'Intolerable' for garda's family to have impasse in Stephen Silver appeal 'drag on', judge says
Lawyers representing Stephen Silver, who is serving a 40-year sentence for the capital murder of Detective Garda Colm Horkan, have said they are unable to advance an appeal against his conviction as they have 'hit a brick wall' in obtaining what they argue is crucial disclosure from the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) relating to psychiatric evidence.
Speaking as the matter was raised during a review of dormant cases at the Court of Appeal on Monday, Mr John Edwards said it was 'intolerable' that Det Gda Horkan's inquest has been delayed as a result of the pending proceedings.
Advertisement
He said that the matter 'cannot drag on'.
Silver (48), a motorbike mechanic from Aughaward, Foxford, Co Mayo, had pleaded not guilty to the murder of Det Gda Horkan knowing or being reckless as to whether he was a member of An Garda Síochána acting in accordance with his duty.
He had pleaded guilty to manslaughter at Castlerea, Co Roscommon on June 17th, 2020, and the jury was told the main issue in the trial was Mr Silver's state of mind at the time of the shooting.
Silver, who killed Gda Horkan by shooting him eleven times with the garda's own gun, was jailed for life with a minimum time to be served of 40 years by a judge at the Central Criminal Court in April 2023.
Advertisement
The court heard Silver had suffered from bipolar affective disorder, though consultant psychiatrist Prof Harry Kennedy said he found 'no positive evidence' Silver had relapsed at the time he shot dead Det Horkan.
However Dr Brenda Wright, then interim clinical director at the Central Mental Hospital, told the court that Silver's illness contributed significantly to his actions at that time.
At the Court of Appeal on Monday, Morgan Shelley BL, representing Silver, said that this was, in effect, a diminished responsibility case and the psychiatric evidence was a 'critical issue'.
Mr Shelley said there was an issue in another case relating to one of the expert witnesses in Silver's trial and his legal team believe the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) may have materials that could be relevant to that. He said they have asked for 'comprehensive disclosure' from the DPP in relation to this but have 'hit a brick wall'.
Advertisement
'We may need this court to determine the issue, or we may need to go to another court for that,' he said.
Mr Justice John Edwards, presiding, said the coroner for County Mayo has written to inform the court that he cannot complete the inquest into Garda Horkan's death until the case is determined. He noted that Silver's appeal was last before the court in December 2023.
Mr Shelley remarked that a proper response from the DPP would assist in moving matters along.
Adjourning proceedings to a case management list on June 20th, Mr Justice Edwards told Mr Shelley that if there was a continuing 'log jam' then a motion could be brought before the court at that stage.
Advertisement
'This cannot drag on, particularly when there is an inquest and a family being prejudiced by this,' said the judge, describing the situation as 'intolerable'.
'This has to be addressed, and it will be addressed quickly from here on,' he added.
During the trial, the jury heard evidence from Silver that he believed Gda Horkan was 'a heavy down from Dublin' who was trying to kill him. He said that Gda Horkan, who was not in uniform and drove an unmarked car, was wearing a Tommy Hilfiger jacket and 'didn't come across' as a garda.
He gave evidence that a struggle ensued between them before he fell to the ground, and in the process of getting up he felt the gun on Gda Horkan's hip.
Advertisement
He said that he felt Gda Horkan 'was trying to kill me'.
Ireland
Roads gardaí should not be exposed to 'excessive d...
Read More
'I kept shooting until the gun finished and there was no ammunition left,' Silver said.
Silver's first trial ended in a jury disagreement. His defence at his second trial was that he could be found guilty of manslaughter either because he believed he was acting in self defence but used excessive force or because his responsibility was significantly diminished due to a mental disorder.
The jury rejected both defences and found him guilty of murdering Gda Horkan, a member of An Garda Siochana acting in the course of his duty. Under the Criminal Justice Act 1990, the judge must impose the ordinary life sentence for murder and specify that Silver serve a minimum of 40 years in prison.
With ordinary remission for good behaviour, Silver will be eligible to apply for parole after he has served 30 years.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BreakingNews.ie
3 hours ago
- BreakingNews.ie
Ian Bailey was 'probably 100% innocent', director of du Plantier murder drama says
Film director Jim Sheridan has said that the late Ian Bailey 'probably was 100 per cent innocent' of the murder of Sophie Toscan du Plantier in West Cork. The battered body of the 39-year-old French film producer was found near her holiday home in Toormore on the outskirts of Schull in West Cork on December 23rd, 2006. Advertisement In an interview with Newstalk Breakfast, Mr Sheridan said he believes the case is a "double injustice. 'I feel Sophie's murderer has never been found, her death has never been avenged. 'A man who probably was 100 per cent innocent has been castigated through life; he lived a horrible life and died a horrible death and has a horrible name. 'I don't think he killed her, and there's not a shred of evidence to say he did.' Advertisement Mr Sheridan's new drama, Re Creation, about the murder, recently premiered at the Tribeca Film Festival in New York. Starring Colm Meaney, Aidan Gilles and Vicky Krieps, it imagines what could have unfolded if the unresolved murder had gone before a jury in Ireland. Ian Bailey, who died in January 2024 at the age of 66, was the self-confessed chief suspect in the case. He was on two occasions detained by gardaí for questioning in relation to the murder. Mr Bailey was convicted in absentia after a trial in France in 2015. He was sentenced to 25 years in prison. Advertisement However, officials in France were unable to extradite him to Paris to serve the sentence handed down by the courts. Mr Sheridan said that Mr Bailey's conviction in Paris was a 'farce.' He said that he 'of course' knew he risked causing upset to the family of Toscan du Plantier with his new drama. 'You can't say because you're upset that you can ruin another man's life,' he said. "There's no evidence.' Mr Sheridan acknowledged that Mr Bailey's history of violence with his former partner, Jules Thomas, was 'not good.' Advertisement He said that there was no doubt of the suffering experienced by the family of Ms Toscan du Plantier. However, Mr Sheridan stressed that the family of Mr Bailey have also suffered over the years. 'I'm sure Ian Bailey's sister was upset that there was nobody at his funeral and that he had to die that ignominious way. I'm sure she's upset.' During a defamation trial in 2014, Mr Bailey admitted that he had been "seriously violent" towards his partner on three occasions. Newstalk Breakfast also heard from Alain Spilliaert, a lawyer for Ms Toscan du Plantier's family. He has not seen the film yet, but has expressed concern about its potential content. Advertisement 'Mr Jean-Pierre Gazeau, the uncle of Sophie and President of the Association, raised the issue of questionable ethics,' he said. 'We feel that it is not relevant to show a fictional movie at this point of time of the criminal investigation. 'This is such a large, sensitive case in Ireland… and it's not finished.' Mr Spilliaert added that it would have been better to wait until the cold case review concludes before any drama about the case goes into the public domain. Meanwhile, the elderly father of Ms Toscan Du Plantier died in December of last year, just days after the 28th anniversary of her murder. Georges Bouniol, who was 98, passed away in Paris after spending close to three decades seeking justice for the murder of his daughter. Mr Bouniol died in hospital with his family at his bedside. For many years, Georges and his wife Marguerite travelled to west Cork at Christmas to attend an anniversary mass for Sophie with their son Bertrand and Sophie's son Pierre-Louis. In 2022, Sophie's uncle Jean Pierre Gazeau said it was the final wish of her parents to see a conviction in the case. He told the Irish Daily Mail that the family had waited too long for justice. 'They are so heartbroken that they still cannot move on with their lives. They've been waiting so long for justice and know they will not be around forever. It's their wish that they will see a successful end to this investigation so they can live the rest of their lives in peace.'
BreakingNews.ie
5 hours ago
- BreakingNews.ie
Young woman says she will not allow sexual assault to define her as cousin is jailed
A young Co Donegal woman has said she will not allow a sex assault on her to define her as her older cousin was jailed for 15 months for the crime. Brave Louise McMenamin waived her anonymity so her cousin Joseph McGinty could be named in court. Advertisement Ms McMenamin was just 10 and Joseph McGinty was aged 14 when he assaulted her during a sleepover at her home. McGinty, now 27, had pleaded not guilty to sexually assaulting Louise McMenamin on an unknown date between June 1st and September 1st, 2012. However, after a three day trial at Donegal Circuit Court, McGinty was found guilty by a jury of the allegation. McGinty, from Ballyshannon, was accused of touching the then ten year old girl on her bum and beneath her breast area while he was visiting the girl in her house on a sleepover. Advertisement McGinty sneaked into the girl's room and touched her on the bottom beneath her nightdress and then touched her breast area. Details of the incident were given at the sentencing hearing by Garda Catherine Henry of Ballyshannon Garda Station. After touching the young girl on her bum and under her chest, the court heard the young girl woke up and McGinty, with an address at Abberlands, Ballyshannon hid down behind the bed and she could hear him breathing. Advertisement She initially pretended to be asleep but when he got up to leave she asked him what he was doing in her room. The girl immediately went downstairs and told her father what had happened and he took the girl into her mother and a complaint was later made. The victim, who told the court that she wanted to be named so that McGinty could be named also, read a heart-wrenching victim impact statement about how the episode had impacted her life so deeply in so many negative ways. But Ms Louise McMenamin also told McGinty how she has now "been courageous enough to hold you accountable, seek justice and stand up to you." Advertisement Witness box She outlined the night she was set upon as a child in detail as she fought back tears in the witness box. She told how she has spent years in therapy with both the Child and Adolescent Mental Health Services (CAMHS) and also the Rape Crisis Centre (RCC) trying to remedy her anxiety and depression but that she still cannot tell herself that she is no longer in danger and safe from McGinty. She added "What you did to me, as a helpless 10 year old child has shaped the young woman I am now, and I hate that you have that power. I will always wonder, and never have the answers, about the person I would have been if you had not taken advantage of me at my most vulnerable. "It has changed the way I look at the world, the way I look at people. You knew right from wrong, and the poor decision you made that night has left me with a lifetime of fallout. I still experience crippling anxiety if I meet you in public, and although I now face up to you as an adult, it is the child in me that has suffered this pain that you caused that I am fighting for. Advertisement "I have carried the guilt of this burden for almost 13 years. The guilt of getting into trouble, the guilt of taking our cousins and extended family away from my brothers, the guilt of knowing that my parents feel like they have failed me. The guilt of missing valuable years without grandparents , the guilt of isolating myself from family and friends that did stand by me. The guilt of still letting this, letting you, control me and so much of my life all these years later. "I am choosing now to no longer carry this guilt, because it is not mine. You caused this, the weight of it has been suffocating and made me feel worthless, I will leave it behind." Ms McMenamin said there were times when questioned if she would be strong enough to face her abuser. But, she added, at aged 23 years, she is thankful that she fought her corner, told her truth and sought justice. And she thanked all those who stood beside her as she sought that justice and revealed how she is now graduating from university. She concluded "This may seem a short incident, but it has been my whole life from the night it took place. I do not deserve to feel this way anymore, I want to move on and start living my life for me, with this chapter closed. "I did not deserve to suffer due to your actions, to be shunned by our family for telling the truth and miss out on so many opportunities because of fear. I will no longer carry the shame of what you put me through, because I did nothing wrong. "It may have taken years, but I have realised that I am so much more than what you did to me. I cannot undo what you have done, and this will always be part of me, but I will not let it define me. Trauma "I survived what happened, and I will be a voice for other girls. I will not collapse under this trauma. I will continue to show bravery, move on and make younger me proud of the woman I have become, despite all the obstacles in my way." The mother of Joseph McGinty also took to the witness stand and told how the incident had had a massive impact on both families. She said that as a mother and an aunt she recognised "the trauma that both of these children have been through." She added that their grandparents had passed away with this matter on their minds. Mrs McGinty said she empathised with the trauma that Louise had suffered but that she was asking the court for leniency for her son. She reflected on how her son had grown up from being a happy boy to waking up with nightmares and being prescribed anti-depressant medication and developing severe eczema. However, he went through college and qualified as a civil engineer who is a popular worker within his company who has the full support of his boss. Mrs McGinty added that her son also respects the verdict of the jury in his case. Barrister for the accused, Mr Colm Smyth, SC, said this was indeed a tragic case which has had a debilitating effect on the extended families. Ms Smyth said it has been recognised the trauma which the victim has gone through but he said his client had suffered too and asked the court to take into account that the offence was committed when he was fourteen years old. He added that the level of maturity must come into play and he produced case law on this aspect of the case. He said McGinty respects the verdict of the court and has the capacity to take it in that time period but again stressed his client was at a very early stage of his development, either sexual or otherwise, at the time. He asked the court to consider a non-custodial sentence given the particular circumstances adding that McGinty has already suffered considerably and has carried the burden since his conviction. Passing sentence, Judge John Aylmer said the aggravating factors in the case was that the victim was only ten years old at the time and the "very severe impact" the offending has had on her as he made reference to her victim impact statement. He referred to the consequences of the assault and how Ms McMenamin still suffered and had to engage in counselling to cope with anxiety, depression and post traumatic stress disorder right throughout her education and has bravely struggled with all those effects. The Judge said he had to decide what the headline sentence for McGinty should be before factoring in that he was only 14 years at the time and said that if it was an adult who snuck into the bedroom then without hesitation he would impose a sentence of three years in prison. He added the law establishes the fact that the accused was 14 years old although he added that there was no evidence as to how sophisticated a young man he was in his development. The fact that he snuck in and sought to commit the offence when Ms McMenamin was asleep and then hid behind the bed when she woke up, indicated that he had full awareness of what he was doing, added Judge Aylmer. He said this was the only evidence he had to make a determination as to the accused's culpability. He said he was entitled to have his own experience of life and of fourteen year olds and add that to his assessment, and with the guidance of authorities open to him, Judge Aylmer said he deemed it appropriate to reduce the sentence by 50% to one of 18 months in prison. He added the few mitigating factors that exist mandate a reduction to one of 15 months in prison, a reduction of one sixth. He then said the question then arises if some or all of the sentence could be suspended as McGinty had come before the courts with no previous convictions and having no adverse attention since the incident. He said he had taken into account that he was a minor and allowed him a 50% reduction. Because of the gravity of the case and there is no admission of guilt and no expression of remorse for the victim to avail of, as well as nothing before the court about rehabilitation for you, Judge Aylmer said this is not a case where the court could justify a suspended sentence. He sentenced McGinty to 15 months in prison and placed him on the sex offender's register for a period of five years. If you have been affected by any of the issues raised in this article, you can call the national 24-hour Rape Crisis Helpline at 1800-77 8888, access text service and webchat options at or visit Rape Crisis Help .
BreakingNews.ie
6 hours ago
- BreakingNews.ie
Two people charged following €240,000 cannabis seizure
Gardaí have charged the two people that were arrested following the seizure by Revenue officers of 12kg of herbal cannabis, with an estimated value of €240,000. The seizures were made at two separate locations in Swords, Co Dublin on Monday. Advertisement The man, aged in his 30s has been charged in relation to the seizure and is due to appear before Balbriggan District Court this morning at 10.30am. The female, aged in her late teens, was charged in relation to the seizure and released on bail. She is due to appear before Balbriggan District Court at a later date. Investigations ongoing, gardaí said.
