Hundreds complain about 'outrageous' Swallow Roundabout delays as councillor takes case to transport secretary
Developer Springfield made changes to the junction near Invergowrie as part of efforts to ease potential congestion caused by the construction of new homes at Dykes of Gray.
However, drivers have faced long delays on the A90 Dundee-bound approach to the roundabout since they were switched on in early March.
Some drivers claim their commute time has doubled since the lights were installed.
One motorist travelling from Perth to Dundee on Wednesday told The Courier: 'Even by Swallow Roundabout standards, today's traffic is outrageous.'
There were further queues as far as Longforgan on Thursday.
Now, Carse of Gowrie councillor Angus Forbes says he is taking the issue to the transport secretary because he has been contacted by so many people about the lights.
Mr Forbes has launched a questionnaire asking people for their experiences.
The councillor has already received about 1,000 responses detailing people's complaints about the roundabout.
The survey closes at 5pm on Friday and the details will be sent to transport secretary Fiona Hyslop.
Mr Forbes told The Courier: 'I am so frustrated by the traffic caused by the roundabout and the volume of complaints that I don't feel I have any other option than to get the Scottish Government involved.
'My constituents are coming to me looking for a solution but I can't even give them an explanation, never mind a solution, and as a councillor, that's not a good place to be.
'My big fear was that there would be carnage while the construction took place but that was handled very well by Springfield.
'It never occurred to me that the issues would be so great after the lights were switched on.'
Drivers shared their experiences in response to Mr Forbes' post.
One said: 'The lights have caused more issues and delays than there ever (were before).
'The lanes aren't clear enough, too, and this causes more delays with people being in the wrong lanes on approach to the roundabout from Perth.'
Another driver wrote: 'It's awful. Doubled my commute time.'
One motorist posted the queues were an 'absolute joke'.
Another said: '(It's) crazy sitting behind red lights with no traffic in front of you or coming round from the right and you can't go because lights are red.
'There are times I counted when 20-50 vehicles could get through if there were no lights.'
Springfield insists it was asked to install the lights by Dundee City Council.
A spokesperson for the developer said: 'As housebuilders building new homes in the area, Swallow Roundabout improvements were included as part of our planning consent.
'We commissioned third-party specialists to design improvements to meet Transport Scotland regulations.
'This was thoroughly reviewed and approved by the relevant authorities, including Transport Scotland, ahead of construction starting and changes to the approved design need to be requested by them.
'The inclusion of traffic lights at this busy junction was specifically requested by Dundee City Council to provide steady and safer movement from each road leading to the roundabout and to introduce safe pedestrian crossings.'
The Courier has approached the council for comment.
However, in 2014, then-director of city development Mike Galloway said the signalisation of the roundabout would 'provide additional capacity to accommodate the extra vehicles associated with the residential developments'.
Transport Scotland says it will respond to Mr Forbes when it receives his letter to the transport secretary.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scottish Sun
16 hours ago
- Scottish Sun
Part of major Scots motorway set to CLOSE this month for site investigations
Read on to find out when the motorway will be closed MOTORWAY SHUTDOWN Part of major Scots motorway set to CLOSE this month for site investigations A STRETCH of a major Scottish motorway is set to close this month for site investigations. Amey will be carrying out the work on behalf of Transport Scotland on a section of the M8 in Glasgow. 2 Site investigations are set to take place at Junction 26 on the M8 this mont Credit: Google Essential site investigations will take place at Junction 26 Hillington Interchange. These works will need total overnight closures. The motorway will be closed at night from Monday, August 18 until Friday, August 22. The investigations are being used to inform future safety improvements that are due to be introduced in the Autumn. Drivers have been warned that diversions will be in place for both eastbound and westbound traffic. Eastbound traffic will be directed to exit the M8 at Junction 26 and follow Hillington Road, Renfrew Road, Shieldhall Road and Helen Street to re-join the M8 eastbound at Junction 24. Westbound traffic will be directed to exit the M8 at Junction 25A (Braehead) and follow Old Govan Road, King's Inch Road and Hillington Road to join the M8 westbound at the Junction 26 on-slip. Access for emergency service vehicles will be maintained throughout these works. All schemes are weather dependent and may be cancelled or rescheduled due to conditions. Amey has thanked road users for their patience and understanding while this work is being undertaken. Shocking moment lorry barrels WRONG WAY down major motorway after crashing through central reservation The M8, which is 60 miles long, is Scotland's busiest motorway. It connects the country's two largest cities, Glasgow and Edinburgh, and serves other large communities including Airdrie, Coatbridge, Greenock, Livingston and Paisley.
Daily Record
2 days ago
- Daily Record
Blair Drummond Safari Park bosses brand route near attraction 'not fit for purpose' after crashes
Campaigners are calling for action to be taken to make the A84 at Blair Drummond Safari Park safer following three road crashes there in a week. Renewed calls have been made for safety measures to be introduced on a section of the A84 near Blair Drummond Safari Park after three accidents in just a week. Two collisions happened at the entrance to the safari park – at the A84's junction with Sommer's Lane – with a third incident at the Blair Drummond Smiddy Farm Shop junction, where the A84 meets the A873. This has led to fresh calls for more traffic calming measures from campaigners, with safari park management backing this call saying the road is 'no longer fit for purpose'. The local community council fears it will 'take a death on the road before anything changes'. The first crash saw the A84 closed at around 1.30pm on Tuesday, July 29. Police received reports of a two-vehicle crash and four people were treated at the scene. Just four days later, another incident occurred at the same location. A driver was arrested and charged following a three-vehicle collision near the entrance of the safari park at around 3.50pm on Saturday, August 2. The crash involved a Mercedes Vito Tourer, a black Seat Leon and Ford Focus Zetec. A 40-year-old woman, who was a passenger within the Mercedes vehicle, was taken to hospital for treatment and a 38-year-old woman and a 46-year-old male, both passengers within the Seat Leon, were also taken to hospital. The occupants of the Ford Focus were uninjured. A 37-year-old man was subsequently arrested and charged in connection with road traffic offences. The third incident occurred on the A84 at the Blair Drummond Smiddy Farm Shop junction on Wednesday after noon. Blair Drummond Safari Park says that it has 'repeatedly raised concerns' with Transport Scotland about the safety of the A84 outside its entrance, but their requests for action have 'consistently been denied'. Park manager Gavin Hughes told the Stirling Observer his staff have stepped in to help when there are crashes outside the visitor attraction. He said: 'Over the years, we have asked for a range of safety measures to be considered – including a reduced speed limit, a slip road, a roundabout, and a pedestrian crossing to help people safely cross from the other side. 'Unfortunately, none of these proposals have been taken forward. 'This is a fast-moving road with poor visibility at our junction. It's used by significant numbers of visitors travelling to both Blair Drummond Safari Park and Briarlands Farm, and it has become busier year-on-year. The A84 is also one of the key routes taken by tourists heading to the north of Scotland, and interest in visiting the Highlands has increased dramatically in recent years. 'On top of that, the local area has seen the arrival of several new businesses, further increasing traffic and pressure. Quite simply, the road is no longer fit for purpose in its current form, and we believe it urgently needs to be re-evaluated. 'Accidents on this stretch occur far too frequently. Just last week, members of our team were first on the scene at a collision, stepping in to make sure everyone was safe, move vehicles off the road, and direct traffic until emergency services arrived. 'We do not have any jurisdiction over the road, which is frustrating both for us and for our customers, many of whom have raised concerns. We believe more must be done to improve safety in this area, and we will continue to push for action on this increasingly busy stretch of road.' Transport Scotland published a safety study on the stretch in March 2019 which said a 'preferred option' to calm traffic would have been the creation of a roundabout there, but said at the time that it was 'not a priority'. A new roundabout to include the A84 and A873 – at the junction of the Blair Drummond Smiddy Farm Shop - was estimated to cost approximately £3.5 million at the time. A Transport Scotland spokesperson this week said the junction outside the safari park main entrance 'has not been identified for safety focused investment based on the collision history over the last three years'. They added: 'But we will discuss the details of the most recent collisions with Police Scotland to understand the circumstances behind them.' Thornhill and Blairdrummond Community Council says that the issue has been a hot topic on their agenda for many years. A spokesperson said: 'The community council have long advocated for a traffic management solution for both the Safari Park and Smiddy junctions. It will take a death on the road before anything changes at this rate.' Trossachs and Teith ward councillor, Martin Earl, said: 'There's a very good reason why councillors, residents and MSPs have been raising this location with Transport Scotland for so long – it's dangerous and will remain so until money is spent and changes are made. 'This must surely now be accepted by them.' Stirling's SNP MSP Evelyn Tweed has written to Transport Scotland and the Transport Secretary, Fiona Hyslop, over the matter, calling for action to improve road safety. She said: 'I have reiterated the desire for a roundabout to be put in place at the junction into the safari park and improvements to be made at the Smiddy and Gargunnock junctions. I'm awaiting a response. I hope that all those who have been involved in these incidents make a full recovery.' Mid-Scotland & Fife Conservative MSP and shadow Minister for Local Government and Public Finance, Alexander Stewart said: 'For a great many year years, local residents have been extremely concerned at the sheer level of accidents, many of them serious, and near-misses at this junction of Sommer's Lane at the entrance to Blair Drummond Safari Park.' He added: 'Many years ago, my Scottish Conservative colleagues were heavily involved in this issue and convinced Transport Scotland to carry out a safety survey of the junction, however whilst the Scottish Government's transport agency conceded that a roundabout at the junction was its 'preferred option', bafflingly they ruled that it wasn't priority 'at this time' and it did not, in their opinion, represent value for money. 'It's easy to speculate that were a roundabout now in place here, maybe these awful accidents may never have happened, however what is absolutely crystal clear now, is that something decisive must be done.' Mr Stewart 'strenuously urged' Transport Scotland to undertake 'urgent action to address this problem' and vowed to write to Transport Scotland to request they implement the report's recommendations. Stirling and Strathallan Labour MP Chris Kane echoed the calls for urgent action, saying: 'This has been a long-standing issue that has been continuously ignored. 'This area has seen far too many accidents, and recent events only confirm that the situation is getting worse. It is clear the current layout is no longer fit for purpose.' Mr Kane has asked Transport Scotland to confirm what steps are being taken to improve safety at these junctions and has requested updated accident statistics to better understand the scale of the problem. 'I will continue pressing this issue until meaningful action is taken. These are preventable risks, and it's time we put public safety first', he added.
BBC News
3 days ago
- BBC News
Calls for second one-way to ease Selkirk gridlock
Calls are being made for a second one-way system to be considered for a Borders weeks after Transport Scotland announced it was taking forward plans for a new roads system around Selkirk high street, a local councillor is pushing for similar changes on other to parked cars and gridlock are regularly reported around the western entrance to the town due to blind bends and difficult Caroline Cochrane has started a petition calling for Mill Street, Buccleuch Road and Yarrow Terrace to also have one-way regulations. She said: "This is something that is being raised time and time again - and it should be treated as a high priority." Last month, Transport Scotland said it - along with partners Bear Scotland and Scottish Borders Council - had identified a series of safety improvements for Selkirk's heavily congested town include a one-way system being introduced on the main A7 as well as new pedestrian Deans, network manager at Bear Scotland said at the time the objective of the project was to enhance safety, while maintaining an appropriate level of service for trunk road traffic through the town one-way regulations were introduced around Buccleuch Road, Mill Street and Yarrow Terrace a decade ago - during repairs to a crumbling hotel wall - costs ruled out it becoming permanent system. At the time the local authority stated new road markings, junction improvements and a Traffic Regulation Order would cost in excess of £220,000. The roads returned to two-way traffic after more than three Cochrane believes issues around the streets, which all have blind bends, have not gone added: "We've tried introducing passing places but they are not working and there continues to be damage to parked cars and gridlock."People who live in the area are having to put up with this every day."I want to take this petition back to Scottish Borders Council and show them how much support there is for a one-way system to be included in future road projects."
