'Intolerable' for garda's family to have impasse in Stephen Silver appeal 'drag on', judge says
Lawyers representing Stephen Silver, who is serving a 40-year sentence for the capital murder of Detective Garda Colm Horkan, have said they are unable to advance an appeal against his conviction as they have 'hit a brick wall' in obtaining what they argue is crucial disclosure from the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) relating to psychiatric evidence.
Speaking as the matter was raised during a review of dormant cases at the Court of Appeal on Monday, Mr John Edwards said it was 'intolerable' that Det Gda Horkan's inquest has been delayed as a result of the pending proceedings.
Advertisement
He said that the matter 'cannot drag on'.
Silver (48), a motorbike mechanic from Aughaward, Foxford, Co Mayo, had pleaded not guilty to the murder of Det Gda Horkan knowing or being reckless as to whether he was a member of An Garda Síochána acting in accordance with his duty.
He had pleaded guilty to manslaughter at Castlerea, Co Roscommon on June 17th, 2020, and the jury was told the main issue in the trial was Mr Silver's state of mind at the time of the shooting.
Silver, who killed Gda Horkan by shooting him eleven times with the garda's own gun, was jailed for life with a minimum time to be served of 40 years by a judge at the Central Criminal Court in April 2023.
Advertisement
The court heard Silver had suffered from bipolar affective disorder, though consultant psychiatrist Prof Harry Kennedy said he found 'no positive evidence' Silver had relapsed at the time he shot dead Det Horkan.
However Dr Brenda Wright, then interim clinical director at the Central Mental Hospital, told the court that Silver's illness contributed significantly to his actions at that time.
At the Court of Appeal on Monday, Morgan Shelley BL, representing Silver, said that this was, in effect, a diminished responsibility case and the psychiatric evidence was a 'critical issue'.
Mr Shelley said there was an issue in another case relating to one of the expert witnesses in Silver's trial and his legal team believe the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) may have materials that could be relevant to that. He said they have asked for 'comprehensive disclosure' from the DPP in relation to this but have 'hit a brick wall'.
Advertisement
'We may need this court to determine the issue, or we may need to go to another court for that,' he said.
Mr Justice John Edwards, presiding, said the coroner for County Mayo has written to inform the court that he cannot complete the inquest into Garda Horkan's death until the case is determined. He noted that Silver's appeal was last before the court in December 2023.
Mr Shelley remarked that a proper response from the DPP would assist in moving matters along.
Adjourning proceedings to a case management list on June 20th, Mr Justice Edwards told Mr Shelley that if there was a continuing 'log jam' then a motion could be brought before the court at that stage.
Advertisement
'This cannot drag on, particularly when there is an inquest and a family being prejudiced by this,' said the judge, describing the situation as 'intolerable'.
'This has to be addressed, and it will be addressed quickly from here on,' he added.
During the trial, the jury heard evidence from Silver that he believed Gda Horkan was 'a heavy down from Dublin' who was trying to kill him. He said that Gda Horkan, who was not in uniform and drove an unmarked car, was wearing a Tommy Hilfiger jacket and 'didn't come across' as a garda.
He gave evidence that a struggle ensued between them before he fell to the ground, and in the process of getting up he felt the gun on Gda Horkan's hip.
Advertisement
He said that he felt Gda Horkan 'was trying to kill me'.
Ireland
Roads gardaí should not be exposed to 'excessive d...
Read More
'I kept shooting until the gun finished and there was no ammunition left,' Silver said.
Silver's first trial ended in a jury disagreement. His defence at his second trial was that he could be found guilty of manslaughter either because he believed he was acting in self defence but used excessive force or because his responsibility was significantly diminished due to a mental disorder.
The jury rejected both defences and found him guilty of murdering Gda Horkan, a member of An Garda Siochana acting in the course of his duty. Under the Criminal Justice Act 1990, the judge must impose the ordinary life sentence for murder and specify that Silver serve a minimum of 40 years in prison.
With ordinary remission for good behaviour, Silver will be eligible to apply for parole after he has served 30 years.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BreakingNews.ie
42 minutes ago
- BreakingNews.ie
No proof Puska's sisters-in-law knew he murdered Ashling Murphy when they burnt clothes, court hears
Jozef Puska's sisters-in-law could not have known, and did not believe, that he murdered Ashling Murphy when they burned the clothes he was wearing at the time he stabbed 23-year-old schoolteacher to death, defence lawyers have told the Central Criminal Court. Lawyers for Jozefina Grundzova (32) and Viera Gaziova (40) delivered their closing speeches to a jury this afternoon. The two women are on trial with their husbands, Marek Puska (36) and Lubomir Puska Jnr (38). Advertisement Jozef Puska, a brother of Marek and Lubomir Jnr, murdered Ashling Murphy on January 12th, 2022, by stabbing her in the neck on the canal towpath outside Tullamore, Co Offaly. Marek and Lubomir Jnr are on trial, accused of withholding information relating to the murder, while Ms Grundzova and Ms Gaziova are accused of impeding Jozef's apprehension or prosecution by burning his clothes. All the accused were living with Jozef Puska, his wife Lucia, and 14 children at Lynally Grove, Mucklagh, Co Offaly when the offences are alleged to have occurred in January 2022. All accused have pleaded not guilty to all charges. Advertisement Paul Murray SC, for Ms Grundzova, told the jury on Tuesday that for his client to be guilty, the jury must be satisfied that she knew what Jozef had done when she helped Ms Gaziova to burn the clothes. Counsel told the jury that "hindsight is a wonderful thing", but they must look at the circumstances in the Puska household in the immediate aftermath of the murder. When his client burned Puska's clothes, she did not have any of the evidence that would later prove Jozef's guilt, Mr Murray said. At that time, about 24 hours after the murder, gardaí also didn't know because they had arrested and were questioning the wrong man, Mr Murray said. Advertisement All Ms Grundzova knew, counsel said, was second-hand information that had been relayed to her regarding conversations between Jozef Puska and others in the household. Jozef had said numerous things which were "obvious nonsense" and "garbled lies", along with the truth - that he had stabbed or killed a girl. Ms Grundzova could not have known that the true part was that Jozef had murdered Ashling Murphy and that the rest was nonsense, counsel said. She, like the others in the household, didn't believe that Jozef could be capable of such a thing. The nub of the prosecution case, counsel said, is that Ms Grundzova knew or believed Jozef Puska to be guilty of the murder of Ashling Murphy at a time when gardaí themselves had arrested an entirely different person. Mr Murray asked the jury to return a verdict of not guilty. Prosecutor Anne Marie Lawlor SC has previously told the jury that all the accused knew what Jozef had done shortly after 9.30pm on the night of the murder. Advertisement She said Jozef told Lubomir Jnr and Marek, who then relayed it to the others in the house. Ms Lawlor said the only reason for the withholding of evidence or burning of clothes was that they didn't want Jozef to be apprehended or prosecuted for murder. Damien Colgan SC, for Ms Gaziova, told the jury that the "crux of the case" is whether his client knew that Jozef Puska had stabbed Ms Murphy. Her view at that time, Mr Colgan said, was that Jozef had been the victim of an assault. When she was told what Jozef had said he did, she didn't believe it because she "didn't believe Jozef was capable of killing anybody". Kathleen Leader SC, for Lubomir Jnr, said her client delayed but did not withhold information. She said he had a reasonable excuse for the delay and asked the jury to consider the "natural sense of protection for his younger brother". She said it is understandable that Lubomir Jnr was reluctant to accept that his brother had "committed a truly horrific murder". Advertisement The family was "particularly close", she said, living together as six adults and 14 children in a four-bed home. Lubomir told gardaí that their relationship was "full of love". When Jozef left the house early on the 12th and returned that night with visible injuries, the initial concern among the close knit family was, Ms Leader said, "not that Jozef had behaved in a criminal manner, much less that he had murdered someone, but that Jozef himself had been hurt in some way." Lubomir Jnr spoke to gardaí on January 14th, 16th and 18th. Ms Leader said the statements reveal the progression of a man "coming to terms with something awful that was not of his doing." She added: "He is working his way to a place where he is able to leave the bonds of family and brotherhood and love and all that entails, to where he discharges his other obligation to society as a whole, which is what he did." Ms Leader said that by January 18th, Lubomir was "squarely supporting the prosecution", telling them everything he knew. She reminded the jury that he said, "If you find out it was him, well, let him. He is going to pay for what he did." Ireland Jozef Puska's brother withheld information to prot... Read More Ms Leader asked the jury to think of someone they love. She added: "Think of that person coming home, out of the blue, and telling you they had done something so truly awful, something you hadn't imagined in your wildest dreams. Was it reasonable in those circumstances to disclose the information in stages?" Ms Leader said the law does not require people to be "superhuman" as she asked the jury to acquit her client. Ms Justice Caroline Biggs has begun her charge to the jury and will continue on Wednesday.
BreakingNews.ie
an hour ago
- BreakingNews.ie
Inquest hears young man fell from apartment block just seconds after talking to gardaí
A young man suffered fatal injuries in a fall from an apartment block in Dublin less than a week after he had been discharged from a psychiatric hospital and just seconds after talking to gardai, an inquest has heard. A sitting of Dublin District Coroner's Court heard relatives of Hassan Mohammad Osman (21) express concern about the circumstances of the death of the 21-year-old Somalian native including that they had not been informed that he had indicated he was suicidal when he was involuntarily admitted to St Vincent's Hospital in Fairview a month earlier. Advertisement A postmortem showed Mr Osman died from a blunt force head injury consistent with a fall from a height. The incident occurred shortly after midnight on September 26th, 2021 at Hampton Wood Point, Finglas. Mr Osman never regained consciousness and died three days later at the Mater Misericordiae University Hospital. Gardaí had been alerted to the scene by a local resident who had recorded a male standing on a windowsill of a fourth floor apartment around 12.20am. Garda Diarmuid Murphy said Mr Osman had come down to the entrance of the apartment block by the time he and a colleague had arrived at the scene. Advertisement Garda Murphy said the young man appeared slightly confused and incoherent but calm in response to some questions. On the way to the deceased's apartment, Mr Osman said he needed to finish 'the game of life' before adding: 'I am God. I must die' which Garda Murphy said he found 'alarming.' Garda Murphy said he followed Mr Osman into his bedroom to check the safety locks of the window after the young man declared he was fine and going to bed. The inquest heard two gardaí, Mr Osman's mother and one of his brothers were with him when he got up and left the room. Advertisement Garda Murphy said he then heard another of the deceased's brothers, who was in the kitchen, shouting about Mr Osman's fall from the balcony. In reply to questions from the coroner, Cróna Gallagher, he said he had planned to detain the deceased under the Mental Health Act but was checking with his family as they were unaware about him being on the windowsill. He accepted that he had been wrong 'to assume the worst was over'. 'As far as we were concerned, he was safe,' said Garda Murphy. Advertisement He told the coroner that gardaí were trained to remain calm in dealing with such cases and to try and de-escalate a situation, but he did not believe the training was 'sufficient enough.' However, Garda Murphy said gardaí 'don't operate with perfect knowledge and make the best judgement.' A consultant psychiatrist, Prosper Obioha, gave evidence that Mr Osman had been admitted to St Vincent's Hospital for a relapse of paranoid schizophrenia that he had first been diagnosed with in 2018. The inquest heard Ms Osman had mental health issues since he was 15 and also had been treated for substance abuse. Advertisement Dr Obioha said the deceased had indicated he was suicidal on admission to the hospital on August 24, 2021 but that he subsequently denied having such thoughts during the remainder of his stay. He accepted Mr Osman's family had not been informed about that, but he explained there were patient confidentiality issues as well as that it appeared not to be 'an ongoing issue.' The psychiatrist outlined how Mr Osman was discharged on September 20, 2021 after improvements in his health and on condition that he took his medication and stopped using cannabis. Dr Obioha stressed that the patient was not psychotic at the time of discharge, while the medication he was prescribed would not have made his situation worse. The deceased's sister, Nima Osman, told the hearing that it was difficult to speak about her brother, whom she described as one of the bravest, strongest people she knew, in the past tense. However, Ms Osman remarked: 'His mental health battles became too heavy to carry alone.' Ms Osman called for greater awareness about mental health issues because of the 'heartbreakingly high' rate of suicide among young men in Ireland. She urged people to be 'more cautious, more human and more aware' with people like her brother. The inquest heard Hassan, Nima and their mother, Nurrto Abdikadir Ahmed, moved to Ireland from Somalia in 2005. Ms Ahmed told the hearing Hassan was her favourite child and that he had a leg amputated following a shooting incident when he was aged 4. She recalled the family had eaten dinner that evening at 8pm before Hassan had gone back to his bedroom. An officer with Fiosrú – the Office of the Police Ombudsman, Liam Hickey, said an investigation had found no breaches of any regulations by gardaí in the eight minutes they had contact with the deceased. Mr Hickey said there were no specific guidelines governing the situation, and it was up to individual gardaí to assess how to deal with what they found. Returning a verdict of self-inflicted death, Dr Gallagher said she could not make a finding of death by suicide as it was unclear that Ms Osman was capable of forming the intent to take his own life given his medical history. The coroner offered her condolences to the deceased's relatives on what she described as 'an extremely sad and tragic case.' If you have been affected by any of the issues raised in this article, you can freephone the Samaritans 24 hours a day for confidential support at 116-123 or email jo@ Alternatively, contact information for a range of mental health supports is available at In the case of an emergency, or if you or someone you know is at risk of suicide or self-harm, dial 999/112.
BreakingNews.ie
an hour ago
- BreakingNews.ie
Court no show for teen after man's fingers hacked off in machete and ammonia attack
A judge has ordered the arrest of a 17-year-old boy who failed to answer bail over a machete, hammer and ammonia attack on a man who had two fingers "amputated" in Dublin last month. The youth, who cannot be named because he is a minor, is accused of assault causing harm to a man, aged 29, and burglary in Clondalkin, Dublin, on May 9th. He was granted bail with strict conditions on May 12th at the Dublin Children's Court but following four-week adjournment he did not return for his next scheduled hearing. Advertisement The case had been listed directions from the Director of Public Prosecutions to be outlined. Noting the youth had not turned up, Judge Brendan Toale issued a bench warrant for his arrest. At his bail hearing last month, Garda Charles McPartland submitted that this case was on the more serious end of the scale for these offences and undoubtedly would proceed on indictment to the Circuit Court, which has wider sentencing powers. He alleged that on May 9th, the injured party was pursued by multiple armed males through the Bawnogue area of Clondalkin. Advertisement He attempted to flee from them on foot until he ran into an independent third-party member of the public's home at Kilcronan View. The court heard that while running into the house, the injured man told the owner to ring gardaí and an ambulance, before he was followed into the property by three or four males. A 999 call from a witness alerted gardaí, who also received a second call believed to have been from the victim who seemed to be hyperventilating, the court heard. Garda McPartland said the house owner reported hearing the man inside shouting "leave me alone, leave me alone". Advertisement Objecting to bail, the investigating officer cited the seriousness of the case and the strength of evidence, which was said to have included CCTV footage from the area where the teen and others were looking for the man. Members of the group were alleged to have been carrying a machete or a claw hammer. The contested bail hearing was told that when the man fled into the house, he went into a child's upstairs bedroom where he was "violently assaulted, sustaining life-altering injuries". Judge Toale heard the injured party sustained two fingers, with his thumb and index finger on his left being cut off; his left middle finger was cut to the bone and "hanging on by skin only". Advertisement It was alleged he suffered a severe laceration to the back of his head, three more to his left leg and another three cuts to his left arm. The garda revealed that the injured party also had an acidic liquid, suspected to be ammonia, thrown over him during the assault. He was taken to hospital for immediate medical intervention, including surgery to attempt to re-attach his amputated fingers, which was unsuccessful. An examination of the scene showed blood in the child's room where the man had fled. The door handle on the inside had "snapped", and the outside handle was "bent out of shape", which Garda McPartland asserted was due to the force used to open the door. Advertisement An off-duty nurse who tried to assist the injured man afterwards also needed to go to hospital due to inhalation of airborne ammonia, the court was told. Questioned by defence barrister, Doireann McDonagh, instructed by solicitor Simon Fleming, Garda McPartland said three people had weapons, but the machete caused the injuries described. It was not alleged that the teenager had the machete. Judge Toale noted from the barrister's submission that the youth could face a lengthy period in custody and away from his family, awaiting trial. At the bail hearing his father told the judge he wanted his son to get back into education to complete the Leaving Certificate. Ireland Man's fingers hacked off in machete, hammer and am... Read More Counsel submitted that the teen would obey conditions and that there was no evidence he would be involved in witness intimidation. The judge set bail and ordered him to have no contact with witnesses, to obey an 11pm-6am curfew at his home, stay out of the housing estate where the incident occurred, and attend a youth service or education. The youth was warned that breaking the terms would result in custody. Two men have also been charged and face separate proceedings on connected charges.
