Judge suggests NSW police had ‘absolutely no evidence' to justify main strip-search in class action
Justice Dina Yehia made the comment in the NSW supreme court during closing arguments in a class action against the police.
The state of NSW has disputed that the vast majority of strip-searches conducted by police between 2018 and 2022 at music festivals were unlawful.
NSW police did, however, admit in court documents before the hearings began last week to unlawfully strip-searching the lead plaintiff, Raya Meredith, at a music festival in 2018.
Meredith is the lead plaintiff of a group of 3,000 people, including children, searched by police. She was strip-searched at the 2018 Splendour in the Grass festival after a drug dog sniffed in her direction but then walked on.
The class action is being led by Slater and Gordon lawyers and the Redfern Legal Centre.
Julian Sexton SC, acting on behalf of NSW police, on Thursday disputed the plaintiff's call for aggravated damages to be paid because of the force's conduct during proceedings.
He argued aggravated damages could not be awarded because Meredith had not been recalled to give evidence about how she felt about NSW police's conduct during the class action.
Yehia said in response she was 'much more concerned' about the police having three iterations of its defence before backflipping shortly before proceedings began and admitting it did unlawfully strip-search Meredith.
'That is a matter, I'll be quite honest with you, of grave concern to me,' Yehia said on Thursday.
The judge said she was concerned the police defence suggested officers had formed a reasonable suspicion to strip-search Meredith based on 'things like her demeanour, what was said outside the tent, and [the officers] recalling it was said outside the tent and not inside'.
'There is absolutely no evidence, unless you can take me to it and I've missed something,' Yehia said to Sexton.
Sign up to Morning Mail
Our Australian morning briefing breaks down the key stories of the day, telling you what's happening and why it matters
after newsletter promotion
'All I have is the officers' statements that say either they don't remember the search, or both that they don't remember the search nor remember the lead plaintiff. In those circumstances, I'm just not sure how this could ever have proceeded in the way that it did with the initial pleadings.'
In the days before the hearing began, the state of NSW withdrew 22 witnesses, mostly police officers who had been due to contest Meredith's version of events. That change saw the case reduced from a scheduled 2o days to three days.
Sexton argued the defence was based on police 'practice' in such instances, adding it was 'not [based] on distinct recollections of somebody'.
Yehia said the police suggesting there were 'reasonable grounds' for the search due to Meredith's physical appearance and body language were 'specific matters relating to this plaintiff in circumstances where [the female police officer who searched her] not only doesn't remember, but as far as I understand it, didn't even make a notebook entry in relation to that interaction'.
Closing arguments before Yehia were expected to end on Thursday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
4 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
'Inappropriate touching' drama as the AFL hands down ruling on video footage
The AFL 's Integrity Unit has closed down an investigation into an incident of 'potential inappropriate touching'. On Saturday, the Brisbane Lions came unstuck against the Swans late on, with the reigning premiers succumbing to a two-point defeat at The Gabba. But a bizarre incident has overshadowed the match after a Brisbane player Henry Smith and Swans player Nick Blakey appeared to feud on the footy pitch during the final minute of the first quarter. The Swans halfback had taken a mark inside Brisbane's forward line before falling to the ground. Smith's foot then appeared to make contact with Blakey's head, with the latter then appearing to kick out at his opponent, tripping him to the ground. As he fell to the ground off-balance, the Brisbane player appeared to reach out with his hand and make contact with Blakey's backside. Nine's Tom Morris stated on Monday that the Lions and Swans had 'been aware of the AFL's enquiries' over the matter. However, he added that there was 'no complaint' from Blakey or the Swans regarding the matter, with the league having subsequently scratched their investigations. A statement from the AFL read: 'Following inquiries by the AFL Integrity Unit into an incident during the Brisbane Lions and Sydney Swans match on Saturday, it has been determined that no further action is required.' On Monday, the Lions said: 'The club is aware the AFL Integrity Unit is looking into an alleged incident from Saturday's match against Sydney. While this process is being conducted, the club will not be commenting at this point.' Morris said that the incident had been 'initially viewed throw a Match Review Officer lens' before it was referred to the AFL's Integrity Unit.
The Sun
4 minutes ago
- The Sun
I earned £100,000-a-year doing a job no one wants – it was easy money but it had a sinister dark side
A DAD has revealed how he earns £100,000 a year doing a job no one wants - but there's an ominous catch. At his peak, Lachie Samuel was raking in almost $5,000 (around £3,700) a week which he splurged on drinks at the pub. 5 5 Lachie left home at 19 to become a fly-in, fly-out (FIFO) in the Western Australian mines - five days of gruelling labour followed by two days at home. When he started, the lifestyle was challenging but cushioned by the hefty pay package he received at the end of the month. He told News AU: 'You would do a 12 hour shift, come back to camp, hit the gym, then head straight to the pub and order as many drinks as you wanted." But while the pay was "more money than he knew what to do with", Lachie soon discovered the dark side of working in such remote locate for long stretches of time. As isolation crept in, the bright-eyed youngster soon found himself splurging his hard-earned cash on alcohol and drugs. But it was in 2013 when his world was turned upside down. He received a call informing him that his partner had attempted to take her own life. After seeking advice from his team leader, he was told that "if she really wanted to do it, she would have". Instead of going home, he decided to stay put in Kargoolie - burying his sadness in work. He asked to switch from five days on and two days off to four weeks work and just one week off - a decision he later came to deeply regret. I make £80,000 doing an entry level job no one wants - and some of my pals earned even more than I do Soon after, Lachie and his partner broke up which hurtled him into a "dark place". He started picking fights with co-workers and was eventually asked to leave and return to Perth where he had no friends or family. Lacking in a support network and carrying "a lot of shame" Lachie squandered his savings on alcohol, drugs and womanising. Soon after, his ex-partner called to tell him she was pregnant with his child. What is FIFO work? FLY-in fly-out or FIFO work in Australia has grown in popularity with the expansion of the mining and resources sectors. They help to build and operate the mines and are provided with food and shelter during their stay. Workers travel to remote locations where they are rostered on for a set number of work days on site and then rest days at home. FIFO workers can be anything from engineers and electricians, to nurses, security guards, chefs and crane operators. They serve a key role in Australia's mining industry. It's difficult work, which has recently been glamorised online for being so lucrative. Source: Bravus mining resources But after months failing to prove himself as a dad, he said, they moved to the east coast. Having finally found purpose again as a parent, the move felt like losing that "last bit of identity" which tragically pushed him to the brink of collapse. 'I remember the moments after, crying, thinking about how I nearly took my daughter's dad. I'm really lucky that being the selfish person I was, I chose to find something in being a better person for her' he said. After trying to take his own life and swimming in a sea of debt, the dad was forced back to the mines where he spent the next three years. Now, Lachie shares his experiences with his own mental health struggles with other FIFE workers to help others in the industry. His advice for anyone looking to get into FIFO is to ask yourself why you want to be there and what about the work attracts you. Over the last few years, social media has been flooded with content promoting the lifestyle. But Lachy has warned keen FIFO workers: 'You should know that your room will be mouldy, the toilet won't be cleaned, there's gunk everywhere. You just hope that the bed has been changed since the last person.' 5 5
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
Family of footy legend whose drug-fuelled death rocked the AFL hit back at his partner after she made stunning claims
The family of former West Coast Eagles great Adam Hunter have responded to claims made by his partner Latisha Yacoub that she is owed money by his relatives. Mr Hunter passed away in February at the age of 43, with a coroner's inquiry stating that the 2006 premiership winner's cause of death related to drug-induced heart failure. Last week, his partner Ms Yacoub, spoke on the day Mr Hunter died, as well as the Eagles great's battle with addiction. Ms Yacoub, a qualified nurse and a mother-of-three, told The West Australian she suspected her partner had taken methamphetamine the day he passed away on February 4. She heartbreakingly opened up on her final moments with Mr Hunter, revealing that she found him on the floor in their bedroom with foam coming out of his mouth. Ms Yacoub, 41, who met the former Eagles player when they were teenagers, revealed she began performing CPR and called an ambulance before he later passed away. In the wide-ranging interview, Ms Yacoub opened up on Mr Hunter's life after professional football, claiming that she had supported the former Eagles utility player during his battles with addiction. The mother-of-three explained she had given him a weekly allowance from her own salary, and had taken out a $40,000 loan to pay his legal bills. However, she also appeared to claim that her relationship with Mr Hunter's family had worsened following his death. 'He didn't have a will but when he died, his family made it clear to me that I would be looked after because of all the money I had spent on him over the past few years, but now things have got very uncomfortable between us,' she told The West Australian. Mr Hunter's family has now responded to Ms Yacoub's claim, stating that they are still grieving and that they are focusing on supporting the Eagles great's young son. 'We are still grieving the loss of our son,' Mr Hunter's family told The West Australian. 'We will be focusing our energy on supporting the people that loved him, our family, close friends and especially Adam's son. 'We hope Latisha gets the help she obviously needs. We will not be making any further comment.' Ms Yacoub also has some of Mr Hunter's belongings stored in her house. Some of those personal effects are understood to include some of his treasured sports memorabilia, fishing equipment and a Toyota Prado. The West Australian has also claimed that Mr Hunter's family is 'furious' that Ms Yacoub has allegedly not allowed them access to the items. The outlet adds that the family are arguing that they should be given to his 14-year-old son. Mr Hunter enjoyed a distinguished career in footy's top flight. He began his footy journey playing for South Bunbury before joining WAFL side Swan Districts in 1999. His impressive performances would see him go on to be drafted as 29th pick in the 1999 National Draft by the Eagles, before making his debut the following year. Mr Hunter would go on to make 151 appearances for the Western Australian club before retiring from pro footy in 2009 following a shoulder injury. Despite being forced to step away from the AFL prematurely, he'd still continue to play club-level footy, turning out for both South Bunbury and Swan Districts. Mr Hunter would go on to make 151 appearances for the Western Australian club before retiring from pro footy in 2009 following a shoulder injury Ms Yacoub also opened up further on her partner's life after footy and his issues with addiction. 'He was working as a truck driver, running freight between Bunbury and Perth, and he would chip in a couple of hundred dollars every week or usually every fortnight to help out with rent but that was it,' she told The West Australian. 'The rest of his money went on drugs. It had always been that way. He had been earning good money when he was playing AFL and had bought some houses but he lost those.' Mr Hunter had multiple houses repossessed and had died bankrupt. Ms Yacoub had claimed that he had sold off some of his football memorabilia to pay of drug dealers. 'His family had given him money a few times, but they refused to step in to stop him going bankrupt, which I completely understand, because he had let them down so many times before,' she added. Mr Hunter and Ms Yacoub had previously split up after she said she 'suspected she wasn't the only woman in his life'. However, the pair reconciled in 2022, with the Eagles great moving into her house. Ms Yacoub explained that she never stopped loving the former footy player: 'To me he was still amazing.' 'He was just so attentive and nice,' she said. 'He would do things like drop in and see me at lunchtime and call in sick for me by pretending to be my brother so we could spend the day together.' During his funeral, Ms Yacoub had called the former footballer 'my lover, my best friend, my soulmate and the absolute love of my life.' 'We've had our fair share of ups and downs but no matter what we both knew that there'd never be anybody else,' she said at the service.
