Replace cops with social workers, 'transit ambassadors' on some 911 calls: Mamdani
Mamdani's position on law enforcement and public safety took center stage following a mass shooting in Manhattan on July 28 that killed four people, including a police officer. In light of the tragic shooting, Mamdani's critics began slamming him for past remarks about defunding the police in New York City.
Mamdani was once again asked about his approach to crime and public safety Monday in a press conference with Sen. Elizabeth Warren, D-Mass., when he offered up his idea.
"I've said time and time again that every decision I make with regards to the NYPD will work backwards from an outcome of public safety and that public safety, we know, it is one that also comes from listening to officers themselves," Mamdani said Monday.
The self-described socialist candidate went on to cite "forced overtime" as a leading cause for many New York City police officers' decision to leave their jobs, noting that NYPD officers receive around 200,000 emergency calls pertaining to a mental health crisis every year.
"The fact that every year we ask them to take on additional responsibilities – we are making it more and more difficult for them to respond to the very responsibilities that drew them to the job in the first place," Mamdani argued. "New Yorkers rightfully have concerns around public safety, and I want to empower police officers to respond to serious crime and hire the mental health professionals to respond to mental health calls."
To explain the issue further, Mamdani pointed to a hypothetical incident involving a distressed tourist, arguing officers are forced to use resources to answer these calls, but that could end if the city were to hire a "transit ambassador."
"This forced overtime is something that we can expect. It's not a surprise. It's a requirement of so much of the asks that we are making of these officers," Mamdani told reporters, in response to questions about his proposal to help reduce law enforcement overtime.
"When we ensure that it's not an officer who has to stand in the middle of the Times Square subway station and answer a question from a tourist about which exit works, and which escalator they can take, and what line is running with delays or without them, but that we actually have a transit ambassador such that that officer can focus on serious crime, it starts to reduce the kind of overtime that has ballooned."
Meanwhile, during a podcast appearance in 2020, the same year Mamdani made his now infamous social media posts calling to defund the NYPD, the socialist candidate for mayor also suggested police should not be the ones responding to domestic violence calls.
"If somebody is surviving, going through domestic violence – there are so many different, different situations that would far better be handled by people trained to deal with those specific situations as opposed to an individual with a gun who has received quite a limited amount of training in general," Mamdani said at the time.
In response to Mamdani's calls to have social workers, not police officers, respond to certain 911 calls related to mental health crises, incumbent Mayor Eric Adams, himself a former NYPD captain, called the idea "irresponsible" and "reckless."
"So when you put civilians in harm's way to respond to a domestic violence incident, that's irresponsible and it's reckless," Adams said while criticizing Mamdani's public safety platform, according to CBS News.
In Mamdani's 17-page public safety plan released earlier this year amid his race to be the Democratic Party's candidate for NYC mayor, he diverged from many of his primary opponents in that he did not envision hiring more officers to the force, according to the New York Times. Rather, per his plan, Mamdani would work to create a Department of Community Safety aimed at expanding mental health teams and other non-law enforcement personnel who can respond to certain 911 calls.
Mamdani's proposal also spoke to eliminating the NYPD's overtime budget and its task force that is responsible for dealing with protests, according to The Times.
Former New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo, who has been a staunch critic of Mamdani's approach to public safety and police, released his public safety platform on Monday, calling for increasing the number of officers on the NYPD's force by about 5,000.
Cuomo, who is running as an Independent after losing to Mamdani in the Democratic Party primary, also wants to increase officer pay and improve access to benefits and pensions for retired officers.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
25 minutes ago
- Yahoo
5 soldiers wounded by fellow soldier in workplace shooting at Fort Stewart in Georgia; suspect in custody, officials say
The alleged shooter, identified as Sgt. Quornelius Radford, was quickly "subdued" by other soldiers, Brig. Gen. John Lubas told reporters. Five soldiers were shot and wounded on Wednesday at a U.S. Army base in Georgia by a fellow soldier in a workplace shooting that prompted a lockdown, officials there say. In a post on its Facebook page, Fort Stewart Hunter Army Airfield said the shooting occurred in the 2nd Armored Brigade Combat Team area shortly before 11 a.m. local time. The alleged shooter was identified as Quornelius Radford, an automated logistics sergeant assigned to the 2nd Brigade Team. At a press conference on Wednesday afternoon, Brig. Gen. John Lubas, commander of the 3rd Infantry Division said Radford was quickly "subdued" by fellow soldiers before law enforcement arrived. "Soldiers in the area that witnessed the shooting immediately, and without hesitation, tackled the soldier, subdued him, and allowed law enforcement to then take him into custody," Lubas said. "These soldiers without a doubt prevented further casualties." All five of the victims were transported to the hospital in stable condition, Lubas said. Three of the victims required surgery, and all are expected to recover. According to Lubas, the shooting occurred at Radford's place of work and involved his co-workers, but he would not speculate on a motive. Lubas said that Radford used a personal handgun, and that the incident remains under investigation. In an earlier alert announcing the lockdown, Fort Stewart said multiple 'casualties" had been reported in what was described as "an active shooter incident." Gates to the base were closed for several hours, and some schools in the area were briefly placed on lockdown. Fort Stewart, which is located about 40 miles southwest of Savannah, is home to about 10,000 people, including soldiers, family members and civilian employees, live there, according to its website. The FBI in Atlanta said on X that its office in Savannah was aware of the incident and "coordinating with Army Criminal Investigation Division for any assistance that might be needed." President Trump was briefed on the shooting, White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt said. Georgia Gov. Brian Kemp wrote on X that he was "in close contact with law enforcement on the ground," adding that his family was "saddened by today's tragedy." "We are keeping the victims, their families, and all those who answer the call to serve in our hearts and prayers, and we ask that Georgians everywhere do the same," Kemp said.
Yahoo
25 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Congress members trying to see ICE detainees at MDC Brooklyn jail barred from entry
NEW YORK — Officials at MDC Brooklyn barred three Democrat members of Congress from conducting an oversight visit of the jail's ICE detention operation, sparking a brief lockdown that led to cancelled legal visits for inmates seeing their defense lawyers. The Congress members, Reps. Adriano Espaillat, Nydia Velazquez and Dan Goldman, showed up at the notorious Sunset Park jail Wednesday morning, but were blocked at the door, then were briefly trapped between the iron gate in front of the jail and its entrance doors. Inside, about 20 defense attorneys visiting their clients abruptly had those visits cut short, multiple lawyers told the Daily News. Jail staff recalled those inmates back to their housing units, and wouldn't let their lawyers leave the MDC for about a half hour as the drama unfolded outside, the attorneys said. Those lawyers included Marc Agnifilo, who represents Sean 'Diddy' Combs and alleged healthcare CEO killer Luigi Mangione, both of whom are housed in MDC, sources said. Agnifilo did not return messages seeking comment Wednesday. 'We were trapped between the gate and the building,' Velazquez told The News. She said that the lawmakers entered the gate and approached the place's front door, and Espaillat asked a masked Immigration and Customs Enforcement agent outside to show his face. 'He [the agent] immediately jumped in front of the gate and locked us inside, and then went upstairs, climbed the steps for the federal building and locked the door so we could not get out to the street,' Velazquez said. 'We couldn't get into the building.' New York Immigration Coalition President Murad Awawdeh, who accompanied the lawmakers, said the ICE agent immediately confronted them, asking for ID, then triggered a lockdown and disappeared into the building. 'It was a circus that the federal prison bureau created,' he said. 'Why is the federal government going so far out of its way to prohibit anyone from seeing what's happening inside their facilities?' Eventually, an assistant to the warden came out, 'and he said what we knew he would say, that we have to request seven days in advance for a permit to allow us to go inside,' Velazquez said. That's against federal law, which gives Congress members the right to make unannounced visits, she said. Starting in June, MDC Brooklyn began holding more than 100 ICE detainees as part of an interagency agreement between ICE and and the Bureau of Prisons to use eight federal facilities across the country to hold immigrants ensnared in Donald Trump's mass deportation machine. 'Denying Members of Congress access to a federal detention facility is outrageous and unacceptable,' Espaillat said in a statement later Wednesday. 'MDC Brooklyn has a well-documented record of abuse. ICE should not be allowed to expand its reach through backdoor deals with federal prisons. This contract must be terminated now.' BOP spokeswoman Randilee Giamusso said Wednesday that the prison system would be happy to accommodate Congress member visits if they give advance notice. 'However, as a law enforcement entity, we must prioritize the safety of our staff, inmates and our facilities. We remain committed to working with our congressional partners,' Giamusso said. 'With proper notice, the BOP is happy to accommodate a request for a site visit from any congressional member.' Espaillat and several other Congress members sued the Trump administration last week, arguing that federal law specifically prohibits immigration detention facilities from requiring prior notice before members of Congress can make oversight visits. 'The Trump administration's lawless efforts to defy that constitutional authority are a gross abuse of power,' Goldman said, 'and we're taking them to court in defense of that principle and to find out what they're hiding.' _____
New York Post
26 minutes ago
- New York Post
Largest NYPD graduating class since 2016 takes stage at MSG as force reverses recruiting woes : ‘A blessing to our city'
The police are out in force. A whopping 965 new NYPD cops filed into Madison Square Garden on Tuesday for a confetti-filled police academy graduation in a hopeful sign the department is turning a corner on its persistent staffing crisis. The class is the largest since 2016, with more than a quarter of its grads — who will soon protect and serve New York City's diverse population — born outside the US, officials said. 'I have felt the tide turning for policing generally and specifically for policing in this city for quite some time now,' NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch told the graduates. 'This is a department and a profession that is once again attracting young and bright talent in big numbers, and that is a blessing to our city.' 4 The NYPD's graduating class is the largest since 2016. Matthew McDermott 4 NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch said the diverse class reflects 'every corner of the city and far beyond it.' Matthew McDermott The young and bright talent in the class includes 252 foreign-born officers, hailing from 41 countries, police officials said. The Dominican Republic was the birthplace of the largest number of graduates — 51 — followed by 44 from Bangladesh, 23 from Haiti and 19 Jamaicans, officials said. Hero NYPD Didarul Islam, who was fatally gunned down in last week's Midtown mass shooting, originally hailed from Bangladesh. And 476 of those new cops also speak a kaleidoscopic 39 different languages, officials said. Tisch said the class reflects 'every corner of the city and far beyond it.' 'You were born in places as close as the Bronx and as far away as South Korea,' she said. 'From the mountains of Nepal to the streets of Santo Domingo, from Bangladesh, Ghana and the Philippines to Poland, Jamaica and Colombia, from Haiti, from Egypt, from China.' 4 The new cops could help the NYPD turn its staffing woes around. Matthew McDermott 4 Mayor Eric Adams hopes to bring the NYPD's headcount back to 35,000. Matthew McDermott The NYPD's headcount has been a persistent cause for concern, as it plunged to roughly 33,500 last year — the lowest level since 1990. A monthly exodus of 200 cops and a surge in retirements — fueled by increasing workloads, exploding overtime and higher-paying jobs in other nearby departments — left New York's Finest in a precarious position. The problem was compounded by the number of NYPD applicants plummeting from 18,000 in 2017 to just 8,000 as 2025 dawned. Mayor Eric Adams, in response to the growing crisis, set a goal of 35,000 officers by late 2026. Tisch, shortly after becoming the fourth police commissioner to serve under Adams, in February reduced the college requirements for prospective cops to enter the police academy. The NYPD is among the last major police forces in the US to have college credit requirements. Before Tisch's changes, it was mandatory for applicants to have at least 60 college credits. The department now only requires 24 credits. Police officials contended the change helped 'level the playing field' and helped pave the way for this year's mammoth academy class. They also credited a social media push encouraging recruitment and holding the police department exam every month. Addressing the graduates, Adams spoke of his own formative time as an NYPD officer — and again crowed about the city seeing record-low gun violence numbers. 'It made me the mayor that I am today,' he said. 'And we were committed to bringing down crime and making sure our city was safe, to raise healthy children and families. 'We've witnessed the lowest number of shootings and victims of shootings in the last seven months, and the recorded history of this city. In the first six months of this year, we we witnessed the lowest number of homicides in the recorded history of this city.' — Additional reporting by Joe Marino
