Ukrainians in Ireland not optimistic about success of peace talks with Putin
Some 100,000 Ukrainians live here, the vast majority of whom arrived since the Russian invasion in February 2022.
Many have decided to stay in the Republic; others, though, will return home if peace can be achieved. Most doubt it will happen any time soon.
Ukraine Action in Ireland (UAI) chairwoman Lisa Karamushka
is in the east of the restive country where the war continues.
READ MORE
'I can't see any major optimism here ... Just constant everyday shelling of the cities and soldiers fighting back attack after attack,' she said.
Ukraine Action in Ireland chairwoman Lisa Karamushka in her home country.
UAI was set up among Ukrainian refugees in Ireland and their supporters to provide medical aid and equipment to the front. So far UAI has sent 32 ambulances and 52 medical evacuation vehicles to Ukraine.
Ms Karamushka said the sight of the red carpet being rolled out for
Russian president Vladimir Putin
in Alaska was 'humiliating and devastating'.
'After all the death and destruction ... Trump still considers him [at the] same diplomatic level of a partner to make negotiations with.'
She believes there is nothing new in Putin's demands, which amount to wanting the world to recognise Crimea and Donetsk as part of Russia, while retaining Ukraine as part of Russia's sphere of influence.
'We have heard absolutely nothing we haven't heard before and no indication of a desire to end this war. Yet,
Trump
claims he has reached success. We don't see any,' she said.
She takes some solace in
Ukrainian president Volodymyr Zelenskiy
travelling on Monday with Europe's most important leaders.
'This gives me hope he will be in stronger position, as Europe has been so far our major supporter. Overall I'm probably not expecting anything to change, probably even hope it won't get worse,' she said.
Ukraine's soldiers are the 'sole reason' for its continued independence, democracy and existence, she said.
Olena Tregub, who is based in the Republic and works for the Ukrainian non-governmental organisation Nako, said expectations of a successful outcome are 'extremely low'.
She believes Mr Trump and his principle negotiator, Steve Witkoff, 'fundamentally misunderstand the Russian president.
'They fail to see that for Putin, this war is not about material interests, nor even about territory. It is an ideological war. It is about the destiny of Ukraine,' she said.
'Putin wants to break Ukraine, to reduce it to a vassal of Russia,' she said.
'That goal has not been achieved. Which means Putin is nowhere near ready for peace.'
She believes Mr Trump took a 'reckless gamble' in meeting Mr Putin without any deal agreed in advance.
'In doing so, he gave Putin legitimacy, handed over his own political capital and risked everything only to walk away empty-handed,' she said.
'The visuals from Alaska were disastrous: American soldiers kneeling to roll out the red carpet for Putin's plane, Trump and Putin walking together on that carpet, even riding in Trump's car.
'These images were not only humiliating for the USA internationally, but ... many Americans also saw this as a shameful display.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
30 minutes ago
- Irish Examiner
Trump says Washington talks could lead to ‘trilat' with Ukraine and Russia
Donald Trump has said that meetings with European leaders could pave the way for three-way talks between the leaders of Ukraine, Russia and the US amid his drive to end the fighting in eastern Europe. The US president is hosting several European leaders at the White House on Monday, including the Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy, UK prime minister Keir Starmer, French President Emmanuel Macron and Nato secretary general Mark Rutte. Speaking to reporters in the Oval Office alongside Mr Zelenskyy, Mr Trump said he would phone the Russian president after the talks. 'I think if everything works out well today, we'll have a trilat, and I think there will be a reasonable chance of ending the war when we do that,' the US president said. We've got to get this right. We've got to make sure there is peace, that it is is lasting peace and that it is fair and that it is just He later added: 'If we don't have a trilat, then the fighting continues.' Vladimir Putin, who Mr Trump met on Friday in Anchorage, Alaska, is set to receive a phone call once the talks have 'finished', the president said. 'We're going to have a phone call right after these meetings today and we may or may not have a trilat.' Asked about 'Nato-like protection' for Ukraine, Donald Trump replied: 'I don't know if you define it that way, but Nato-like? I mean, we're going to give, we have people waiting in another room right now, they're all here, from Europe. 'Biggest people in Europe. 'And they want to give protection, they feel very strongly about it, and we'll help them out with that.' Mr Trump's envoy Steve Witkoff had suggested that measures similar to Nato's article five mutual defence provision could be offered by the US without Kyiv joining the alliance. The Ukrainian president wore a black shirt with buttons and a black blazer to the meeting at the White House. President Donald Trump meets with Ukraine's President Volodymyr Zelensky in the Oval Office (Julia Demaree Nikhinson/AP/PA) His attire appeared to become a point of irritation for Mr Trump during a previous meeting in February, when he was wearing a black polo bearing the Ukrainian coat of arms and the US president said: 'He's all dressed up today.' In their latest meeting, Mr Trump indicated he agreed with a reporter who described Mr Zelenskyy as looking 'fabulous in that suit'. Mr Zelenskyy earlier said he wanted to thank first lady of the United States Melania Trump, who on Friday penned a plea to Mr Putin, imploring him to protect the 'innocence' of children. 'Undeniably, we must strive to paint a dignity-filled world for all – so that every soul may wake to peace and so that the future itself is perfectly guarded,' she wrote. Mr Zelenskyy presented Mr Trump with a letter from his wife. Mr Starmer who met with Mr Zelenskyy and several other European leaders on Monday before arriving at the White House, had earlier said in a video posted to X: 'Everybody wants it to end, not least the Ukrainians. 'But we've got to get this right. We've got to make sure there is peace, that it is is lasting peace and that it is fair and that it is just. 'That's why I'm travelling to Washington with other European leaders to discuss this face to face with President Trump and President Zelenskyy, because it's in everyone's interests, it's in the UK's interests that we get this right.'
Irish Independent
31 minutes ago
- Irish Independent
Donald Trump to set up meeting with Putin and Zelensky to end war after ‘very good' meeting with Ukrainian leader
Timeline of territorial shifts in Russia's war on Ukraine Russia's troops are continuing their slow war of attrition in eastern and northern Ukraine, even as the conflict enters a pivotal phase with a series of high-level meetings that are part of US President Donald Trump's push for peace. In the three-and-a-half years since Moscow launched its full-scale invasion of Ukraine, the front line has continued to move slowly with some unexpected strikes also redrawing the map. Here is a look at some of the main events in the conflict: February 24 2022: Russian President Vladimir Putin launches an invasion of Ukraine from the north, east and south. Russian troops quickly reach Kyiv's outskirts, but their attempts to capture the capital and other cities in the north-east meet stiff resistance. March 5 2022: Russian advances toward Kyiv and Kherson reach their height. The port city of Mariupol is surrounded. April 2 2022: Ukraine defeats Russian forces in Kyiv after throwing them back in Chernihiv. August 29 2022: Ukraine's first counter-offensive starts in the east and south. September 30 2022: Russia illegally annexes Donetsk, Luhansk, Kherson and Zaporizhzhia regions of Ukraine, even though it does not fully control either of the four. September to November 2022: Ukrainian forces reclaim vast parts of the Kharkiv, Mykolaiv and Kherson regions in the first counter-offensive, including the city of Kherson itself. May 22 2023: Russia claims control of Bakhmut after months of fighting. June 6 2023: As Ukraine's long-anticipated second counter-offensive starts, the Russian-controlled Kakhovka Dam explodes, sending a wall of water into southern Ukraine and upending Ukrainian battle plans. Autumn 2023: The second Ukrainian counter-offensive ends, with little change to the front line. February 18 2024: Russian forces take complete control of the eastern city of Avdiivka after months of combat. April 19 2024: The US House of Representatives approves a 61 billion dollar package for Ukraine after months of delay. May 10 2024: Russia launches a new offensive in the north-eastern region of Kharkiv, capturing a string of villages and opening a new front in the war. August 6 2024: Ukraine launches a lightning incursion into Russia's Kursk region, holding territory along the border in an unexpected and embarrassing episode for the Kremlin. January 20 2025: Mr Trump is inaugurated as the 47th president of the United States. His election raises uncertainty as to whether Washington will continue to support Ukraine. April 26 2025: Moscow says all Ukrainian troops have been forced out from Russia's Kursk region. Several weeks later, Mr Putin visits the area in a show of strength and is filmed speaking with local volunteers. June 1 2025: Ukraine strikes airfields deep inside Russia by launching drones that have been secretly stored and transported across the country on the back of trucks. The attack is codenamed Operation Spider Web. Summer 2025: Russia and Ukraine both step up drone strikes with the ability to strike deep into each other's territory. June 30 2025: Russia says it has taken full control of Ukraine's Luhansk, one of four regions that Moscow illegally annexed in September 2022. July 31 2025: Russia says it has taken full control of the strategically important Ukrainian city of Chasiv Yar after a grinding, months-long assault. August 2025: Russian forces continue their push in the Donetsk region, where the Kremlin has focused the bulk of military efforts, capturing small villages and closing in on Pokrovsk, a strategically important city. August 15 2025: Mr Putin meets Mr Trump in Alaska for the first Russia-US summit in four years to discuss ending the war in Ukraine. Ukraine's President Volodymyr Zelensky and European officials say Mr Putin wants Ukraine to withdraw from the remaining 30pc of the Donetsk region that it controls as part of a deal.
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Student with place on UCD master's course still awaiting evacuation from Gaza
The Department of Foreign Affairs said it was aware of the case of a student who needed to be evacuated from Gaza to start her course at University College Dublin . The student, who did not wish to be named, said she was a 25-year-old architect in training. She said she was accepted earlier this year on to a master's degree course in architecture, urbanism and climate action at UCD. The university did not respond to requests for comment. READ MORE The woman has tried to lobby TDs to help her get out of Gaza, so she can start her course this coming academic year. Correspondence seen by The Irish Times showed the student had been advised she would qualify for a visa on the basis of her paperwork, but such a permit would only be issued if the Government approved another evacuation mission. Ireland has so far facilitated the evacuation of a number of third-level students from Gaza to Ireland. In July, a group of nine Palestinian students arrived in Ireland to take up scholarships for the 2025-2026 academic year under the Government's Ireland-Palestine scholarship programme, which is run by Irish Aid . Another three Ireland-Palestine scholarship fellows were evacuated from Gaza in April, having been able to leave in 2024. A spokesman for the department said it was 'aware' of the woman's situation. 'While the department is limited in the assistance it can provide to non-Irish citizens, it is currently exploring options to assist individuals who are eligible to travel to Ireland,' he said. Student activists from universities across Dublin have organised a demonstration on Tuesday outside the department's headquarters at Iveagh House in the city centre. They are demanding the Government facilitate the evacuation of Gazan students who have a confirmed place in Irish universities and are due to begin their studies in September. Many of these Gazan students have received scholarships from the Irish Representative Office in Ramallah through the Irish Aid-run programme, which provides 30 scholarships for one-year master's degrees. Others have received supports from individual Irish universities, often called 'sanctuary scholarships'. 'With few safe passages out of Gaza, these students are being left cruelly stranded by the government that invited them here in the first place,' a coalition of students' unions from Trinity College , UCD, DCU and the National College of Art and Design (NCAD), who organised the protest, said in a joint statement. Harry Johnston, chair of Trinity College Dublin boycott, divestment and sanction group, a student-led pro-Palestinian organisation with no affiliation to the university's administration, said the goal of the protest was 'to demand better from our Government'. He said there were 'over 40 students currently trapped in Gaza' who were to begin their studies in Ireland soon. 'The Department of Foreign Affairs is in charge of issuing visas and should be pressuring Israeli authorities to ensure that these people can escape,' he said. The department's office is a regular place of pro-Palestinian protest. Last May, red paint was splattered on the facade of Iveagh House and in August last year the words 'Gaza BDS now' were painted on Iveagh House in an act that was investigated by gardaí as criminal damage.
