Calls for EU to intervene in row over charges for hand baggage on budget airlines
Last week European consumer groups called for Brussels to investigate the pricing policies of seven airlines, including Ryanair, easyJet and Wizz Air.
Airlines were 'exploiting consumers', said Agustín Reyna, director general of BEUC, an umbrella group for 44 consumer organisations, and were 'ignoring the EU top court who ruled that charging [for] reasonably sized hand baggage is illegal'.
'Haven't we all experienced the fear of our hand baggage not fitting in the airline's sizers and being charged extra fees?' he said.
Whereas once travellers worried about the weight of suitcases going in the hold, now it is shrinking hand baggage allowances that cause anxiety in airport queues.
In recent years it has become common practice for travellers to face a fee if they want to carry on all but the smallest of bags, with charges varying between airlines.
Passengers with Ryanair, for example, can carry a small bag that fits under the seat for nothing. However, if a gate check reveals it is oversized the fee is £60. A larger cabin bag can be added to a flight booking for £6 to £36 depending on the route but, again, if it is deemed too large it costs £75 to stow.
Spain has become a battleground for the issue. Last year its Consumer Rights Ministry fined five budget airlines, including Ryanair, a total of €179m for charging passengers for hand luggage and seat reservations. This month a Spanish judge ordered Ryanair to refund a passenger €147 (£124) in hand luggage charges racked up across five flights, including a return trip from Spain to the UK.
In the ruling, Judge Raquel Martínez Marco said 'carry-on luggage is an essential element of passenger transportation' and therefore 'cannot be subject to a price supplement'. The case was backed by Spanish consumer rights organisation Facua, which has been decrying the 'illegal surcharge' since 2018.
Kenton Jarvis, easyJet's chief executive, suggested passengers were happy to pay for the service they wanted. He said a third of its customers 'take no ancillaries, and therefore are happy taking the free [smaller] cabin bag'. Expecting them to pay for people who want bring a larger cabin bag 'doesn't feel very consumer friendly', he said.
Jarvis added that free cabin bags were previously a 'big logistical headache' for easyJet because they could not all fit in the overhead lockers. This led to delays and passengers being inconvenienced by having their bag put in the hold. 'That's why it is good to just ask the traveller to pay for what they want,' he said.
Ryanair's chief executive, Michael O'Leary, said it would not be changing its policies: 'The Spanish have a mad minister who's decided that as General Franco passed some law 30 years before Spain joined the European Union, passengers are free to bring as much baggage as they want,' he said.
'It's a clear breach of European regulations,' he said. 'The European Commission have already told Spain it's illegal.'
Any attempt to intervene would be in breach of the regulation that guarantees airlines the freedom to set prices and policies free from political interference, O'Leary added.
'In the short term, you have a couple of the consumer agencies in Spain taking decisions at local court level and trumpeting these,' he said. 'It's not going to change. We're not changing our policy. It will get referred to the European courts; we'll be appealing those rulings. In reality, there isn't that demand from passengers.'
Reyna said that given the current review into EU legislation governing air passenger rights there was an opportunity to clarify what services should be included in a basic ticket price.
'Our data shows that consumers expect to see a small item and a piece of hand luggage when buying basic tickets,' he said.
'Policymakers should also define hand luggage's 'reasonable size and weight' to avoid surprises at the airport and ultimately reduce the number of disputes costing consumers and airlines time and money.'
Kevin Bodley, a consultant at law firm Steele Raymond, who specialises in aviation law, said the Spanish ruling 'had delivered a clear message against hidden airline fees'. While neither the Spanish judgment nor future EU laws are binding in the UK they could still 'influence legal reasoning and consumer rights discussions in the UK', he said.
'The end result suggests the emergence of an increasing level of protection to passengers at the expense of the airlines,' Bodley said. 'However, this may well be cancelled out by the need for airlines to increase overall fare levels to cover this at the ultimate expense of travellers.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Times
39 minutes ago
- Times
Pensioners to make up a quarter of adults in Britain by 2075
Pensioners will make up a quarter of the adult population within the next 50 years because of improvements in life expectancy, according to an official review into the state pension age. Suzy Morrissey, the independent reviewer, said that the number of people of state pension age or over was expected to rise by 55 per cent to 19.5 million by 2075. The number of those aged over 85 is on course to increase from 1.8 million to 5.1 million in the same time frame. The proportion of those who are over the state pension age is forecast to rise from 22 per cent of over-16s to 28 per cent, while the cost of the state pension will rise from about 5 per cent of GDP to 7.7 per cent by the early 2070s.
Times
39 minutes ago
- Times
How to protect yourself from (and treat) mosquito bites
While this long, hot summer poses challenges for farmers, gardeners, firefighters and water companies, it does facilitate one of my greatest pleasures: alfresco dining. And, horse flies and wasps aside, eating outside in the UK tends not to be associated with unwelcome guests — unlike in hotter countries, where mosquitoes can't wait to join you for dinner. Fortunately bites from mozzies and gnats in the UK are generally little more than an irritation, but elsewhere they pose a major threat, transmitting infectious diseases such as malaria, dengue, yellow fever, zika virus and chikungunya — all of which can be brought home by returning travellers. Indeed, the UK Health Security Agency has recently released data on chikungunya — a viral infection that causes fever and joint pain — that shows a threefold increase in cases in England during the first six months of this year. It is still rare at 73 confirmed cases, far fewer than the 1,000 or so people with malaria that you would expect during the same period in the UK. • Read more from Dr Mark Porter While anti-malarial drugs and vaccines can help to protect against some of the nastier threats abroad, the most basic defence is simply to avoid being bitten — something that applies here in the UK too, if you want to make the most of your time outside. And, as with any battle plan, the first step is to understand your enemy. Mosquitoes are a problem at dusk and, in hotter countries, at dawn. Their primary source of energy is nectar from plants, but females have to supplement their diet because of the demands of egg production and so turn to sucking blood. And while they use a combination of sensory cues — visual, olfactory, thermal — to target you, the carbon dioxide in your breath is one of the most important ones. Put simply, mozzies can detect ambient CO2 levels and fly 'upstream' towards the highest concentration (you). And it's not only your breath that will attract them but also the CO2 in the fumes from your candles and barbeque. And here's where a decent repellent such as Deet can help: not only does it make your skin taste nasty if they do find you, it is also thought to act as a cloaking device, jamming their CO2 sensors and making you harder to most people, I don't like plastering myself with chemicals, but I have always favoured Deet over 'natural' repellents such as citronella — and it is a stance backed by research. One study comparing 16 commercially available repellents found that volunteers using 24 per cent Deet were protected for an average of just over five hours when they put their arms in a tank full of mosquitoes. Meanwhile those using 10 per cent citronella (the strongest tested) were bitten within 20 minutes. Some studies have shown citronella in a more favourable light, but I would still stick to Deet or other proven products containing PMD, IR3535 and picaridin. • Read more expert advice on healthy living, fitness and wellbeing And be wary of lighting lemon-scented or citronella candles: even if they do contain something that will repel mosquitoes (and many don't), the CO2 they produce may negate that benefit. You should also avoid using too much aftershave and perfume because fragrances may attract bugs. Last but not least, ensure that you cover up — anything from socks and trousers to protect your legs to sleeping under a mosquito net in trouble spots abroad. If you are still bitten — and you will be — most cause short-lived problems, but if troublesome the best remedy is typically to apply a topical steroid cream (hydrocortisone) and take an antihistamine. If the redness and swelling worsens or the area becomes painful and/or is weeping despite trying both medications, then it may be infected and you should seek medical advice. However, redness and swelling, even if marked, is normally caused by inflammation triggered by a delayed immune reaction to anticoagulants injected by the mosquito. An inflamed bite tends to be itchy, whereas an infected one is more likely to be sore or painful. However it can be hard to tell the difference and antibiotics are often over-prescribed by doctors who prefer to err on the side of caution. How your body reacts to bites depends to some extent on how often you have been bitten before. If you have never been bitten by a mosquito, then you probably won't react much at all. If, like most of us, you have been bitten numerous times, then you can react quite badly. And at the other end of the spectrum, if you have been bitten frequently for years then the reaction may start to wane — a variation in the immune response that may explain why some people (my wife, Ros) seem to be bitten more than others (me). Alternative explanations are available … The UK Health Security Agency is concerned about the rise in cases of infection with the chikungunya virus in returning travellers to the UK. The virus is spread by bites from infected mosquitoes. Affected regions include Africa, southeast Asia, the Indian subcontinent, the Pacific region, the subtropical regions of the Americas and the Caribbean. Most cases identified this year have been found in travellers returning from Sri Lanka, India and Mauritius. Chikungunya is normally a self-limiting condition that causes one to two weeks of fever, muscle and joint pain, headaches, and skin rashes. However, the joint pain can be severe and persist for much longer. Rarely, the infection can be fatal.
Reuters
an hour ago
- Reuters
Gold prices steady as investors assess Trump–Zelenskiy meeting
Aug 18 (Reuters) - Gold prices were largely steady on Monday, as investors focused on U.S. President Donald Trump's meeting with Ukrainian and European leaders, and the Federal Reserve's annual symposium in Jackson Hole this week. Spot gold was marginally down at $3,333.32 per ounce at 01:42 p.m. ET (1742 GMT), after hitting its lowest level since August 1 earlier in the session. U.S. gold futures for December delivery settled 0.1% lower at $3,378. The U.S. dollar gained 0.3%, making greenback-priced bullion more expensive for other currency holders. Trump said the U.S. would "help out" Europe in providing security for Ukraine as part of any deal to end Russia's war in Ukraine, as he and President Volodymyr Zelenskiy began a hastily arranged White House meeting to discuss a path to peace. The European leaders will meet with Trump afterwards in the White House's East Room at 3 p.m. EDT (1900 GMT), according to the White House. The meeting between Trump and Zelenskiy follows Trump's meeting with Putin on Friday, where the two leaders agreed to pursue a peace deal without implementing a ceasefire. "There was not much reaction in gold to the Putin-Trump meeting. I think we'll continue in this price range. The next inflection point is the Federal Reserve (conference)," said Marex analyst Edward Meir. Minutes from the U.S. central bank's July policy meeting are due on Wednesday, ahead of the Fed's annual conference in Jackson Hole, Wyoming, scheduled for August 21–23. Fed Chair Jerome Powell is expected to speak at the event. Investors will be watching out for Powell's remarks on the economic outlook. While markets have already priced in a 25 basis point cut, there's an outside chance of a 50 basis point reduction, which could drive gold prices higher, Meir said. Gold tends to perform strongly in environments with low interest rates and heightened uncertainty. Elsewhere, spot silver rose 0.1% at $38.02 per ounce, while platinum fell 0.1% to $1,334.10. Spot palladium gained 1% to $1,122.86 after falling to its lowest level since July 10 earlier in the session.
