Judge suggests NSW police had ‘absolutely no evidence' to justify main strip-search in class action
A Sydney judge says the way the New South Wales police force defended a claim it unlawfully strip-searched a woman at a music festival – including a last-minute admission – was 'of grave concern to me'.
Justice Dina Yehia made the comment in the NSW supreme court during closing arguments in a class action against the police.
The state of NSW has disputed that the vast majority of strip-searches conducted by police between 2018 and 2022 at music festivals were unlawful.
NSW police did, however, admit in court documents before the hearings began last week to unlawfully strip-searching the lead plaintiff, Raya Meredith, at a music festival in 2018.
Meredith is the lead plaintiff of a group of 3,000 people, including children, searched by police. She was strip-searched at the 2018 Splendour in the Grass festival after a drug dog sniffed in her direction but then walked on.
The class action is being led by Slater and Gordon lawyers and the Redfern Legal Centre.
Julian Sexton SC, acting on behalf of NSW police, on Thursday disputed the plaintiff's call for aggravated damages to be paid because of the force's conduct during proceedings.
He argued aggravated damages could not be awarded because Meredith had not been recalled to give evidence about how she felt about NSW police's conduct during the class action.
Yehia said in response she was 'much more concerned' about the police having three iterations of its defence before backflipping shortly before proceedings began and admitting it did unlawfully strip-search Meredith.
'That is a matter, I'll be quite honest with you, of grave concern to me,' Yehia said on Thursday.
The judge said she was concerned the police defence suggested officers had formed a reasonable suspicion to strip-search Meredith based on 'things like her demeanour, what was said outside the tent, and [the officers] recalling it was said outside the tent and not inside'.
'There is absolutely no evidence, unless you can take me to it and I've missed something,' Yehia said to Sexton.
Sign up to Morning Mail
Our Australian morning briefing breaks down the key stories of the day, telling you what's happening and why it matters
after newsletter promotion
'All I have is the officers' statements that say either they don't remember the search, or both that they don't remember the search nor remember the lead plaintiff. In those circumstances, I'm just not sure how this could ever have proceeded in the way that it did with the initial pleadings.'
In the days before the hearing began, the state of NSW withdrew 22 witnesses, mostly police officers who had been due to contest Meredith's version of events. That change saw the case reduced from a scheduled 2o days to three days.
Sexton argued the defence was based on police 'practice' in such instances, adding it was 'not [based] on distinct recollections of somebody'.
Yehia said the police suggesting there were 'reasonable grounds' for the search due to Meredith's physical appearance and body language were 'specific matters relating to this plaintiff in circumstances where [the female police officer who searched her] not only doesn't remember, but as far as I understand it, didn't even make a notebook entry in relation to that interaction'.
Closing arguments before Yehia were expected to end on Thursday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Sun
2 hours ago
- The Sun
Full tragic timeline of 3-week hunt for Pheobe Bishop – from airport disappearance to housemate arrests and horror find
PHEOBE Bishop mysteriously vanished over three weeks ago in a gripping disappearance case which puzzled the world. The shocking story has been plagued by grim twists and heartbreaking pleas after the 17-year-old teenager went missing near an airport on May 15. 16 16 16 16 Before she disappeared, Pheobe had been living in the town of Gin Gin, which is north of Brisbane in Australia. The sleepy neighbourhood has a population of about 1,100 people. The teenager had been living in a derelict pad - which had a foul smell and was very noisy according to neighbours. She lived there with two housemates: James Wood, 34, and Tanika Bromley, 33. On the day she went missing, Pheobe was meant to board a flight to see her boyfriend in Western Australia. Her housemates drove her to Bundaberg airport, but police said CCTV there never even saw her enter the terminal and she never actually checked in. She was on her way to Perth to visit her "high-school sweetheart" boyfriend. Pheobe reportedly made a last minute call to him at 8:30am mere moments before she was set to get on the flight to Western Australia. A family member said: "She didn't check in for her flight to visit her boyfriend who she spoke to on the phone at 8.30am." According to the Daily Mail, Wood said the couple had an explosive argument in the car with Pheobe over whether she could do her makeup before arriving at the airport. He said they pulled over just under a kilometre from their destination. Wood and Bromley then allegedly walked off and were away from Pheobe and the car for five minutes, according to the 34-year-old. A missing person's report was issued for her one day later on May 16. Her worried sick sister, Kaylea Bishop, sent Wood and Bromley a simple text, demanding to know the whereabouts of her sibling. She said: "Where is my sister?" On the following weekend, her desperate mum Kylie Johnson made emotional pleas for anyone with information to come forward. By May 18, over 400 missing person posters with Pheobe's photo had been plastered across the Wide Bay region. The next week, on Monday May 19, police launched their search for Pheobe. It covered land along Bundaberg's Airport Drive and the surrounding areas. 16 16 16 16 But mysteriously, police didn't find any sign of the teen or her belongings. Police, along with Pheobe's mum, described her disappearance as out of character on May 20. They also asked the public for information about the 2011 grey Hyundai ix35 hatch, owned by Bromley, that had been seen around Airport Drive at the time of Pheoebe's disappearance. The next day, police updated the case and said they were treating Pheobe's disappearance as a suspicious. They also declared two crime scenes - one being the run-down home she was living at, and the other being the infamous Hyundai she was driven to the airport in. After inspecting the foul-smelling home, police found four dead dogs rotting inside. But it was later understood that these four pups died of natural causes. Airport Drive, Samuels Road and Gin Gin were also named as locations of interest. On May 22, Detective Acting Inspector Ryan Thompson stressed the importance of public information. In a chilling plea, he said: "People don't vanish." 16 16 16 The day after that, police revealed they were searching through bushland and waterways at Good Night Scrub National Park, near to where Pheobe was last seen. This scan went on for the next two days, during which police dogs joined the hunt. On May 25 Bromley was arrested in a major twist after police allegedly found weapons in her silver Hyundai. On May 26, the search area was expanded - before cops made a harrowing revelation. They believed evidence had been moved from the Good Night Scrub area before they arrived there. And on this same day, a new number plate was discovered to have been suspiciously painted and taped over the notorious Hyundai's original plate. The gruelling search effort in Good Night Scrub National Park then continued from May 27 for five more days. Disturbingly, the search appeared to lose hope as police said they would no longer be doing any more physical scans for Pheobe on Wednesday, June 4. They said they would restart any searches only when they had relevant information. But in a dramatic twist on the very same day - Pheobe's housemate Wood was arrested. 16 However, no charges were made and he was released a day later on June 5. And in yet another turn in the tale - Wood and Bromley were then both arrested and charged with murder on the same day Wood was released - exactly three weeks after Pheobe went missing. They were each charged with one count of murder and two counts of interfering with a corpse. Shocking footage released on Friday showed the moment police arrested Wood and escorted him out of an RV for the "homicide of Pheobe Bishop". Both Wood and Bromley appeared at Bundaberg Magistrates Court on Friday morning. Outside the building, Pheobe's heartbroken sister Kaylea Bishop said her sibling was 'loved and missed' dearly. Kaylea and Pheobe had a close relationship and were planning to move in together last year. And in the latest heartbreaking update, human remains were found during a search for Pheobe. They are yet to be identified, but police have spoken to Pheobe's family regarding the harrowing discovery. The body was found close to Good Night Scrub National Park, near Gin Gin, on Friday, June 6 at around 2:30pm. 16 Pheobe's mum then made a heartbreaking statement. She said: "I didn't think my heart could break anymore than it did when you went missing, or when the charges were laid but this. "This is ripping me apart." Pheobe had previously said online that she wasn't living with her mum, and that she had been "in and out" of home for years. Cops are now set to allege that Wood, Bromley and Pheobe were all in the car when it arrived at Airport Drive near Bundaberg Airport in the morning of May 15. They believe that the trio never actually left the car. Detective Inspector Craig Mansfield said: "Our evidence will outline the fact that three people arrived near to the airport, and three people never exited that vehicle." Wood and Bromley will appear in court on August 11.
The Guardian
4 hours ago
- The Guardian
Should Sydney's light rail carriages be modified after second death in two years?
For the second time in two years, a pedestrian has died after being struck by a tram on Sydney's light rail. New South Wales police said they found a man under a tram carriage in Surry Hills on Thursday afternoon. Paramedics treated him at the scene, but he died. Police said initial inquiries showed the man was attempting to cross the light rail track between two carriages when the tram began moving and trapped him. In May 2023, a teenage girl died after attempting to cross a street in Sydney's CBD between two tram carriages. She became trapped underneath one of them when the tram started moving, suffering fatal injuries. Sign up for Guardian Australia's breaking news email That two similar deaths occurred just two years apart meant police, the premier, and transport bureaucrats fielded questions from the media this week over whether the light rail network, and the trams themselves, should be made safer. Dr Geoffrey Clinton, a senior lecturer in transport management at the University of Sydney, said it was 'probably wise' for the government to investigate additional safety measures to stop people from attempting to climb over them. Sydney's light rail network uses a few different tram models – what bureaucrats call 'rolling stock'. What they have in common is that they typically have separate carriages that are coupled together to form a longer vehicle, unlike trams in Melbourne, which have only one carriage. Many of the trams now have 'danger' signs on the joinery between the carriages, warning people not to try to climb over them. Clinton said the state government or the network's private operator, Transdev, could consider additional signage. 'Or even something like a net between the two carriages to discourage people from trying to clamber through,' he said. He posed the idea of running the trams twice as frequently with only one carriage, making them half as long, but said it didn't 'seem like a feasible solution'. '[That] would very expensive to do and wouldn't add to the capacity of the network, but it would double the labour cost,' he said. The transport minister, John Graham, declined to comment. A Transport for New South Wales (TfNSW) spokesperson said the man's death was 'extremely distressing'. The NSW police inspector, Anderson Lessing, on Thursday said that after speaking to witnesses and reviewing CCTV, it appeared the man had stepped between the tram carriages off the platform at the light rail stop on Devonshire Street. 'There's obviously risk involved, but it comes back to personal responsibility when you do cross the tram line, and it's that balance that we have to get right,' he said. Sign up to Breaking News Australia Get the most important news as it breaks after newsletter promotion The TfNSW coordinator-general, Howard Collins, expressed his condolences to the man's family and first responders. He said the Office of the National Rail Safety Regulator (ONRSR) would work with Transdev to establish whether any safety recommendations could be made or whether the death was 'a case of really unfortunate misadventure'. The ONRSR also reviewed the 2023 light rail death. On Friday, there was some confusion between the government and Transdev over whether the operator had received a report from the regulator. ONRSR later confirmed its investigation reports were not released to operators. The Australian Transport Safety Bureau and NSW Office of Transport Safety Investigations said they had not reviewed the 2023 death and would not to review Thursday's one either. '[We] have reviewed the initial available information and determined that, as in the 2023 occurrence … it is unlikely an independent transport safety investigation would identify any new or unknown transport safety factor that could prevent an incident of this nature from occurring in the future,' a spokesperson said. The premier, Chris Minns, said he was sorry for the man and his family, but he wouldn't be drawn on whether the government was considering any safety upgrades. 'The safety regulator's in place,' he said. 'It's obviously the case that whenever there's a terrible event like this, a terrible incident, they conduct an investigation.' Terry Lee-Williams, a transport planning strategist, said it was 'awful that somebody died', but overall, Sydney's light rail network was safe and 'actually quite a low speed system'. One suggestion for improving safety could be replacing the trams with the concertina-like ones used in Melbourne, he said, but this would be costly. He said Sydney's trams were a 'standard design' and similar to those operated in many European countries. 'You don't see much of the Melbourne-style trams around the world because they're less accessible,' he said. 'Sydney has very narrow, windy streets.'
Daily Mail
5 hours ago
- Daily Mail
EXCLUSIVE The four-word text that sparked a tragic hunt for missing teen Pheobe Bishop - as her housemates are now charged with her murder
The hunt for missing teen Pheobe Bishop was triggered by a frantic text from her sister to the last-known people to see her alive, Daily Mail Australia can reveal. Pheobe's housemates James Wood and Tanika Bromley have now been charged with the 17-year-old's murder and two counts each of interfering with her corpse. She vanished on May 15 after leaving the ramshackle home in Gin Gin, near Bundaberg in central Queensland, that she shared with Wood and Bromley. They told police they had given her an early morning lift to Bundaberg Airport to board a plane on a trip to see her boyfriend in Perth. But Pheobe never made it to check in, and her older sister Kaylea, 18, triggered the search when the family was alerted Pheobe had never arrived in Western Australia. In an text to Wood and Bromley on May 16, Kaylea demanded to know: 'Where is my sister?' Three weeks later detectives have accused the housemates of Pheobe's murder, and on Friday notified the family they had found human remains. Just hours earlier Kaylea had begged for help finding her sister's body in an impassioned plea outside Bundaberg Magistrates Court after Bromley and Wood's murder charges were heard. She sat in the far corner of the front row, staring straight ahead flanked by friends, family and a court security guard as details of the murder charges against the couple were read out. Neither Wood nor Bromley appeared in person or by video link for the hearing and afterwards Kaylea walked outside to make her heartbreaking statement. 'We just want her home,' she said tearfully through red-rimmed eyes. 'I don't know what to say, if you've got any information about Pheobe or the car, just come forward. 'Three weeks is too long for us as a family. She was loved, she's missed dearly.' Kaylea and Pheobe had a close relationship and had been planning to move out of the family home and into a house together last year. On Friday, the girls' mother Kylie Johnson paid tribute to Kaylea for facing the media to speak up for her allegedly murdered sister. 'Kaylea your strength, determination and dedication to bring Phee Phee home is such a reflection of your fierce love for your sister,' Ms Johnson posted on Facebook. 'Pheobe would be so proud of the way you handled yourself today just as we are. We WILL bring Phee home - I don't care how long it takes but we will get her home.' After the remains were found she posted again, saying: 'I didn't think my heart could break anymore then it did when you went missing, or when the charges were laid, but this! This is ripping me apart.' Pheobe was last seen on May 15 leaving the Gin Gin home, near Bundaberg in central Queensland, where she was living with Wood, 34, and Bromley, 33. The couple allegedly drove Pheobe to Bundaberg Airport at 8.30am for a flight to Brisbane and then on to Perth, where she planned to meet up with her boyfriend. She never got on the plane and Detective Inspect Craig Mansfield told reporters on Friday that, as the investigation progressed, all hope was lost of finding Pheobe alive. 'Our evidence will outline the fact that three people arrived near to the airport and three people never exited that vehicle,' he told reporters on Friday. 'Our investigation will detail the facts that we believe Pheobe was murdered and then her body was moved. 'We will allege that Pheobe was moved more than one occasion.' Pheobe had been living with the couple prior to her disappearance on May 15. The couple were arrested in Bundaberg on Thursday night and were each charged with one count of murder and two counts of interfering with a corpse. They remain in custody and were due to front Bundaberg Magistrates Court on Friday morning but did not appear via video link. The arrests came after Wood was initially arrested on Wednesday and then released without charge. The arrests came after James Wood (pictured) was initially arrested on Wednesday and then released without charge Police towed Wood's SUV which he had 'effectively been living out of it from time to time' for forensic examination The search for Pheobe had been scaled back on Wednesday after police spent weeks combing several areas of interest. They included the property in Gin Gin where Pheobe lived with Wood and Bromley and a grey Hyundai ix35, thought to have been used to take the teen to the airport. Det. Insp. Mansfield told reporters while he could not speculate on motive, he said police have 'information that would suggest some form of motivation'. Police have also towed Wood's SUV which he had 'effectively been living out of it from time to time' for forensic examination on Thursday night.
