Flyer does not prove assisted death legal for minors in Canada
"Looks like the Canadian gov't reccomends (sic) offering MAiD to our children," says the caption of a May 20, 2025 video shared on Facebook. "Unbelievable! They have to be stopped!"
The clip, viewed more than 35,000 times, includes images of what appears to be a brochure discussing a recommendation from Canadian lawmakers to expand assisted dying to mature minors.
Similar claims citing the pamphlet as alleged proof of changes to MAID spread in online articles and on X, TikTok and Instagram.
Image
Screenshot of a Facebook post taken June 3, 2025
Image
Screenshot of an Instagram post taken June 3, 2025
The posts gained traction as bills allowing assisted death are currently under debate in France and the United Kingdom.
Canada first legalized MAID, intended for people with a "grievous and irremediable" medical condition, in 2016 (archived here). Different forms of euthanasia are also legal in other jurisdictions outside Canada.
Initially, a person's natural death had to be "reasonably foreseeable" to be granted the procedure, but updates in 2021 opened eligibility to people whose deaths were not immediately imminent (archived here).
False and misleading claims about MAID in Canada frequently surface online, often the program is being opened up to children.
In 2023, a parliamentary committee did recommend that mature minors should be given the right to choose MAID. But as of June 3, 2025, people under 18 years old have never been eligible for the procedure in Canada.
"The eligibility criteria set out in the Criminal Code require that a person must be a minimum of 18 years of age and capable of making decisions with respect to their health," said Mark Johnson, spokesman for Health Canada. "The Government of Canada is not considering any legislative changes to this requirement that minors cannot be assessed for nor receive MAID."
Additionally, a reverse image search reveals that the pamphlet highlighted online was printed by the Evangelical Fellowship of Canada in 2024, as part of a push to discourage the expansion of access to the procedure (archived here). It did not come from the Canadian government, as the posts imply.
Studies and recommendations
A Special Joint Committee on Medical Assistance in Dying studied issues related to MAID between 2021 and 2023 (archived here). During this time, individuals, experts and advocacy groups presented their points of view on what could be changed in Canada's approach to assisted death.
Following the testimonies, the committee recommended that mature minors should be eligible to access MAID with safeguards in place, including restrictions limiting requests for people under 18 years old to only those whose deaths were reasonably foreseeable (archived here).
The government responded to the recommendation with concerns about balancing minors' personal autonomy with safety, and it did not include any provision allowing medically assisted death for people under 18 (archived here).
"This could only happen if legislation was introduced and passed to change the Criminal Code," said Alisha Hall, spokeswoman for Dying With Dignity Canada, a group that advocates for mature minors to be allowed the right to choose MAID.
Hall told AFP that since Dying With Dignity's report to the committee in 2022, it had not made any further presentations to government bodies on MAID and mature minors (archived here).
Eligibility
While some of the posts referencing the pamphlet also implied that MAID could be used by those dissatisfied with life, Canada requires an applicant to have a "grievous and irremediable" medical condition.
According to the Justice Canada website, MAID applications need to be approved by at least two medical professionals, and information must be provided about how to withdraw a request (archived here).
The ministry also says people applying for the procedure who do not have reasonably foreseeable deaths must be informed about alternative options of treatment.
The latest annual report on MAID recorded that 95.9 percent of people who received the procedure in 2023 did so while their deaths were reasonably foreseeable, with cancer being the most frequently cited underlying condition (archived here).
Those whose deaths were not foreseeable reported living with issues such as diabetes, frailty, autoimmune problems and chronic pain, according to the report.
Some argue the availability of the procedure can leave other issues unaddressed, including those surrounding quality of life for people living with disability or in poverty. Media have previously reported on applicants seeking medically assisted death for social reasons including isolation, and practitioners struggling with requests for MAID from people living with disabilities or difficult economic situations.
Offering MAID as an option for people suffering solely from a mental illness was slated to go into effect in 2024, but this change was postponed until at least March 2027 (archived here).
Read more of AFP's reporting on misinformation in Canada here.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
AFP
4 hours ago
- AFP
Doctored video falsely linked to recent Kenya-Tanzania diplomatic dispute
Activists and politicians from Kenya and Uganda recently travelled to Tanzania to show solidarity with opposition leader Tundu Lissu, who is facing treason charges. However, several of them were detained and deported, and two of the activists accused authorities of torture and sexual assault. A video published on social media claims to show CNN's Fareed Zakaria weighing in on the events. But the clip is altered; the audio is AI-generated, and CNN confirmed it did not publish the video. 'Tanzania vs Kenya Gen-Zs @CNN-Today News,' reads the text overlaid on a TikTok post published on May 22, 2025. Image Screenshot of the altered post, taken on May 28, 2025 The clip includes what appears to be a segment from the CNN show Global Public Square with host Fareed Zakaria. Below are photos of Tanzanian President Samia Suluhu Hassan and Kenyan activist Boniface Mwangi. The chyron reads: 'Fareed's Take' and 'Not in My Country: Why Tanzania is going after Open Society'. 'Let's step back for a moment and recognise where we are right now,' Zakaria says at the beginning of the clip. The CNN host is not seen again from the four-second mark of the video, but a voice that sounds like Zakaria's is heard over images, speaking about last year's 'Kenyan Gen-Z-led demonstrations that began as a tax revolt and quickly evolved into a national reckoning'. 'This week, Tanzania's President Samia Suluhu Hassan issued one of her strongest warnings yet. 'Not in my country,' she said, referring to a group of East African organisers who, according to Tanzanian intelligence, were flown into Dar es Salaam, booked into $400-a-night hotels, handed shopping money, and sent to target her government,' the voice adds. The video further claims that the 'Open Society Foundation's Southern Africa office' was responsible for funding the activists in what is part of a bigger 'digitally coordinated, foreign-funded' disruption. Towards the end of the audio, the voice says that 'Suluhu isn't rejecting activism,' but 'rejecting manipulation'. The audio is illustrated by visuals: images from Kenya's 2024 anti-government protests, a recent address by Hassan, clips of Open Society Foundations founder George Soros, and old articles regarding the suspension and regulation of non-governmental organisations in Ethiopia, Uganda, Rwanda and Zimbabwe. The video was published elsewhere on Facebook, X, Instagram and YouTube. Foreign activists A diplomatic row erupted between Kenya and Tanzania after Kenyan and Ugandan activists and politicians who travelled to Tanzania to witness opposition leader Lissu's treason trial on May 19, 2025, were detained and subsequently deported. As the trial proceeded, Hassan issued a stern warning stating she would not allow foreign activists to interfere with Tanzania's internal affairs or cause chaos (archived here). Two of the activists, Agather Atuhaire from Uganda and Kenya's Boniface Mwangi, later accused Tanzanian authorities of torture and sexual assault during their incommunicado detention (archived here and here). These events have attracted both local and international attention, as calls for investigations intensify (here, here and here). However, the video showing Zakaria's assessment of the situation is doctored. Doctored video AFP Fact Check conducted reverse image searches on keyframes from the clip and found that the introduction was taken from a real Fareed Zakaria segment published by CNN on May 4, 2025 (archived here). In the first three seconds of the original segment, Zakaria starts with the initial footage used in the TikTok video and says: 'Let's step back for a moment and recognise where we are right now.' However, rather than talking about Kenya and Tanzania, he goes on to say that 'the United States has launched a trade war with the world's second-largest economy, China'. The chyron font and text also look different in the original footage. 'Fareed's take,' it reads, without any subhead about Tanzania. Image Screenshots comparing the doctored video (top) and the original CNN footage (bottom) While the voice sounds like Zakaria's throughout the TikTok video, there are some noticeable discrepancies in the audio -- the slightly robotic tones, unnatural pacing and odd inflections -- starting from the moment he is no longer visible onscreen. For example, there are unnatural pauses in the middle of sentences, such as when the voice says 'Kenyan [long pause] Gen-Z-led demonstrations that began as a tax revolt' and 'a group of East African organisers who, according to Tanzanian intelligence, were flown [long pause] into Dar es Salaam'. This is corroborated by InVID-WeVerify's audio detection tool which suggests strong evidence of voice cloning. Image A screenshot of InVID-WeVerify's voice cloning detector results, taken on May 28, 2025 AFP Fact Check found no record of Zakaria commenting on the recent Tanzania-Kenya dispute. 'This video purportedly showing CNN's Fareed Zakaria's take on foreign influence in Tanzania and Kenya never aired on CNN and is entirely fabricated,' Mariana Piñango, a spokesperson for CNN, told AFP Fact Check. Additionally, contrary to the claim in the AI-generated video, there has been no public statement from Tanzania's national intelligence authority addressing the detention of the Kenyan and Ugandan activists or linking them to any paid foreign influence operations. The Open Society Foundations denied the accusations made in the video in an email response to AFP Fact Check. 'The video is an AI-generated fake that includes false allegations against the Open Society Foundations. We are a nonpartisan charitable organisation that works across Africa and around the world to promote human rights, equity, and justice.' AFP Fact Check previously debunked another claim related to the recent Kenya-Tanzania tensions.
LeMonde
8 hours ago
- LeMonde
At trial over banner targeting Aya Nakamura, far-right activists stand by their actions
On March 8, 2024, as rumors swirled that Aya Nakamura would headline the Olympic Games opening ceremony, around 15 young far-right activists, members of the group Les Natifs, gathered on Île Saint-Louis in the center of Paris to unfurl a banner hostile to the French-Malian singer: "No way, Aya, this is Paris, not the Bamako market!" The slogan referenced lyrics from one of Nakamura's hits ("Djadja") and her birthplace, the Malian capital. Heirs to the far-right group Génération Identitaire, which was dissolved in 2021, Les Natifs – who have 10,000 followers on Instagram and 19,000 on X – specialize in actions involving hostile posters and banners, often targeting immigration or promoting the defense of "European civilization." Recently, activists plastered portraits of Joan of Arc and Sainte Geneviève over images of veiled women displayed at the Basilica of Saint-Denis, in the northern Paris suburb. Posted on their X account and viewed nearly 4.5 million times, the photo of the anti-Nakamura banner was accompanied by a short text lamenting President Emmanuel Macron's supposed plan: "To replace French elegance with vulgarity, to Africanize our popular songs, and to sideline the native population in favor of extra-European immigration." The message demanded that "France be represented by an artist embodying our heritage, our values and our identity!"
AFP
9 hours ago
- AFP
Old protest clip filmed in Pakistan-held Kashmir, not India
"The video is said to be from Jammu and Kashmir," reads the Hindi-language caption to the video filmed from a serpentine mountain road. "After ceasefire, as CRPF and CISF troops were returning from borders, Muslim traitors attacked their convoy with stones," adds the May 26, 2025 Facebook post, using the acronyms for paramilitary organisations functioning under India's Home Ministry (archived link). "In response, the forces opened fire. Chaos ensued, in which nine stone pelters slipped and died. The army recorded the entire incident via drone. Several security vehicles were damaged." Image Screenshot of the false post taken May 30, 2025 Similar posts also rocketed on X and Threads following the worst fighting between India and Pakistan in decades that brought the nuclear-armed rivals to the brink of war. The crisis was triggered by an attack on tourists in Indian-administered Kashmir that New Delhi accuses it neighbour of supporting. Islamabad denies the charge. More than 70 people on both sides died in the four-day military confrontation that ensued, which ended with an unexpected ceasefire on May 10 (archived link). AFP found no official reports the incident described in the false posts occurred following the crisis, and the circulating video has been misrepresented. A reverse image search of keyframes found a longer version published on Facebook on May 15, 2024 (archived link). "Kashmiris Pelting Stones At The Convoy Of Pakistani Security Forces In Pakistan Occupied Kashmir," reads its caption. Image Screenshot comparison of the false post (L) and the video uploaded on Facebook An AFP journalist watched the video and was able to identify the mountain pass as Lohar Gali in Pakistan-administered Kashmir's Muzaffarabad region. Corresponding visuals on Google Maps confirm the location (archived link). Image Screenshot comparison of the falsely shared video (L) and Google Street View imagery of the area with similarities highlighted by AFP Pakistani news outlets Dawn and Geo News Urdu embedded similar visuals in reports about the incident (archived here and here). According to Dawn newspaper, at least three civilians were killed and several others injured after a paramilitary force operating under the Pakistan Army opened fire at people protesting against rising prices of wheat-flour and inflated electricity bills (archived link). AFP has debunked the barrage of misinformation around the recent South Asia crisis here.
