U.S. judge rules in Meta's favour in authors' copyright lawsuit over AI training
A federal judge in San Francisco ruled on Wednesday for Meta Platforms META-Q against a group of authors who had argued that its use of their books without permission to train its artificial intelligence system infringed their copyrights.
U.S. District Judge Vince Chhabria said in his decision the authors had not presented enough evidence that Meta's AI would dilute the market for their work to show that the company's conduct was illegal under U.S. copyright law.
Chhabria also said, however, that using copyrighted work without permission to train AI would be unlawful in 'many circumstances,' splitting with another San Francisco judge who found on Monday in a separate lawsuit that Anthropic's AI training made 'fair use' of copyrighted materials.
'This ruling does not stand for the proposition that Meta's use of copyrighted materials to train its language models is lawful,' Chhabria said. 'It stands only for the proposition that these plaintiffs made the wrong arguments and failed to develop a record in support of the right one.'
A spokesperson for the authors' law firm Boies Schiller Flexner said that it disagreed with the judge's decision to rule for Meta despite the 'undisputed record' of the company's 'historically unprecedented pirating of copyrighted works.'
A Meta spokesperson said the company appreciated the decision and called fair use a 'vital legal framework' for building 'transformative' AI technology.
Canada, other countries struggling to come up with new rules for AI and copyright
Disney, Universal sue AI image-generator Midjourney for copyright infringement
The authors sued Meta in 2023, arguing the company misused pirated versions of their books to train its AI system Llama without permission or compensation.
The lawsuit is one of several copyright cases brought by writers, news outlets and other copyright owners against companies including OpenAI, Microsoft MSFT-Q and Anthropic over their AI training.
The legal doctrine of fair use allows the use of copyrighted works without the copyright owner's permission in some circumstances. It is a key defense for the tech companies.
Chhabria's decision is the second in the U.S. to address fair use in the context of generative AI, following U.S. District Judge William Alsup's ruling on the same issue in the Anthropic case.
AI companies argue their systems make fair use of copyrighted material by studying it to learn to create new, transformative content, and that being forced to pay copyright holders for their work could hamstring the burgeoning AI industry.
Copyright owners say AI companies unlawfully copy their work to generate competing content that threatens their livelihoods. Chhabria expressed sympathy for that argument during a hearing in May, which he reiterated on Wednesday.
The judge said generative AI had the potential to flood the market with endless images, songs, articles and books using a tiny fraction of the time and creativity that would otherwise be required to create them.
'So by training generative AI models with copyrighted works, companies are creating something that often will dramatically undermine the market for those works, and thus dramatically undermine the incentive for human beings to create things the old-fashioned way,' Chhabria said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Globe and Mail
18 minutes ago
- Globe and Mail
Social Tools Built on Solana Set to Launch as Imagen Network Accelerates AI-Driven Development
New toolkits on Solana enable faster, smarter social interaction across decentralized creator communities Singapore, Singapore--(Newsfile Corp. - June 26, 2025) - Imagen Network, the decentralized AI-powered social platform, is preparing to launch a new suite of lightweight social tools developed specifically for Solana. These tools mark a major step forward in Imagen's mission to create modular, AI-enhanced community infrastructure across multichain environments. Advancing decentralized interaction with scalable AI-powered social tools. To view an enhanced version of this graphic, please visit: Built to capitalize on Solana's high-speed, low-cost performance, the new toolkit includes auto-generative post engines, context-aware moderation tools, and dynamic content personalization systems. These features will empower creators and communities to deploy smart social experiences in real time-whether for creator DAOs, node-based social hubs, or AI-enhanced discussion threads. The Solana-based launch is part of Imagen's broader expansion strategy to deliver cross-chain, scalable social intelligence features. With existing presence across Ethereum and BNB Chain, Imagen is now streamlining access and performance by leveraging Solana's transaction throughput and efficiency-giving users instant, AI-supported control over content, identity, and engagement. This launch aligns with Imagen's commitment to user-led infrastructure and AI-powered collaboration. By fusing blockchain scalability with intelligent design, Imagen continues to reshape how decentralized communities build, interact, and thrive. About Imagen Network Imagen Network is a decentralized social platform that blends AI content generation with blockchain infrastructure to give users creative control and data ownership. Through tools like adaptive filters and tokenized engagement, Imagen fosters a new paradigm of secure, expressive, and community-driven networking. About KaJ Labs KaJ Labs is a decentralized research organization focused on developing innovative solutions in artificial intelligence, blockchain, and Web3 infrastructure. The organization invests in high-impact projects that prioritize decentralization, transparency, and community empowerment. KaJ Labs supports platforms like Imagen Network to build intelligent, user-owned ecosystems that redefine digital experiences. Media Contact Dorothy Marley KaJ Labs +1 707-622-6168 media@ Social Media Twitter Instagram
Globe and Mail
an hour ago
- Globe and Mail
Tariff Shock to Weigh on U.S. Growth: JPMorgan (JPM) Sees 1.3% GDP, 40% Recession Risk
JPMorgan (JPM) analysts warn that ramped-up U.S. tariffs are set to unleash a 'stagflationary impulse,' pushing economic growth down to 1.3% in 2025 from earlier forecasts of 2%, while rekindling inflationary pressures. The bank now sees a 40% chance of recession in the back half of next year as higher import levies bite into corporate margins and consumer purchasing power. They project U.S. GDP growth of just 1.3% this year, trimmed from 2%, attributing the downgrade to negative shocks from trade barriers. The combination of sluggish output and persistent price gains echoes the 1970s malaise, raising the specter of stagflation and elevating recession risks well above historical averages. Market Overview: Recession probability at 40% in H2 2025; GDP growth trimmed to 1.3% from 2%; Tariffs cited as primary drag on activity. Key Points: Stagflationary impulse raises inflation fears; Term premium on U.S. Treasuries likely to widen by 40–50 bps; Fed cuts expected later, with 100 bps by spring 2026. Looking Ahead: Bearish on the dollar amid slower U.S. growth; Tech and AI sectors to underpin equity strength; Foreign demand for Treasuries to wane as debt swells. Bull Case: Despite downgraded GDP growth and elevated recession risks, JPMorgan remains constructive on U.S. equities, expecting strong fundamentals in the Tech and AI sectors to drive markets toward new highs. Tariffs and stagflation concerns are largely priced into the market, and any signs of stabilization or policy relief could trigger a rebound in sentiment and asset prices. Tech and AI sectors continue to demonstrate robust earnings growth and innovation, providing a resilient core for equity market performance even amid broader economic headwinds. While Treasury yields are expected to remain elevated, clarity on Fed rate cuts by spring 2026 could support a rally in risk assets as investors anticipate easier policy ahead. Dollar weakness could benefit U.S. exporters and multinational corporations, offsetting some of the drag from higher import costs. The market's focus on AI and tech leadership suggests that select sectors will continue to attract investment and outperform, even as the broader economy slows. Bear Case: JPMorgan analysts warn that ramped-up U.S. tariffs will push economic growth down to just 1.3% in 2025 and rekindle inflationary pressures, raising the specter of stagflation and a 40% chance of recession in the second half of the year. Higher import levies are expected to bite into corporate margins and consumer purchasing power, further dampening economic activity and increasing the risk of a prolonged slowdown. Term premiums on U.S. Treasuries are likely to widen by 40–50 basis points as foreign, Fed, and bank demand for government debt wanes, increasing borrowing costs for businesses and households. Fed rate cuts are expected to come later than previously anticipated, with only 100 basis points of easing projected by spring 2026, leaving markets exposed to tighter financial conditions for longer. JPMorgan is bearish on the dollar amid slower U.S. growth, which could amplify inflationary pressures by raising the cost of imports and further straining consumer budgets. While tech and AI sectors are expected to underpin equity strength, any major policy or geopolitical shocks could quickly undermine market confidence and trigger a broader sell-off. JPMorgan's strategists forecast two-year Treasury yields (TLT) around 3.5% and 10-year yields near 4.35% by year-end, even as term premiums climb. They foresee foreign, Fed and bank demand ebbing in a larger debt market, increasing borrowing costs over time. Despite policy uncertainty, the bank remains constructive on U.S. equities, expecting Tech and AI fundamentals to drive markets toward new highs—provided no major policy or geopolitical shocks intervene.
Globe and Mail
an hour ago
- Globe and Mail
Oil rises as draw in U.S. crude stocks signals firm demand
Oil prices inched higher, extending gains from the previous day as a larger-than-expected draw in U.S. crude stocks signalled firm demand, while investors remained cautious about the Iran-Israel ceasefire and stability in the Middle East. Brent crude futures rose 15 cents, or 0.2%, to $67.83 a barrel by 0330 GMT. U.S. West Texas Intermediate (WTI) crude gained 20 cents, or 0.3%, to $65.12 a barrel. Both benchmarks climbed nearly 1% on Wednesday, recovering from early-week losses after data showed resilient U.S. demand. 'Some buyers are favouring solid demand indicated by falling inventories in U.S. weekly statistics,' said Yuki Takashima, economist at Nomura Securities. 'But investors remain nervous, seeking clarity on the status of the Iran-Israel ceasefire,' he said, adding that market attention is now shifting to OPEC+ production levels. Opinion: Canada can help its allies ditch their dependence on Russian energy Takashima forecast WTI would likely return to the $60-$65 range, its pre-conflict levels. ANZ analysts said that with the de-escalation of conflict between Iran and Israel, the market's focus had returned to fundamentals, and pointed to data showing U.S. crude oil inventories fell for a fifth straight week. 'US government data showed the US driving season is in full swing after a slow start,' ANZ analysts said in a note. U.S. crude oil and fuel inventories fell in the week to June 20 as refining activity and demand rose, the Energy Information Administration (EIA) said on Wednesday. Crude inventories fell by 5.8 million barrels, the EIA said, exceeding analysts' expectations in a Reuters poll for a 797,000-barrel draw. Gasoline stocks unexpectedly fell by 2.1 million barrels, compared with forecasts for a 381,000-barrel build as gasoline supplied, a proxy for demand, rose to its highest since December 2021. On Saturday, Igor Sechin, the head of Russia's largest oil producer Rosneft, said OPEC+, which groups together the Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries and allies including Russia, could bring forward its output hikes by around a year from the initial plan. Meanwhile, U.S. President Donald Trump hailed the swift end to war between Iran and Israel and said Washington would likely seek a commitment from Tehran to end its nuclear ambitions at talks with Iranian officials next week. Trump also said on Wednesday that the U.S. has not given up its maximum pressure on Iran – including restrictions on sales of Iranian oil – but signalled a potential easing in enforcement to help the country rebuild.
