Hispanic officers allege mistreatment in Miami Gardens, call for chief's removal
The Miami Gardens officers — who said they were suspended or demoted after filing complaints of unfair treatment with the city — have also demanded the termination of Police Chief Delma Noel-Pratt, named the city's first female Black chief in the largest Black majority city in Florida in 2017.
'The current police chief is out of control in terms of the mistreatment and abuse of officers, in particular Hispanic officers and officers who complain about wrongdoing,' Attorney Michael Pizzi said from a conference room at his Miami Lakes law office Wednesday, four of the five officers at his side.
Miami Gardens police officers Juan Gonzalez, Christian Vega, Francisco Mejido, Rudy Hernandez and Sgt. Pedro Valdes all said they were retaliated against by command staff after questioning promotions, discipline and how rules are enforced internally.
Federal complaint filed
The officers have already filed a complaint with the Florida Commission on Human Relations and U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission. Under federal law, the EEOC has up to 180 days to conduct an investigation into claims of discrimination or it must issue a notice of right to sue, allowing the officers to seek damages through a lawsuit. A whistleblower lawsuit can be filed in 30 days after giving the city notice.
Sgt. Valdes claims he was relieved of duty for six months, forced to sit home 10 hours a day with pay — without any type of explanation.
'I was told, go home. No cause,' Valdes said. 'It's demoralizing because I have family members, including my wife, who's a police officer there. To play with our emotions and mental state for no reason — it's not right.'
Miami Gardens Police executive officer Emmanuel Jeanty wouldn't go into detail about the reasons Valdes was relieved of duty, but said it was 'false' that the officer wasn't given a reason.
'He was informed and signed paperwork,' Jeanty said.
The city did not comment on the officers' accusations when asked Wednesday. The police department, however, stood behind its decisions involving them.
'As the chief of police, I have every right to make the transfers or demotions that I see fit,' Noel-Pratt said.
Miami Gardens, with a population of 110,000, is 71% Black and 26% Hispanic, according to the city's website. The police department's officers, in comparison, are 48% Black and 36% Hispanic as of 2024, according to data from the Florida Department of Law Enforcement.
Claims of demotions, harassment, abuse
The officers claimed the targeted harassment campaign by the department left them with severe mental and emotional stress, even PTSD. Pizzi noted that some of the officers who served in the U.S. military were shocked and appalled that interactions with fellow officers were where they experienced trauma, not on the battlefield or on the streets fighting crime.
Valdes, a 17-year Miami Gardens police veteran, said he was relieved of duty for six months without explanation and was only recently reinstated last week.
Valdes said he had led a violent crime unit credited with reducing crime by 14%, only to be abruptly removed and reassigned. He also alleged that the department has systematically replaced experienced Hispanic and white officers with younger Black officers.
Officer Francisco Mejido, a 13-year Miami Gardens police veteran, said his K-9 partner was taken away and he was removed from the unit after a minor body camera violation — even though his replacement had the same infraction.
'I had to break that news to my two young kids, to my wife,' Mejido said. 'Ever since then, the agency has come after me with multiple forms of discipline.'
He also spoke of a broader issue of inconsistent disciplinary practices and favoritism within the department.
Officer Juan Gonzalez, a 12-year Miami Gardens police veteran, described being reprimanded for speaking to other Hispanic officers at a crime scene.
'I was scolded for talking to Hispanic officers on scene,' Gonzalez said. 'I was followed by my supervisor in a threatening manner, in a hostile fighting position, with both fists clenched.'
Gonzalez said he was demoted and removed from a federal task force assignment, resulting in a loss of income.
The officers say their complaints to internal affairs, the city manager and human resources have been ignored. Now, they're turning to the courts.
'They've all stood up and complained,' Pizzi said. 'And they've all been targeted as a result of their complaints.'
Miami Herald staff writer Devoun Cetoute contributed to this report.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


CBS News
7 hours ago
- CBS News
Irvine man charged with hate crimes after allegedly beating elderly driver and throwing hot coffee at another
An Irvine man faces hate crime charges after he allegedly threw a hot cup of coffee at a man and beat an elderly driver while shouting racial slurs. The Orange County District Attorney's Office described suspect Robert Tackett's actions as "hate motivated attacks" against two Hispanic men. Prosecutors charged Tackett, 54, with four counts related to the assaults, including inflicting injury on an elderly adult. He faces a maximum of eight years in state prison if convicted on all counts. He's being held at the Orange County Jail in lieu of $500,000 bail. "Hate is a venom that poisons everything – and everyone – it touches. An attack motivated by hate is not an attack on just a single individual; it is an attack on the very fabric of our society and our community as a whole," Orange County District Attorney Todd Spitzer said. The two alleged assaults happened on July 22 in two Orange County cities. In the morning, Tackett allegedly followed a garbage truck driver through Irvine on Sand Canyon Avenue near the 5 Freeway. The Irvine Police Department said Tackett tried to run the other driver off the road while shouting racial slurs at him. The Orange County District Attorney's Office said he allegedly tried to crash into the garbage truck twice, but the other driver quickly slammed the brakes and avoided a collision each time. After intentionally trying to crash into the victim, Tackett allegedly threw a hot cop of coffee that landed on the victim's face, hands and car interior, according to Irvine PD. The second assault happened at around 5:30 p.m. in Westminster. Tackett allegedly got out of his work van while stopped at a light, repeatedly punched a 72-year-old driver through an open window and shouted racial slurs. The California Highway Patrol arrested Tackett in Mammoth two days after the attacks. "Every member of our society deserves to go about their days unafraid that they would be targeted because of the color of their skin, their gender, or their sexual orientation," Spitzer said. "We must collectively combat hate by speaking up and speaking out against hate – and haters – to continue to send a strong message that hate will never be tolerated here in Orange County or anywhere."

9 hours ago
Justice Department maneuvers to keep Trump loyalists atop US attorneys' offices in LA and Nevada
The Justice Department has maneuvered in recent days to keep two pro-Trump loyalists in acting leadership positions at the U.S. attorneys' offices in Los Angeles and Nevada, in an effort to extend their tenures beyond a statutory 120-day limit. According to a Justice Department official, the interim U.S. Attorney for Nevada Sigal Chattah and interim U.S. Attorney for Los Angeles Bill Essayli were both designated as acting U.S. attorneys for their respective offices just before their terms were set to expire and federal judges in the district would convene to appoint their replacements. The moves are a continuation of what is now becoming a trend for DOJ, as its controversial temporary picks to lead U.S. attorneys' offices around the country face resistance from the federal bench to extend their service. The department made similar moves in both the District of New Jersey with Trump's former personal attorney Alina Habba, as well as in the Northern District of New York, where John Sarcone III was also appointed "acting" U.S. attorney after judges declined to approve his temporary extension. The administration recently explained it's legal justification for working around existing statute that requires interim U.S. attorneys to vacate their post after 120 days, essentially setting forth a process in which officials like Chattah, Essayli and Habba resign in order to create a vacancy at the position of U.S. attorney -- followed by their appointment by Trump as a designated "acting" U.S. attorney who can then serve for at least another 210 days. The maneuvering is already facing legal challenges, though the Justice Department has been adamant that judges should not be in the position to determine who heads up the top prosecutorial offices in districts around the country -- an issue that is only piling up as some of the administration's more controversial nominees face delays and other potential headwinds in the Senate. Both Chattah and Essayli have faced scrutiny during their short tenures over their lengthy past histories as pro-Trump firebrands, as well as allegations they've sought to weaponize their offices to advance the administration's agenda. Prior to her tenure, Chattah was accused of making racist remarks describing then-Rep. Jamaal Bowman as a "hood rat" and a "ghetto rat." She also stated that Nevada AG Aaron Ford, who is Black and who Chattah campaigned against in 2022, "should be hanging from a f****** crane." Chattah denied the accusations she is racist in a recent interview with a CBS affiliate, and said "there's not an extremist bone in my body." Essayli, who was appointed to his post in early April, has separately faced accusations of politicizing his office by aggressively pursuing charges against protesters of the administration's immigration agenda, resulting in some embarrassing setbacks in court. Essayli has denied his actions are driven by politics. On Tuesday, his office moved to dismiss charges against Alejandro Orellana, a man charged with allegedly distributing face shields to protesters in LA, whose criminal case was announced with great fanfare by Essayli earlier this month. Trump's supporters cheered the initial move to charge, though many legal experts questioned the use of felony civil disorder statutes being applied to Orellana's alleged actions in distributing the face shields. Other controversial actions by Essayli have led to resignations by many of the career prosecutors who staff the U.S. Attorney's Office in Los Angeles, including a misdemeanor plea deal he entered into with a Los Angeles County sheriff's deputy who had been convicted of felony assault. Just hours before the administration extended his tenure on Wednesday, Essayli moved to dismiss a corporate fraud case against Trump donor Andrew Wiederhorn, the founder and chairman of the restaurant chain Fatburger.


Chicago Tribune
10 hours ago
- Chicago Tribune
Charges unsealed for alleged shooter's brother in fatal Hammond shooting
Charges were unsealed Wednesday for the brother of an alleged shooter who ambushed and shot a married couple in a car. Alexis Cruz, Jr., 20, is charged with murder and attempted murder in the Sept. 14, 2024 death of Steven Gonzalez, 20, of Hammond. His wife was wounded. Cruz's brother Xavier Cruz, 18, is charged as the alleged shooter. Records allege Alexis was an accomplice. Police allege Alexis believed the woman stole a gun from him. Filings show he is in custody in San Antonio and is awaiting extradition. Hammond Police Detective James Onohan responded around 5:46 p.m. that evening to the 400 block of Huehn Street. Surveillance footage showed three males walking in a gangway toward the car. One of the men, a relative of the brothers, now 20, has not been charged to date in public filings. A third teen was a light-skinned Hispanic, with glasses, a Chicago Bulls baseball hat and wavy hair. 'He just smoked them,' Cruz's relative said after the shooting.