logo
Socialist MEP warns Commission against weakening CAP's labour protections

Socialist MEP warns Commission against weakening CAP's labour protections

Euractiv07-07-2025
After visiting Italy's largest shanty town, Estelle Ceulemans of the Socialist and Democrats (S&D) group in the European Parliament told Euractiv that the EU is at a crossroads on workers' rights, as pressure builds to weaken the Common Agricultural Policy's 'social conditionality'.
Estelle Ceulemans, a Belgian MEP and S&D coordinator in the Parliament's committee on employment and social affairs, visited Borgomezzanone in Apulia with a delegation organised by the European Federation of Food, Agriculture and Tourism Trade Unions (EFFAT).
What follows is an edited transcript. You have just visited Italy's largest shanty town, Borgomezzanone, where many migrants who work in agriculture live. What did you see there?
Inhumane living conditions. No water, no sanitary facilities... they have generators for electricity, but for everything else it is truly a matter of survival. Not to mention their working conditions, of course. They must work under the control of gangmasters, who are organised in pyramid-like, mafia-style structures. These are truly lawless zones for the workers, who are paid on average €2 per hour. It's also 40 degrees here.
Is this a local failure in which Brussels has little involvement or influence?
We visited one of the largest settlements here, but across the entire province there are around 20,000 workers living in similar conditions. It's almost an industrial-scale organisation of worker exploitation. Sadly, this situation exists elsewhere in Italy and in other parts of Europe.
So should the EU do more to protect labour rights?
Clearly, this is our responsibility. Our S&D colleague, Johan Danielsson, will lead an own-initiative report in the Parliament's employment committee (EMPL) to better regulate subcontracting chains, the role of intermediaries, and inspections.
As is the case in some member states, we need to set targets to ensure that, especially in high-risk sectors like agriculture, at least 8% of companies are inspected each year. We urge the Commission to propose a directive to this effect.
The social conditionality mechanism of the Common Agricultural Policy (CAP), which links farm subsidies to compliance with labour standards, is now in the spotlight. Some member states and conservative MEPs are calling for it to be reviewed or even scrapped, arguing that it results in double penalties and excessive burdens. Should the Commission reconsider this system in the future CAP?
If the system is revised, it should be strengthened, not weakened or eliminated. We want more EU directives to be added to the conditionality system, especially the one on minimum wage. It won't be easy, but it's a fight we must lead. If the law and money are not aligned, nothing changes.
We also want CAP payments to be tied to the number of declared workers. Because what we've seen here is a huge number of undeclared workers, which is a hallmark of the agricultural sector.
The Commission is set to present its CAP proposal soon, which is expected to 'simplify' social conditionality to make it easier to implement by member states. What do you expect from this move?
We'll see, but we are concerned. We already know that the current Commission's idea of 'simplification' leans towards 'deregulation'. And we've already heard rumours that the question of respecting social rights is somehow in question. Whatever happens, we will lead the necessary fights to reinforce social conditionality, including through sanctions.
Social conditionality already exists in a country such as Italy. However, as we have seen, these rules are not being respected. It's very important to step out of the EU bubble and engage with the situation on the ground. This is the only way to face the reality.
(adm, de)
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Foreign ministers call for immediate Gaza ceasefire in joint statement
Foreign ministers call for immediate Gaza ceasefire in joint statement

Euractiv

time7 minutes ago

  • Euractiv

Foreign ministers call for immediate Gaza ceasefire in joint statement

Foreign ministers from several countries — including EU member states and Hadja Lahbib, the bloc's equality commissioner — signed a joint statement on Monday calling for an immediate end to the war in Gaza and the negotiation of a ceasefire. The joint statement, led by the UK government and endorsed by several EU foreign ministers as well as countries such as Canada, Australia, and Japan, declared that 'the war in Gaza must end now.' The letter called on the Israeli government to 'immediately lift restrictions on the flow of aid' and to allow the UN and humanitarian NGOs to operate freely and deliver assistance to civilians. It also expressed opposition to any steps aimed at altering the status of the occupied Palestinian Territories, specifically referencing Israel's E1 settlement plan. "If implemented, [it] would divide a Palestinian state in two, marking a flagrant breach of international law and critically undermine the two-state solution," it said. Equality Commission Hadja Lahbib, who also signed the letter, stated in a post on X that the crisis in Gaza had reached 'an intolerable level.' She added: 'Only an immediate, unconditional and permanent ceasefire can end the suffering.' The signatories also said they were prepared to take 'further action' to support an immediate ceasefire and advance 'a political pathway to security and peace for Israelis, Palestinians and the entire region.' (aw)

In EU first, Germany to allow Taliban officials to work at Afghan missions
In EU first, Germany to allow Taliban officials to work at Afghan missions

Euractiv

time37 minutes ago

  • Euractiv

In EU first, Germany to allow Taliban officials to work at Afghan missions

BERLIN – Germany has become the first EU country to allow Afghanistan's Taliban regime to send officials to Germany to assist with the deportation of Afghan nationals. This move follows a push from Interior Minister Alexander Dobrindt for direct talks with the radical Islamist Taliban to facilitate regular deportations of rejected asylum seekers and convicted offenders to Afghanistan. Such flights had been largely halted due to diplomatic and human rights concerns after the militia toppled the Western-backed government in 2021. But Germany resumed deportations to Afghanistan on Friday – only the second such flight since 2021. As part of this arrangement, mediated by Qatar, the German government has approved the deployment of two Afghan consular officers to Germany, it confirmed on Monday. The officials would "support further planned deportation flights", said government spokesperson Stefan Kornelius. Berlin has insisted that this did not constitute recognition of the Taliban, according to the Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung (FAZ), which first reported the decision on Friday. Russia is currently the only country to have officially recognised the Taliban as Afghanistan's legitimate government, following an announcement three weeks ago. Still, Germany's decision marks a significant policy shift, as the newly elected government has pledged to crack down on illegal migration after a series of violent attacks linked to rejected asylum-seekers earlier this year. It also led a group of EU interior ministers, who called for regular deportations to Afghanistan and Syria at a dedicated migration summit on Friday. Norway, a non-EU member, is so far the only European country to have accepted an acting Taliban envoy, however. Germany maintains no formal diplomatic ties with the Taliban, with the German government saying there was only strictly technical cooperation on a regular basis. The two Afghan officials have previously worked for the Western-backed government and had no known history of extremism, according to the FAZ . They could arrive "soon" and would be based at the Afghan embassy in Berlin and the consulate in Bonn, without holding formal diplomatic rank. (aw)

Budapest claims deal with Belgrade, Moscow on new pipeline for Russian oil
Budapest claims deal with Belgrade, Moscow on new pipeline for Russian oil

Euractiv

time2 hours ago

  • Euractiv

Budapest claims deal with Belgrade, Moscow on new pipeline for Russian oil

Hungarian Foreign Minister Péter Szijjártó has announced an agreement with 'Serbian and Russian colleagues' to build a new oil pipeline between Serbia and Hungary, aimed at consolidating imports of Russian crude oil – just as the EU moves to finally freeze the Kremlin out of its energy market. In a typically provocative social media post on Monday, Szijjártó blamed the EU's ongoing efforts to prohibit Russian fossil fuel imports for driving up energy prices to 'several times' those in other parts of the world. 'And this is no wonder, given Brussels is forcibly dismantling energy ties, banning Russian energy sources and blocking supply routes,' Szijjártó wrote on social media. The move comes as the EU actively seeks to close off the remaining imports of Russian gas – flows that, although substantially reduced since the full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022, still provide considerable revenue for the Kremlin's unprovoked war against its smaller neighbor. Legislators are currently negotiating a proposal to ban imports of Russian gas completely by 2027. The European Parliament's lead negotiator is also pushing to extend the prohibition to pipeline oil, while also bringing forward the deadline. The announcement from Budapest came after a video conference between Szijjártó, Russian Deputy Energy Minister Pavel Sorokin, and Serbian Energy Minister Dubravka Đedović, the state-controlled news agency MTI reported. The proposed pipeline could be operational as early as 2027, MTI reported, although few details were provided about the nature of the agreement with Moscow and Belgrade. In a video clip included in the report, Szijjártó – whose government, led by Prime Minister Viktor Orbán, has long made capping domestic energy bills a key element in election campaigning – reiterated his criticism of EU energy policy. 'We will not allow this,' Szijjártó said. 'We will build pipelines and open up new sources of supply, and so maintain Europe's lowest energy bills for the Hungarian people.' According to recent statistics, Hungarian households have the lowest gas bills in the EU at €3.20 per 100 kWh compared to €16.71 in the Netherlands and €18.93 in Sweden. Hungary and neighbouring Slovakia have repeatedly obstructed EU attempts to impose economic sanctions on Russian oil and gas, where unanimity among all 27 EU member states is required. However, the REPowerEU package currently under negotiation between governments and the European Parliament would require only a qualified majority to pass into law. (aw)

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store