Former US official says Israel should give Patriot interceptors to Ukraine
Dan Caldwell, a former senior advisor to US Defence Secretary Pete Hegseth, wrote on X that: "Trump has made clear he wants to provide Ukraine with more air defense assets. With that in mind, I think the best place to get them from with the least amount of trade offs against US and allied readiness is from Israel's stocks of retired Patriot PAC-2 missiles/batteries."
"Israel has already provided one Patriot battery and about 90 missiles to the U.S. for refurbishment, which was then reportedly sent on to Ukraine. According to open source data, Israel probably has about eight batteries and several hundred missiles left in storage," he said.
"Considering the significant amount of THAAD and SM-3/6 interceptors expended in defense of Israel during the 12 day war the U.S. has more than enough standing to ask Israel to send a portion of its retired Patriot stockpile back to the U.S. which can then be provided to Ukraine," he added.
US President Donald Trump has grown frustrated with his Russian counter-part Vladimir Putin as peace talks stall, saying earlier this week he was full of 'bullshit'.
New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch
Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters
Trump promised to send defensive weapons to Ukraine in a U-turn after the administration had ordered a pause on weapons shipments that included Patriot interceptors. Axios news reported that Trump promised to send 10 interceptors to Ukraine, underscoring how precious a commodity patriots have become.
The war in Ukraine, the US campaign against the Houthis and the Israel-Iran conflict have exhausted the supply of interceptors. Patriot batteries are also in short supply.
Middle East Eye was the first to reveal during the recent Israel-Iran conflict that US officials were concerned about the pace at which they were using interceptors to defend Israel from ballistic missile attacks.
The Guardian later reported that it only has about 25 percent of the Patriot missile interceptors that planners at the Pentagon assess are needed for all the US's military operations globally. A US official confirmed that classified number to MEE.
Iran receives Chinese surface-to-air missile batteries after Israel ceasefire deal Read More »
During the recent conflict with Iran, the US joined directly in Israel's defence using Terminal High Altitude Area Defence (Thaad) batteries and guided-missile destroyers firing SM-3/6 ship-based missiles to shoot down Iranian ballistic missiles.
The Trump administration has already pulled at least one older Patriot battery from Israel, a US official told MEE. The US planned to refurbish the system before sending it to Ukraine. It's unclear if that delivery has taken place.
According to leaked classified documents, Ukraine received the newer Pac-3 interceptors from the US, the Netherlands and Germany in the early years of Russia's invasion. Israel maintains a stockpile of Pac-2 interceptors, which would also meet Ukraine's needs and address shortages.
Israel decommissioned its Pac-2 air-defence systems when it developed its three-tiered air defence of the Iron-dome, David's Sling and Arrow 2 and 3 systems. These systems are co-produced and co-developed with the US.
The US is informed of Israeli supplies and production, but one US official familiar with the programme told MEE that it's likely Israel does not disclose its entire production capabilities to the US. Israel, like the US and its other partners, has a motivation to keep its stockpile high.
Israel has been reluctant to meet all of Ukraine's demands for weaponry and ammunition since Russia's 2022 invasion. One of Israel's main points was that it could not afford to irk Moscow, which had air defence systems in Syria, but allowed Israeli warplanes freedom of action to bomb Iranian targets. However, Bashar al-Assad, Russia and Iran's ally, was toppled from power in December 2024.
Russia has also demurred on providing the Islamic Republic of Iran with S-400 air defence systems, instead selling it the S-300, experts say.
'Israel also needs to take into account its own relations with Russia - who so far has held back supplying certain advanced weapons to Iran,' Caldwell said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Middle East Eye
5 hours ago
- Middle East Eye
BBC condemned for repeating Israeli narrative on slain journalist Anas al-Sharif
BBC's reporting on the killing of several Palestinian journalists in Gaza has been on the receiving end of fierce criticism, with thousands on social media saying the broadcaster is 'parroting the Israeli narrative'. Late on Sunday local time, prominent Al Jazeera correspondents Anas al-Sharif and Mohammed Qreiqeh were killed in a drone strike on a press tent near al-Shifa hospital in Gaza City. The strike also took the lives of Al Jazeera staff Ibrahim Zaher, Mohammed Noufal and Moamen Aliwa, as well as freelance journalist Mohammed al-Khalidi. While many around the world mourned their losses, the BBC's coverage of the slain journalists received backlash for repeating Israel's accusation that Sharif had a "dual role" as "journalist and terrorist". Israel has routinely made such claims about journalists, which have been strongly rejected by the Committee to Protect Journalists. One social media user suggested that this was a character assassination, right after Israel killed him. New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters "Lets bring in our colleague Yolande Knell who is in Jerusalem. The accusation from Israel is that Anas al Sharif had a dual role, he was both in their words journalist and terrorist..." The IDF assassinated him. Now the BBC assassinates his character. — Saul Staniforth (@SaulStaniforth) August 11, 2025 In another report, a BBC news anchor said, 'Israel says Anas Al-Sharif was a member of Hamas, a claim long rejected by the news network, his family, and the Committee to Protect Journalists (CPJ).' For many on social media, the news anchor adding the fact that Al Jazeera and the CPJ rejected these claims was not enough, with one saying, 'the BBC stooped so low it should be banned from broadcasting after parroting the Israeli narrative.' The @BBC just stooped so low it should be banned from broadcasting after parroting the Israeli narrative about murdered @AnasAlSharif0 — Sarah Wilkinson (@swilkinsonbc) August 10, 2025 The BBC's coverage also ignited criticism of many other western media outlets. Many on social media suggested that media outlets that remained silent while Israel continued its assaults on Gaza for 21 months were 'complicit' in the "genocidal machine". One social media user compiled headlines from western media outlets, in which the German Bild magazine wrote, 'Journalist in disguise as terrorists killed in Gaza'. Anas a beacon of light, killed by cowards to hide their crimes. You never stood when they threatened him for telling the truth#Reuters, #Bild, #Sky, #BBC & all other apologists/propagandists for a genocidal machine you're complicit We will never forget. We will never forgive — Osama Bin Javaid (@osamabinjavaid) August 11, 2025 Others praised Sharif for standing 'unbowed before Zionism, exposing Israel's war crimes with integrity and honour'. In one social media post, a person shared a screenshot from the BBC, saying: 'Anas Al-Sharif worked for a Hamas media team in Gaza before the current conflict.' The person wrote, 'The BBC has repeatedly abandoned the core principles of journalism, choosing to support the genocide rather than report the truth about its victims.' The BBC (@BBC) insists on adopting the Israeli narrative, falsely claiming that Anas Al-Sharif was affiliated with Hamas. Al-Sharif was broadcasting and reporting the genocide in #Gaza live, day in and day out—and for that, he was deliberately killed. The BBC does not shy away… — Sahat English 🇵🇸 (@sahatenglish) August 11, 2025 According to Gaza's government media office, Israel has killed 238 Palestinian journalists since the start of the war in October 2023. Over 61,000 Palestinians have been killed in the enclave, and starvation is looming, with more than 200 dead from hunger. Rights groups and press freedom advocates have described the war in Gaza as the deadliest conflict for journalists in modern history while human rights groups, scholars and some countries quantify it as a genocide.
Middle East Eye
6 hours ago
- Middle East Eye
Largest US socialist organisation passes resolution supporting Palestinian resistance
The Democratic Socialists of America (DSA), the largest socialist organisation in the United States, passed a resolution on Sunday that supports the Palestinian right to resist and makes supporting Israel an expellable offence. The resolution, passed with a 56 to 43 percent vote at DSA's biennial convention, also allocates resources to pro-Palestine organising and emphasises the Palestinian right to return "from the river to the sea". One of DSA's most influential members is New York State assemblyman Zohran Mamdani, who in June won the Democratic Primary for Mayor of New York City. Mamdani is part of the DSA's 'State Socialists in Office', a nine-person bloc of DSA-endorsed officials elected to office. Mamdani has historically supported the Palestinian-led Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions (BDS) movement, which aims to make Israel comply with international laws and respect Palestinian rights through non-violent means. He also says he would discourage the use of the phrase 'Globalise the Intifada' and says Israel 'has a right to exist as a state with equal rights'. The DSA wields influence over several important unions around the country, such as the United Auto Workers (UAW). New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters The UAW was one of seven major unions representing nearly half of unionised workers in the US, which called for the end of all US military aid to Israel. Still, some unions, like the International Longshoremen's Association (ILA), have refused to call for an arms embargo. When the ILA workers went on strike in October, union workers continued to ship military cargo despite the work stoppage. The resolution Sunday's resolutions contained both political and practical commitments for DSA. Politically, the resolution supports al-Thawabit, or the Palestinian red lines, the unifying principles outlined by the Palestinian Liberation Organisation in 1977. These principles include the recognition of Jerusalem as the capital of Palestine, the Palestinian right to resist and the right to self-determination. Zohran Mamdani's support for Palestinian rights sealed mayoral primary win, poll shows Read More » The resolutions also make publicly and consistently opposing the BDS movement, taking money from pro-Israel lobbying groups, and supporting the transfer of funds or weapons to Israel an expellable offence. Elected officials are expected to be held to similar standards by DSA. Last year, DSA unendorsed representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez over her support for the funding of the Iron Dome, an Israeli defence system, and a definition of antisemitism that considers Zionism a protected class. Practically, Sunday's resolution resolved to devote attention and resources to the 'Student Intifada', a term activists have used to describe pro-Palestine protests on university campuses, and to the Mask off Maersk campaign. The Mask Off campaign, spearheaded by the Palestinian Youth Movement, aims to halt the shipments of arms to Israel by shipping giant Maersk. Moroccan unions have called on their workers to boycott Maersk vessels carrying military cargo, and Spanish port authorities have denied entry to Maersk ships transporting weapons to Israel. DSA's resolution states it will leverage its influence in the labour movement to enact similar pressure on Maersk in the United States. Shifting politics When the DSA was founded in 1982, the organisation and its leader, Michael Harrington, supported Israel. Harrington described Zionism as a 'national liberation movement' and DSA initially held largely liberal Zionist views. But as DSA grew and pro-Palestine sentiments became more widely accepted among the American left, DSA's position gradually changed. Sunday's resolution, and its support for al-Thawabit, represent a years-long political shift from DSA's initial liberal Zionist principles towards more pro-Palestine positions. This shift has hastened since the beginning of Israel's war on Gaza, which has killed more than 61,000 Palestinians and has been recognised by several countries, as well as leading rights groups and experts, as an act of genocide. Several hours after the resolution was passed, Israel killed six journalists in Gaza in a targeted assassination, a move condemned by human rights organisations globally.
Al Etihad
6 hours ago
- Al Etihad
Trump signs order extending China tariff deadline for 90 days, official says
11 Aug 2025 23:06 WASHINGTON (REUTERS)US President Donald Trump has signed an executive order extending a pause in sharply higher US tariffs on Chinese imports for another 90 days, a White House official said.A tariff truce between Beijing and Washington had been set to expire on August 12 at 00:01 (04:01 GMT), but the Trump administration had hinted the deadline could be order prevents U.S. tariffs on Chinese goods from shooting up to 145%, with Chinese tariffs on U.S. goods set to hit 125%, rates that would have resulted in a virtual trade embargo."We'll see what happens," Trump told a press conference, when asked how he planned to extend the deadline. "They've been dealing quite nicely. The relationship is very good with President Xi (Jinping) and myself."Imports from China are currently subject to 30% tariffs, including a 10% base rate and 20% in fentanyl-related tariffs imposed by Washington in February and March. China had matched the de-escalation, lowering its rate on US imports to 10%. The two sides in May announced a truce in their trade dispute after talks in Geneva, Switzerland, agreeing to a 90-day period to allow further talks. They met again in Stockholm, Sweden in late July, but did not announce an agreement to further extend the deadline.
