, they are actually described as 'altered or synthetic content', which means AI-generated. But even though these music videos are clearly false, a number of English-speaking influencers have fallen for them and continue to share them. Nancy Blaq, a Ghanaian influencer with 2.7 million followers, shared the version 'sung' by Beyoncé on Facebook. 'During her sold-out concert at Madison Square Garden last night, the global superstar paused between her chart-topping hits to deliver a message that left the audience in awe: 'God protect Ibrahim Traoré, protect Burkina Faso'', the influencer wrote in a post from May 10. The video was also shared on May 4 by a Facebook page said to be the Russian television channel Rossiya 1 Afrique. Pro-Traoré content has also been shared by social media users who support the Alliance of Sahel States (AES), which includes Mali, Niger and Burkina Faso. "Viva Ibrahim Traoré, Viva the Burkinabé army, Viva the AES army," wrote one pro-AES Facebook user in French along with the Beyoncé music video. 294 fake music videos shared by 127 YouTube channels Our team set out to determine just how widely these fake clips had been shared. To do so, we used a software program that enabled us to identify the fake pro-Traoré music videos published on YouTube and how many views they had obtained. While the first versions of 'God Protect Ibrahim Traoré' appeared on YouTube in March, most were published in early May. We counted at least 294 fake music videos that were posted on YouTube. Together, they obtained more than 8.6 million views. These videos were shared on at least 127 YouTube channels. Most of these chains were created recently and have existed for between six and two months. A fair number of them only contain pro-Ibrahim Traoré content, which suggests they were specifically created to support the Burkinabé president. AI was also used to create the page graphics for a number of these YouTube channels. For example, the text on the banners of some of them is gibberish, which can often happen with AI-generated images. 'It's clear that this is a coordinated campaign' 'It's clear that this is a coordinated campaign,' says Samba Dialimpa Badji, a researcher in disinformation and fact-checking at the University of Oslomet in Norway. 'Even if we don't have the elements to prove that Burkina Faso's government is behind this communication campaign, they are certainly benefiting from it.' The Burkina Faso government does not have a history of using AI to create fake videos en masse. "What we've observed up until now is that they mostly relied on influencers on social media -- WhatsApp, Facebook, Twitter -- who posted content glorifying Ibrahim Traoré or showing their support for the military junta in power in Burkina Faso. AI makes it possible to create fake content very rapidly, easily and in large quantity,' Dialimpa Badji added. 'There is no sign that real people are behind these posts,' says the researcher. 'It could be that the accounts sharing this content were also AI-created. One single person could easily do that: create different accounts on different social media platforms and create content in an automated way,' Dialimpa Badji said. Music videos made in Nigeria Our team was able to make contact with the person behind the YouTube channel where a clip called 'God Protect Ibrahim Traoré by R. Kelly" garnered more than 1.9 million views. The person claims to be the creator of this video, which checks with the date the video was created. The YouTuber, who is based in Nigeria, says he is an artist who specialises in using AI to create music videos. He said that he charges about $1,000 (€881) for each music video. He said that using AI to make videos honouring the president of Burkina Faso started out as a personal project. 'My motivation was that Ibrahim Traoré does what many African leaders don't do,' he said. 'I admire him a lot.' 'When people saw that these videos were going viral on my channel, they started asking me to make the same kind of video for them,' he said. 'So that's when I started charging for creating the music videos and promoting them.' The creator said that he was actually behind most of the popular music videos celebrating Ibrahim Traoré on YouTube and TikTok. We weren't able to verify this claim. He also did not respond to our questions about the identity of his sponsors. "The people behind this campaign probably looked for people who had the skills to create AI-generated content [like in Nigeria] where you can easily find someone to carry out this service,' Dialimpa Badji said. Was the publication of these music videos coordinated with Burkina Faso's government? Why was there a sudden explosion of pro-Traoré music videos in May? Interestingly, the Burkina Faso government launched a new communication campaign to up the profile of the president at the same time that many of these videos were posted online. On April 27, Burkina's Information Agency published a news brief boldly claiming that 'Captain Ibrahim Traoré [is] worshipped around the world'. As proof, the news agency cited a tweet by the well-known Ghanaian rapper, Sarkodie, who posted the message 'God Protect Ibrahim Traoré' on X on April 25 -- exactly the same phrase as the music videos. A few days later, on April 30, Burkina Faso's authorities declared a ' global day in support of Ibrahim Traoré', calling for people to take to the streets in Burkina Faso and abroad. The posting of these fake music videos seems coordinated with the communication campaign meant to promote Traoré's image, said Mathieu Pellerin, an analyst specialist in the Sahel region with International Crisis Group: 'Since taking office, President Traoré has been using direct references to Thomas Sankara, which give him an air of legitimacy, considering the Burkina Faso population's adoration for Sankara". Thomas Sankara was the revolutionary president of Burkina Faso who was assassinated in 1987. Even today, Sankara is an anti-colonial, pan-Africanist icon in Africa. "This aligns perfectly with the ideas that Traoré wants to represent for his country and beyond: popular uprising, a rupture with colonialism and imperialism in favour of sovereignty, both for Burkina Faso and in a pan-African sense. These are also the messages transmitted by this AI campaign, which is amplifying his message outside of Burkina Faso.' Videos aimed at an English-speaking public Most of these fake music videos promoting Ibrahim Traoré feature singers from the English-speaking world. This isn't by chance. According to the BBC, the users posting most content on X in support of Ibrahim Traoré are from the English-speaking world, including Nigeria, Kenya, South Africa and the United States. 'We've noticed that these posts are especially going viral in English-speaking countries. So I think that means that these countries have been targeted, probably in an attempt to break out of the straightjacket of the French-speaking world,' says Dialimpa Badji, 'They have probably concluded that in the French-speaking world, particularly in West Africa, a percentage of the public will already know about Traoré. And so perhaps that populations won't be as easy to manipulate with this type of content, because they know a bit already about the situation in the Sahel, in Burkina Faso, in Niger… where there is already a sort of defiance against those in power." 'This propaganda is probably meant to mask the failure of Traoré's security policies and to promote his political position both nationally and internationally, to reduce the chance that he might end up diplomatically isolated,' Pellerin says. 'He's had undeniable success with the latter, considering his popularity within the region and internationally. But I don't think that it is quite the same internally. Even though the president has a base of popular support, it seems like that has been eroding, considering the fact that the regime hasn't been able to restore security in the country. Not to mention the fact that increasing numbers of civilians have been arrested.' In recent weeks, Burkina Faso has suffered several setbacks in its fight against jihadists with JNIM, a terrorist group linked to Al Qaeda. 'Considering the success of this campaign, it wouldn't be surprising if other countries start using the same technique -- like Mali, for example, where disinformation is already rampant,' Dialimpa Badji said.
