
Brother who killed sister with hammer detained indefinitely
Exeter Crown Court heard the siblings were reclusive and at the time of the Miss Law's death there was an 'inter-related spiral of mental decline'.
Jo Martin KC, prosecuting, said on the afternoon of January 17, Law phoned 999 and told the operator: 'I've killed my sister, and so I need you to come.
'We've both gone mad, I mean, mentally. I just couldn't cope with it all.'
The emergency services found Miss Law dead in her bed having suffered severe head injuries.
'He told the police there had been a build up from Christmas Day, although there had been no big argument,' Miss Martin said.
'He said, 'I kept hitting her to make sure because I didn't want to leave her. She wanted to die, the same as I did'.
'He went on to say, 'Part of my problem is being reclusive and withdrawn. The last thing you want to do is go to counselling or go to the doctor'.'
After being taken to the police station Law told officers he had intended to take his own life and was detained under the Mental Health Act.
A post-mortem examination found Miss Law had suffered 'catastrophic head injuries' from at least six blows from a hammer.
Police investigations found the siblings led quiet but separate lives, despite sharing their former parents' home.
'They were not well known to their neighbours,' Miss Martin said.
'What though did seem to be known of the two of them was they didn't have a particularly good sibling relationship.
'They led independent lives to the extent that they would shop and eat separately.
'When the police spoke to all of the friends and neighbours, it was clear that despite what they knew of their fraught relationship, no one had anticipated it would end in the killing of Judith by her brother.'
Miss Martin said Law told psychiatrists that both he and his sister spoke of suicide and that he was becoming 'increasingly stressed'.
'On January 17 he said that they'd had a conversation about how long it would take them both to rot if they just stayed in bed and didn't eat,' she said.
'He said that he recalled thinking that this was the day to end their lives.'
Law, of Lark Rise, Newton Poppleford, had previously been charged with murder but pleaded guilty to manslaughter by reason of diminished responsibility.
Two psychiatrists found he had been suffering from a 'severe depressive disorder' which had affected his culpability.
Dan Pawson-Pounds, defending, said tensions between the siblings had exacerbated after their village had flooded in 2023 and their home needed repairs.
'The characterisation of the relationship between Mr Law and his sister is a difficult one because of course they were both relatively reclusive, Mr Law rather more than his sister,' he said.
'It appears that Mr Law's reclusive nature was a longstanding character trait developed over a number of years and was identifiable from the latest the mid-1990s.
'The knowledge of the neighbours and others of their relationship was naturally and inevitably somewhat limited.
'We would say that whilst there were clear tensions in that relationship, and those tensions were obviously exacerbated by the flood damage to their home and the ongoing repair work in 2023, it does appear that the balance of the observations taken from third parties is that while they lived their lives largely separately under the same roof, there was no suggestion of any violence at all between them.'
Judge Anna Richardson imposed a hospital order under Section 37 of the Mental Health Act and a restriction order under Section 41 – meaning Law can be detained indefinitely.
'On January 17 this year you rang 999 telling the operator that you had killed your sister, that you had struck her with a hammer more than once, and that you had both gone mad,' she said.
'You exhibited substantial signs of disturbance in your manner during that call.
'You have since told medical experts that your intention was to kill Judith and yourself, but you were unable to go through with killing yourself.
'I accept that you are genuinely remorseful.
'I have concluded that the protection of the public is not best served by passing a penal sentence which would be of relatively short duration.
'Rather the justice of the case and the public are better served by the making of a hospital order under Section 37 of the Mental Health Act.
'I am satisfied that you are suffering from a mental disorder of a nature and degree which makes it appropriate for you to be detained in hospital for medical treatment.'

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


ITV News
24 minutes ago
- ITV News
Woman who stabbed father-of-six on Christmas Day guilty of murder
An ex-partner who murdered her ex boyfriend on Christmas Day last year has been guilty of his murder. The court had previously heard that Kirsty Carless, 33, was "fuelled by cocaine and alcohol" when she took a taxi from her home in Cannock, Staffordshire to her ex-partner's home in Norton Canes in the early hours of December 25 last year. Carless, 33, took a knife in a taxi to confront Louis Price, 31, after seeing his profile on a dating app, Stafford Crown Court heard. She was convicted unanimously of murder and possessing an offensive weapon in a public place. Carless was also found guilty by majority of assault occasioning actual bodily harm over a previous incident, but cleared of intentional strangulation. While there she plunged a kitchen knife she had taken from her home into Price's chest, a court had previously heard. At the time of the stabbing Carless was known to police. She had been on police bail after allegedly strangling Louis Price the previous year. A charge which she had denied. Police confirmed that a referral was made to the IOPC following recent contact.

Rhyl Journal
29 minutes ago
- Rhyl Journal
Jealous woman who stabbed ex in heart on Christmas Day guilty of his murder
Kirsty Carless, 33, plunged a knife into 31-year-old Louis Price's heart in the early hours of December 25 2024, in an attack 'motivated by anger and jealousy and fuelled by cocaine and alcohol' after a friend sent her a picture of his Tinder profile, Stafford Crown Court heard. On Wednesday, after around a day of deliberation, a jury of seven men and five women found her guilty of murder and possession of an offensive weapon by unanimous verdicts in relation to the fatal stabbing. She was also found guilty of assault occasioning actual bodily harm by a majority of 11 to one in connection with an incident in November 2024. She was cleared of intentional strangulation in relation to the same incident. The trial was told Carless, of Haling Way in Cannock, Staffordshire, had been at the pub drinking double vodka and cokes with a male friend on December 24. She later had sex with the male three times at his home before a female friend sent her a screenshot of Mr Price's Tinder profile at around 1.30am on Christmas Day, which left her angry. Carless then left the male friend's home, took a taxi back to her house, where she picked up a kitchen knife and got another taxi to Mr Price's parents' address in Elm Road, Norton Canes, where she expected to find him with a woman. CCTV showed her running up the front path into the house and then 'stalking' him around the garden before he was later found with a single stab wound to the chest on the conservatory floor. Carless had called Mr Price 45 times between 2.15am and 2.44am while she waited for the taxi to take her to the address where he had been staying since their relationship ended – only breaking up what prosecution counsel Jonas Hankin KC called the 'barrage' of calls to impatiently phone the company to check where her taxi was. After arriving at the address, Carless asked the taxi driver to wait outside while she went into the property to stab Mr Price at around 3am. The taxi driver reported that around 30 seconds after Carless let herself into the property with a key, he heard a 'very loud and prolonged' scream from a man and that he 'sounded scared'. Less than two minutes after arriving at the scene, Carless was 'anxious and sweating' as she got back into the taxi and demanded the driver take her to her parents' home, where she admitted what she had done and 999 was called. Father-of-six Mr Price had been considered by police to be 'at very high risk of domestic abuse' and Carless was on police bail at the time of the fatal stabbing after strangling Mr Price on November 11 2024. On that occasion, Mr Price phoned 999 to say Carless had poured bleach over tracksuits worth £400 after she put them in the bin, had thrown a glass candle holder at him, pulled him down the stairs and choked him. He was seen crying on police body-worn video footage, telling the officer: 'It's f****** embarrassing… it can't keep happening, man.' In a witness statement after the incident, he said the relationship, which started in 2021, had been 'on the whole, abusive', that she had stopped him doing things he liked, such as playing football and had physically abused him. The trial was told of several previous incidents in which the police had been called, including an incident on March 5 2023, in which Carless had said Mr Price had punched her and been violent and he was arrested, before later retracting her statement. A neighbour had recalled seeing Carless hitting Mr Price with a metal pole in the ribs outside her house on a different occasion. Mr Price's friend, Demi-Louise Deakin, also told the trial he had confided in her about his on-off relationship with Carless when they attended a funeral at the end of November 2024, telling her he was 'scared of Kirsty' and feared 'something bad would happen' if he did not leave her. In her evidence to the trial, Carless said she had no recollection of stabbing him, was 'not a violent person' and had only gone to Mr Price's address as she believed he had taken money from inside a card she had in her home. She said she picked up a knife with the intent to destroy the caravan he was staying in in his parents' back garden and had 'panicked' after Mr Price was stabbed and fled. Judge Mr Justice Choudhury thanked the jury for their service and said Carless would be sentenced on Thursday.

Western Telegraph
an hour ago
- Western Telegraph
Jealous woman who stabbed ex in heart on Christmas Day guilty of his murder
Kirsty Carless, 33, plunged a knife into 31-year-old Louis Price's heart in the early hours of December 25 2024, in an attack 'motivated by anger and jealousy and fuelled by cocaine and alcohol' after a friend sent her a picture of his Tinder profile, Stafford Crown Court heard. On Wednesday, after around a day of deliberation, a jury of seven men and five women found her guilty of murder and possession of an offensive weapon by unanimous verdicts in relation to the fatal stabbing. She was also found guilty of assault occasioning actual bodily harm by a majority of 11 to one in connection with an incident in November 2024. She was cleared of intentional strangulation in relation to the same incident. Kirsty Carless, 33, had drunk alcohol and taken cocaine before she stabbed her ex-partner Louis Price in the chest on Christmas Day last year (Staffordshire Police/PA) The trial was told Carless, of Haling Way in Cannock, Staffordshire, had been at the pub drinking double vodka and cokes with a male friend on December 24. She later had sex with the male three times at his home before a female friend sent her a screenshot of Mr Price's Tinder profile at around 1.30am on Christmas Day, which left her angry. Carless then left the male friend's home, took a taxi back to her house, where she picked up a kitchen knife and got another taxi to Mr Price's parents' address in Elm Road, Norton Canes, where she expected to find him with a woman. CCTV showed her running up the front path into the house and then 'stalking' him around the garden before he was later found with a single stab wound to the chest on the conservatory floor. Carless had called Mr Price 45 times between 2.15am and 2.44am while she waited for the taxi to take her to the address where he had been staying since their relationship ended – only breaking up what prosecution counsel Jonas Hankin KC called the 'barrage' of calls to impatiently phone the company to check where her taxi was. Carless was seen on CCTV running from the taxi to the house where Louis Price was staying in Norton Canes just before she stabbed him to death (Staffordshire Police/PA) After arriving at the address, Carless asked the taxi driver to wait outside while she went into the property to stab Mr Price at around 3am. The taxi driver reported that around 30 seconds after Carless let herself into the property with a key, he heard a 'very loud and prolonged' scream from a man and that he 'sounded scared'. Less than two minutes after arriving at the scene, Carless was 'anxious and sweating' as she got back into the taxi and demanded the driver take her to her parents' home, where she admitted what she had done and 999 was called. Father-of-six Mr Price had been considered by police to be 'at very high risk of domestic abuse' and Carless was on police bail at the time of the fatal stabbing after strangling Mr Price on November 11 2024. Carless had fled the scene of the stabbing in a taxi and went to her parents' address, where her stepfather called 999 (Staffordshire Police/PA) On that occasion, Mr Price phoned 999 to say Carless had poured bleach over tracksuits worth £400 after she put them in the bin, had thrown a glass candle holder at him, pulled him down the stairs and choked him. He was seen crying on police body-worn video footage, telling the officer: 'It's f****** embarrassing… it can't keep happening, man.' In a witness statement after the incident, he said the relationship, which started in 2021, had been 'on the whole, abusive', that she had stopped him doing things he liked, such as playing football and had physically abused him. The trial was told of several previous incidents in which the police had been called, including an incident on March 5 2023, in which Carless had said Mr Price had punched her and been violent and he was arrested, before later retracting her statement. Carless told a trial at Stafford Crown Court she had no recollection of the fatal attack (Staffordshire Crown Court/PA) A neighbour had recalled seeing Carless hitting Mr Price with a metal pole in the ribs outside her house on a different occasion. Mr Price's friend, Demi-Louise Deakin, also told the trial he had confided in her about his on-off relationship with Carless when they attended a funeral at the end of November 2024, telling her he was 'scared of Kirsty' and feared 'something bad would happen' if he did not leave her. In her evidence to the trial, Carless said she had no recollection of stabbing him, was 'not a violent person' and had only gone to Mr Price's address as she believed he had taken money from inside a card she had in her home. Louis Price was a 'devoted fisherman' who loved football and his six children, his family said after his death (Family handout/PA) She said she picked up a knife with the intent to destroy the caravan he was staying in in his parents' back garden and had 'panicked' after Mr Price was stabbed and fled. Judge Mr Justice Choudhury thanked the jury for their service and said Carless would be sentenced on Thursday.